You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Puncheon
November 16 2026 10.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Puncheon


Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Icepick Tony Flag Chester 05 Feb 17 11.02am

Originally posted by chateauferret

Pity we brought on Ledley instead of Flamini. Pity the Home Office couldn't issue Milevojevic' visa in time, as well.

I can only guess he is still not 100% as the last few outings he's been rock solid.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

rikz Flag Croydon 05 Feb 17 12.21pm

Originally posted by Icepick Tony

Yes, let's compare Punch to one of the best playmakers ever? His basic story with us over the last 2/3 seasons has been, he wasn't good enough to be a winger once Wilf and Bolasie were on song so he was tried out as a No.10 as Chamakh was injured all the time. He got the odd goal in the beginning but the way the team set up allowed him to basically float and not really have many duties.
He then he got pushed further back into the midfield as apparently he is very technical and good on the ball.

He is out of his depth now and can't play the position, regardless of who is next to him he doesn't have the vision or ability needed to play the role. Our team isnt good enough to carry him so it highlights how ineffective he is. He isn't a Kroos, Pirlo or a Motta, he's a lad from south London who done alright but has never been top quality. Not an international midfielder that you're comparing him to.

Yesterday really did show how much of a difference Cabaye makes in our midfield 3 as once he went off we were lost in the middle.

Summed him up perfectly.

 

Mstrobez Flag 05 Feb 17 2.24pm

Originally posted by mattteo


Well thank you for the kind words and the vast improvement you bring on this site.

For your knowledge, all those players were wingers in their youth

For your knowledge Puncheon played on the wing for us at the age of 27 and started playing number 10 at 29. But your knowledge on palace is so limited I would question whether or not you actually support us.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 05 Feb 17 2.47pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

For your knowledge Puncheon played on the wing for us at the age of 27 and started playing number 10 at 29. But your knowledge on palace is so limited I would question whether or not you actually support us.

...... Nah!

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

mattteo Flag 05 Feb 17 7.35pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

For your knowledge Puncheon played on the wing for us at the age of 27 and started playing number 10 at 29. But your knowledge on palace is so limited I would question whether or not you actually support us.


FOR MY KNOWLEDGE WHAT??? HOW IS ANY OF WHAT YOU WROTE THERE SUPPOSED TO CONTRADICT WHAT I SAID OR IMPROVE MY KNOWLEDGE?

WHY ARE YOU BEING A JACKASS AND TELLING ME THAT I DON'T SUPPORT THIS TEAM?

 

cols123 Flag beckenham 05 Feb 17 7.40pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Pirlo played in front of the defence in his last years. He wasn't very different from Puncheon. Thiago Motta does it for PSG, Kroos for Madrid sometimes.

Not a defensive midfielder, but a deep lying playmaker. If there are 2 central box-to-box midfielders in front of him, it's doable. All he'd have to do is maintain position and close spaces, as the other 2 midfielders would be the ones doing the tackles. McArthur and Cabaye could be those.

But I reckon Allardyce will always play them differently: McArthur and Cabaye lower, Puncheon behind the striker. And not having the necessary pace in that position where you're basically the second striker really damages the pressing and recovery of the team.

Puncheon is like Pirlo

Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha!!!

I needed a laugh like this!


 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 05 Feb 17 7.48pm

Originally posted by mattteo


Well thank you for the kind words and the vast improvement you bring on this site.

For your knowledge, all those players were wingers in their youth

So were Thierry Henry & David Trezeguet but if you think you can compare them to Punch then you are deluded.

You do actually understand that Football Manager is not 'real' don't you?

Quoting stats does not prove knowledge of the game, just knowledge of the numbers. Take yesterday's Hull V Liverpool: the scousers had:

72% possession
22 shots v 7
15 corners v 1

but, guess what, they lost 2-0.

PS: no need to SHOUT we can read in lower case too.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

cpfc1976 Flag Reading 05 Feb 17 7.56pm

Originally posted by mattteo


FOR MY KNOWLEDGE WHAT??? HOW IS ANY OF WHAT YOU WROTE THERE SUPPOSED TO CONTRADICT WHAT I SAID OR IMPROVE MY KNOWLEDGE?

WHY ARE YOU BEING A JACKASS AND TELLING ME THAT I DON'T SUPPORT THIS TEAM?

Dear oh dear. Still going matteo....

Pirlo like Puncheon??? Ha ha ha. A day later and you still haven't given us the punchline.

 

mattteo Flag 05 Feb 17 8.19pm

Originally posted by Nobbybm

So were Thierry Henry & David Trezeguet but if you think you can compare them to Punch then you are deluded.

You do actually understand that Football Manager is not 'real' don't you?

Quoting stats does not prove knowledge of the game, just knowledge of the numbers. Take yesterday's Hull V Liverpool: the scousers had:

72% possession
22 shots v 7
15 corners v 1

but, guess what, they lost 2-0.

PS: no need to SHOUT we can read in lower case too.

Take those statistics into consideration, SMART PANTS, and realize that Liverpool is 4th and Hull is f******ing 18th and it was just 90 minutes that nobody could control.

But at the end of the championship, Liverpool will be at least 10 positions higher BECAUSE of those statistics

 

cpfc1976 Flag Reading 05 Feb 17 8.27pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Take those statistics into consideration, SMART PANTS, and realize that Liverpool is 4th and Hull is f******ing 18th and it was just 90 minutes that nobody could control.

But at the end of the championship, Liverpool will be at least 10 positions higher BECAUSE of those statistics

Yeah and we came 11th in 13/14 with about 30% possession. We are doubling that this season and are bottom three and getting beat every week.

 

mattteo Flag 05 Feb 17 8.37pm

Originally posted by cpfc1976

Dear oh dear. Still going matteo....

Pirlo like Puncheon??? Ha ha ha. A day later and you still haven't given us the punchline.

The idea is that when Pirlo got slow and couldn't run anymore as a winger, he became a central midfielder.
Not that Puncheon is as good as him. Proportions must be kept, we're talking about Juventus and Palace here. But Benteke is still the type of Mandzukic striker and Mandanda is still a goalkeeper like Buffon.

The point is that Pirlo played first man in front of the defence when Juventus won their first title under Conte. 3 at the back: Bonucci, Barzagli, Chiellini. Pirlo in front of the defence, with Vidal and Pogba as box-to-box. 2 strikers: Tevez and Morata.

In Allegri's first season, they even ditched Barzagli and played Marchisio as a third box-to-box midfielder and still won the league by a great margin.
Now, they go between 3-5-2 and 4-4-2. But they still have a playmaker in front of the defence: Pjanic.

And many low level teams have one too, to distribute the balls: Huddlestone for Hull, Shelvey for Newcastle, Charlie Adam for Stoke, Wilshire plays there many times, Jurado for Espanyol, Huszti for Eintracht.....

All of those players were a lot faster when younger, but got slower and more intelligent with the passage of time. I don't see why Puncheon can't play like this as long as he has Cabaye and McArthur to sweep in front of him. Do you think Milivojevic is that much different from Puncheon? Good technique, slow feet. This is exactly what you'll get from him

 

mattteo Flag 05 Feb 17 8.38pm

Originally posted by cpfc1976

Yeah and we came 11th in 13/14 with about 30% possession. We are doubling that this season and are bottom three and getting beat every week.

It's the number of shots and the goals scored that matter, not necessary the possession

 

cpfc1976 Flag Reading 05 Feb 17 8.41pm

Originally posted by mattteo

It's the number of shots and the goals scored that matter, not necessary the possession

Well sorry to piss on your chips but we also scored less goals and had less shots at the same point that season too.

 

mattteo Flag 05 Feb 17 9.12pm

Originally posted by cpfc1976

Well sorry to piss on your chips but we also scored less goals and had less shots at the same point that season too.

Less as opposed to what? Not opposed to 2 of the 3 teams that got relegated.

It doesn't happen 100% of the time, but most of the time teams that score more finish higher

 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 05 Feb 17 9.13pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Take those statistics into consideration, SMART PANTS, and realize that Liverpool is 4th and Hull is f******ing 18th and it was just 90 minutes that nobody could control.

But at the end of the championship, Liverpool will be at least 10 positions higher BECAUSE of those statistics

And Leicester won the EPL with 37% average possession.

The actual fact is statistics are objective & results are not. You sit there at your keyboard spouting 'facts' that actually mean diddly squat in the real world. When called out you simply get abusive.

Look at WBA this season, unless I am imagining things they are sitting 8th in the table with the least possession, shots etc of any team in the top half of the league other than Burnley - who are much worse, statistically speaking, yet are 9th.

Liverpool may well finish at least 10 places higher than Hull but that's because of points won, not simply statistics. The game yesterday may have only been 90 minutes but the stats you usually cling to show quite clearly that Liverpool 'controlled' that game. Fact is they didn't win it, end of.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 05 Feb 17 9.19pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Less as opposed to what? Not opposed to 2 of the 3 teams that got relegated.

It doesn't happen 100% of the time, but most of the time teams that score more finish higher

incorrect. The top 3 in the last 6 seasons have been made up (mostly) by the teams that conceded the least.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

OldFella Flag London 05 Feb 17 9.22pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Take those statistics into consideration, SMART PANTS, and realize that Liverpool is 4th and Hull is f******ing 18th and it was just 90 minutes that nobody could control.

But at the end of the championship, Liverpool will be at least 10 positions higher BECAUSE of those statistics

I have a compelling vision of you as being Willo's lovechild, but with Tourette's

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

cpfc1976 Flag Reading 05 Feb 17 9.30pm

Originally posted by OldFella

I have a compelling vision of you as being Willo's lovechild, but with Tourette's

Ha ha. We'll know for sure when he is says that's f**king riseable hogwash'

 

mattteo Flag 05 Feb 17 9.58pm

Originally posted by Nobbybm

And Leicester won the EPL with 37% average possession.

The actual fact is statistics are objective & results are not. You sit there at your keyboard spouting 'facts' that actually mean diddly squat in the real world. When called out you simply get abusive.

Look at WBA this season, unless I am imagining things they are sitting 8th in the table with the least possession, shots etc of any team in the top half of the league other than Burnley - who are much worse, statistically speaking, yet are 9th.

Liverpool may well finish at least 10 places higher than Hull but that's because of points won, not simply statistics. The game yesterday may have only been 90 minutes but the stats you usually cling to show quite clearly that Liverpool 'controlled' that game. Fact is they didn't win it, end of.

That is so incorrect. WBA have A LOT of shots each game. Mainly because they're masters of counter attack

 

mattteo Flag 05 Feb 17 10.04pm

Originally posted by Nobbybm

incorrect. The top 3 in the last 6 seasons have been made up (mostly) by the teams that conceded the least.

That's so bull****
Leicester, Arsenal and Tottenham have only had less goals scored than 4th place Man City. But they've had more goals scored than the other 16 participants, that's why they finished higher.

This is what happens in every league, around the world, ALWAYS.

Yes, a good attack isn't all there is, this isn't rocket science and you can still get relegated with 50 goals, like Stuttgart did. But if you score more you have a higher percentage chance of finishing in a better position. Especially since the introduction of the 3 points per win rule. The rest are exceptions

 

Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Puncheon