You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Trident
November 21 2026 11.59pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Trident


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
steeleye20 Flag Croydon 26 Apr 17 3.18pm

Its so 80's so out of date like the cold war concept its had its day like nuclear power itself.

When these subs go into service the Trident will be 70 years old.

The present Trident subs have plenty of life left they just need plugs and an oil change.

There is enough time to cancel the new Trident and install a less costly and more effective system which actually makes some sort of sense.

Corbyn just said that he would not authorise a 'first strike' that is all.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 26 Apr 17 3.27pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Its so 80's so out of date like the cold war concept its had its day like nuclear power itself.

When these subs go into service the Trident will be 70 years old.

The present Trident subs have plenty of life left they just need plugs and an oil change.

There is enough time to cancel the new Trident and install a less costly and more effective system which actually makes some sort of sense.

Corbyn just said that he would not authorise a 'first strike' that is all
.

Yep, but that hasn't been conveyed by the media. Hence why people make uninformed accusations and base their vote on lies and misinformation.

 

palace_in_frogland Flag In a broken dream 26 Apr 17 3.27pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

NATO's nuclear capability is split between France and the UK. The general assumption is that the US would come to the assistance of the UK and NATO. France has some nuclear submarines (always one in service) and a number of more conventional deployable warheads.

However, the UK and Frances nuclear capability are both sovereign based, rather than assets of NATO.

The UK unlike France has no real capacity for airborne deployment, since the scrapping of the Vulcan bombers.

Not since the mid 90's when they retired Mirage IV, their Vulcan type bomber!

They can use smaller aircraft like Rafale, with aerial refuelling to deliver over long distance, but then so could the UK if it wanted to.

 

Part Time James Flag 26 Apr 17 3.31pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Its so 80's so out of date like the cold war concept its had its day like nuclear power itself.

When these subs go into service the Trident will be 70 years old.

The present Trident subs have plenty of life left they just need plugs and an oil change.

There is enough time to cancel the new Trident and install a less costly and more effective system which actually makes some sort of sense.

Corbyn just said that he would not authorise a 'first strike' that is all.

Maybe he couldn't envisage a situation whereby he'd be allowed to influence the decision.

 




jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Apr 17 3.33pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Its so 80's so out of date like the cold war concept its had its day like nuclear power itself.

When these subs go into service the Trident will be 70 years old.

The present Trident subs have plenty of life left they just need plugs and an oil change.

There is enough time to cancel the new Trident and install a less costly and more effective system which actually makes some sort of sense.

They don't use spark plus and oil filters (well not in the way its implied) they're nuclear powered submarines.

I think its been approved and contracts issued at least for the new reactors and submarines. So I suspect that any cancellation will involved penalty payment clauses.

One of the likely issues around Trident is that we buy the missile systems from the US, which is serious business between the UK treasury and US military trade.

Originally posted by steeleye20
Corbyn just said that he would not authorise a 'first strike' that is all.

Much as I might want him to win the election, I very much doubt he'll have to make that choice - and Trident isn't really a first strike solution anyhow.

The UK has no first strike capacity, short of unleashing at some 64 plus nuclear warheads, at a pre-selected target, that's with 4500 miles of the submarine (give or take 800 ft - Trident missiles aren't notably very accurate - but then nuclear warheads don't really require precision targeting).

No Prime Minister in the UK is going to order a first strike except as part of a NATO defence against an overwhelming force. Sure they might say they would 'in certain circumstances' but unless that's the use of a real WMD against the UK, its never going to happen (and the use in the case of WMD really constitutes a retaliatory strike).

It'd take one hell of a conventional attack to justify deploying nuclear weapons.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 26 Apr 17 4.05pm

Informative as ever J.

My comments about spark plugs and oil change made in gest.

However I did say that nuclear power has had its day I meant for this trident really but thinking about it isn't nuclear just a ruination in every way?

The never-ending cost, the never-ending problem of nuclear waste, the accidents the degredation of this country into a nuclear dustbin. the cost of the energy itself.

Its only a few years ago that Tony Blair was saying ok to nuclear and it seemed the only way to go but not now even Japan with its technical prowess has messed it up badly.

Over to you

 

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Apr 17 4.22pm

Jamie, as I said, the risks involved in a nuclear attack upon the UK are not straightforward, free of risk nor easy for any particular enemy with a conventional threat to us that we know about.

Added to this difficulty is the reality that any conventional action taken against us like this would inevitably involve going to war against Nato and hence America. So taking care of our complication would be as just a drop in the ocean compared to the planning involved against their arsenal.

It is a huge and largely pointless risk....Rationality says it would only be a last throw of the dice.

So I find the general implication that we don't have an effective deterrent to be highly spurious. It isn't the best in the world but is difficult to combat without risking significant losses yourself.

The options for this country not to have a nuclear option are far more riskier and tantamount to certain blackmail or implementation. This point is extremely important.

The concept of mutual destruction has worked extremely effectively. Compare how many lives we lost in wars before it to how many we lost in wars after having a nuclear capacity.

Without honest actors looking to also reduce their nuclear capacity we are left with the least risky option of maintaining a nuclear capacity.

Its influence goes far beyond just defence and those who think they know better are in my opinion not fit to make decisions that affect the security of my kids.

If we gave up our nuclear capacity we would further weaken Nato and leave America thinking that he doesn't have any real effective allies in an institution it eyes as more of a burden than a plus. Our influence in the world would lessen along with losing our seat on the security council....which has plenty of ethically doubtful people on it already.

In a Europe that for decades has looked to scrimp on defence spending and rely on big brother America (which plenty of the hypocrites hate) Britain along with France has a proud and respected tradition of standing up and maintaining military defences worthy of the name.

Those who want to turn us into a military Norway can sit and spin as far as I'm concerned.

Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Apr 2017 4.29pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Apr 17 4.33pm

Isn't the maximum missile range of Trident 11 7,500 miles?

Each submarine carries up to sixteen Trident II D-5 missiles, which can each carry up to twelve warheads, for a maximum of 192 warheads per vessel. However, the British government announced in 1998 that each submarine would carry only 48 warheads.

The government said that there would be at 'least' one sub active at one time with at least one other at sea on training...which presumably could become active if necessity requires.

Portillo is wrong...our nuclear deterrent is independent as the US has no veto upon its use only assurances....It is also definitely a deterrent because without it the complications for a perspective enemy looking to win become far easier.

Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Apr 2017 4.42pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Apr 17 4.40pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays
So I find the general implication that we don't have an effective deterrent to be highly spurious. It isn't the best in the world but is difficult to combat without risking significant losses yourself.

Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Apr 2017 4.29pm)

We don't, Trident doesn't and can't really work effectively like that. We need to move to either a long range Navy missile solution (possibly submarine based), using longer range missile systems or land based Long Range intercontinental ballistic missile system.

There is no point or value in surrendering our deterrent, as there is nothing really on the table to make that worth undertaking (and if we did, then NATO's only nuclear capacity is the French systems).

But Trident, isn't anything other than a almost out of date solution, to an enemy that's no longer a major threat, that just keeps us 'nuclear' for the sake of saying it.

Or we're going to need a lot more submarines if we're going to always have one 4600 miles off the coast of each potential nuclear threat.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Apr 17 4.44pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

We don't, Trident doesn't and can't really work effectively like that. We need to move to either a long range Navy missile solution (possibly submarine based), using longer range missile systems or land based Long Range intercontinental ballistic missile system.

There is no point or value in surrendering our deterrent, as there is nothing really on the table to make that worth undertaking (and if we did, then NATO's only nuclear capacity is the French systems).

But Trident, isn't anything other than a almost out of date solution, to an enemy that's no longer a major threat, that just keeps us 'nuclear' for the sake of saying it.

Or we're going to need a lot more submarines if we're going to always have one 4600 miles off the coast of each potential nuclear threat.

Russia isn't a major threat?....China isn't a major threat? Sure trade matters but we are only ever a mad leader or situation away from danger.

Just because the cold war turned into a lukewarm war doesn't mean it won't get considerably colder. The time frames here on alternative systems span decades.

As I say are you sure you have the distance correct for this system because the stats I've found show a much greater range.


Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Apr 2017 4.54pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Apr 17 5.02pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Russia isn't a major threat?....China isn't a major threat? Sure trade matters but we are only ever a mad leader or situation away from danger.

So which one is Trident going to be used against (hint it has to be Russia, because China is realistically outside the operational range of Trident).

Going forwards we need to realistically be able to deploy nuclear capability towards Russia, China, North Korea, Iran, pakistan and maybe Saudi Arabia. There is probably some wisdom in being able to target South America, as sooner or later Brazil or Argentina might go down the nuclear path.

As it stands, it takes three trident submarines to have 'a final strike' solution against one of country.

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Just because the cold war turned into a lukewarm war doesn't mean it won't get considerably colder. The time frames here on alternative systems span decades

Because we've dilly dallied around Trident for political reasons, rather than face the fact that well be left with an increasingly obsolete system.

Originally posted by Stirlingsays
As I say are you sure you have the distance correct for this system because the stats I've found show a much greater range.

Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Apr 2017 4.49pm)

Last I heard the Polaris missile on a Trident Submarine had around a 4500 or so mile effective range.

Problem with Trident, is its going to be 80-120bn plus spent on an increasingly less effective and versatile system - largely because of deals in place with US and UK arms industry jobs and so we can say 'we have a nuclear option' (which might have to be launching a strike on a different country than the one that attacked us).

It was a mistake in the 80s for the Conservatives to move entirely to the Trident system (which just happens to be a huge US Arms industry spend), and its been a continual mistake to keep focused on Trident decade on decade, even though the world has been changing.

The problem isn't that 'the enemies of the cold war' aren't a threat, its that Trident isn't really any use against the enemies of the modern era and future.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 26 Apr 17 5.32pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Isn't the maximum missile range of Trident 11 7,500 miles?

Each submarine carries up to sixteen Trident II D-5 missiles, which can each carry up to twelve warheads, for a maximum of 192 warheads per vessel. However, the British government announced in 1998 that each submarine would carry only 48 warheads.

The government said that there would be at 'least' one sub active at one time with at least one other at sea on training...which presumably could become active if necessity requires.

Portillo is wrong...our nuclear deterrent is independent as the US has no veto upon its use only assurances....It is also definitely a deterrent because without it the complications for a perspective enemy looking to win become far easier.

Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Apr 2017 4.42pm)

Isn't "our" nuclear deterrent - ie the actual missiles - leased from its US manufacturer?

It's all bollocks anyway. Go ahead and name me the states that are lining up to attack the UK that we're deterring, with the reasons why you chose them.

Then feel free to list the direct benefits to the average UK citizen - who unsurprisingly won't have disappeared in a ball of nuclear fire - of those £200+ billions that this "renewal" will cost over time.

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Apr 17 5.57pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Last I heard the Polaris missile on a Trident Submarine had around a 4500 or so mile effective range.

According to Wiki the range of Trident 11 is 7,500 miles.

[Link] (look on the right hand side for the range capacity)

The distance between the UK and China is 4,831 miles. Once your sub(s) sets off towards Greece or around the horn of Africa those distances become far less.

I should imagine you can reach the parts you wish to, and the enemy can't be sure where that sub is and be certain that they can eliminate it in time.....Not with having to also worry about the US and France's systems at the same time....Like I say, it's a massive risk and hence a deterrent and it becomes a realistic last throw of the dice rather than a probable reliable victory.

As for enemies like NK....We only need to be able to reach those that can reach us.....And if NK were a strike threat to us we could move into range.

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

It was a mistake in the 80s for the Conservatives to move entirely to the Trident system (which just happens to be a huge US Arms industry spend), and its been a continual mistake to keep focused on Trident decade on decade, even though the world has been changing.

I'm not so sure that it's a mistake if it cements in the Americans as allies. That's essentially been the British strategy since the war and I think holistically it's the most sensible course of action.

Are the nuclear strike alternative systems that much better?

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

The problem isn't that 'the enemies of the cold war' aren't a threat, its that Trident isn't really any use against the enemies of the modern era and future.

I can see that this is your opinion but I disagree.

We can reach the main potential enemies. If we can't America can. I'm not sure your stats are reliable based on what I've seen and we have a solid alliance with the States....despite the best efforts of those on the left that would wish otherwise.....Probably watch 'Love Actually' on repeat.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Apr 17 6.10pm

Originally posted by Mr_Gristle

Isn't "our" nuclear deterrent - ie the actual missiles - leased from its US manufacturer?

It's all bollocks anyway. Go ahead and name me the states that are lining up to attack the UK that we're deterring, with the reasons why you chose them.

Then feel free to list the direct benefits to the average UK citizen - who unsurprisingly won't have disappeared in a ball of nuclear fire - of those £200+ billions that this "renewal" will cost over time.

'Leased'....Haha! Never heard of that one. What are you trying to say? That we aren't allowed to use them?

The US has no veto upon our use of nuclear weapons. We have given assurances, which makes sense but it's our finger on the button.

As for who is a direct threat?...Is that how you think of having a defence is it? Quick...let's design a system (even though it takes decades to sort out)..design a system that only deals with direct threats right now.

I can't imagine anyone would put you in charge of anything important with thinking like that.

Our threats at the moment are Russia and China. We are essentially a support prop within Nato for the US....We along with France are the added complication that makes nuclear war unrealistic and nuclear blackmail off the table.

With you and those who think like you at the helm we would be subject to nuclear threat blackmail and everything else that goes with it.

As for the benefits to the average citizen. It is having a deterrent...as opposed to you not having any....Like I have said...how many world wars have there been since WW2? You are the real risk taker not me.


Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Apr 2017 6.35pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 26 Apr 17 6.22pm

Former Conservative Defence Minister Michael Portillo has recently described Trident as a “waste of money” which is “completely past its sell-by date”, and “neither independent” nor “any sort of deterrent”

So after today and thanks to posters:

1. Waste of money - Absolutely

2. Sell-by-date - Absolutely

3. Neither independent - Not sure brain still trying to work it out

4. Any sort of deterrent - No but not absolutely

IMO the present system should continue for its remaining life of 15 years but not be renewed, as there is no benefit in not having what is already there.



 

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 26 Apr 17 7.00pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

'Leased'....Haha! Never heard of that one. What are you trying to say? That we aren't allowed to use them?

The US has no veto upon our use of nuclear weapons. We have given assurances, which makes sense but it's our finger on the button.

As for who is a direct threat?...Is that how you think of having a defence is it? Quick...let's design a system (even though it takes decades to sort out)..design a system that only deals with direct threats right now.

I can't imagine anyone would put you in charge of anything important with thinking like that.

Our threats at the moment are Russia and China. We are essentially a support prop within Nato for the US....We along with France are the added complication that makes nuclear war unrealistic and nuclear blackmail off the table.

With you and those who think like you at the helm we would be subject to nuclear threat blackmail and everything else that goes with it.

As for the benefits to the average citizen. It is having a deterrent...as opposed to you not having any....Like I have said...how many world wars have there been since WW2? You are the real risk taker not me.


Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Apr 2017 6.35pm)

If you seriously think Russia or China are poised, ready to strike against the UK militarily, you really have bought the propaganda 100%. If you think Russia are about to roll the Red Army over the plains or Central Europe, you're about 50 years behind the times. Pray tell what military threat China poses to any European country?

China has economic clout and Russia has a bucketload of resources - perhaps you buy into the premise that this "power" is a threat to us? If it is, it's only one that's going to be addressed by offensive, not deterrent, force.

Do you genuinely believe that a non-Trident UK - even if outside NATO - would be subject to "nuclear blackmail" from Russia? Really?

Still, you're entitled to your view. I stand by the fact that I believe the UK at large would be a lot better off spending the obscene sums of money involved on its own people and I believe they would still be around and free to benefit from it rather than be dead or a Russian vassal.

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Apr 17 7.21pm

Originally posted by Mr_Gristle

If you seriously think Russia or China are poised, ready to strike against the UK militarily, you really have bought the propaganda 100%. If you think Russia are about to roll the Red Army over the plains or Central Europe, you're about 50 years behind the times. Pray tell what military threat China poses to any European country?

China has economic clout and Russia has a bucketload of resources - perhaps you buy into the premise that this "power" is a threat to us? If it is, it's only one that's going to be addressed by offensive, not deterrent, force.

Do you genuinely believe that a non-Trident UK - even if outside NATO - would be subject to "nuclear blackmail" from Russia? Really?

Still, you're entitled to your view. I stand by the fact that I believe the UK at large would be a lot better off spending the obscene sums of money involved on its own people and I believe they would still be around and free to benefit from it rather than be dead or a Russian vassal.

You think China and Russia are peaceful? Hahaha! And you think I'm buying propaganda! Just ask eastern Europe about Russia and any country just off the coast of China about how safe they feel.

Both of those countries do precisely what they think they can get away with...whatever incurs the least cost.

Defence isn't about protecting against what is here right now....It is about being powerful enough not to be taken lightly....Just ask Tibet about having little in the way of military defence.

Talk about living in la la land. Labour member are we? If not you should be.

And I want to know...why wouldn't a nuclear defenseless UK be subject to nuclear blackmail?


Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Apr 2017 7.23pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

coulsdoneagle Flag London 26 Apr 17 7.27pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Much as I might want him to win the election, I very much doubt he'll have to make that choice - and Trident isn't really a first strike solution anyhow.

The UK has no first strike capacity, short of unleashing at some 64 plus nuclear warheads, at a pre-selected target, that's with 4500 miles of the submarine (give or take 800 ft - Trident missiles aren't notably very accurate - but then nuclear warheads don't really require precision targeting).

No Prime Minister in the UK is going to order a first strike except as part of a NATO defence against an overwhelming force. Sure they might say they would 'in certain circumstances' but unless that's the use of a real WMD against the UK, its never going to happen (and the use in the case of WMD really constitutes a retaliatory strike).

It'd take one hell of a conventional attack to justify deploying nuclear weapons.

I agree with this, but I can't really see Nato or Russia using strategic nuclear weapons even against an overwhelming conventional force. Russia as the USSR had a no first strike policy, and that was dropped at the end of the USSR but its tactical plan in response to an attack would probably be to use Taccy Nukes against forces that crossed in to Russia. I think tactical nuclear weapons could be used defensively but its hard to see anyone who has both the capability and the desire to get in to a situation that could escalate to that level.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Apr 17 7.36pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

I agree with this, but I can't really see Nato or Russia using strategic nuclear weapons even against an overwhelming conventional force. Russia as the USSR had a no first strike policy, and that was dropped at the end of the USSR but its tactical plan in response to an attack would probably be to use Taccy Nukes against forces that crossed in to Russia. I think tactical nuclear weapons could be used defensively but its hard to see anyone who has both the capability and the desire to get in to a situation that could escalate to that level.

It's fine to speculate on probabilities but no one sensible would ever design a defence system on what you think the other side would do.

You design a system that could punish if attacked....they do the same and hence you have stalemate.

Hence no world wars for two and half generations.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 26 Apr 17 10.06pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

You think China and Russia are peaceful? Hahaha! And you think I'm buying propaganda! Just ask eastern Europe about Russia and any country just off the coast of China about how safe they feel.

Both of those countries do precisely what they think they can get away with...whatever incurs the least cost.

Defence isn't about protecting against what is here right now....It is about being powerful enough not to be taken lightly....Just ask Tibet about having little in the way of military defence.

Talk about living in la la land. Labour member are we? If not you should be.

And I want to know...why wouldn't a nuclear defenseless UK be subject to nuclear blackmail?


Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Apr 2017 7.23pm)

What would Russia or China want to blackmail us over? Stop buying cheap tat from us and we'll bomb you? Stop laundering our money through London property and we'll nuke you?

You do make a good point about having nukes to stop people messing with you. A quick check on history since 1980 will show who attacks countries that can't defend themselves with nukes.

Russia and China certainly aren't peaceful, but I say again, where's the threat to us that's worth spending another £200+ billion on?

Edited by Mr_Gristle (26 Apr 2017 10.07pm)

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Trident