You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Not getting a good feeling about Frank
November 16 2026 9.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Not getting a good feeling about Frank


Page 4 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
GladAllOver27 Flag 20 Jul 17 8.33am

Originally posted by Andy_G

I do share some of the concerns of the OP but posting them this early was always asking for abuse.

I was hoping for a slower style/system change but it looks as if we are going from the off which could well lead to another poor start and trouble by christmas. Really hope I'm wrong.

I share a similar concern and feel for us to be successful in this formation, we need a big personal change. Whereas we could stick to a 433 and only need 3 players but with this 3-4-3, I feel we maybe need 6 or 7. This formation doesn't suit most of our current defenders and the likes of puncheon too slow in possession.

Edited by GladAllOver27 (20 Jul 2017 8.33am)

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 20 Jul 17 8.39am

Originally posted by GladAllOver27

I share a similar concern and feel for us to be successful in this formation, we need a big personal change. Whereas we could stick to a 433 and only need 3 players but with this 3-4-3, I feel we maybe need 6 or 7. This formation doesn't suit most of our current defenders and the likes of puncheon too slow in possession.


That's the way I thought we'd be going, especially as the budget would appear to be limited to about that number of signings. If we'd gone with 4-3-3 yesterday I'd boldly suggest we'd have seen a different result.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 20 Jul 17 9.07am

Originally posted by GladAllOver27

I share a similar concern and feel for us to be successful in this formation, we need a big personal change. Whereas we could stick to a 433 and only need 3 players but with this 3-4-3, I feel we maybe need 6 or 7. This formation doesn't suit most of our current defenders and the likes of puncheon too slow in possession.

Edited by GladAllOver27 (20 Jul 2017 8.33am)

A year ago I'd have probably agreed however, Chelski just won the title with 3 at the back not in their preferred positions & two wingbacks that were never wingbacks. There was a good article in the Times a while back that detailed how these 5 were all out of their natural positions/comfort zones but Conte made it work.

I think what it boils down to is these guys are professional footballers and, to a degree, should be able to play in any system.

What makes me feel better is FdB's comments from the outset - he wants to try & change us, it won't happen overnight & he will adapt things accordingly. He's even been quoted as saying he will always learn from his mistakes - something Pardew never managed to do & that nearly cost us our EPL status.

I, for one, am still excited by the prospect of a new era for us but am not expecting an instant impact, nor miracles at this early stage.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Spender Flag Orpington 20 Jul 17 9.19am

The bottom line in the Premiership is that if a Club cannot afford to buy very top quality players throughout the side then it has to do what Big Sam preached and focus first and foremost on keeping a clean sheet. SP has made it clear that we are cash constrained in this transfer window so rather than trying to get an ordinary squad of players to play Sexy "pass from the back" football, we need to stick with "Clean Sheet First" football that kept us up under Sam. Even that is going to be a challenge without Sakho in the heart of our defence but it is the way to go this Season.

FDB could be undoing the good work that Big Sam put in place.

Yesterday did ring alarm bells and the lack of any suggested top quality signings 3 weeks before our Season starts does not help.

Bringing in players like Lofus Cheek is all very well if he can be used as a bench player but he is never going to make a massive difference instantly to our performance at Premiership standard. He's just finding his feet as a young player.

 

fishbone Flag London 20 Jul 17 9.21am

Agree strongly with nobby
Rome wasn't built in a day but when they had finished it lasted more than a thousand years

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Jul 17 9.25am

Originally posted by Spender

The bottom line in the Premiership is that if a Club cannot afford to buy very top quality players throughout the side then it has to do what Big Sam preached and focus first and foremost on keeping a clean sheet. SP has made it clear that we are cash constrained in this transfer window so rather than trying to get an ordinary squad of players to play Sexy "pass from the back" football, we need to stick with "Clean Sheet First" football that kept us up under Sam. Even that is going to be a challenge without Sakho in the heart of our defence but it is the way to go this Season.

FDB could be undoing the good work that Big Sam put in place.

Yesterday did ring alarm bells and the lack of any suggested top quality signings 3 weeks before our Season starts does not help.

Bringing in players like Lofus Cheek is all very well if he can be used as a bench player but he is never going to make a massive difference instantly to our performance at Premiership standard. He's just finding his feet as a young player.

Spender

Given your reservations, maybe you believe that in our circumstances and recent 'Success' under Allardyce, that Dyche would have been a better choice as manager ?

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 20 Jul 17 9.26am

The thing that concerned me most was the service to benteke. Stop our wingers and wd have no creativity through thd middle. I know we've got RLC in, but think we really still need a creative no.10....

 

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 20 Jul 17 9.26am

I love this post OP. This site is full of irrational optimism, unjustified suicidal negativity, Wikipedia driven facts, spiteful jibes and complete nuts with a little bit of good analysis thrown in for good measure.

Your OP fits the unjustified negativity, by the end there will be a bit of everything else added too.

Thanks for brightening my day.

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 20 Jul 17 9.33am

Originally posted by GladAllOver27

I share a similar concern and feel for us to be successful in this formation, we need a big personal change. Whereas we could stick to a 433 and only need 3 players but with this 3-4-3, I feel we maybe need 6 or 7. This formation doesn't suit most of our current defenders and the likes of puncheon too slow in possession.

Edited by GladAllOver27 (20 Jul 2017 8.33am)

Agreed

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 20 Jul 17 9.51am

Originally posted by Nobbybm

A year ago I'd have probably agreed however, Chelski just won the title with 3 at the back not in their preferred positions & two wingbacks that were never wingbacks. There was a good article in the Times a while back that detailed how these 5 were all out of their natural positions/comfort zones but Conte made it work.


But we are not Chelsea and do not, nor can we buy, players of the quality that they have. We need to cut our cloth according to our means and let's not forget that we beat them, in their own backyard, last season with our 'inferior' brand of football. Who were the April Fools that day?

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Jul 17 9.55am

Originally posted by bexleydave


But we are not Chelsea and do not, nor can we buy, players of the quality that they have. We need to cut our cloth according to our means and let's not forget that we beat them, in their own backyard, last season with our 'inferior' brand of football. Who were the April Fools that day?

Get the feeling that some of our supporters are thinking of the word 'Transition' and shuddering when one considers some of the issues in the past !

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 20 Jul 17 10.03am

I honestly think this 3-4-3 talk is complete, utter and total Bollocks if playing with Delaney and Dann in the center. Who played midfield and was supposed to be ahead of the defense? I genuinely was pleased with the first half as I could not detect a minor bit off difference from us under Allerdyce but maybe I am tactically blind.
And further more: this was a hyped training session. The fact that 30 odd thousand locals scream at every touch and it is on TV does not make it more then a pre season training game.

Originally posted by bexleydave


That's the way I thought we'd be going, especially as the budget would appear to be limited to about that number of signings. If we'd gone with 4-3-3 yesterday I'd boldly suggest we'd have seen a different result.


 

Spender Flag Orpington 20 Jul 17 10.22am

Spender

Given your reservations, maybe you believe that in our circumstances and recent 'Success' under Allardyce, that Dyche would have been a better choice as manager ?

Hi Wllo

Too late for Dyche talk now we have to work with what we have but certainly Big Sam was a top Class Manager and I'm afraid that FDB already looks to be a step down. CPFC form post Pardew and with Sakho was good for a mid table finish at least this Season. It worked because we focused on keeping a Clean Sheet as a fundamental principal.

We should have added Sakho and one other top quality player to the first eleven that ended last Season and gradually increased the drive to get our youth team players coming through. To tear up the approach that it took Big Sam weeks to install in the players is madness with only 3 weeks before the Season starts. Even FDB struggled to find any positives at all from yesterday's showing in his Post Match Press Conference.

Edited by Spender (20 Jul 2017 10.24am)

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 20 Jul 17 11.04am

Not fixing what isn't broken applies as much to football as anything else. I see no point at all in changing our style simply because it happens to be the way our current manager either played, or prefers. FDB is clearly not a stupid guy so I doubt very much whether he plans to change things just for their own sake, or before we are capable of doing so. I therefore think last night might have been a little experimental. It certainly did not get the best out of Benteke. I suspect we might mix and match how we play, according to the opposition and whether we are at home or away. Being flexible and capable of adapting to changed circumstances would strengthen us, especially at home against the weaker sides. Playing fast counter attacking football away, and against the better sides at home, has worked well, both for us and the others in similar circumstances.


Edited by Wisbech Eagle (20 Jul 2017 11.04am)

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

ideaair Flag Ide Hill 20 Jul 17 11.44am

This is a most interesting rangen of opinions and forgetting the usual individuals who seem to take every opportunity to slag off with their brand of bad language and those who always seek to blame Steve Parrish for everything- the ater should remember that if he had not been prepared to put up the money to keep the club from going bankrupt there would not be a CPFC today.

Big Sam aved us from relegation by insisting that a clean sheet was more important than scoring 4 goals and loosing 5-4.

Frank 's defence in this game was wide open and had Liverpool stacked more often instead of practising holding the ball the score would have been higher than 2-9.

The points that "Spender" makes are wel written and make good sense. It is only the 1st game and we must wait and see how Frank tightens up our defence

Not seeming to be able to get Sako from Liverpool is a major blow for us, had he been playing on in this game I do not think we wouls have let in a 35yd shot.

Do not start getting despondent before the season even starts- its what happens between 12th August and Christmas.

Ideaair

 

ideaair Flag Ide Hill 20 Jul 17 11.47am

Sorry about 2-9!! Finfer trouble.

Ideaair

 

eaglesdare Flag 20 Jul 17 12.19pm

For some reason im seeing the way dougie freeedman left us in a new light recently.

I feel it was more parish demanding a nicer way of playing football. and then tried with holloway and pardew.

 

Aray Flag South London 20 Jul 17 12.26pm

Originally posted by the.universal

Look - I know it's very early days and we can't draw too many conclusions yet, but I do have a few concerns:

Recent palace history shows we fare much better keeping it tight and attacking on the break and horrendously badly when we try and open up and outplay better teams:
Holloway (too open) replaced by Pulis (did well).
Pardew (too open) replaced by Allardyce (did well).

We don't have the players to pass out from defence through central midfield, so we will need wholesale player changes to make that happen.

From the friendly today, we took far too many liberties in deep areas with high risk and little potential reward. In this way I was reminded of Holloway.

The other thing I don't like is how gleeful Parish was with getting FdB in. I wonder whether he has fully engaged his rational mind on this one.

So, I'm not making any concrete conclusions just yet, very early days as we all know. But I feel Frank has to get on with defensive / keeper recruitment pronto.

Its a pre-season game. Our first. Get. A. Grip.

 

Mr Palaceman Flag 20 Jul 17 1.52pm

Originally posted by eaglesdare

For some reason im seeing the way dougie freeedman left us in a new light recently.

I feel it was more parish demanding a nicer way of playing football. and then tried with holloway and pardew.

Sorry but this is one of the silliest posts in this thread and there are some very silly posts here.

What you "feel" has no basis in reality. The fact that you are still trying to drag up an old championship manager I find laughable.

Freedman left because he didn't believe that his beloved Palace were as good as Bolton. He thought he was going to a bigger club with more money and his excuse was that "his family were in danger".. Knob.

I remember that even Speroni tweeted WTF when he heard that freedman was going.

Just like Pulis and Bruce and despite being a club legend he didn't want to be here. He just didn't believe in us as a club and where is he today? Right up knob street. I suspect you must be neighbours.

We are now in the Premiership and had, what, 6 coaches/managers in the dug out since then...

Dougie was a fool to himself, Trump is the president of the United States, Britain voted for Brexit and the world is in fact, a globe. There are some things you just need to accept and move on, even though it doesn't "feel" right.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

Pikester Flag Worthing 20 Jul 17 2.06pm

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

and where is he today? Right up knob street. I suspect you must be neighbours.

Made me laugh.

 


You fed me, you bred me, I'll remember your name.

Page 4 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Not getting a good feeling about Frank