You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Just what has gone wrong?
November 16 2026 8.34am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Just what has gone wrong?


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
ItsCPFCforme Flag 16 Sep 17 4.16pm

I am baffled by our quite staggering decline over the last two seasons when we have, on paper, perhaps one of the best squads we have had in a long time (ever in my memory at least). Where is the team that finished 11th then 10th? What on EARTH has precipitated such a disaster? The timing seems to be around the appearance of the Yanks but you can't say they haven't put the money in (apart from the debacle of the recent transfer window that is...)

I don't necessarily think we are already screwed this season - far too early and Hodgson has had no time as of yet - but looking medium term we have been s***e for a while... just when we were on the cusp of perennial mid-table stability. I am pretty sure, looking back on threads from a few seasons back, that older posters said 'it's the Palace way to screw it up'. Well, you seem right! But why is that?

 

Painter Flag Croydon 16 Sep 17 4.26pm

Confidence is shot to pieces, once we go a goal behind, game over.
Roy has a hell of a job, not impossible, but he needs a few lucky breaks.

 

cp forever Flag south london 16 Sep 17 4.32pm

Completely agree, stoic patience is the name of the game for us for quite a while to come, we also suffer from the lack of confidence which is adding to the problems at home games. I just hope Roy is made of the stuff that will help the players get through this.

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 16 Sep 17 4.33pm

Being taught to play like Barcelona and then like Fulham team of a ymfew years back.. Very regimented rather than free flowing.. Mall in the space of five games has probably done the players heads in

 

chateauferret Flag 16 Sep 17 4.34pm

Assuming we end up eight games gone and nulle points we will have eleven games left until the halfway point and we will need to win six of them if we aren't to be cut adrift by then.

Leicester
Wet Spam
Seaweed
Bournemouth
Stoke
Toon

 


============
The Ferret
============

miles18 Flag Telford 16 Sep 17 4.37pm

Starts with the owners.

Players going through so many managers isn't good.

 



.

BigNasty12 Flag Halifax 16 Sep 17 4.45pm

Originally posted by ItsCPFCforme

I am baffled by our quite staggering decline over the last two seasons when we have, on paper, perhaps one of the best squads we have had in a long time (ever in my memory at least). Where is the team that finished 11th then 10th? What on EARTH has precipitated such a disaster? The timing seems to be around the appearance of the Yanks but you can't say they haven't put the money in (apart from the debacle of the recent transfer window that is...)

I don't necessarily think we are already screwed this season - far too early and Hodgson has had no time as of yet - but looking medium term we have been s***e for a while... just when we were on the cusp of perennial mid-table stability. I am pretty sure, looking back on threads from a few seasons back, that older posters said 'it's the Palace way to screw it up'. Well, you seem right! But why is that?


Hold it I thought Roy Hodgson's direct style would be the answer for these players? It shouldn't take ANYTIME for these guys to get the Direct Style of Roy Hodgson. After all the direct style is the ONLY way we can play. Maybe just maybe it isn't that at all. Maybe just maybe it's the players like Joel Ward, Wayne Hennessey, Jason Puncheon, James McArthur, Bakary Sako, and Chung-yong Lee are not Premier League quality now or ever in some instances. Maybe the Board, Chairman Saint Steve (genuflect when you say that Pal), and the Americans should've backed Frank de Boer in the Summer Transfer Window. #HodgsonOut

 

Painter Flag Croydon 16 Sep 17 4.47pm

Originally posted by miles18

Starts with the owners.

Players going through so many managers isn't good.

Hasn't done Watford any harm!

Swansea have a fair churn of managers as well.

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 16 Sep 17 4.48pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Assuming we end up eight games gone and nulle points we will have eleven games left until the halfway point and we will need to win six of them if we aren't to be cut adrift by then.

Leicester
Wet Spam
Seaweed
Bournemouth
Stoke
Toon

This period of games which falls in November will, in my opinion define our season. We have a block of 5/6 games all against mid table to lower table teams.

How we fare in this period will determine our fate I believe.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

geoff Flag Midhurst 16 Sep 17 4.48pm

Credit where it's due it's only taken us 5 days to learn to play like England against Iceland!!!! Where has it gone wrong.....top down!!!!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 Sep 17 4.57pm

Originally posted by BigNasty12


Hold it I thought Roy Hodgson's direct style would be the answer for these players? It shouldn't take ANYTIME for these guys to get the Direct Style of Roy Hodgson. After all the direct style is the ONLY way we can play. Maybe just maybe it isn't that at all. Maybe just maybe it's the players like Joel Ward, Wayne Hennessey, Jason Puncheon, James McArthur, Bakary Sako, and Chung-yong Lee are not Premier League quality now or ever in some instances. Maybe the Board, Chairman Saint Steve (genuflect when you say that Pal), and the Americans should've backed Frank de Boer in the Summer Transfer Window. #HodgsonOut

After 11 and a few more the rest aren't good enough which is why Frank should've waited for his 'revolution' after promising 'evolution.' Or at least we had a full strength 11 and maybe some points, confidence and momentum but alas, he didn't want to consider that.

He and Parish were responsible for the transfers. Parish is generally late and rumour is Frank either lacked input or wasn't interested in particular players or changed his mind. He's used to not having to do it. He should've been sacked as soon as they realised he was rushing the project and well before the season.

 


COYP

richardxtra Flag Kettering 16 Sep 17 4.58pm

Could it be that we have a squad full of players on the decline?
Cabaye
Puncheon
Dann
Tomkins
McCarther

All nearing 30 or over. Add

Ward
Benteke
Henessey

Who are in poor form and confidence shot and we don't have the nucleus for a team that is going to survive. I worry that we can only play one way and have no plan B regarding a striker. It doesn't look good to me.

 

heath_eagle Flag haywards heath 16 Sep 17 4.58pm

No sustained form for nearly 2 years.
3 managers quiting without having another job to go to.
Today's team was made up of signings from 7 managers.
Boardroom disharmony, I understand Parish didn't even know FDB had been sacked by the Americans hence his drunk sounding twittering on Sunday night.
An extremely poor transfer window that didn't address urgent needs.
And to top it all reports / rumours of player power.
Good luck Roy.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 Sep 17 4.58pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Assuming we end up eight games gone and nulle points we will have eleven games left until the halfway point and we will need to win six of them if we aren't to be cut adrift by then.

Leicester
Wet Spam
Seaweed
Bournemouth
Stoke
Toon

You don't need to win that many because in the last 10 or so games you can and teams do pick up more than 1 point per game.

 


COYP

dreamwaverider Flag London 16 Sep 17 5.43pm

The hard facts are with Zaha and Sakho we will be very average. Without them we are simply not good enough.
Those two coming back soon will improve us and we might win again by scoring some goals. But we must be favourites for relegation right now.
All the above posts pointing out very valid issues just add to our woes.
We are going to struggle.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 16 Sep 17 5.53pm

The football has been so sh@t this season that the only thing I enjoy on match days is a pint beforehand and my trip to the chicken shop afterwards.

My son wants a new Palace shirt. Normally I would get his favourite player printed on the back - this year i'm thinking about getting MORLEYS emblazoned across the back as its the best thing about our Saturdays at the moment.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Del7 Flag 16 Sep 17 5.54pm

We will know our fait by Christmas, regrettable as it may sound but we will be all but relegated by the time that we play Arsenal on Boxing Day, just in time for the players agents to start sorting out their moves .... I suspect that we wil end up doing a Blackburn,Wigan, Blackpool and dare I say it Charlton as we slip deep into decline and debt.
I just can't see any reaction, a new manager today and the response from the players was .............. Naff all !

 

Zschopautaler Flag 16 Sep 17 5.55pm

We brought a bit of American money to Selhurst Park and these guys pull the strings. They have no idea about football or the premier league. Liverpool and Man Utd both had problems with Americans and they are far bigger clubs than Palace.
Parish is their man to do the dirty work.I appreciate they need to try to protect their investment,I think they might loose some of their money. It won't hurt them very much they have enough, but they are destroying Crystal Palace.

 

The Dolphin Flag 16 Sep 17 5.59pm

When Parish kept faith with Pardew after the 2016 Cup Final we were toast.
We have never recovered despite staying up.
When they are all fit we have a good first team but we are unbalanced and short on quality.
I hope i am wrong but with Hodgson in charge we have no inspiration either.
Relegation is staring us in the face already and sadly for the first time ever i have to look at Steve Parish - i think he has made one error too many now.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 Sep 17 6.03pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

The football has been so sh@t this season that the only thing I enjoy on match days is a pint beforehand and my trip to the chicken shop afterwards.

My son wants a new Palace shirt. Normally I would get his favourite player printed on the back - this year i'm thinking about getting MORLEYS emblazoned across the back as its the best thing about our Saturdays at the moment.

You have problems if the highlight of your week is a visit to a morleys chicken shop.

 


COYP

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Just what has gone wrong?