This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
You obviously think our squad is too big! Think some of us, including myself actually think the opposite.
|
|
|
Originally posted by loosebolts
And who do we keep for the rest of the season?! You're proposing to rip the heart and soul out of the squad? We need more players, not to get rid of what would be good squad players, even first XI on their day.
We won't get rid of all of them because clubs won't take certain ones at current wages and form. We currently only have 1 place for a striker so we have to move out a few in January. It's academic re: survival imo as Parish has likely nailed on relegation. It's a fair shout for the summer and tbh there's going to be more leaving in the summer. All those first on the team sheet players all sold. Edited by Rudi Hedman (03 Oct 2017 9.28am)
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by kev64
Nobody is going to purchase our out of contract players in Jan, when they are released in June. Plus if we're still well in the mire come Jan, players like Sako, JM, JW WH and Jules will be needed for the championship. The cost of replacing them 20 plus mill. The only question is why did we sign Mutch on a 5 yr deal ...
Where did I suggest that jules and Jimmy Mac should be let go ? Joel Ward as I understand it does not want to sign a new contract currently and therefore it is better for us to sell him if possible. If we are relegated players such as Hennessey and Sako will not get us back up. If as you say Sako and Hennessey are useful in the Championship ,then I would suggest that some desperate clubs in the Championship may come knocking in Jan - for a reasonable price of course.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan
You obviously think our squad is too big! Think some of us, including myself actually think the opposite. Not at all, the squad is just full of players that need to be moved on as they will not do a good enough job for us in either division at current levels. As I suggested it is time for Lumeka and Lokilo and the rest to fill the gaps - I am certain they will battle harder in their positions than some of those mentioned.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Palace in the Blood
The original poster is living in cloud cuckoo land. No firm descisions will be taken on out of contract players until our position is clearer. If we are in championship contract offers will be less for obvious reasons and will likely be less than they are on now This means some may decide to sign pre-contract agreements. The January window will be used to increase depth of squad a new striker/goalkeeper. If we are looking a relegation Certs these will be players for championship and if we are still in with a chance of keeping our EPL status then I would expect to see solid EPL quality professionals arrive not names. If we are certs for relegation I think we may sell Sakho, Benteke Amdros and possibly Wilf in January. Purely as we may get better prices then. This money will be used to build a squad capable of playing in Championship or lower EPL
I have suggested clearing out the dead wood (Cabaye being the exception - really like him but his best days are behind him). 7 out 3 kept and a Striker, Keeper and Right Back brought in. Overall wages reduced by using some of the younger talented players Lumeka, Lokilo, Wan Bissaka as back up. The whole point of clearing out the dead wood is to give us a chance of staying up - if we continue to play Ward, Sako, Lee, Hennessey, Damo and Kelly then we will be down. I cannot see us being certs for relegation by January and you say Ian in Cloud Cuckoo Land ?
|
|
|
Originally posted by CoombsyEagle
Not at all, the squad is just full of players that need to be moved on as they will not do a good enough job for us in either division at current levels. As I suggested it is time for Lumeka and Lokilo and the rest to fill the gaps - I am certain they will battle harder in their positions than some of those mentioned. We're in a bad place because the good ones are too expensive to keep and the sh1t ones I couldn't trust to perform in the championship. The only player I think fits is Jimmy. Either too expensive to keep or too sh1t to keep and possibly deluded to think the offer isn't high enough. It will be about 10 players we'd need to move out to completely address it all. I hope they're planning for either league and not the usual leave it to the last hour or just not fill a position.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by CoombsyEagle
I have suggested clearing out the dead wood (Cabaye being the exception - really like him but his best days are behind him). 7 out 3 kept and a Striker, Keeper and Right Back brought in. Overall wages reduced by using some of the younger talented players Lumeka, Lokilo, Wan Bissaka as back up. The whole point of clearing out the dead wood is to give us a chance of staying up - if we continue to play Ward, Sako, Lee, Hennessey, Damo and Kelly then we will be down. I cannot see us being certs for relegation by January and you say Ian in Cloud Cuckoo Land ? You are suggesting decimating the depth of squad in January when at we will most probably be around relegation zone due to our bad start. The young players you suggest do not need to be in 25 anyway. If we were to place Hennessey, Ward and Kelly on market we would get buyers. We already need 1 keeper so we would need 2 and we need replacements for other 2. The replacements will be on EPL wages so little if any saving. Cabaye I agree with you is past his best but I am not sure we will get a buyer and he will want to see contract out. Most of the others you suggest other than Sako (I can see him going back to Wolves) we are unlikely to find buyers due to wages. Of the players you suggest keeping Jules may stay but is not adequate cover in EPL. McArthur will not extend unless he is a first team regular so I think he will move on. Freddie time will tell but he is not EPL (or championship) level at present. The priorities in January have to be getting cover where we need it. Players like Ward and Kelly are adequate bench players at worst so in my view will be kept till our future is clearer.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Palace in the Blood
You are suggesting decimating the depth of squad in January when at we will most probably be around relegation zone due to our bad start. The young players you suggest do not need to be in 25 anyway. If we were to place Hennessey, Ward and Kelly on market we would get buyers. We already need 1 keeper so we would need 2 and we need replacements for other 2. The replacements will be on EPL wages so little if any saving. Cabaye I agree with you is past his best but I am not sure we will get a buyer and he will want to see contract out. Most of the others you suggest other than Sako (I can see him going back to Wolves) we are unlikely to find buyers due to wages. Of the players you suggest keeping Jules may stay but is not adequate cover in EPL. McArthur will not extend unless he is a first team regular so I think he will move on. Freddie time will tell but he is not EPL (or championship) level at present. The priorities in January have to be getting cover where we need it. Players like Ward and Kelly are adequate bench players at worst so in my view will be kept till our future is clearer. As we only have 1 spare place in the squad, we're going to have to sell/release a couple before we can get the 2 or 3 players we will need.
|
|
|
Originally posted by spartakev2
As we only have 1 spare place in the squad, we're going to have to sell/release a couple before we can get the 2 or 3 players we will need. As long as we have more than 25 senior players they don't need to be named in squad. Which although a waste of money (We are good at that) should not stop other players coming in.
|
|
|
Is this true? Can anyone confirm? Originally posted by CoombsyEagle
Where did I suggest that jules and Jimmy Mac should be let go ? Joel Ward as I understand it does not want to sign a new contract currently and therefore it is better for us to sell him if possible. If we are relegated players such as Hennessey and Sako will not get us back up. If as you say Sako and Hennessey are useful in the Championship ,then I would suggest that some desperate clubs in the Championship may come knocking in Jan - for a reasonable price of course.
|
|
|
Well I would like to know why Sako and Hennessy who are proven championship players would then have to go? Obviously there will be a lot of people moving on (Wilf, Sakho, Cabaye, Milo, Benteke, Townsend come to mind first) , but you talk about selling players on relatively high wages as an easy task. You don't really think anyone is going to take Mutch or Ward and pay us millions do you? Originally posted by CoombsyEagle
Not at all, the squad is just full of players that need to be moved on as they will not do a good enough job for us in either division at current levels. As I suggested it is time for Lumeka and Lokilo and the rest to fill the gaps - I am certain they will battle harder in their positions than some of those mentioned.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan
Is this true? Can anyone confirm? While FDB was manager this came out. Whilst I think there was probably some truth to this at the time,as FDB had made it clear he didn't rate him I think that he may be more open to staying now
|
|
|
He should consider himself bloody lucky to be anywhere near a premier league squad and would be very surprised if another club even a decent championship club would want him. My god, what did he do for the first and last goal on Saturday. Has been embarrassingly poor imo. Originally posted by Palace in the Blood
While FDB was manager this came out. Whilst I think there was probably some truth to this at the time,as FDB had made it clear he didn't rate him I think that he may be more open to staying now
|
|
|
Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan
Is this true? Can anyone confirm?
Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five! |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.