You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > FYP podding with parish and bowett tonight.
November 16 2026 7.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

FYP podding with parish and bowett tonight.


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Maine Eagle Flag USA 20 Jan 18 8.50pm

Originally posted by Painter

Someone like Dougie Freeman.

I would rather have someone else, a real football man, run the transfer side of it, without his input

You forgot to bold the important bit. Would also rather have someone who actually has some experience as a director of football (or whatever DF is) than another "jobs for the boys" move by SP. He said his favorite Palace goal ever was scored by Freedman, then goes and hires the guy. I wonder if he hired him because he was the best man for the job, or for a different reason, waddya reckon?

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Painter Flag Croydon 20 Jan 18 9.11pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

I would rather have someone else, a real football man, run the transfer side of it, without his input

You forgot to bold the important bit. Would also rather have someone who actually has some experience as a director of football (or whatever DF is) than another "jobs for the boys" move by SP. He said his favorite Palace goal ever was scored by Freedman, then goes and hires the guy. I wonder if he hired him because he was the best man for the job, or for a different reason, waddya reckon?

Who would you have?

You have no idea what Freeman does or what transfers are being worked on or why they are not progressing. Its easier just to blindly criticize without any insight as to what is going on.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 20 Jan 18 9.33pm

Originally posted by Painter

Who would you have?

You have no idea what Freeman does or what transfers are being worked on or why they are not progressing. Its easier just to blindly criticize without any insight as to what is going on.

I would have someone other than Parish running the club if I could choose, I can google people running football clubs well around the world, as can you, I would have one of them (as opposed to someone who makes awful mistakes all the time, like Parish).

Freedman is fine but he should be autonomous and not be beholding to Parish for transfer decisions, or he should report to someone who knows what they are doing. Correct, we all only have the insight of what we can see with our own eyes (1) and what the people say (2). re 1 - we are in the midst of a massive injury crisis, on the back of the most mismanaged transfer window in the history of the club, on the back of the longest, most protracted and painful manager search I can ever remember, which yielded the worst managerial appointment in the history of the club. So Parish is really on a roll. Re (2) he basically admitted he never likes to sign a player except on the last day of the window because he thinks you cannot get value otherwise.

Firstly why reveal your thinking to people you are negotiating with, and secondly how about putting that nonsense aside for once and doing what is so blatantly obviously needed that a 3 year old could figure it out - we need more first team options NOW. Here we go again though, no urgency, no decisiveness, players linked all over the shop, this one having a medical, that one in a meeting with the club, blah blah blah. We should have signed at least 1 player by now to give the club a shot in the arm and give our manager something to be happy about.

Edited by Maine Eagle (20 Jan 2018 9.34pm)

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 20 Jan 18 9.52pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

I would have someone other than Parish running the club if I could choose, I can google people running football clubs well around the world, as can you, I would have one of them (as opposed to someone who makes awful mistakes all the time, like Parish).

Freedman is fine but he should be autonomous and not be beholding to Parish for transfer decisions, or he should report to someone who knows what they are doing. Correct, we all only have the insight of what we can see with our own eyes (1) and what the people say (2). re 1 - we are in the midst of a massive injury crisis, on the back of the most mismanaged transfer window in the history of the club, on the back of the longest, most protracted and painful manager search I can ever remember, which yielded the worst managerial appointment in the history of the club. So Parish is really on a roll. Re (2) he basically admitted he never likes to sign a player except on the last day of the window because he thinks you cannot get value otherwise.

Firstly why reveal your thinking to people you are negotiating with, and secondly how about putting that nonsense aside for once and doing what is so blatantly obviously needed that a 3 year old could figure it out - we need more first team options NOW. Here we go again though, no urgency, no decisiveness, players linked all over the shop, this one having a medical, that one in a meeting with the club, blah blah blah. We should have signed at least 1 player by now to give the club a shot in the arm and give our manager something to be happy about.

Edited by Maine Eagle (20 Jan 2018 9.34pm)

Parish is doing a bloody fantastic job though. You really can’t deny that as we sit at the top table for our record breaking 5th straight year. I’d like to know how you’re measuring his failures against his success barometer of what I just mentioned. Because the successes far exceed the failures.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

the.universal 20 Jan 18 10.07pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

I would have someone other than Parish running the club if I could choose, I can google people running football clubs well around the world, as can you, I would have one of them (as opposed to someone who makes awful mistakes all the time, like Parish).

Freedman is fine but he should be autonomous and not be beholding to Parish for transfer decisions, or he should report to someone who knows what they are doing. Correct, we all only have the insight of what we can see with our own eyes (1) and what the people say (2). re 1 - we are in the midst of a massive injury crisis, on the back of the most mismanaged transfer window in the history of the club, on the back of the longest, most protracted and painful manager search I can ever remember, which yielded the worst managerial appointment in the history of the club. So Parish is really on a roll. Re (2) he basically admitted he never likes to sign a player except on the last day of the window because he thinks you cannot get value otherwise.

Firstly why reveal your thinking to people you are negotiating with, and secondly how about putting that nonsense aside for once and doing what is so blatantly obviously needed that a 3 year old could figure it out - we need more first team options NOW. Here we go again though, no urgency, no decisiveness, players linked all over the shop, this one having a medical, that one in a meeting with the club, blah blah blah. We should have signed at least 1 player by now to give the club a shot in the arm and give our manager something to be happy about.

Edited by Maine Eagle (20 Jan 2018 9.34pm)

Life is not so simple. You clearly have not listened to the latest podcast. It’s really worth a listen and I defy you to not like Steve Parish more after hearing him speak at length about the club he loves.

 


Vive le Roy!

Painter Flag Croydon 20 Jan 18 10.08pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

I would have someone other than Parish running the club if I could choose, I can google people running football clubs well around the world, as can you, I would have one of them (as opposed to someone who makes awful mistakes all the time, like Parish).

Freedman is fine but he should be autonomous and not be beholding to Parish for transfer decisions, or he should report to someone who knows what they are doing. Correct, we all only have the insight of what we can see with our own eyes (1) and what the people say (2). re 1 - we are in the midst of a massive injury crisis, on the back of the most mismanaged transfer window in the history of the club, on the back of the longest, most protracted and painful manager search I can ever remember, which yielded the worst managerial appointment in the history of the club. So Parish is really on a roll. Re (2) he basically admitted he never likes to sign a player except on the last day of the window because he thinks you cannot get value otherwise.

Firstly why reveal your thinking to people you are negotiating with, and secondly how about putting that nonsense aside for once and doing what is so blatantly obviously needed that a 3 year old could figure it out - we need more first team options NOW. Here we go again though, no urgency, no decisiveness, players linked all over the shop, this one having a medical, that one in a meeting with the club, blah blah blah. We should have signed at least 1 player by now to give the club a shot in the arm and give our manager something to be happy about.

Edited by Maine Eagle (20 Jan 2018 9.34pm)

I doubt that you have ever tried to buy a footballer, but you appear to think its as easy as buying a loaf of bread.
Unless you pay way over the value of the player, its obviously not easy. You have to find a player that can fit straight into the first team, the player needs to want to come, his club must want to sell ( if he is any good, why would they? ), need to negotiate via his agent, agree terms, get a medical done, our manager must agree to him being added to the squad.
Southampton are in the bottom 3, have £75m from Van Dyke sale, but have bought nobody and they held up as a wonderfully run club.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 20 Jan 18 10.40pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Parish is doing a bloody fantastic job though. You really can’t deny that as we sit at the top table for our record breaking 5th straight year. I’d like to know how you’re measuring his failures against his success barometer of what I just mentioned. Because the successes far exceed the failures.

What successes? The only good hires he has made are well known names, anyone could hire Warnock, Allardyce, Pulis and Hodgson. The one time he tried to do something different he totally fouled it up with FDB. He has the right intentions on the business side of the club, but at the football side he is hopeless. Could you please list his successes, other than staying in the league, which has mostly been despite Parish rather than thanks to him. What other premier league chairman would have allowed us to walk out of the last transfer window with no keeper or strikers signed? We then sacked off a young keeper to make a squad space and didnt bring anyone in. Its amateur hour time and again.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 20 Jan 18 10.42pm

Originally posted by the.universal

Life is not so simple. You clearly have not listened to the latest podcast. It’s really worth a listen and I defy you to not like Steve Parish more after hearing him speak at length about the club he loves.

My first comment on this thread stated that I had in fact just listened to Parish go on for about 2 hours on FYP. Please read it. It makes me more and more sure that Parish is not cut out for this line of work.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 20 Jan 18 10.49pm

Originally posted by Painter

I doubt that you have ever tried to buy a footballer, but you appear to think its as easy as buying a loaf of bread.
Unless you pay way over the value of the player, its obviously not easy. You have to find a player that can fit straight into the first team, the player needs to want to come, his club must want to sell ( if he is any good, why would they? ), need to negotiate via his agent, agree terms, get a medical done, our manager must agree to him being added to the squad.
Southampton are in the bottom 3, have £75m from Van Dyke sale, but have bought nobody and they held up as a wonderfully run club.

Dont mean to be glib but what makes you be so sure of that, have you signed any players? Please check Southampton's squad depth compared to ours, and their current injury list.

Yes you list all of the things that are hard about getting transfers done. They are the same factors which exist for every club, in every league, on the first or last day of a transfer window. Parish SHOULD have paid over the odds for Niasse or Tosun, and paid their high agent fee requests or whatever it was, because allowing us to only have 1 fit premier league striker is absolutely scandalous and negligent in the extreme, its real schoolboy stuff.

We have no clue when it comes to squad management or cohesive long term planning regarding transfers. Far too many players have no competition and that breeds complacency. I dont have a personal vendetta against Parish, I just want to see someone competent and capable to run the club properly. The last transfer window, and the FDB manager searches were not run competently or with any nous whatsoever, they were calamitous and amateurish.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

the.universal 20 Jan 18 11.19pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

My first comment on this thread stated that I had in fact just listened to Parish go on for about 2 hours on FYP. Please read it. It makes me more and more sure that Parish is not cut out for this line of work.

In which case I wholeheartedly disagree with you.

Your reply about who you'd rather have in charge "I'd just google it". That's such a silly comment it's hard to know where to start. So, you just google a chairman and then they turn up, right?! A bit like UberEats, but with multimillionaires.

Maybe let's narrow it down. I'll ask you, who has done a better job as chairman of Crystal Palace than Steve Parish.

Goldberg, Noades, Jordan..... any others you can remember?

 


Vive le Roy!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 20 Jan 18 11.27pm

Maine, I concur with a lot of your criticisms of Parish and it's true that his escape artist managers have dug him and us out of the sh1t. I also agree that the money should've been paid out for either Tosun or Niasse, and looking at it Tosun was more acceptable to Parish going by the cheek of the relatives acting as Niasse's agents.

But the problem is that that was the traditional and conventional summer window and the January window is quite different. You're right the summer was a shambles, as it was the summer before, but it's unlikely it can be corrected until 2 days or 2 hours before the window closes.

By all means moan like a p*** star if on the 1st February we have only Benteke as a forward plus other vulnerabilities.

 


COYP

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 20 Jan 18 11.28pm

Originally posted by the.universal

In which case I wholeheartedly disagree with you.

Your reply about who you'd rather have in charge "I'd just google it". That's such a silly comment it's hard to know where to start. So, you just google a chairman and then they turn up, right?! A bit like UberEats, but with multimillionaires.

Maybe let's narrow it down. I'll ask you, who has done a better job as chairman of Crystal Palace than Steve Parish.

Goldberg, Noades, Jordan..... any others you can remember?

Whilst I agree with the thrust of your point.....Arthur Wait?

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

the.universal 20 Jan 18 11.41pm

Originally posted by Mr_Gristle

Whilst I agree with the thrust of your point.....Arthur Wait?

I'm not familiar with his work, but I'm guessing he must have done something right.

 


Vive le Roy!

Maine Eagle Flag USA 20 Jan 18 11.51pm

Originally posted by the.universal

In which case I wholeheartedly disagree with you.

Your reply about who you'd rather have in charge "I'd just google it". That's such a silly comment it's hard to know where to start. So, you just google a chairman and then they turn up, right?! A bit like UberEats, but with multimillionaires.

Maybe let's narrow it down. I'll ask you, who has done a better job as chairman of Crystal Palace than Steve Parish.

Goldberg, Noades, Jordan..... any others you can remember?

The question was "who would you rather have" which is the lazy cop out response to anyone who dares to question if Parish is the right man to lead the club. Before Parish and co turned up they had just as much reason to run the club as the next man. Well, except one glaring omission which is that other that being fans of Palace they werent involved in football whatsoever. Lastly yes how about Arthur Wait??? You throw them up I will knock them out of the park, that was an easy one, universal.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

the.universal 20 Jan 18 11.59pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

The question was "who would you rather have" which is the lazy cop out response to anyone who dares to question if Parish is the right man to lead the club. Before Parish and co turned up they had just as much reason to run the club as the next man. Well, except one glaring omission which is that other that being fans of Palace they werent involved in football whatsoever. Lastly yes how about Arthur Wait??? You throw them up I will knock them out of the park, that was an easy one, universal.

Why you want to run down the person overseeing our most successful period ever is beyond me. Maybe just spend a few moments appreciating where we are now, and where we have been.

No-one is above criticism but SP is doing a good job based on the history of our club.

 


Vive le Roy!

Maine Eagle Flag USA 21 Jan 18 12.02am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Maine, I concur with a lot of your criticisms of Parish and it's true that his escape artist managers have dug him and us out of the sh1t. I also agree that the money should've been paid out for either Tosun or Niasse, and looking at it Tosun was more acceptable to Parish going by the cheek of the relatives acting as Niasse's agents.

But the problem is that that was the traditional and conventional summer window and the January window is quite different. You're right the summer was a shambles, as it was the summer before, but it's unlikely it can be corrected until 2 days or 2 hours before the window closes.

By all means moan like a p*** star if on the 1st February we have only Benteke as a forward plus other vulnerabilities.

My issue is that Parish doesnt show me that he can learn from his mistakes, Rudi. This is much bigger than just this transfer window, but he has just shown me once again how, IMHO, he doesnt go about things the right way.

We should have been going hell for leather to bring in at least 1 player by now, and if we have to pay a few million quid over the odds, then you know what, we should have done that.

Sometimes signing a new player is greater than the sum of its parts, meaning the overall shot in the arm it gives the supporters, the players, and the gaffer can be way more significant than that new players' actual performances.

But no - we are still dithering around like normal with transfers.

His lack of evolution and learning is what I find to be the most troubling thing about his tenure. After all of these years how he could quite so spectacularly balls up the FDB manager search is beyond me, it just shouldnt be allowed to happen.

Add that together with the fiasco of not signing a keeper or striker last window, not making an early signing in this window despite what Hogdson calls his worst injury crisis in his career ever; its just too many calamitous mistakes for my liking.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 21 Jan 18 12.07am

Originally posted by the.universal

Why you want to run down the person overseeing our most successful period ever is beyond me. Maybe just spend a few moments appreciating where we are now, and where we have been.

No-one is above criticism but SP is doing a good job based on the history of our club.

Because he isnt any good as a chairman....next question?

You are just going by the numbers now mate. Next you will say "we wouldnt even have a club without Parish!" I get it, and I dont want to diminish that. Parish, Browett and co got off their backsides and did something about the club being on the brink, instead of just talking about it in pubs, or in their case at wine tastings and dinner parties.

They put their money where their mouth was, and they deserve a massive debt of gratitude for that, forever more.

I just dont think Parish is a very good chairman, and doesnt have the right approach to running the club, especially hiring and firing of staff and players. Those 2 facts can co-exist. He saved our hides, but he is not a good chairman.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

the.universal 21 Jan 18 12.30am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Because he isnt any good as a chairman....next question?

You are just going by the numbers now mate. Next you will say "we wouldnt even have a club without Parish!" I get it, and I dont want to diminish that. Parish, Browett and co got off their backsides and did something about the club being on the brink, instead of just talking about it in pubs, or in their case at wine tastings and dinner parties.

They put their money where their mouth was, and they deserve a massive debt of gratitude for that, forever more.

I just dont think Parish is a very good chairman, and doesnt have the right approach to running the club, especially hiring and firing of staff and players. Those 2 facts can co-exist. He saved our hides, but he is not a good chairman.

I didn't mention them saving the club. You bought that up. What I actually said is, he must be a good chairman as he's overseen the most successful period in our history. We are doing well, he is in charge, therefore he is doing well. You are entitled to a different view, but those are the facts. #rafafacts

 


Vive le Roy!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Jan 18 12.39am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

My issue is that Parish doesnt show me that he can learn from his mistakes, Rudi. This is much bigger than just this transfer window, but he has just shown me once again how, IMHO, he doesnt go about things the right way.

We should have been going hell for leather to bring in at least 1 player by now, and if we have to pay a few million quid over the odds, then you know what, we should have done that.

Sometimes signing a new player is greater than the sum of its parts, meaning the overall shot in the arm it gives the supporters, the players, and the gaffer can be way more significant than that new players' actual performances.

But no - we are still dithering around like normal with transfers.

His lack of evolution and learning is what I find to be the most troubling thing about his tenure. After all of these years how he could quite so spectacularly balls up the FDB manager search is beyond me, it just shouldnt be allowed to happen.

Add that together with the fiasco of not signing a keeper or striker last window, not making an early signing in this window despite what Hogdson calls his worst injury crisis in his career ever; its just too many calamitous mistakes for my liking.

These points I agree with and if he wasn't a 17% shareholder he definitely wouldn't be repeated.

Those errors are inexcusable and indeed, as I may have inferred, happened in the summer. We're now in the January window and the factors and variables and shysters change. Right we shouldn't be in that situation but we are so Parish has to correct the wrongs, AGAIN.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (21 Jan 2018 12.39am)

 


COYP

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 21 Jan 18 9.51am

Everton have spent close on £70 million on Pickford, Tosun and Walcott and yet they couldn't beat WBA at home.
Just saying.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > FYP podding with parish and bowett tonight.