This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Cabaye Injury
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
VinceHilaire London 20 Jan 18 5.04pm |
|
|
Just our luck!
Can’t believe he got injured in the flipping 87th minute. Looked quite bad - a kick on the calf and twist of the ankle.
Fingers crossed not serious!
|
Jefroc Crete 20 Jan 18 5.13pm |
|
|
I am really beginning to believe Palace can’t play more than two games in a row without getting a serious injury!
Always remembering walking from the Holmesdale to the Whitehorse end at half time!
|
thai-eagle chiang mai 20 Jan 18 5.27pm |
|
|
Have no reason to criticise Roy H, but why wait so long with substitutions? Especially midfielders covering so much distance......like Yohan Cabaye injuried 5 min. before full time on 1-4. Game was lost anyway and our French maestro has struggled lately.
|
Bromley Eagle Inverness 20 Jan 18 5.27pm |
|
|
Losing at the Arse is what we do. Bank the 0 points and move onto games we can win.
[Link]
|
Chubskip 20 Jan 18 5.30pm |
|
|
Time we went shopping.
|
boo909 Figeac 20 Jan 18 5.57pm |
|
|
I love Cabaye, one of my favorite players but he was wrong for this game Jairo should have started or at the very least been brought on as soon as Roy saw it wasn't working, on the ten minute mark at the latest. Roy has to take some of the blame for this game. His lack of action in the first half is just bizarre, unless as someone else has pointed out that he was trying to make a point to Parish about transfers and if that's true (I'm not 100%% sure it is) he's done it at the expense of one of our most creative players.
Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.
|
dp Tunbridge Wells 20 Jan 18 6.23pm |
|
|
Don’t be daft. Roy is a professional, no way he would risk Cabaye to prove a point. Hopefully we will have a few back for the West Ham game, and another few in, that is where we need a result.
|
mattteo 20 Jan 18 6.33pm |
|
Originally posted by boo909
I love Cabaye, one of my favorite players but he was wrong for this game Jairo should have started or at the very least been brought on as soon as Roy saw it wasn't working, on the ten minute mark at the latest. Roy has to take some of the blame for this game. His lack of action in the first half is just bizarre, unless as someone else has pointed out that he was trying to make a point to Parish about transfers and if that's true (I'm not 100%% sure it is) he's done it at the expense of one of our most creative players.
You would have subbed off a 32 year old respected player like Cabaye on the 10 minute mark?
That's just a big no-no in football. Plus, it wasn't just Cabaye's fault today. I can't see a difference with him subbed off
|
silvertop Portishead 20 Jan 18 6.33pm |
|
|
If serious, a worse event than the loss.
|
boo909 Figeac 20 Jan 18 6.47pm |
|
Originally posted by mattteo
You would have subbed off a 32 year old respected player like Cabaye on the 10 minute mark?
That's just a big no-no in football. Plus, it wasn't just Cabaye's fault today. I can't see a difference with him subbed off
If I was a well respected talented manager who knew my stuff I probably wouldn't have played him in the first place considering we were up against a team that were going to run our midfield ragged. I know I'm clutching at straws here and a lot went wrong and I'm in no way blaming Cabaye. If anything I'm blaming Roy for not doing something sooner. I think in a match where you are 4 down after 16 minutes the "big no-nos" in football should go out the window.
Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.
|
Sportyteacher London 20 Jan 18 6.51pm |
|
|
Time to also shelve the type of players who are not regularly making even the subs bench. Long term, we need a final 25 who are capable of vying for the top spots in both league and cup with scope to rotate. We're nowhere near that level yet.
|
dp Tunbridge Wells 20 Jan 18 6.55pm |
|
Originally posted by boo909
If I was a well respected talented manager who knew my stuff...
I think you should have stopped there.
|
dp Tunbridge Wells 20 Jan 18 7.04pm |
|
Originally posted by Sportyteacher
Time to also shelve the type of players who are not regularly making even the subs bench. Long term, we need a final 25 who are capable of vying for the top spots in both league and cup with scope to rotate. We're nowhere near that level yet.
Good point. I feel that we lost our depth the summer we signed Benteke for our entire budget, or close to it. We ended up with Fryers in our regular first team squad!!!
The trouble is that the sort of players you are talking about are the sort that will be waiting to see if anyone else comes knocking. So patience is required.
|
mattteo 20 Jan 18 7.22pm |
|
Originally posted by boo909
If I was a well respected talented manager who knew my stuff I probably wouldn't have played him in the first place considering we were up against a team that were going to run our midfield ragged. I know I'm clutching at straws here and a lot went wrong and I'm in no way blaming Cabaye. If anything I'm blaming Roy for not doing something sooner. I think in a match where you are 4 down after 16 minutes the "big no-nos" in football should go out the window.
In my opinion, Cabaye is not a slow or lazy player. Anyway, he is twice as fast and hard-working as Bakary Sako. I'd have played Cabaye, I think anyone would have. But I wouldn't have played both Benteke and Sako. And it's not that Sako wouldn't want to run more, he just can't do it anymore with his height and weight. Not in an attacking midfielder or side midfielder position. You already had Benteke as a non-moving man up front. Add to that Sako in a game against Arsenal? For me it's either/or.
|
boo909 Figeac 20 Jan 18 7.23pm |
|
Originally posted by dp
I think you should have stopped there.
My point exactly, I'm not, what do I know. But even you have to admit Roy was slow to react to what was happening. This is the first time since he statrted I've even considered criticising him but I think it's valid in this case.
Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.
|
boo909 Figeac 20 Jan 18 7.26pm |
|
Originally posted by mattteo
In my opinion, Cabaye is not a slow or lazy player. Anyway, he is twice as fast and hard-working as Bakary Sako. I'd have played Cabaye, I think anyone would have. But I wouldn't have played both Benteke and Sako. And it's not that Sako wouldn't want to run more, he just can't do it anymore with his height and weight. Not in an attacking midfielder or side midfielder position. You already had Benteke as a non-moving man up front. Add to that Sako in a game against Arsenal? For me it's either/or.
Not slow or lazy at all, if you look at my original post I say how much I rate him, but he has been tiring very quickly recently at the very least I would have taken him off sooner, I just think we needed what Jairo could bring to the game more than the flair and creativity that Cabaye brings, not better just different for different games.
Edited by boo909 (20 Jan 2018 7.27pm)
Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.
|
chateauferret 20 Jan 18 7.35pm |
|
|
Twisted ankle.
[Link]
============ The Ferret ============
|
southnorwoodhill 20 Jan 18 7.45pm |
|
|
He's done. Decent player but has looked knackered / crocked for a few games now - doubt we'll be seeing him again.
|
alaneagle1 Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 20 Jan 18 8.11pm |
|
Originally posted by dp
Good point. I feel that we lost our depth the summer we signed Benteke for our entire budget, or close to it. We ended up with Fryers in our regular first team squad!!!
The trouble is that the sort of players you are talking about are the sort that will be waiting to see if anyone else comes knocking. So patience is required.
The first part of your post is wrong. In the Summer of 2016 we signed, Benteke,Tomkins,Townsend and Mandanda. It was part funded by selling Bolasie.
Fryers was signed in 2014 so was there to be selected.
Your second comment patience is required is correct.
Palace 13th 2017/18.
|
Spiderman Horsham 20 Jan 18 8.24pm |
|
Originally posted by mattteo
In my opinion, Cabaye is not a slow or lazy player. Anyway, he is twice as fast and hard-working as Bakary Sako. I'd have played Cabaye, I think anyone would have. But I wouldn't have played both Benteke and Sako. And it's not that Sako wouldn't want to run more, he just can't do it anymore with his height and weight. Not in an attacking midfielder or side midfielder position. You already had Benteke as a non-moving man up front. Add to that Sako in a game against Arsenal? For me it's either/or.
You are joking right? (and I love Yohann) You are joking again aren't you? When you say Bakary can't run! He was played in a front 2 not AM nor side midfielder? Not sure what games you watch to be honest
|