You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace Line Up Without Zaha for Everton
November 16 2026 7.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace Line Up Without Zaha for Everton


Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
PALACE FOR EVER Flag London 08 Feb 18 1.05pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Lineup Vs Everton' by Guntrisoft

No Townsend.

 


The pyramid to beat all pyramids!!

[Link]

Find out what team is in which division, eg which division is Coppull United in?

FairweatherEagle Flag London 08 Feb 18 1.12pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Lineup Vs Everton' by Guntrisoft

Is he injured?

 

Baldfella Flag Wigan 08 Feb 18 1.18pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Lineup Vs Everton' by Guntrisoft

Hennessy

Ward TFM Sakho Tomkins PVA

MCArthur Luka Cabaye

Townsend Benteke

Playing Townsend through the middle gives him more licence to shoot on sight!

The bench whatever 7 players they can cobble together they probably won’t get on anyway!

 

PA Flag Bedfordshire 08 Feb 18 1.23pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Lineup Vs Everton' by Guntrisoft

Originally posted by Baldfella

Hennessy

Ward TFM Sakho Tomkins PVA

MCArthur Luka Cabaye

Townsend Benteke

Playing Townsend through the middle gives him more licence to shoot on sight!

The bench whatever 7 players they can cobble together they probably won’t get on anyway!

I reckon I’d go for this line up too.
Difficult to make a case for Sørloth or Rakip until we’ve seen them play.

D

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 08 Feb 18 1.29pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Lineup Vs Everton' by Guntrisoft

Originally posted by Baldfella

Hennessy

Ward TFM Sakho Tomkins PVA

MCArthur Luka Cabaye

Townsend Benteke

Playing Townsend through the middle gives him more licence to shoot on sight!

The bench whatever 7 players they can cobble together they probably won’t get on anyway!


I can't imagine Roy will use a back 3/5. In fact I can't recall him ever doing so, and he puts the team shape before the individuals, so I doubt you'll get your way this weekend!

I'd guess:

Hennessey
TFM Tomkins Sakho PVA
Cabeye Luka Riedewald McArthur
Benteke Townsend

 

fledgling Flag Beckenham 08 Feb 18 1.42pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Ok, let me be more precise. If he had in mind Ward for the left back position, he wouldn't have named both Ward (or TFM, depending on who was starting and who was back-up) and Souare on the bench on the same time. Seems like a waste of space to have someone there who you wouldn't send in no matter what. He'd have named....Mutch or someone

But Ward's a handy addition to the bench as he can cover all the defensive positions and, at a push, holding midfield. Souare could cover left sided offence and defence only. So arguably yes if there was a LB needed Souare would go in ahead off the bench but then that would also depend on how the game was panning out.

I just think Ward gives you that feeling of a 'solid' pro to start a game with, safe pair of hands. Souare's been out for a long while and wasn't he rumoured to be going out on loan? His style is more erratic and I think the emphasis till Wilf's back will be solidity and organisation to avoid getting beaten.

 

Baldfella Flag Wigan 08 Feb 18 1.43pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Lineup Vs Everton' by Guntrisoft

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt


I can't imagine Roy will use a back 3/5. In fact I can't recall him ever doing so, and he puts the team shape before the individuals, so I doubt you'll get your way this weekend!

I'd guess:

Hennessey
TFM Tomkins Sakho PVA
Cabeye Luka Riedewald McArthur
Benteke Townsend

I agree that normally Roy is a strict 4-4-2 man however I think these are extenuating circumstances where we need to pick our strongest team and also bear in mind the opposition! For instance I don’t think Cabaye has the legs for left midfield especially if he is chasing Walcott or Yala for long periods!

 

Norway Eagle Flag Singapore 08 Feb 18 1.44pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Lineup Vs Everton' by Guntrisoft

I LIke this one 2 up front


Hennessy

TFM-----Tomkins-----Sakho-----Van Ahnholt
McCarthur-----Cabaye-----Luka------Chungy


Benteke------Sorloth

 

eddiqc Flag Tunbridge wells 08 Feb 18 1.56pm

Originally posted by fledgling

I just think Ward gives you that feeling of a 'solid' pro to start a game with, safe pair of hands.

Seriously? Please tell me that's sarcasm.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 08 Feb 18 2.00pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Lineup Vs Everton' by Guntrisoft

Hennessey

TFM, Tomkins, Sakho, PVA

Luka, Reidewald,

Townsend, Cabaye, McArthur,

Benteke

I feel that with both Luka and Reidewald in defensive midfield it will nullify Walcott and allow TFM and PVA to get further up the field.

 

Sheks Crows Eye Flag Virginia 08 Feb 18 2.23pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Lineup Vs Everton' by Guntrisoft

I'm ashamed to admit that I forgot about Townsend, has he done enough this year? Recently his service has been good, but on the whole?

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 08 Feb 18 2.36pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I wonder if he still has his pace. If not then no way can he play there. Not sure of his history either, has anyone got any details of where he has played in his career other than LB?

I agree about pace. If he doesn't have it then it can't work but no doubt the club will know. To be fair, he'd need pace to be a good full back because his positioning was never ideal even before his injury.

I believe he is a converted winger btw. I am probably wrong though.

I fully understand why Roy is wary of starting him as a full back. Roy is bound to worry that the accident could have made Pape a more hesitant player.

If he flakes one tackle, that can easily lead to a goal and a much more nervy defence. There's less risk if he has an attacking role.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

TheBigToePunt Flag 08 Feb 18 2.42pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Lineup Vs Everton' by Guntrisoft

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Hennessey

TFM, Tomkins, Sakho, PVA

Luka, Reidewald,

Townsend, Cabaye, McArthur,

Benteke

I feel that with both Luka and Reidewald in defensive midfield it will nullify Walcott and allow TFM and PVA to get further up the field.

Actually this is probably the most likely line up and shape. He could always stick townsend up top if needed.

 

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 08 Feb 18 2.50pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Lineup Vs Everton' by Guntrisoft

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Hennessey

TFM, Tomkins, Sakho, PVA

Luka, Reidewald,

Townsend, Cabaye, McArthur,

Benteke

I feel that with both Luka and Reidewald in defensive midfield it will nullify Walcott and allow TFM and PVA to get further up the field.

Very similar to how we started against Newcastle with McCarthur on the wing, can see this being the starting 11.

 

fledgling Flag Beckenham 08 Feb 18 3.02pm

Originally posted by eddiqc

Seriously? Please tell me that's sarcasm.

Not at all. Under a certain managerial style Ward is a solid PL defender. Admittedly he lost his way a bit but under Roy he was playing well again before getting injured.

 

JtCpfc Flag 08 Feb 18 3.53pm

Originally posted by fledgling

Not at all. Under a certain managerial style Ward is a solid PL defender. Admittedly he lost his way a bit but under Roy he was playing well again before getting injured.

He hasn't lost his way under Roy at all, he's just not a 'solid' as you say, premier league standard defender, TFM is better.

 

mattteo Flag 08 Feb 18 4.05pm

Originally posted by fledgling

Not at all. Under a certain managerial style Ward is a solid PL defender. Admittedly he lost his way a bit but under Roy he was playing well again before getting injured.


He's not quality enough to get your club in the top 10 in the PL. I'd compare him to Simpson from Leicester. He was just...there...when they won the league. Nobody remembers him. Unlike how we remember how good Fuchs was as a left back. But now Simpson is a title winning player.
Like Ward is a Premier League player.
And TFM is not a much better option.
Compare what TFM does with what PVA does on the other side.

 

fledgling Flag Beckenham 08 Feb 18 4.23pm

Originally posted by JtCpfc

He hasn't lost his way under Roy at all, he's just not a 'solid' as you say, premier league standard defender, TFM is better.

I didn't say he'd lost his way under Roy; under Roy he's found some form again and is a 'safe' option at full back.

I think TFM will be better but I feel his positional sense is questionable....although his speed of recovery helps him out. For me as an attacking force he flatters to deceive - his final ball is often woeful and his decision making is poor.

Any way my original point was I think Roy will go with JW ahead of Souare at LB when - in Zaha's absence - I'm assuming not losing will be prioritised in the short term.

 

fledgling Flag Beckenham 08 Feb 18 4.26pm

Originally posted by mattteo


He's not quality enough to get your club in the top 10 in the PL. I'd compare him to Simpson from Leicester. He was just...there...when they won the league. Nobody remembers him. Unlike how we remember how good Fuchs was as a left back. But now Simpson is a title winning player.
Like Ward is a Premier League player.
And TFM is not a much better option.
Compare what TFM does with what PVA does on the other side.

I agree but that's not the point. I'm looking at the next few games where Zaha will be out and I assume Roy's plan will be not to get beat rather than field a side that will elevate us to the top 10.

I'm just saying you know what you're getting with Ward, he's solid, reliable and he'll do a decent job defensively in a team that's set up not to lose.

 

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 08 Feb 18 4.28pm

Originally posted by mattteo


He's not quality enough to get your club in the top 10 in the PL. I'd compare him to Simpson from Leicester. He was just...there...when they won the league. Nobody remembers him. Unlike how we remember how good Fuchs was as a left back. But now Simpson is a title winning player.
Like Ward is a Premier League player.
And TFM is not a much better option.
Compare what TFM does with what PVA does on the other side.

A bit of an unfair comparison given that PVA is 27 and has had 3 or so seasons playing in the Premiership already. TFM is 19 and this is his first season playing regularly. Actually against Newcastle he was up and down the wing like PVA and looked pretty similar in terms of contribution.

 

Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace Line Up Without Zaha for Everton