This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by chris123
I have no reason to doubt your stats - the problem is 97% aren't game changers - it's the critical ones that the error rate has been so prevalent. Yesterday being yet another example. For days and perhaps weeks after a controversial decision, everyone across football has their say. Was it or wasn't it? Should it have been or should it not have been? Despite the replay angles using 'Slow-Mo' and numerous views of this footage often these discussions do not result in agreement. With just seconds to react and all manner of tricks being played on officials by players, a 98% success rate is hugely impressive at a time where refereeing in the PL has got harder - they make 70% more sprints now than they did a few seasons back.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
For days and perhaps weeks after a controversial decision, everyone across football has their say. Was it or wasn't it? Should it have been or should it not have been? Despite the replay angles using 'Slow-Mo' and numerous views of this footage often these discussions do not result in agreement. With just seconds to react and all manner of tricks being played on officials by players, a 98% success rate is hugely impressive at a time where refereeing in the PL has got harder - they make 70% more sprints now than they did a few seasons back.
|
|
|
Originally posted by grumpymort
Regarding our Penalty in some ways you can say we was lucky because Wilfs foot was way too high so ref would of stopped the game for that. At the end of the day we threw away another game it was nothing to do with the ref and had Mane been sent off whos to say we would of gone on to win anyway the past has shown we don't do well against 10 men It had plenty to do with the ref. Who's to say we wouldn't have gone on to win 4-1? We might have drawn. If Benteke had put us 2-1 up we might have won, drawn or lost. No one has a crystal ball, but a referee refusing to enforce the laws of the game definitely had a major effect on that game. Edited by Dangermouse (01 Apr 2018 12.21pm)
That's Life |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
As I mentioned before (And quoted the law), a deliberate handball is not a mandatory caution.All depends on the circumstances. Not seen the TV footage but in Mane's case, to my humble self it didn't look as though he handled the ball to prevent our team getting possession he handled because he thought Liverpool were getting a free kick.But he will know the reason and all of us can only speculate.And we can only speculate as to what Swarbrick was thinking. Why he handled it deliberately is totally irrelevant. He handled it deliberately and as no foul had been given to him it robbed us of having Cabaye and Andros 2 on 1 with van Dyke in the area. It couldn't be any clearer that it was a cautionable offence. Whether he thought he should get a free kick is irrelevant.
That's Life |
|
|
Originally posted by Dangermouse
It had plenty to do with the ref. Who's to say we wouldn't have gone on to win 4-1? We might have drawn. If Benteke had put us 2-1 up we might have won, drawn or list. No one has a crystal ball, but a referee refusing to enforce the laws of the game definitely had a major effect on that game. How can one say that if they had been down to 10 men this would have had a major effect on the game? Over the years I have seen teams go down to 10 men and the other side have struggled to break them down. At the end of the day we lost because of Benteke's pathetic efforts in front of goal and Sakho's inept defending.We saw with our eyes the contribution of Benteke and Sakho - what would have happened if Mane had been sent off his hypothetical and speculative.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
How can one say that if they had been down to 10 men this would have had a major effect on the game? Over the years I have seen teams go down to 10 men and the other side have struggled to break them down. At the end of the day we lost because of Benteke's pathetic efforts in front of goal and Sakho's inept defending.We saw with our eyes the contribution of Benteke and Sakho - what would have happened if Mane had been sent off his hypothetical and speculative.
That's Life |
|
|
Originally posted by Dangermouse
Why he handled it deliberately is totally irrelevant. He handled it deliberately and as no foul had been given to him it robbed us of having Cabaye and Andros 2 on 1 with van Dyke in the area. It couldn't be any clearer that it was a cautionable offence. Whether he thought he should get a free kick is irrelevant. I don't think the scenario I highlighted is that ridiculous. In any event, since my post you highlighted I have seen footage on 'Goals on Sunday and mentioned that it appeared that Mane tried to prevent Cabaye getting on the ball and bursting through, something I never saw at the game. I understand Dermot Gallagher speculated that Swarbrick might have lost some focus in that instant and clearly the decision not to award a second yellow will form part of the post-match analysis of the referee.We can only speculate as to his thinking.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dangermouse
You are of course entitled to your opinion about the views I have expressed. The rest of your post is not worth commenting on.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
For days and perhaps weeks after a controversial decision, everyone across football has their say. Was it or wasn't it? Should it have been or should it not have been? Despite the replay angles using 'Slow-Mo' and numerous views of this footage often these discussions do not result in agreement. With just seconds to react and all manner of tricks being played on officials by players, a 98% success rate is hugely impressive at a time where refereeing in the PL has got harder - they make 70% more sprints now than they did a few seasons back.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I don't think the scenario I highlighted is that ridiculous. In any event, since my post you highlighted I have seen footage on 'Goals on Sunday and mentioned that it appeared that Mane tried to prevent Cabaye getting on the ball and bursting through, something I never saw at the game. I understand Dermot Gallagher speculated that Swarbrick might have lost some focus in that instant and clearly the decision not to award a second yellow will form part of the post-match analysis of the referee.We can only speculate as to his thinking. I speculate he cheated.
That's Life |
|
|
Originally posted by the silurian
I totally refute the allegation that Swarbrick cheated in not awarding a second yellow card.I will certainly defend Swarbrick against this charge.One can only speculate as to his thinking but it was certainly not influenced by any so called "Big club bias" or external influences and all that hogwash. He will have to explain his decision as part of his post-match analysis. Edited by Willo (01 Apr 2018 12.43pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I totally refute the allegation that Swarbrick cheated in not awarding a second yellow card.I will certainly defend Swarbrick against this charge.One can only speculate as to his thinking but it was certainly not influenced by any so called "Big club bias" and all that hogwash. He will have to explain his decision as part of his post-match analysis. Oh goody. When he explains it and they decide he's done wrong do we get awarded the three points?
That's Life |
|
|
Originally posted by Dangermouse
Oh goody. When he explains it and they decide he's done wrong do we get awarded the three points? With respect this is a ridiculous question. The "Three points" we lost were down to Messrs Benteke and Sakho.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
With respect this is a ridiculous question. The "Three points" we lost were down to Messrs Benteke and Sakho. Really. If Mane is rightly sent off does Salah still get that chance. If Mane is rightly sent off do we even create those two chances for Benteke. Tell me exactly how the game pans out, cos I don't know. What I do know is we would have won, drawn or lost. Just would have liked the chance to find out without the ref totally changing the course of the game. Edited by Dangermouse (01 Apr 2018 12.55pm)
That's Life |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I totally refute the allegation that Swarbrick cheated in not awarding a second yellow card.I will certainly defend Swarbrick against this charge.One can only speculate as to his thinking but it was certainly not influenced by any so called "Big club bias" or external influences and all that hogwash. He will have to explain his decision as part of his post-match analysis. Edited by Willo (01 Apr 2018 12.43pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dangermouse
Really. If Mane is rightly sent off does Salah still get that chance. If Mane is rightly sent off do we even create those two chances for Benteke. Tell me exactly how the game pans out, cos I don't know. What I do know is we would have won, drawn or lost. Just would have liked the chance to find out without the ref totally changing the course of the game. Edited by Dangermouse (01 Apr 2018 12.55pm) Precisely which is the point I have been making - we really don't know what would have been the effect of Liverpool going down to 10 men. What we DO know is that Benteke fluffed two chances and Sakho was culpable for both goals.Sick and tired of these late winners at Home.
|
|
|
Originally posted by the silurian
Dear oh dear. Edited by Willo (01 Apr 2018 1.38pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Dear oh dear. Edited by Willo (01 Apr 2018 1.38pm) we do try willo but you can only see one side, the referees side, you never ever admit that they may have made an error (ok you say they make general errors, but you NEVER comment on one specific error, like mark in the cup final or yesterdays failure to award a second PS where was the rhetorical grandstanding?? I cant see it! Edited by the silurian (01 Apr 2018 1.57pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by the silurian
we do try willo but you can only see one side, the referees side, you never ever admit that they may have made an error (ok you say they make general errors, but you NEVER comment on one specific error, like mark in the cup final or yesterdays failure to award a second PS where was the rhetorical grandstanding?? I cant see it! Edited by the silurian (01 Apr 2018 1.57pm) I of course have never attended such a post-match analysis for obvious reasons but I do know how they are conducted. Each PL game is assessed 'Forensically' by a former senior referee who scrutinises every decision using the match footage and 'ProZone' to measure the officials’ technical performance. Match delegates assess the accuracy and consistency of decision making and their management of the match.I understand it is a vigorous evaluation with no stone left unturned. We have witnessed a referee being demoted and clearly if a referee was consistently not performing to standard he would be removed from the Elite list.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I of course have never attended such a post-match analysis for obvious reasons but I do know how they are conducted. Each PL game is assessed 'Forensically' by a former senior referee who scrutinises every decision using the match footage and 'ProZone' to measure the officials’ technical performance. Match delegates assess the accuracy and consistency of decision making and their management of the match.I understand it is a vigorous evaluation with no stone left unturned. We have witnessed a referee being demoted and clearly if a referee was consistently not performing to standard he would be removed from the Elite list. OK thank you...so if at his assessment Swarbrick is adjudged to have made a big error, what is his likely punishment? A fine? Demotion for a game? Of course, he is being judged by other referees who will obviously see things from his perspective! We have witnessed 1 referee being demoted, 1 out of all the referees over the years! Not very stringent then is it! Other than your good self, Souness is the only other pundit who believes he was correct in not booking and sending off mane, hopefully next weeks referee will see any handball by a Palace player as a simple error and let it go with no punishment, but I wont be holding my breath!
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.