You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Kevin Kilbane
November 16 2026 7.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Kevin Kilbane


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
npn Flag Crowborough 23 Apr 18 4.37pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

As much as I love wilf, the problem is that almost every time he gets tackled and ends up on the floor, even if it's not a foul, he sits there waving his arms about claiming he wad fouled. The example on saturday, when the general sense of opinion seems to be that he stumbled for the first penalty claim, he still appealed for the penalty, despite (apparently) telling the defender after the game that it wasn't a penalty. He then spends half the game arguing with opponents. Yes, I know He gets fouled a hell of a lot and gets targeted. But he's our match winner, so he's going to. I just wish sometimes he'd just get up and get on with the game.

Edited by spartakev2 (23 Apr 2018 3.36pm)

I accept that he appeals for penalties he thinks are probably not, but if you're going top criticise people for asking the question, you need to criticise players for putting their arm up for a corner when they know full well the ball has come off them last.

The first wasn't a penalty, but wasn't a dive either - he stayed up at 45 degrees for about 5 paces after the challenge, before gravity finally got the better of him. I'm still not 100% the other was a penalty, but also not a dive.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 23 Apr 18 5.34pm

Just a thought on Wilf's challenge on the keeper.

Why did no-one just say like they used to, "brave goalkeeping"?

Years ago a goalkeeper who came out with his arms at someones feet knew he was going to get clattered in a 50/50 but they did it anyway. The comment then was brave goalkeeping and not, "savage attack by outfield player, send him off".

The game has gone soft, Wilf had every right to try and get a toe on that and personally I thought the keeper did well.

 

Numbers Man Flag Tulse Hill 23 Apr 18 5.44pm

I agree Kevine Kilbane’s comments were an absolute disgrace. Wilf’s trickery in the penalty box will always mean he will lose more than his share of marginal decisions. Watford are a very physical team and he will always receive, unfairly, pretty rough treatment. I seem to remember that Mariappa gave penalties away when he played for us.

 

tshepp897 Flag Dublin - Cabra 23 Apr 18 6.24pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Unfortunately not everyone sees Wilf in the same light as diehard Palace fans do and I don't really see anything wrong with Kilbane's comments as they were his honestly held views.

He was a pundit on national television and was asked a specific question so how can his comments be deemed "unnecessary" when all he did was answer the question and when all is said and done were his comments biased or is it your own view that's biased

I think it is true that we are all one-eyed a little on here. But when KK used the argument about falling into the penalty (while running towards it and being fouled just outside it) as example that Wilf was looking for penalties, he really showed his agenda - that is just pure idiocy and he is not an idiot.

 


The cellophane illusion of a starry sky / Stretched over an open sore.
Big Nothing

SwordFish Flag Peasmarsh,East Sussex 23 Apr 18 8.37pm

In the words of @HLTCO he is a complete #w***puffin

 


“This is a crisis, a large crisis.... in fact if you have a moment, it’s a 12 storey crisis, magnificent entrance hall, carpeting throughout, 24 hour portage , and an enormous sign on the roof saying “This , is a large crisis” - Edmund Blackadder

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 23 Apr 18 8.53pm

Biggest worry for me nowadays and none of these "experts" seem to have a problem with it is the targeting of the oppos star player and the orchestrated appealing. Players like Wilf, are continually fouled by many different players and every time they go down at least 5 of 6 players surround the situation screaming dive. Every time Wilf went down the cheerleading squad sprang into action. Doucoure ran 30 yards to push Wilf. Really, he had that good a view or was he just following orders to get the player booked/sent off? Wilf has admitted that one thing that really annoys him is players fouling him, then trying to pull him up to his feet while screaming at him that he dived. The only time they went off script was when he was tripped just outside the box, then the cheerleading squad all ran up demanding, not that he dived, but that it was outside the area. It's the default setting for defenders nowadays it seems.
Also this weekend we saw Dawson take out Ings, blatant cheating. No one cares. Valencia was given the slip by Alli and he hauled him down as he was heading towards the area. Blatant cheating. No one cares.
Defenders go into every game to cheat. They dive to get themselves out of trouble. They kick, elbow, pull and trip attackers outside the area all game then when a forward makes them pay in the box, we all feel sorry for them. Why do we accept them constantly cheating, but players like Wilf, Alli, Sterling, Richarlison etc are pilloried for making the most of their unfair attentions. Seems to me we've got it all wrong.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

chateauferret Flag 23 Apr 18 9.10pm

Originally posted by Dangermouse

Biggest worry for me nowadays and none of these "experts" seem to have a problem with it is the targeting of the oppos star player and the orchestrated appealing. Players like Wilf, are continually fouled by many different players and every time they go down at least 5 of 6 players surround the situation screaming dive. Every time Wilf went down the cheerleading squad sprang into action. Doucoure ran 30 yards to push Wilf. Really, he had that good a view or was he just following orders to get the player booked/sent off? Wilf has admitted that one thing that really annoys him is players fouling him, then trying to pull him up to his feet while screaming at him that he dived. The only time they went off script was when he was tripped just outside the box, then the cheerleading squad all ran up demanding, not that he dived, but that it was outside the area. It's the default setting for defenders nowadays it seems.
Also this weekend we saw Dawson take out Ings, blatant cheating. No one cares. Valencia was given the slip by Alli and he hauled him down as he was heading towards the area. Blatant cheating. No one cares.
Defenders go into every game to cheat. They dive to get themselves out of trouble. They kick, elbow, pull and trip attackers outside the area all game then when a forward makes them pay in the box, we all feel sorry for them. Why do we accept them constantly cheating, but players like Wilf, Alli, Sterling, Richarlison etc are pilloried for making the most of their unfair attentions. Seems to me we've got it all wrong.

Wise words.

However you forget to mention that many defenders especially at shall we say "certain" clubs also go into each game aiming to maim, cripple and disable forwards like Wilf (or anyone else who's better than them) and are allowed by the refs to get away with it time and time again. Look at Bakary Sako. Or for that matter the disgusting assault committed by Grujic last season on Tomkins. Just two examples of many. And again Wilf, again and again and again.

Edited by chateauferret (23 Apr 2018 9.11pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Mstrobez Flag 23 Apr 18 9.26pm

Originally posted by npn

I accept that he appeals for penalties he thinks are probably not, but if you're going top criticise people for asking the question, you need to criticise players for putting their arm up for a corner when they know full well the ball has come off them last.

The first wasn't a penalty, but wasn't a dive either - he stayed up at 45 degrees for about 5 paces after the challenge, before gravity finally got the better of him. I'm still not 100% the other was a penalty, but also not a dive.

Come on, seriously?

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 23 Apr 18 10.06pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Wise words.

However you forget to mention that many defenders especially at shall we say "certain" clubs also go into each game aiming to maim, cripple and disable forwards like Wilf (or anyone else who's better than them) and are allowed by the refs to get away with it time and time again. Look at Bakary Sako. Or for that matter the disgusting assault committed by Grujic last season on Tomkins. Just two examples of many. And again Wilf, again and again and again.

Edited by chateauferret (23 Apr 2018 9.11pm)

Agree. It really goes without saying that Watford were determined to get Wilf sent or carried off on Saturday. Brighton tried it, Huddersfield succeeded twice and Bournemouth always try it. It's time to clamp down on ALL cheating or just let them get on with it and as painful as it can be, you just have to take the rough with the smooth decisions wise.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 23 Apr 18 10.24pm

Originally posted by Dangermouse

Agree. It really goes without saying that Watford were determined to get Wilf sent or carried off on Saturday. Brighton tried it, Huddersfield succeeded twice and Bournemouth always try it. It's time to clamp down on ALL cheating or just let them get on with it and as painful as it can be, you just have to take the rough with the smooth decisions wise.

Or maybe we need to get a bit nastier. Not saying deliberately hurt people. But i do feel we are a bit 'nice' and need to get a bit more streetwise sometimes.

 

essetwentyone Flag london 23 Apr 18 11.00pm

I’m fed up with this idea that the first one wasn’t a pen - just stumbling . Kami in GOS showed clearly a shirt pull. Anywhere else on the pitch it would be a foul - stumble or no. Why is there a difference between in and out of the penalty area? It was a shirt pull - therefore a foul - therefore a pen . End of !

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 24 Apr 18 5.07am

Originally posted by spartakev2

maybe we need to get a bit nastier. Not saying deliberately hurt people. But i do feel we are a bit 'nice' and need to get a bit more streetwise sometimes.

It wasn't that long ago that someone was quoted as saying that "you don't play Palace and expect to be able to kiss your girlfriend that night"

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 24 Apr 18 5.07am

The speed these players run at, the way things look when slowed down, added with players being able to leave a foot in (to get touched) as an art form, sets people up to fail.

They play the game so many times, they do drills every day - law of averages is if you see a player about to make a challenge, you set yourself up in a specific position and you are getting taken out.

Who was it, for swansea, Olsen? he did it, he dived hoping the player would connect, had he did, it would have looked a perfect foul - unfortunately, the player with drew.

There must be a thousand penalties where if you edited out the defender making the foul, it would look like a dive - by that i mean strikers invite the foul and fall down at the perfect point making the case for a stone wall foul - i say inviting as it is a foul, but the striker knew.

There are also thousand more legit fouls.

This is what wild needs to do, in my opinion, every time he gets fouled or he falls (for whatever reason) just get up and leave the ref to make the decision, sitting there wide eyed, arms in the air - it doesn't do him justice.

 


This was once a quality forum....

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 24 Apr 18 7.37am

A fairer view of the situation than that of Kilbane:

[Link]

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

chateauferret Flag 24 Apr 18 7.46am

What about this from the commentator during last night's Everton v Toon match.

"That's clever from Gayle. A little touch on the defender, just enough to knock him off balance".

Otherwise known as a "foul".

 


============
The Ferret
============

npn Flag Crowborough 24 Apr 18 9.49am

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Come on, seriously?

I didn't say it wasn't, just not 100% (certainly at full speed). It took almost freeze frame to show the foot held up on Mariappa, and I'm trying to be as objective as I can

 

kenners46 Flag sydenham village 24 Apr 18 9.53am

Did anyone see Stirlings dive versus Swansea on Sunday, yet no one says a word

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 24 Apr 18 12.06pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

What about this from the commentator during last night's Everton v Toon match.

"That's clever from Gayle. A little touch on the defender, just enough to knock him off balance".

Otherwise known as a "foul".


On the other hand Gayle was wiped out by Keane late on when he could have been through one on one. Keane got a yellow. Keane clearly cheated, yet no one has a problem with defenders doing this time and again, game after game.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 24 Apr 18 12.10pm

What a knob. 'He's falling into the penalty area' which was a few inches from where he was tripped.

There is a lot of competition, but that is possibly the most stupid comment I have ever heard on MOTD.

Edited by Slimey Toad (24 Apr 2018 12.16pm)

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 24 Apr 18 12.56pm

Originally posted by kenners46

Did anyone see Stirlings dive versus Swansea on Sunday, yet no one says a word

I did. He was on his way down well before he was actually tackled. If that had been wilf he would have been slaughtered in the media.

 

Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Kevin Kilbane