You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Better Achievment - Pulis, Allardyce or Hodgson?
November 16 2026 7.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Better Achievment - Pulis, Allardyce or Hodgson?


Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Midlands Eagle Flag 13 May 18 11.16am

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

He did, but then look at Sam and Roy again. When Roy took over we didn’t even have a goal to our name let alone a point!

True but we had a much better squad that was underperforming badly whereas Pulis didn't have that luxury

 

Welsh Eagle Flag 13 May 18 11.17am

Originally posted by Shufflin

Id say RH. If he keeps this form up who knows? Might even dona Burnley.

The question was which manager has had the greatest achievement in keeping us up!

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 13 May 18 11.19am

Originally posted by Shufflin

Id say RH. If he keeps this form up who knows? Might even dona Burnley ala Dyche and wrangle our way into Europe?

Roy ruled out any such ambitions at this week's press conference and highlighted the dangers of not concentrating on just staying in the PL.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 13 May 18 11.55am

I think we should also consider the quality of the opposition now, has it improved since Pulis time.

I rather think so, this year the PL had no bad teams IMO, West Brom Stoke and the Swans all lot of quality investment stadiums etc. must be quite a blow after that.

Of course you can only play what is in front of you.

 

Aray Flag South London 13 May 18 12.06pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

I think we should also consider the quality of the opposition now, has it improved since Pulis time.

I rather think so, this year the PL had no bad teams IMO, West Brom Stoke and the Swans all lot of quality investment stadiums etc. must be quite a blow after that.

Of course you can only play what is in front of you.

Clubs spending on players/infrastructure doesn’t necessarily translate into performance in the field. Plenty of disjointed squads out there despite expensive purchases.


 

CPFC1965 Flag Warrington 13 May 18 12.13pm

All three are about equal in their influence, Lilies gave us the strength and defensive mentality, Allardyce bought quality and Hodgeson has taught us how to play.All are integral to our premiership status.

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 13 May 18 12.15pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

True but we had a much better squad that was underperforming badly whereas Pulis didn't have that luxury

If I remember rightly, Pulis had a blinding January transfer window which had an immediate impact...

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 13 May 18 12.19pm

Pulis, without question.

Just take a look at that squad and then make your decision.

When your starting XI for the first game back in the prem includes Dobbie and Wilbraham, that should be enough to realise what he had 5 months to work with, plus being so far behind.

Roy has done a great job but he has had a far better squad to work with.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 13 May 18 12.22pm

Roy served up quality football practically without a striker all season. That’s no mean feat.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 13 May 18 12.36pm

Originally posted by pstrutt

Roy served up quality football practically without a striker all season. That’s no mean feat.

He did, but moving Wilfred into a central role along with Andros worked a treat. Which many on here lambasted...

 

Ouzo Dan Flag Behind you 13 May 18 1.09pm

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

He did, but moving Wilfred into a central role along with Andros worked a treat. Which many on here lambasted...

Wilf played as a Striker coming through the Academy, it was only when he made his first team debut he was moved outside.
Ferguson was also planning to play him as a Striker before he left.

I honestly never doubted Wilf's ability to play upfront

 


The mountains are calling & I must go.

Shufflin Flag Wellington 13 May 18 1.27pm

Originally posted by Welsh Eagle

The question was which manager has had the greatest achievement in keeping us up!

Sorry i thought it said who had the best achievement in the dire straits we found ourself in. And then if he could keep it up who knows?

 

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 13 May 18 1.31pm

I love Roy’s style of play. His professionalism, his calm attitude and that he loves the club. He is building a top 7 team.

However, what Pulis achieved with our squad was absolutely remarkable. He turned water into wine. It was truly phenomenal.

Pulis by a country mile.

 

Username Flag Horsham 13 May 18 9.46pm

Hodgson.

Pulis and Allardyce might have both started with ‘worse’ squads, but both had the luxury of splashing the cash in January and bringing in players.

Not only did Roy rely almost entirely on our existing squad, he also had a horrible injury crisis to deal with.

As effective as the other two were, Hodgson has also done it by getting us to play some lovely football. We’ve scored some beautiful team goals this season. His style of play is finally allowing us to take points off the teams we ‘should’ beat. In the past we’ve stayed up knicking results at Anfield or Stamford Bridge, but then losing at home to Burnley etc.

This season we still played well against the big boys, and with a fully fit squad and a bit of luck might have knicked at least one of those games, but we finally seem like we can unlock teams who come to Selhurst for a point.

In terms of development it’s actually a massive step, and exactly what Parish was looking for in the summer.

Also, I’m sure it’s been mentioned already, but although it went very south in the end, Pardew’s first six months were very impressive and should be counted in this discussion. The end of the second Warnock era was comfortbaly the worst I think we’ve played since being back in the Prem. That home loss to Southampton was truly abysmal.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

PalacePhotoMan Flag Wallington 13 May 18 9.57pm

Originally posted by Username

Hodgson.

Pulis and Allardyce might have both started with ‘worse’ squads, but both had the luxury of splashing the cash in January and bringing in players.

Not only did Roy rely almost entirely on our existing squad, he also had a horrible injury crisis to deal with.

As effective as the other two were, Hodgson has also done it by getting us to play some lovely football. We’ve scored some beautiful team goals this season. His style of play is finally allowing us to take points off the teams we ‘should’ beat. In the past we’ve stayed up knicking results at Anfield or Stamford Bridge, but then losing at home to Burnley etc.

This season we still played well against the big boys, and with a fully fit squad and a bit of luck might have knicked at least one of those games, but we finally seem like we can unlock teams who come to Selhurst for a point.

In terms of development it’s actually a massive step, and exactly what Parish was looking for in the summer.

Also, I’m sure it’s been mentioned already, but although it went very south in the end, Pardew’s first six months were very impressive and should be counted in this discussion. The end of the second Warnock era was comfortbaly the worst I think we’ve played since being back in the Prem. That home loss to Southampton was truly abysmal.


Sorry but this season's opening day v Huddersfield, followed by the defeat v Swansea, were the worst 2 matches I've seen here for years. You are right that the Southampton game under Warnock was bad, but to start a season in total disarray with the talent we had on show today available, was unforgivable. RH has turned the season round using the same players available to the Dutch clown, showing him what was possible with this team playing to its strengths and despite our one true centre forward being woefully out of form. It's been nothing short of miraculous.

 


Zaha, Williams, Murray, Ambrose, Scannell.

A 5-man forward line who scored 3 goals in 10 minutes on 27th September 2011 at .......................

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 May 18 10.05pm

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

He did, but moving Wilfred into a central role along with Andros worked a treat. Which many on here lambasted...

Nobody lambasted it because we had no striker to select. It was having no striker as back up that was lambasted.

On which was the best achievement I’d rather leave all of them deserving their merit but Hodgson has us playing the best football. However he now has the issue of possibly 2 midfielders not being here next season.

 


COYP

fozzaisere Flag 13 May 18 10.53pm

Pulis - our squad when he took us on was poor.

 

Cy Bais Flag Minneapolis MN 13 May 18 11.51pm

I'd say Roy because we looked good beating the drop. :-)

 

Eternal Optimist Flag Kentlyn 14 May 18 12.51am

Here is a thought to ponder. If you do the maths, if CP's results from the 8th match onwards had been replicated over the whole season we would have finished where Burnley finished (not sure how the goal difference would have stacked up). So CP might have been playing in Europe next year!

As for who deserves the credit I think it should go to the Board for making the hard decisions about sacking managers and finding new, really effective ones. The obvious concern is why did successive managers burn out or leave?

 

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 14 May 18 1.45am

Originally posted by Eternal Optimist

Here is a thought to ponder. If you do the maths, if CP's results from the 8th match onwards had been replicated over the whole season we would have finished where Burnley finished (not sure how the goal difference would have stacked up). So CP might have been playing in Europe next year!

As for who deserves the credit I think it should go to the Board for making the hard decisions about sacking managers and finding new, really effective ones. The obvious concern is why did successive managers burn out or leave?

Because they clash with Steve Parish. There is no other answer.

 

Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Better Achievment - Pulis, Allardyce or Hodgson?