You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > MOTD (Zaha)
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

MOTD (Zaha)


Page 4 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
CrazyBadger Flag Ware 18 Sep 18 10.42am

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Correct Johnoo,

The tackle at Huddersfield would have been a red also had it been done on Hazard .

Would VAR help ? Not sure as I am sure it is was stated that VAR dor red cards would only be used for cases of mistaken identity. If the Ref chooses to only book the player what can be done ?

Yellow cards for the Capoue tackle and the tackle by the Huddersfield thug on Saturday just give the thugs the green light to put a career threatening tackle in on Wilf every game and not get sent off. Get booked ? no problem pass the fouling onto a team mate that has not been booked.

I disagree, I think that it was given a yellow as the ref was Attempting to Be lenient as it was early in the game; which Is wrong, such things should not determine punishment.

Also, a Couple of seasons back i remember there was a game where Hazard was obviously Targeted - which i think was the last time this issue came up. So the Fact that it was Zaha not Hazard had no affect on the decision.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 18 Sep 18 11.08am


By coming onto MOD and complaining so vehemently Wilf has only shown his concern. This will be noted by other defenders and will be used to intimidate Wilf more.
Palace need to be clever. If Wilf is so marked, by at least two players all the time and more when he has the ball, this must release space for others to use. I do not see much of that. I wonder how defenders would feel,if Wilf went so deep these defenders were well out of position? It is an open field for someone.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 18 Sep 18 11.36am

Originally posted by TheExpatEagle

The funny thing is I remember when our defenders used to kick the opposing strikers all over the pitch and nobody shouted for us to stop.

Anyone remember the matches v Everton in the early 90s? Eric Young breaking Keown's nose (albeit not a striker) in the ZDS Final, etc.

I don't approve of Zaha getting hacked all over the place but what's good for the goose is good for the gander. We can't have double morals about this.


Thats all well and good; but we're not in that era now are we. Tackling is an art, a combination of timing and decision making.

Its eradication has left us with players that do not know how to win a ball cleanly anymore, and as such with players that a far more finely tuned than those of yesteryear (even the 90's) it more dangerous.

In the good old days you could slide in, win the ball as the opponent flies over your head on a muddy wet pitch. It was deemed a good tackle then...not now.

So lets not fall into the trap of comparing it the anything we used to do or see 20 years ago....like Lineker and Shearer did

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 18 Sep 18 11.39am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Wilf would benefit hugely from watching Messi and the way he conducts himself on the pitch. If he controls his temper he destroys opponents. That goal he scored Saturday was as good as any Messi, Ronaldo solo effort, in fact I would go as far as to say it was sublime and that is how you show the opposition who is boss.


Different types of tackling though...in Spain you get more 'cynical' nudges, blocking and pulling...we're talking about potentially career threatening tackles in the Watford and Huddersfield scenarios. Messi get crowded out most of the time, not assaulted in a one on one situation.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

chateauferret Flag 18 Sep 18 4.49pm

Originally posted by Lyons550


Different types of tackling though...in Spain you get more 'cynical' nudges, blocking and pulling...we're talking about potentially career threatening tackles in the Watford and Huddersfield scenarios. Messi get crowded out most of the time, not assaulted in a one on one situation.

Funnily enough though when Sergio Ramos did it to Mo Salah it went down like a s***e sandwich at a wedding.

Edited by chateauferret (18 Sep 2018 4.50pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

TheExpatEagle Flag 18 Sep 18 6.57pm

Originally posted by Lyons550


Thats all well and good; but we're not in that era now are we. Tackling is an art, a combination of timing and decision making.

Its eradication has left us with players that do not know how to win a ball cleanly anymore, and as such with players that a far more finely tuned than those of yesteryear (even the 90's) it more dangerous.

In the good old days you could slide in, win the ball as the opponent flies over your head on a muddy wet pitch. It was deemed a good tackle then...not now.

So lets not fall into the trap of comparing it the anything we used to do or see 20 years ago....like Lineker and Shearer did

I'm not talking about 'good old days' and whatnot and no some things Palace players got up to in the 90s were not okay at the time and would be called 'sh*thousery' even then.

My point is some Palace fans like our defenders to let some opposition players know they are 'in England' but don't like it when it happens to our players.

How many Palace fans just 4 years ago liked it when Suarez, Terry, etc got tough tackled and blatantly fouled? When Jedi was giving out no-nonsense tackles in midfield? How about Man City at home last season?

As I said, I am not saying it is okay for Zaha to get kicked but some Palace fans don't mind us dishing it out but don't like it when some clubs come up and give it to us.

Football is a contact sport. Zaha complaining that he feels he can't do some skills because he might get fouled isn't getting sympathy from me because if Ronaldo was playing against us I'd hope he'd not be allowed to pi*s about like he used to.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 18 Sep 18 11.23pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

I disagree, I think that it was given a yellow as the ref was Attempting to Be lenient as it was early in the game; which Is wrong, such things should not determine punishment.

Also, a Couple of seasons back i remember there was a game where Hazard was obviously Targeted - which i think was the last time this issue came up. So the Fact that it was Zaha not Hazard had no affect on the decision.

So you agree the ref was wrong and it was a red card offence .

You just don't think it would be more more likely that it would have been red if it was Hazard.
I think it would .

Anyway can anyone answer the question of would VAR have helped ? Bearing in mind the referee booked the players and as far as I can recall VAR for reds card offences was to sort out mistaken Id ?

 

johnno42000 Flag 19 Sep 18 1.54am

Good article in the Sun about Wilf, something I thought I'd never say.

[Link]

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 19 Sep 18 7.33am

Originally posted by TheExpatEagle

I'm not talking about 'good old days' and whatnot and no some things Palace players got up to in the 90s were not okay at the time and would be called 'sh*thousery' even then.

My point is some Palace fans like our defenders to let some opposition players know they are 'in England' but don't like it when it happens to our players.

How many Palace fans just 4 years ago liked it when Suarez, Terry, etc got tough tackled and blatantly fouled? When Jedi was giving out no-nonsense tackles in midfield? How about Man City at home last season?

As I said, I am not saying it is okay for Zaha to get kicked but some Palace fans don't mind us dishing it out but don't like it when some clubs come up and give it to us.

Football is a contact sport. Zaha complaining that he feels he can't do some skills because he might get fouled isn't getting sympathy from me because if Ronaldo was playing against us I'd hope he'd not be allowed to pi*s about like he used to.


TBF he was set up a bit. Straight after the match, what was the first thing he was asked? Good 3 points? Great goal? No....you were on the end of some tasty challenges there wilf....on the spur of the moment, what's he supposed to say...

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 19 Sep 18 9.30am

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

I disagree, I think that it was given a yellow as the ref was Attempting to Be lenient as it was early in the game; which Is wrong, such things should not determine punishment.

Also, a Couple of seasons back i remember there was a game where Hazard was obviously Targeted - which i think was the last time this issue came up. So the Fact that it was Zaha not Hazard had no affect on the decision.

So you agree the ref was wrong and it was a red card offence .

You just don't think it would be more more likely that it would have been red if it was Hazard.
I think it would .

Anyway can anyone answer the question of would VAR have helped ? Bearing in mind the referee booked the players and as far as I can recall VAR for reds card offences was to sort out mistaken Id ?


yes I do believe it was a red, and the ref was wrong. He tried to not 'spoil' the game by sending someone off so early - which is a farcical excuse, but one which ref often seem To apply. So no, I don't think it would have been given against Hazard either.


Edited by CrazyBadger (19 Sep 2018 9.35am)

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 19 Sep 18 11.09am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Growing Support For Wilf' by bexleydave

Nice to see quite a few pundits coming out and showing support for Wilf and his treatment on theback of his interview.

A mate just pointed me to this article doing just that in todays Sun

[Link]

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 19 Sep 18 11.40am

Originally posted by TheExpatEagle

I'm not talking about 'good old days' and whatnot and no some things Palace players got up to in the 90s were not okay at the time and would be called 'sh*thousery' even then.

My point is some Palace fans like our defenders to let some opposition players know they are 'in England' but don't like it when it happens to our players.

How many Palace fans just 4 years ago liked it when Suarez, Terry, etc got tough tackled and blatantly fouled? When Jedi was giving out no-nonsense tackles in midfield? How about Man City at home last season?

As I said, I am not saying it is okay for Zaha to get kicked but some Palace fans don't mind us dishing it out but don't like it when some clubs come up and give it to us.

Football is a contact sport. Zaha complaining that he feels he can't do some skills because he might get fouled isn't getting sympathy from me because if Ronaldo was playing against us I'd hope he'd not be allowed to pi*s about like he used to.

It should be, but its not anymore. The real issue is the standard of reffing...giving fouls for nudges and letting assaults go with barely a yellow.

As I said earlier, there's nothing wrong in my book for good hard (but fair) tackling...as I said, its an art which has been sadly lost.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 19 Sep 18 12.13pm

Originally posted by Lyons550

Originally posted by TheExpatEagle
I'm not talking about 'good old days' and whatnot and no some things Palace players got up to in the 90s were not okay at the time and would be called 'sh*thousery' even then.

My point is some Palace fans like our defenders to let some opposition players know they are 'in England' but don't like it when it happens to our players.

How many Palace fans just 4 years ago liked it when Suarez, Terry, etc got tough tackled and blatantly fouled? When Jedi was giving out no-nonsense tackles in midfield? How about Man City at home last season?

As I said, I am not saying it is okay for Zaha to get kicked but some Palace fans don't mind us dishing it out but don't like it when some clubs come up and give it to us.

Football is a contact sport. Zaha complaining that he feels he can't do some skills because he might get fouled isn't getting sympathy from me because if Ronaldo was playing against us I'd hope he'd not be allowed to pi*s about like he used to.

It should be, but its not anymore. The real issue is the standard of reffing...giving fouls for nudges and letting assaults go with barely a yellow.

As I said earlier, there's nothing wrong in my book for good hard (but fair) tackling...as I said, its an art which has been sadly lost.

Football is a Contact sport, but it is not a FULL Contact sport.
this [Link] defines it quite nicely (even if it is from the US!)
Shoulder barges are probably the only instance in the game that contact is allowed in the rules. Tackling in football is a grey area - Contact in a tackle is not really in the rules but some contact is inevitable which is why the Excessive Force rule was implemented, so it's accepted as part of the game without really being in the rules.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

YT Flag Oxford 19 Sep 18 12.47pm

Originally posted by TheExpatEagle

The funny thing is I remember when our defenders used to kick the opposing strikers all over the pitch and nobody shouted for us to stop.

Anyone remember the matches v Everton in the early 90s? Eric Young breaking Keown's nose (albeit not a striker) in the ZDS Final, etc.

I don't approve of Zaha getting hacked all over the place but what's good for the goose is good for the gander. We can't have double morals about this.

I assume ‘etc’ includes Keown exacting revenge on the Ninja in the subsequent league game at Selhurst Park, for which he received his marching orders.

Edited by YT (19 Sep 2018 12.47pm)

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 19 Sep 18 2.18pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

Football is a Contact sport, but it is not a FULL Contact sport.
this [Link] defines it quite nicely (even if it is from the US!)
Shoulder barges are probably the only instance in the game that contact is allowed in the rules. Tackling in football is a grey area - Contact in a tackle is not really in the rules but some contact is inevitable which is why the Excessive Force rule was implemented, so it's accepted as part of the game without really being in the rules.


I know what the rules state, shame the refs dont, or more to the point (to prevent any further pedantry) don't appear to.

The shoulder barge/collision is ironically the greyest area of all..how many times do they call a foul for one outside the box, but then allow the same inside.

Consistency is what's required, as well as an understanding through experience of having played the game. That way tackles the like of which we've seen in both the Watford and Huddersfield games would be straight reds.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 19 Sep 18 3.30pm

Originally posted by Lyons550


I know what the rules state, shame the refs dont, or more to the point (to prevent any further pedantry) don't appear to.

The shoulder barge/collision is ironically the greyest area of all..how many times do they call a foul for one outside the box, but then allow the same inside.

Consistency is what's required, as well as an understanding through experience of having played the game. That way tackles the like of which we've seen in both the Watford and Huddersfield games would be straight reds.

Consistency is difficult when there is pressure - mainly from Pundits - to 'use their common sense' rather than implement the rules. How often have we heard the ref should not have sent a player off in the interest of keeping the spectacle or other such drivel.
It's not the ref's fault that player 1 attempted to break someones leg in the opening minutes of a game.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

The Dolphin Flag 19 Sep 18 6.07pm

He will always get kicked but the Capoue one the one on Saturday were deliberate, nasty, vicious and possibly season ending tackles.
That is the difference and those tackles should be outlawed.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 19 Sep 18 6.30pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

Consistency is difficult when there is pressure - mainly from Pundits - to 'use their common sense' rather than implement the rules. How often have we heard the ref should not have sent a player off in the interest of keeping the spectacle or other such drivel.
It's not the ref's fault that player 1 attempted to break someones leg in the opening minutes of a game.

Yes, they're under pressure from players, managers, spectators, and even "pundits". But that's why their hourly wage rate for what they do (at least in the Premiership) is a multiple of what the average worker gets, and it's no justification for not applying the rules according to their own best judgment, irrespective of any other considerations. They don't all do that.

 

YT Flag Oxford 19 Sep 18 6.36pm

Pedantry alert! Isn’t it shoulder ‘charge’ and not ‘barge’? It always used to be called that, but maybe it was always a colloquialism ie not a term used in the laws. Anyone know?

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 19 Sep 18 7.36pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

He will always get kicked but the Capoue one the one on Saturday were deliberate, nasty, vicious and possibly season ending tackles.
That is the difference and those tackles should be outlawed.

'Those'tackles are outlawed.

 

Page 4 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > MOTD (Zaha)