This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Willo
Maine Eagle I agree with the general thrust of your comments. Our goalscoring is a major concern and if we don't improve in this area there is every chance that we will plummet through the dreaded relegation trapdoor.Supporters have lost faith in our current strikers to deliver the goods necessary to avert the drop. To be fair, 2 of our potentially best strikers are currently residing in the injury room, that’s nobody’s fault. I assume Benteke had been carrying his injury for sometime, that would explain his poor form, but was asked to play as we had no viable alternative.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
To be fair, 2 of our potentially best strikers are currently residing in the injury room, that’s nobody’s fault. I assume Benteke had been carrying his injury for sometime, that would explain his poor form, but was asked to play as we had no viable alternative. I understand the injury situation but even if/when Benteke and Wickham return to full fitness, I believe that supporters will have no faith that they will score enough goals to avoid the dreaded drop. Apropos, calls for a new goal scorer, any proven one costs a great deal of money and we are not in the market to lavish significant funds in order to purchase one.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dg1937
With respect, Willo, I think whether supporters have faith is by-the-by. The question is whether Roy has faith. On paper, a fit strike force of 1) Benteke 2) Wickham 3) Ayew and 4) Sorloth ought to be good enough. The problem is that because 1 and 2 aren't fit we are having to rely on 3 and 4. Obviously there are other issues: will Benteke ever regain the form he has been capable of in the past; will Wickham ever recover fully from his serious injury? Roy won't knowthe answer to these questions any more than we can but he is one of the most experienced managers in the business and will make his own judgements. Where I do agree with you is that there are unlikely to be significant funds available in January and what funds there are will likely mostly come from player sales. The sort of proven goalscorer we are all crying out for will be very expensive and we won't be the only club in the market. My belief is that the players we would be willing to offload wouldn't generate significant funds.In terms of striker accusations, I am wholly in agreement with your comments - we might need to go down the Loan route.
|
|
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
One can only assume that Roy is bashing down SP's door every day telling him that a striker who can actually do what it says on the tin will change us from bottom 5 to top 8. Just think we had that fantastic strike on our books but due to complete foolishness, ignorance ,arrogance and poor judgment let him go for peanuts and now we have only monkeys!!
|
|
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
One can only assume that Roy is bashing down SP's door every day telling him that a striker who can actually do what it says on the tin will change us from bottom 5 to top 8. Just think we had that fantastic striker on our books but due to complete foolishness, ignorance ,arrogance and poor judgment let him go for peanuts and now we have only monkeys!!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
To be fair, 2 of our potentially best strikers are currently residing in the injury room, that’s nobody’s fault. I assume Benteke had been carrying his injury for sometime, that would explain his poor form, but was asked to play as we had no viable alternative. if that's true then it's really poor squad management from RH
|
|
|
Lets raise a new share issue and get some more American's on board with some new WONGA
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
To be fair, 2 of our potentially best strikers are currently residing in the injury room, that’s nobody’s fault. I assume Benteke had been carrying his injury for sometime, that would explain his poor form, but was asked to play as we had no viable alternative. New goal scorer? I would take any goal scorer! I think Ian Wright is available and I would say he is more old than new. Benteke cant score goals anymore and Wickham can’t stay fit. Therefore yes I reckon we need a new one.
Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha. |
|
|
I think some people are using the news that Benteke had been carrying an injury as an excuse of his poor form.. Has he been carrying it for the last 15 months? When would this injury have occurred? Would he not have got decent rest during the summer? Once we secured our PL status last season, why wouldn't he have been rested if he had an injury? Why would the coaches have pushed him to play during pre-season if he was carrying an injury? I would say if he was carrying an injury then it is the one he received versus Halmstad rather than anything he received last season. That means he has not had poor form this season, it is his level based on last season. That said, at the end of the day he is a striker who has been getting goal scoring chances and missing them rather than not being presented with them. He has missed 'simple' chances with his left, right and head. I'm not trying to be overly critical of him. I hope he comes back and starts scoring because we can't afford a player of his potential ability and we'd lose too much money if we sold him. I just don't accept his poor form is due to carrying an injury.
South London and Proud - an Crystal Palace blog, podcast and discussion forum. CLICK HERE [Link] |
|
|
Originally posted by SouthLondonAP
I think some people are using the news that Benteke had been carrying an injury as an excuse of his poor form.. Has he been carrying it for the last 15 months? When would this injury have occurred? Would he not have got decent rest during the summer? Once we secured our PL status last season, why wouldn't he have been rested if he had an injury? Why would the coaches have pushed him to play during pre-season if he was carrying an injury? I would say if he was carrying an injury then it is the one he received versus Halmstad rather than anything he received last season. That means he has not had poor form this season, it is his level based on last season. That said, at the end of the day he is a striker who has been getting goal scoring chances and missing them rather than not being presented with them. He has missed 'simple' chances with his left, right and head. I'm not trying to be overly critical of him. I hope he comes back and starts scoring because we can't afford a player of his potential ability and we'd lose too much money if we sold him. I just don't accept his poor form is due to carrying an injury. you are spot on, apart from his first season with us he has not performed and has lacked energy and determination, he fails to work defenders off the ball creating spaces for other to move forward with his size and physic he should be able to create havoc in the oppositions box. He also lacks floor skills and most of all can't take penalties. He is to comfortable on his salary, we should sell him for whatever we can get and reinvest in something better!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
you are spot on, apart from his first season with us he has not performed and has lacked energy and determination, he fails to work defenders off the ball creating spaces for other to move forward with his size and physic he should be able to create havoc in the oppositions box. He also lacks floor skills and most of all can't take penalties. He is to comfortable on his salary, we should sell him for whatever we can get and reinvest in something better! Whatever the issues with Tekkers, a return to form for him might be our best bet of getting out of the mire. Ayew and Sorloth look further away. We may well spend a lot in Jan on a striker/s but that does not mean it will be fixed. What I'm saying I feel that the positives are more likely to come internally than externally. How many strikers have rocked up in Jan and completely turned a team ? Tevez did it for the Spammers, many seasons ago. Think the major click may well come within the squad already.
“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ” |
|
|
We'll know if Benteke has any hunger left when he returns, I hope he is up for it, and has something to prove.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Booted Eagle
Whatever the issues with Tekkers, a return to form for him might be our best bet of getting out of the mire. Ayew and Sorloth look further away. We may well spend a lot in Jan on a striker/s but that does not mean it will be fixed. What I'm saying I feel that the positives are more likely to come internally than externally. How many strikers have rocked up in Jan and completely turned a team ? Tevez did it for the Spammers, many seasons ago. Think the major click may well come within the squad already. Goes without saying that it would be excellent if Benteke started to score goals but we have all been waiting for seemingly an eternity for him to deliver. One goal since January, and that from the penalty spot, says it all. Game on game we have been hoping he rediscovers his scoring form and game on game he has been totally abject.I suspect there is little faith amongst supporters that he will cure our ills up front.
|
|
|
I appreciate this is a fairly confidential matter but do we know how much is available to spend this January?
|
|
|
Originally posted by premier fan
I appreciate this is a fairly confidential matter but do we know how much is available to spend this January? $1.50 and a book of luncheon vouchers
|
|
|
Originally posted by EagleinSF
.50 and a book of luncheon vouchers Half the luncheon vouchers have already been used. The manager asked for an advance on next years LV's but I don't think that happening. Unless it's a good signing we would be better off saving our money. I think we have enough to muddle through and as another poster mentioned January signings are expensive and not always successful.
One more point |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.