You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should Palace prioritise the FA CUP?
November 16 2026 6.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Should Palace prioritise the FA CUP?


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Zaha127 Flag 27 Dec 18 12.49pm

January is around the corner. Hopefully if Palace can get a few signings even on loan i.e. Batshuyai, Moses then the side will be improved.


Should Palace play full time in every FA CUP game? Because if they win it (big if) they can qualify for Europa I think?

 

ogyogyogy Flag herne bay 27 Dec 18 12.58pm

Our squad would not be strong enough for European football and stay in the premier league in my opinion

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 27 Dec 18 1.12pm

Just have to look at Burnley to see what an Europa Cup adventure has done to them.
Played 7 matches in it pre season and have not recovered from the experience.
Having said that I do think wwe should treat the FA Cup seriously

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 27 Dec 18 1.33pm

We won't play a full strength team v the haddocks and I'd be surprised if we risked a jaded player in round 4 (if we made it). Southampton is just a few days later I think.

so I think we will simply aim to put out strong teams and see where it takes us. if a favourable draw got us to round 6 and we looked set in a safe league position, why not prioritise it then?

Edited by Ginger Pubic Wig (27 Dec 2018 1.35pm)

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

chris123 Flag hove actually 27 Dec 18 1.36pm

Only in the final.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 27 Dec 18 1.46pm

I am sure we will give squad players their chance in the earlier rounds. If we progress and our league position has improved I see no reason why we wouldn't go for it. We would all love another couple of trips to Wembley!

 

jeeagles Flag 27 Dec 18 2.17pm

With Pardew, we were doing well at Christmas so it was worth it.

Not this year.

 

cantrbury eagle Flag Canterbury 27 Dec 18 8.48pm

this is our year come on you palace

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 27 Dec 18 9.46pm

Originally posted by cantrbury eagle

this is our year come on you palace

Our year for ...?

I can't believe it has taken half of the season to get the team to shoot at goal ... it could take another half to get them to hit the thing.

Intensive shooting training is urgently required. Leave the FA Cup to fate!

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

timmyb Flag Banstead 27 Dec 18 9.48pm

It saddens me that it is ever even a consideration that we should not take the FA cup seriously.

We have emerged from our second worst Autumn of the last two years with 7 points from the last 3 home games and have just taken 4 points from two trips to Manchester. Roy has managed this with a team with no centre forwards.

We are significantly better than the bottom four and this will not change.

I well understand the desire to preserve top flight status after decades of swift returns to the championship...but if that is the sum total of our ambitions then we will one day become Stoke City...a club almost losing the will to live after a decade in the Prem becoming increasingly uncompetitive.

I have said this before...being as Palace fan has taught me a great deal of life lessons; perseverance, groundless optimism and so forth. I don't feel like I am owed anything, I never expect to see Palace as league champions, but oh my goodness an FA cup win would make 40 years of roller coasting worthwhile.

I am still not over the 1990 final...have tried to erase the 2016 one from my memory. I couldn't give two hoots about playing in Europe...that's not a reason for not trying to win the oldest cup competition in the world. Win the cup and play the youth team in Europa qualifying...please can we just take the tournament seriously?

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 27 Dec 18 10.07pm

A great competition which we have a half realistic chance (along with other Prem mid table teams) of winning. If we did, it would be the best moment in our history.

With Benteke and Wickham returning, the early rounds will give them valuable game time to get their sharpness back. We have pretty good depth in midfield and defence so can rotate there whilst still fielding decent players.

I don’t think we’ve quite got the points in the board yet to fully go for the cup but if we are still in competition by round 5 and the league position is looking healthier, then yes, we should the go full throttle for it. It would be a dream to travel Europe to watch Palace.

 

Dean_CPFC Flag South london 27 Dec 18 10.50pm

Take each game as it comes. First up, let's smash Grimsby out the way. We need a good attendance first.

 

cantrbury eagle Flag Canterbury 27 Dec 18 10.54pm

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

Our year for ...?

I can't believe it has taken half of the season to get the team to shoot at goal ... it could take another half to get them to hit the thing.

Intensive shooting training is urgently required. Leave the FA Cup to fate!

I am 52 it would be so good to win something.So close in 1990 and 2016 why not this year if Leicester can win the title anything is possible.

 

essetwentyone Flag london 27 Dec 18 11.16pm

We have a team capable of beating anyone on the day as proven last week so we could make a very good cup team. We should go all out in the Cup but that doesn’t mean playing the first team in every game. Our squad should be good enough to beat lower division teams.
As for Burnley’s experience in Europe I would counter that with Roy’s exploits at Fulham when they reached the final ( albeit easier then ) .
We need to live the dream

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 27 Dec 18 11.26pm

The FA cup has lost it, it was probably about a few years after we lost 1-0 to Man.U, sadly.

 

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 28 Dec 18 12.12am

Originally posted by timmyb

It saddens me that it is ever even a consideration that we should not take the FA cup seriously.

We have emerged from our second worst Autumn of the last two years with 7 points from the last 3 home games and have just taken 4 points from two trips to Manchester. Roy has managed this with a team with no centre forwards.

We are significantly better than the bottom four and this will not change.

I well understand the desire to preserve top flight status after decades of swift returns to the championship...but if that is the sum total of our ambitions then we will one day become Stoke City...a club almost losing the will to live after a decade in the Prem becoming increasingly uncompetitive.

I have said this before...being as Palace fan has taught me a great deal of life lessons; perseverance, groundless optimism and so forth. I don't feel like I am owed anything, I never expect to see Palace as league champions, but oh my goodness an FA cup win would make 40 years of roller coasting worthwhile.

I am still not over the 1990 final...have tried to erase the 2016 one from my memory. I couldn't give two hoots about playing in Europe...that's not a reason for not trying to win the oldest cup competition in the world. Win the cup and play the youth team in Europa qualifying...please can we just take the tournament seriously?

Great post - 100% agree. Surely it’s about winning something. What’s the point if it’s just about hoping for 17th every year.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 28 Dec 18 12.32am

The FA cup should be given the upmost respect - we should field a strong side capable of beating the opponent. However, with respect to grimsby, we should be able to utilise the squad and win.

I would like us to win the FA cup, but ignore the european tour that comes with it as our squad isn't strong enough to compete. Instead, field youth and fringe players.

However, that's on the basis we won it this year.. in a few years, i would expect us to be a comfortable mid table club and looking at the cup as a means to get into europe.

 


This was once a quality forum....

dreamwaverider Flag London 28 Dec 18 4.39am

Originally posted by timmyb

It saddens me that it is ever even a consideration that we should not take the FA cup seriously.

We have emerged from our second worst Autumn of the last two years with 7 points from the last 3 home games and have just taken 4 points from two trips to Manchester. Roy has managed this with a team with no centre forwards.

We are significantly better than the bottom four and this will not change.

I well understand the desire to preserve top flight status after decades of swift returns to the championship...but if that is the sum total of our ambitions then we will one day become Stoke City...a club almost losing the will to live after a decade in the Prem becoming increasingly uncompetitive.

I have said this before...being as Palace fan has taught me a great deal of life lessons; perseverance, groundless optimism and so forth. I don't feel like I am owed anything, I never expect to see Palace as league champions, but oh my goodness an FA cup win would make 40 years of roller coasting worthwhile.

I am still not over the 1990 final...have tried to erase the 2016 one from my memory. I couldn't give two hoots about playing in Europe...that's not a reason for not trying to win the oldest cup competition in the world. Win the cup and play the youth team in Europa qualifying...please can we just take the tournament seriously?


Great post

 

Norway Flag Sandnes,Norway 28 Dec 18 8.34am

Norwegian fans can enjoy the match v. Grimsby live on Viasat 2 - great - looking forward to seeing some fringe players, and maybe one of the last chances for Speroni to play for Palace

 


Norway

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 28 Dec 18 9.27am

No.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should Palace prioritise the FA CUP?