This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Bullhorn76
This is scary now Williams , puncheon , mutch , and now sorloth with a possibility of Kirby going on loan as well ! I bloody well hope we have some irons in the fire other wise our team will be waferthin I’m quite pleased so far. Four players gone, none of whom would feature in a full strength first team squad and freeing up some wages and space for some new faces. Hopefully two quality, long term signings who will immediately compete for first team selection.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Bullhorn76
This is scary now Williams , puncheon , mutch , and now sorloth with a possibility of Kirby going on loan as well ! I bloody well hope we have some irons in the fire other wise our team will be waferthin None of them were anywhere near the first 11 so it doesn’t bother me. Even if we only got 2 bodies in but they were actually decent players it would be a good trade off.
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace1fan
I do hope so. In fact if we were a half decent championship side I would be concerned if we got him in. As said nice guy but not rated by me at all. Never really given a proper run of games, so not sure how we can judge too much. Personally, I think he's got the goods and with some confidence would be a great striker. Time will tell.
|
|
|
Originally posted by sprites
Never really given a proper run of games, so not sure how we can judge too much. Personally, I think he's got the goods and with some confidence would be a great striker. Time will tell. I don't know how anyone could reach that conclusion from what we've seen of him since he put on a Palace shirt. He looks nowhere near PL quality and has not improved in 12 months. I dread him coming on as he plods around like a demented donkey. Sorry, but he has to go ... anywhere!!! (Update) Hallelujah ... just read the donkey has landed in Ghent. He won't be missed this side of the Channel. Edited by Henry of Peckham (08 Jan 2019 8.18pm)
Denial is not just a river in Egypt |
|
|
Originally posted by Bullhorn76
This is scary now Williams , puncheon , mutch , and now sorloth with a possibility of Kirby going on loan as well ! I bloody well hope we have some irons in the fire other wise our team will be waferthin It’s not.puncheon may have made a few appearances in the last 5 minutes of games .
|
|
|
Passing on Solanke was definitely the right call for where we are now. That said I’d like a different option up front. Maupay is the one who interests me most. He seems to offer more mobility than we have. I also like the idea that he’s youngish and may have done resale value! I know Roy is a fan if prem experience but I’d like to see us develop more players. It may be wrong think but it bugs me that the only two players I can recall us turning a profit in are Gayle and Bolassie. Part of our financial strife is down to our lack of outward sales. I don’t like it but teams in our position do need to be able to turn some form of income from sales. On Maupay I think he could be the sort of player who adds something new to our attack and could be a sound investment. I just don’t know what the price might be. If he came in at 12-14 then I’d say yes. Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot
I would imagine that Kirby going out on loan is surely just for experience.. He's very highly rated.. We have a few in the the U23s who need some loan moves to build up experience. I'm actually behind Roy and the board on passing on Solanke... £19m for a guy who has played a handful of league cup games and friendlies... plus failing a medical with us... Don't get me wrong he may turn out to be amazing but it's a lot of money for someone with little experience... But Jesus we need some cover up front.. I'm not confident we will get it though.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Omph
It may be wrong think but it bugs me that the only two players I can recall us turning a profit in are Gayle and Bolassie. Part of our financial strife is down to our lack of outward sales. I don’t like it but teams in our position do need to be able to turn some form of income from sales. Murray and Jedinak are two more for you
|
|
|
Thanks. Silly of me to forget Murray but I would have sworn - wrongly - that we gave Jedi a free. That still only adds about 10 mill to the transfer profit. It seems very thin pickings.i suppose that it comes down to our eternal relegation battle dictating safe transfers of hard bitten players with prem experience. Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Murray and Jedinak are two more for you
|
|
|
Originally posted by Omph
Silly of me to forget Murray but I would have sworn - wrongly - that we gave Jedi a free. That still only adds about 10 mill to the transfer profit. All of which was probably used to pay off various managers
|
|
|
Originally posted by The Royster7
the dismal approach with regard to Solanke is rediculous. How about spending cash on players like him (No doubt he will score against us for Bournemouth) Rumours are that he wouldn't be fit for another few weeks and then will take a few more weeks to get match fit. An alleged loan fee of £2m is rather a lot to spend on a player who might only play for us for a couple of months
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Rumours are that he wouldn't be fit for another few weeks and then will take a few more weeks to get match fit. An alleged loan fee of £2m is rather a lot to spend on a player who might only play for us for a couple of months And I think a lot of the stadium spend is hygiene factors isn't it? I.e. the infrastructure is on its last legs. Edited by chateauferret (09 Jan 2019 2.11pm)
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by Omph
Thanks. Silly of me to forget Murray but I would have sworn - wrongly - that we gave Jedi a free. That still only adds about 10 mill to the transfer profit. It seems very thin pickings.i suppose that it comes down to our eternal relegation battle dictating safe transfers of hard bitten players with prem experience. Or you could look at it another way. That we manage to hang onto our better players. I'm sure we could make a log of money from Zaha, Townsend, and a few others. But would rather we hung onto them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Omph
I know Roy is a fan if prem experience but I’d like to see us develop more players. It may be wrong think but it bugs me that the only two players I can recall us turning a profit in are Gayle and Bolassie. Part of our financial strife is down to our lack of outward sales. I don’t like it but teams in our position do need to be able to turn some form of income from sales. The dynamics of the transfer market have changed due to the money now swilling around in the Premier. We are no longer a selling club of our best players, as in the past. The transfer fees are no longer so relevant, its the wages that are the big factor due FFP. Clubs aren't prepared to buy players for a higher fee and take their wage deal.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NickinOX
First, what is your actual evidence that we were ever even in for Defoe. Second, from what the club, and Warnock, have said about Liverpool things changed after a deal was agreed. Also, when the club said Solanke was injured and would not be able to come straight into the team, that has turned out to be true. So, 0 from 2 claims so far. January 14: Ince, Dann, Ledley, Hennessey, Puncheon. January 15: Mutch, Zaha, Souare, Anderson, Sanogo, Lee. January 16: Adebayor. January 17: Milivojovic, Van Aanholt, Schlupp, Sakho. January 18: Sorloth, Rakip, Cavalieri, Jach. Two excellent windows, one mixed, two poor. Maybe not quite as bad as you make out. We clearly need a decent striker, and some midfield creativity, but let’s not make stuff up to make a point. All over the media today that Defoe rejected our approach as very impressed by the Gerrard project at Rangers.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Bullhorn76
I don’t know if dazza has any more info but some dizzy doughnut who goes by transfer geezer on Twitter reckons niasse deal dead and hodgson not impressed by Batshuayi goal return this season so probably won’t go for him either Totally untrue, Palace have 4 or 5 options but taking time as looking to get best deal. The above 2 are on the list. For SP it’s all about the best deal for the club under the current constraints, we just need to be paitient there will be incomings.
|
|
|
We will be dazzled by the greatness of our new signings.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Jacey
All over the media today that Defoe rejected our approach as very impressed by the Gerrard project at Rangers. And at his age, so would I. Great way to play out your last couple of years of football. Easier than thd premiership and probably gets to play almost every game.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.