This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Goalkeeper on loan a must
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
deetee 19 Jan 19 5.28pm |
|
|
Following Speroni's disaster at Anfield it is obvious we need an keeper ASAP With key cup and league games in the next month we can't wait on Guaita or Hennessey. Surely there are experienced number3 keepers at Premiership clubs who would welcome a few games.
|
xomnea 19 Jan 19 5.37pm |
|
|
Name an experienced number 3 anyone would want in goal ahead of Speroni even after that clanger? Rob Green? No thanks.
|
DeanMiles Telford 19 Jan 19 5.42pm |
|
|
Vorm? Spurs won't use him as they have a decent number 2 now. Not sure if he'd be available but I'd take him as a number 2 for the rest of the season.
|
NI_palace_fan Newtownards 19 Jan 19 5.43pm |
|
|
Possibly Man Utd’s lee grant??
|
xomnea 19 Jan 19 5.48pm |
|
|
We should have snapped Vorms arm off seasons ago. Can’t see spurs letting him go leaving them with just Lloris and the handsome Italian. In theory we’ve got Vicente, Hennessy, Julian to see us through (with hopefully the young Brazilian somewhere in the mix). Julian will retire and Hennessy surely moved on at the end of the season but I wouldn’t make any rash decisions off the back of that performance if I was Parish.
|
Maine Eagle USA 19 Jan 19 6.26pm |
|
Originally posted by deetee
Following Speroni's disaster at Anfield it is obvious we need an keeper ASAP With key cup and league games in the next month we can't wait on Guaita or Hennessey. Surely there are experienced number3 keepers at Premiership clubs who would welcome a few games.
I have to agree, much as I dont want to. He might have done better with the first, but the 3rd goal is a massive howler.
He is pushing 40 and hasnt played in ages, it would have been a lot easier to come in at home vs Cardiff, but this is the big leagues.
I think Hodgson might be keen to play a different goalie in the next game, by hook or by crook.
Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.
|
chateauferret 19 Jan 19 7.34pm |
|
Originally posted by Maine Eagle
I have to agree, much as I dont want to. He might have done better with the first, but the 3rd goal is a massive howler.
He is pushing 40 and hasnt played in ages, it would have been a lot easier to come in at home vs Cardiff, but this is the big leagues.
I think Hodgson might be keen to play a different goalie in the next game, by hook or by crook.
It's what you might call Hodgson's Choice, isn't it?
- Keeper who's nearly 40 and f***ed up last time out - Newbie straight out the ACademy - New keeper straight off the plane still with jetlag or - Keeper with a goosed leg?
============ The Ferret ============
|
PalazioVecchio south pole 19 Jan 19 11.26pm |
|
|
i still think Speroni could give us decent defense against a team at the bottom half of the table.
Liverpool at Anfield......not exactly shameful. One bit of bad luck for the high goal,
we all know Speroni has the experience, the brain, the brilliant past-performances that show us he CAN do it.
and as for his legs and reflexes ?
What age was Buffon when he played in the champions league/ world cup ?
a keeper is only as good as the players in front of him. Liverpool may win the Prem. So that is not the yardstick to measure Jules.
play him against Fulham.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford
|
joe_cpfc Basingstoke 20 Jan 19 12.39am |
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
i still think Speroni could give us decent defense against a team at the bottom half of the table.
Liverpool at Anfield......not exactly shameful. One bit of bad luck for the high goal,
we all know Speroni has the experience, the brain, the brilliant past-performances that show us he CAN do it.
and as for his legs and reflexes ?
What age was Buffon when he played in the champions league/ world cup ?
a keeper is only as good as the players in front of him. Liverpool may win the Prem. So that is not the yardstick to measure Jules.
play him against Fulham.
First of all are you seriously comparing Speroni to Buffon? “A keeper is only as good as the players infront of him”? So the Tranmere keeper could play for Barcelona then? We all love him obviously but he should have had 2 of those goals, probably 3, if he was still up to it he would have but he’s far from up to it now. I don’t see how it matters that it was away to Liverpool either, not one of those 4 goals were wonder goals and a shot is a shot wether it’s at Anfield or Exeter.Ive read so many comments slating everyone who dare have the opinion that he had a mare just because he’s a club legend.I love him as much as the next Palace fan and I won’t hold it against him but the bloke had an absolute shocker.Id hate to see him crumble now and let in a shed load of goals in his final few games for us so I say play the Tupper kid or the new Brazilian if he’s signed in time.
|
Vaibow vancouver/croydon 20 Jan 19 12.50am |
|
|
I would hate for that to be his last game, he has one or two chances for redemption, in the fact that he leaves on a positive - this hasn't changed anything, but it's always nice to leave on a high and i think he will recognise that too.
This was once a quality forum....
|
CharlesPaterson 20 Jan 19 1.09am |
|
Originally posted by joe_cpfc
Ive read so many comments slating everyone who dare have the opinion that he had a mare just because he’s a club legend.I love him as much as the next Palace fan and I won’t hold it against him but the bloke had an absolute shocker.Id hate to see him crumble now and let in a shed load of goals in his final few games for us so I say play the Tupper kid or the new Brazilian if he’s signed in time.
Agree with this, His second half performance was awful.
We have to get a replacement in or play the U23 kid.
|
CharlesPaterson 20 Jan 19 1.14am |
|
|
Too risky for such an important game. Think we need minimum 4 points from these two games, Southampton and Fulham.
|
CB 20 Jan 19 7.16am |
|
|
Teams will target him on crosses and corners even more too.
|
Casual Orpington 20 Jan 19 7.21am |
|
Originally posted by joe_cpfc
First of all are you seriously comparing Speroni to Buffon? “A keeper is only as good as the players infront of him”? So the Tranmere keeper could play for Barcelona then? We all love him obviously but he should have had 2 of those goals, probably 3, if he was still up to it he would have but he’s far from up to it now. I don’t see how it matters that it was away to Liverpool either, not one of those 4 goals were wonder goals and a shot is a shot wether it’s at Anfield or Exeter.Ive read so many comments slating everyone who dare have the opinion that he had a mare just because he’s a club legend.I love him as much as the next Palace fan and I won’t hold it against him but the bloke had an absolute shocker.Id hate to see him crumble now and let in a shed load of goals in his final few games for us so I say play the Tupper kid or the new Brazilian if he’s signed in time.
Agree . Love Speroni. Don’t know if he’s lost it or had a bad game , but of the 4 goals , a decent keeper shouldn’t be letting in more than 2.
|
becky over the moon 20 Jan 19 7.49am |
|
|
Any player that has been out of the 1st team for a year would need to get 'match fit' again - speed, stamina and sharp, fast reactions.
Whilst a keeper won't need the speed and stamina so much, the sharp and fast reactions definitely are an essential of his game....... Jules was not match fit yesterday, and it showed.
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers
|
Henry of Peckham Eton Mess 20 Jan 19 8.13am |
|
Originally posted by becky
Any player that has been out of the 1st team for a year would need to get 'match fit' again - speed, stamina and sharp, fast reactions.
Whilst a keeper won't need the speed and stamina so much, the sharp and fast reactions definitely are an essential of his game....... Jules was not match fit yesterday, and it showed.
Last week, it was clear Wayne was not up to full speed probably due to lack of recent playing time so it was a huge ask to expect Speroni to step in and be on top form not having played a competitive PL game for over 12 months.
Edited by Henry of Peckham (20 Jan 2019 10.58am)
Denial is not just a river in Egypt
|
YT Oxford 20 Jan 19 8.17am |
|
Originally posted by CharlesPaterson
Too risky for such an important game. Think we need minimum 4 points from these two games, Southampton and Fulham.
I’m not sure it’s a minimum necessity; I’d be happy with 4 from these two.
Maybe Jules will play against Tottenham in the cup tie to hopefully get back on track. I take some of the comments about being ‘thrown in’ to the cauldron at Anfield, but surely any club’s 3rd choice keeper should be fit and ready to ‘don the gloves’ at any time...otherwise you might as well just have 2 in the squad.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)
|
JohnB 20 Jan 19 8.26am |
|
|
People are mental. It was his first game in a year against the best attacking team in the league. I can't go on holiday for two weeks without feeling like I'm Bambi on ice when I get back into the gym let alone not playing for a year.
The guys is a club legend. He deserves more respect and patience.
Besides, it wouldn't be Jules if he didn't have a howler in his first game...
|
Norway Sandnes,Norway 20 Jan 19 8.37am |
|
|
Julian is and will forever remain a Palace legend - if the injuries to Guita and Hennesey takes time - what about buying Nick Pope from Burnley - he is excellent
Norway
|
Palace Geezer Empire Made 20 Jan 19 11.02am |
|
|
At least one goal was a defected goal, another was after a hand ball.
Growing old is mandatory; growing up is optional.
|