You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > The Duckenfield/Mackrell Verdicts
November 22 2026 7.32pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Duckenfield/Mackrell Verdicts


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 03 Apr 19 4.25pm

[Link]

So David Duckenfield, whose stunning incompetence was held to be at fault for the needless deaths at Hillsborough by the Warrington Coroner’s Inquest, gets to fight another day after a jury couldn’t reach a unanimous verdict. Gordon Mackrell, who was Sheffield Wednesday’s Club Secretary & Safety Officer at the time, was found guilty of violating the Health & Safety Act (1974). Still, literally weeks before the 30th anniversary of this monstrous tragedy & the resulting cover-up, justice for those who died & those who must live with the horrible memories continues to be an unnecessarily long & winding road, filled with jarring potholes.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 03 Apr 19 5.49pm

Originally posted by kenbarr

[Link]

So David Duckenfield, whose stunning incompetence was held to be at fault for the needless deaths at Hillsborough by the Warrington Coroner’s Inquest, gets to fight another day after a jury couldn’t reach a unanimous verdict. Gordon Mackrell, who was Sheffield Wednesday’s Club Secretary & Safety Officer at the time, was found guilty of violating the Health & Safety Act (1974). Still, literally weeks before the 30th anniversary of this monstrous tragedy & the resulting cover-up, justice for those who died & those who must live with the horrible memories continues to be an unnecessarily long & winding road, filled with jarring potholes.

I am not defending Duckenfield but the game should never have been held at that ground in the first place. Others most bear responsibility for that. On the day he made many mistakes and was clearly out of his depth the jury had to decide did that amount to manslaughter.

They heard the evidence and clearly could not come to a conclusion. If I had relatives that died there I would would want someone to blame and go to jail but that is not justice it is why we pick an impartial panel to try and arrive at that.

Edited by Badger11 (03 Apr 2019 5.50pm)

 


One more point

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 03 Apr 19 6.32pm

I really don't see the purpose of another trial of Duckenfield.

It feels like revenge he is a bit of a scapegoat.

He was incompetent? He has to live with it every day.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 03 Apr 19 6.41pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

I really don't see the purpose of another trial of Duckenfield.

It feels like revenge he is a bit of a scapegoat.

He was incompetent? He has to live with it every day.

There's a man speaking from experience

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Stirlingsays Flag 03 Apr 19 6.42pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

I really don't see the purpose of another trial of Duckenfield.

It feels like revenge he is a bit of a scapegoat.

He was incompetent? He has to live with it every day.

By god, we agree on something.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 05 Apr 19 1.27pm

Waiting a trifling 30 years for an inconclusive outcome ?

Shhurrley not ?

We have only waited a season for the police investigation into Palace fans bringing knives and knuckle-dusters to the Mansex.

Here's a theory

*A man opts to take a task beyond his capacity, in order to seek promotion.
*The man has recorded alcoholic tendencies
*The man should have undertaken a walkover of the site before his designated task. This was not done
*The task goes belly-up
*The man cannot remember what he was doing in the
hours before his task began, when the walkover should have been done
(fill in the gaps)


AAAAAnd, after taking legal advice,..the person on trial doesn't even testify.

Edited by Forest Hillbilly (05 Apr 2019 1.36pm)

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 06 Apr 19 12.43pm

The persecution and prosecution of Duckenfield is to appease the families of the innocent victims of this tragic incident. It is also to appease the wider Liverpool community.

Whilst certain policing decisions on the day have been scrupulously picked apart since and with the benefit of 30 years hindsight, they were made at the time with the best of intentions, in extremely difficult circumstances and often with just seconds or split seconds to consider them.

It is obvious and apparent to most, what caused the tragedy and who were to blame for the deaths of 96 people from events on that day at Hillsborough......and it was not David Duckenfield!

Edited by Phil’s Barber (06 Apr 2019 12.46pm)

 

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 06 Apr 19 1.11pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

The persecution and prosecution of Duckenfield is to appease the families of the innocent victims of this tragic incident. It is also to appease the wider Liverpool community.

Whilst certain policing decisions on the day have been scrupulously picked apart since and with the benefit of 30 years hindsight, they were made at the time with the best of intentions, in extremely difficult circumstances and often with just seconds or split seconds to consider them.

It is obvious and apparent to most, what caused the tragedy and who were to blame for the deaths of 96 people from events on that day at Hillsborough......and it was not David Duckenfield!

Edited by Phil’s Barber (06 Apr 2019 12.46pm)

Your point of view ignores certain facts. Duckenfield lied about how Exit Gate C was opened to Graham Kelly of the FA. That lie was repeated in good faith by Mr. Kelly on national Media. Mr. Duckenfield repeatedly failed to act to alleviate the situation in the Leppings Lane terrace even though he had full sight of it from the Control Box. The testimony of countless PCs assigned to the match confirm this. A commander must take responsibility for actions both taken or not taken which results in a disaster the scope of Hillsborough. Your apologia for Mr. Duckenfield failed to convince the inquiries chaired by Lord Justice Taylor & the Bishop of Liverpool. The Corner Inquest at Warrington found him to be one of many to be culpable.

However, blaming Hillsborough entirely on him is grossly unfair and allows others to escape responsibility. The FA chose Hillsborough knowing, or they should have known, of the potential for a catastrophic crushing dating back to 1991. Sheffield Wednesday also bears a lion’s share of the responsibility and this criminal court jury recognized that with the conviction of Mackrell. Too few stewards placed badly plus too few entry points led to this disaster. The club, the FA & the command of the South Yorkshire Police bear responsibility right up to & including the Commissioner & Chief Constable. This the Warrington Inquest recognized.

I hope you are not falling back on the tired lie that drunken, ticketless Liverpool supporters are responsible. All credible evidence put that deception to bed. It took a quarter century for that to happen. Professor Philip Scraton perhaps put it best. The underlying, fundamental cause of Hillsborough was a “conspiracy of complacency.” It must never be allowed to happen again.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 06 Apr 19 1.45pm

I’m not talking about events after the day, the subsequent reporting of it or events during the subsequent investigation.

Simply what happened at the Leppings Lane end in the lead up to kick off and the actual cause of the tragedy, which was NOT David Duckenfield...as will be demonstrated at court in due course.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 14 Apr 19 7.41am

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

I’m not talking about events after the day, the subsequent reporting of it or events during the subsequent investigation.

Simply what happened at the Leppings Lane end in the lead up to kick off and the actual cause of the tragedy, which was NOT David Duckenfield...as will be demonstrated at court in due course.

Correct.

The police trying to pin blame on innocent victims and their treatment of the families was an absolute disgrace and deserves admonishment of the highest order.
That said, this has been a 30 year war to clear Liverpool fans of culpability, it's got nothing to do with justice.

Justice would be recognising all of the root causes. An inadequate ground, over selling by the fa, an inexperienced commander and as tough as it is to swallow for them, 50,000 odd ticketless fans turning up last minute and rushing the turnstiles.

If, from the very beginning, old bill had gone with the truth (we had to open the gates as a crush was developing outside) leading to the inevitable crush happening in the ground, a decision made through lack of experience under extreme conditions, rather than disgracefully trying to shift all blame onto those poor innocent victims then all of this would be avoided. The Sun newspaper didn't help matters.

 

YT Flag Oxford 14 Apr 19 9.27am

Originally posted by kenbarr

[Link]

So David Duckenfield, whose stunning incompetence was held to be at fault for the needless deaths at Hillsborough by the Warrington Coroner’s Inquest, gets to fight another day after a jury couldn’t reach a unanimous verdict. Gordon Mackrell, who was Sheffield Wednesday’s Club Secretary & Safety Officer at the time, was found guilty of violating the Health & Safety Act (1974). Still, literally weeks before the 30th anniversary of this monstrous tragedy & the resulting cover-up, justice for those who died & those who must live with the horrible memories continues to be an unnecessarily long & winding road, filled with jarring potholes.

I'm not sure what your point is. That the jury was also incompetent, perhaps? Isn't everyone entitled to justice, including Mr Duckenfield, which includes the right to be considered innocent unless a jury of your peers decides ofherwise?

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 14 Apr 19 10.40am

Originally posted by YT

I'm not sure what your point is. That the jury was also incompetent, perhaps? Isn't everyone entitled to justice, including Mr Duckenfield, which includes the right to be considered innocent unless a jury of your peers decides ofherwise?

No, that is not my point. They went with what was presented in court just as the jury in the OJ SImpson murder trial did and came back with an acquittal based on the admissable evidence. Duckenfield and his legal team has presented evidence that some in the jury believed and others didn't. He will be tried again. Based on all I have read and heard, which is considerable, my opinion of the actions or inactions taken by David Duckenfield remains constant. He is materially responsible for the events at Hillsborough Football Ground on that dark April day in 1989. He is not by any means the only one responsible by any means. He is also not responsible for the cover-up. His is a sad story. He was never meant to be in that position but a series of unrelated events caused him to be there. Yet, there he was and with a full view of the Leppings Lane shelf terrace. He is, to be sure, a broken man, done in by his own failings and by those above him in the South Yorkshire Constabulary who allowed their biases concerning football supporters to influence their professionalism and then their innate sense of self-preservation to create an intolerable situation. By no means do I want Duckenfield to become the Hillsborough scapegoat. HE should answer solely for what he did and didn't do on the day. Others must answer for the cover-up, how the ground was staffed and indeed chosen for that match.

As for the so-called "50,000 ticketless fans" mentioned in an earlier post, that has been disproven by video evidence released in the Independent Commission (Bishop of Liverpool et.al.) report and corroborated by the Warrington Inquest. When the exit gate was opened on Duckenfield's orders, fans were clearly shown waving their tickets at the camera. If there were ticketless people at the match the objective evidence shows they were not a factor in the disaster, It was just another canard foisted upon us by those in the establishment to obstruct justice.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 14 Apr 19 11.14am

Originally posted by kenbarr

No, that is not my point. They went with what was presented in court just as the jury in the OJ SImpson murder trial did and came back with an acquittal based on the admissable evidence. Duckenfield and his legal team has presented evidence that some in the jury believed and others didn't. He will be tried again. Based on all I have read and heard, which is considerable, my opinion of the actions or inactions taken by David Duckenfield remains constant. He is materially responsible for the events at Hillsborough Football Ground on that dark April day in 1989. He is not by any means the only one responsible by any means. He is also not responsible for the cover-up. His is a sad story. He was never meant to be in that position but a series of unrelated events caused him to be there. Yet, there he was and with a full view of the Leppings Lane shelf terrace. He is, to be sure, a broken man, done in by his own failings and by those above him in the South Yorkshire Constabulary who allowed their biases concerning football supporters to influence their professionalism and then their innate sense of self-preservation to create an intolerable situation. By no means do I want Duckenfield to become the Hillsborough scapegoat. HE should answer solely for what he did and didn't do on the day. Others must answer for the cover-up, how the ground was staffed and indeed chosen for that match.

As for the so-called "50,000 ticketless fans" mentioned in an earlier post, that has been disproven by video evidence released in the Independent Commission (Bishop of Liverpool et.al.) report and corroborated by the Warrington Inquest. When the exit gate was opened on Duckenfield's orders, fans were clearly shown waving their tickets at the camera. If there were ticketless people at the match the objective evidence shows they were not a factor in the disaster, It was just another canard foisted upon us by those in the establishment to obstruct justice.

OJ is a poor comparison.

He got let off because he was black and the pressure was deliberately put on the jury not to make a 'racist' decision. Bloke was bang guilty, even on the evidence presented at the time. Biggest miscarriage of justice in modern history.

Duckenfield never set out to deliberately murder anyone, nor is he solely responsible as you seem to believe.

 

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 14 Apr 19 11.35am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

OJ is a poor comparison.

He got let off because he was black and the pressure was deliberately put on the jury not to make a 'racist' decision. Bloke was bang guilty, even on the evidence presented at the time. Biggest miscarriage of justice in modern history.

Duckenfield never set out to deliberately murder anyone, nor is he solely responsible as you seem to believe.

Your analysis betrays a basic lack of understanding of the Simpson case. I recommend you read the book “Outrage” by Vincent Bugliosi. His is a veteran prosecutor’s take on what happened and my points are based on his. In his view, the prosecution made many fundamental errors in presenting its case and the jury was abused by the court. He disagrees with the verdict but understands how it came about. For reference, Bugliosi successfully prosecuted Charles Manson for the Tate-LaBianca murders and had him sentenced to death which was commuted when the Supreme Court ruled capital punishment unconstitutional in the early 1970s. Neat trick considering Manson was not present at either murder scene.

I believe the charge against Duckenfield was something along the lines of criminal negligence so intent is not a relevant issue. These charges stem from the findings of the Warrington Inquest where he gave evidence.

The parallel between Simpson & Duckenfield is the juries. One came back with a declarative verdict, the other did not. Both had to wrestle with conflicting evidence. Perhaps the CPS needs to evaluate its performance.


 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 14 Apr 19 1.03pm

Originally posted by kenbarr

Your analysis betrays a basic lack of understanding of the Simpson case. I recommend you read the book “Outrage” by Vincent Bugliosi. His is a veteran prosecutor’s take on what happened and my points are based on his. In his view, the prosecution made many fundamental errors in presenting its case and the jury was abused by the court. He disagrees with the verdict but understands how it came about. For reference, Bugliosi successfully prosecuted Charles Manson for the Tate-LaBianca murders and had him sentenced to death which was commuted when the Supreme Court ruled capital punishment unconstitutional in the early 1970s. Neat trick considering Manson was not present at either murder scene.

I believe the charge against Duckenfield was something along the lines of criminal negligence so intent is not a relevant issue. These charges stem from the findings of the Warrington Inquest where he gave evidence.

The parallel between Simpson & Duckenfield is the juries. One came back with a declarative verdict, the other did not. Both had to wrestle with conflicting evidence. Perhaps the CPS needs to evaluate its performance.


Absolute nonsense of the first order.

Just another Hol poster who thinks they're smarter than they are.

In what world can you draw parallels between a US murder case to this instance of historical corporate manslaughter (or whatever the charge is) in the UK?

Just imagine the scene:

"In defence we quote the ruling of state of California Vs OJ Simpson case"

It's a bizarre and completely irrelevant comparison. Laughable.

Edited by ChrisGC (14 Apr 2019 1.11pm)

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 14 Apr 19 1.07pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

OJ is a poor comparison.

He got let off because he was black and the pressure was deliberately put on the jury not to make a 'racist' decision. Bloke was bang guilty, even on the evidence presented at the time. Biggest miscarriage of justice in modern history.

Duckenfield never set out to deliberately murder anyone, nor is he solely responsible as you seem to believe.

The biggest mistake in the OJ trial was to televise it and for the public to know the names of the jurors. Most of the black jurors lived in black neighbourhoods, maybe they thought he was innocent but it would be a brave person to find him guilty when all your neighbours will know how you voted.

 


One more point

Stirlingsays Flag 14 Apr 19 1.10pm

Originally posted by kenbarr

Your analysis betrays a basic lack of understanding of the Simpson case. I recommend you read the book “Outrage” by Vincent Bugliosi. His is a veteran prosecutor’s take on what happened and my points are based on his. In his view, the prosecution made many fundamental errors in presenting its case and the jury was abused by the court. He disagrees with the verdict but understands how it came about. For reference, Bugliosi successfully prosecuted Charles Manson for the Tate-LaBianca murders and had him sentenced to death which was commuted when the Supreme Court ruled capital punishment unconstitutional in the early 1970s. Neat trick considering Manson was not present at either murder scene.

I believe the charge against Duckenfield was something along the lines of criminal negligence so intent is not a relevant issue. These charges stem from the findings of the Warrington Inquest where he gave evidence.

The parallel between Simpson & Duckenfield is the juries. One came back with a declarative verdict, the other did not. Both had to wrestle with conflicting evidence. Perhaps the CPS needs to evaluate its performance.


Bugliosi was a brilliant man and he was very critical of that jury. Anyone who had seriously read and watched him over Simpson knew that he understood that race was a significant reason Simpson got off.

He claimed that he could have overcome this bias. I don't believe he could personally. As long as the defence provided some 'out' for the jury.....the jury were going to take it.....Besides the bias and the general dimness these people had to go back to their communities after and they knew the risks.

However Bugliosi liked to present himself as the master lawyer and a 'look how smart I am' angle was a big part of his approach to media.

But I don't mind arrogance when someone can back it up....and he could.

As for the Duckenfield/Mackrell case, personally I don't like scapegoats and that's what we have here. This tragedy was an event waiting to happen.....and they are the expendable human links in a chain.

Money is no replacement for the loss but we have nothing else and the families deserved compensation and I hope they received it.....I don't see how ruining the lives of pawns in a game of incompetence chess where the rules were already set helps anyone.

Nothing changes till you get bodies.....same old, same old.

However.....punishment for cover ups is something else entirely.


Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Apr 2019 2.57pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 14 Apr 19 1.16pm

Originally posted by Badger11

The biggest mistake in the OJ trial was to televise it and for the public to know the names of the jurors. Most of the black jurors lived in black neighbourhoods, maybe they thought he was innocent but it would be a brave person to find him guilty when all your neighbours will know how you voted.

Very true, totally agree. It boiled down to race.

The final nail in the coffin was the lead detective on tape coming out with racial slurs.
Rodney King was fresh in everyone's mind too. OJ got off simply because his defence team made it about race.

One of the jurors gave the black power salute ffs.

How any of this is relevant to Hillsborough is boggling my mind.

 

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 14 Apr 19 1.27pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Bugliosi was a brilliant man and he was very critical of that jury. Anyone who had seriously read and watched him over Simpson knew that he understood that race was a significant reason Simpson got off.

He claimed that he could have overcome this bias. I don't believe he could personally. As long as the defence provided some 'out' for the jury.....the jury were going to take it.....Besides the bias and the general dimness these people had to go back to their communities after and they knew the risks.

However Bugliosi liked to present himself as the master lawyer and a 'look how smart I am' angle was a big part of his approach to media.

But I don't mind arrogance when someone can back it up....and he could.

Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Apr 2019 1.14pm)

Your analysis of Bugliosi is essentially correct. He had the ability to back up his claims. I believe he would have obtained a conviction by managing the testimony & evidence better. Marcia Clark was not supposed to be lead prosecutor. Someone named Hodgeman was supposed to but had to bow out. I may have the name wrong. Christopher Darden has an absolote ‘mare. He got psyched out by the defense team, particularly Cochran & Scheck. While Bugliosi rightly cites as a factor he also shows both the prosecution & the judge made considerable errors. Among the legal scholars supporting Bugliosi’s arguments is Lawrence Tribe of Harvard Law School.

Bugliosi died a few years ago. Among his meant legal accomplishments was winning a moot court trial prosecuting Lee Harvey Oswald for the murder of John F Kennedy & Officer J.D. Tippett that was held in London.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

Stirlingsays Flag 14 Apr 19 1.28pm

Originally posted by Badger11

The biggest mistake in the OJ trial was to televise it and for the public to know the names of the jurors. Most of the black jurors lived in black neighbourhoods, maybe they thought he was innocent but it would be a brave person to find him guilty when all your neighbours will know how you voted.

If the trial hadn't have been moved downtown then that jury demographic would have been different and so would have the verdict.

Moving that trial decided it....filming it put the cherry on top.

Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Apr 2019 1.29pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > The Duckenfield/Mackrell Verdicts