You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Young Boys - Match thread
November 16 2026 6.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Young Boys - Match thread


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 13 Jul 19 8.52pm

So if I had to rate the players today:

Guiata: 5 - made a major mistake coming for the ball that led to the first goal (although PVA was largely responsible), other than that had a decent game
Ward: 6 - I thought he looked decent out there
Kelly: 5 - Barely noticed him
Dann: 6 - Like Kelly, but he does win every header
PVA: 4 - responsible for the first goal, gave the ball away too much
Townsend: 6 - ran around a lot, had a nice shot in second half
McArthur: 5 - ran around a lot, unfortunate to deflect in the second goal, not much else
Luka: 6 - made a few decent tackles
Schlupp: 5 - also gave the ball away too much. I still don't see what Hodgson sees in him
Sorloth: 2 - Really pathetic. Perhaps the play that summarizes him up best was right before the half when he had the ball, ran into space then fell down as soon as defenders came close
Benteke: 3 - not much better than Sorloth - although will give him the benefit of doubt, as probably didn't go in hard for headers in pre-season, and only had Sorloth to head to
Meyer: 7 - my player of the game (if I had to pick one). Made a difference for large parts of the second half. Had some poor touches, but many more good touches.
Riedawald: N/A - looked okay when he came on, but too short of time to rate
Woods: N/A - almost had a good header, but too short to rate
Wickham: 7 - I know, the same time as the prior two, but I actually thought he looked miles better than Sorloth or Benteke. Although may be easier as he only played for 10 mins
Dryer: N/A - Think he had 1 or 2 touches

Hodgson: 3 - played way too defensive in most of the game. Allowed YB to control the game, by not challenging the defenders. It's pre-season, go for it!

 

CT Charlie Flag 13 Jul 19 8.59pm

Serious question: Has Sorloth ever made even a single play that suggests he has potential? A trap, a pass, a turn, a dummy; a shot or a header with power... I've simply never seen him make a move that suggests he might be useful. Baffling.

 

Kant Flag exeter 13 Jul 19 10.04pm

I’ve not been a fan of Meyer as I think for all his undoubted skill he gets muscled out too easily in the Prem, but he totally transformed it for us today when he came on in the second half. If this is a taste of things to come then I think we can regard today’s game as a success; especially if management have also drawn the same conclusions as the rest of us about Sorloth. 2/10 was generous. Swallow the loss, chalk it down to experience and move him on.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 13 Jul 19 10.16pm

Originally posted by CT Charlie

Serious question: Has Sorloth ever made even a single play that suggests he has potential? A trap, a pass, a turn, a dummy; a shot or a header with power... I've simply never seen him make a move that suggests he might be useful. Baffling.

For about 30 seconds against Grimsby (whilst attacking the WHL end) he looked the part. He trapped the ball well and laid it off nicely and then took up a half decent position to receive the return ball.

Other than that he looked quite strong and almost ‘quick’ whilst warming up along the touch line in one of the games just before he went out on loan.

 

gerry theagle Flag newbury 13 Jul 19 10.50pm

Read my post YT, the team we played today were not as you put it low grade opposition, they are the top Swiss side and do pretty well in the Champions League. We are not Champions League material... yet. Do a bit of research before you post.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 13 Jul 19 10.54pm

Originally posted by YT

On today's evidence, our scouting team might as well be on the pitch.

Maybe we should add Barry Bannell to our scouting team. He always had plenty of success against Young Boys.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 13 Jul 19 11.17pm

Originally posted by gerry theagle

Read my post YT, the team we played today were not as you put it low grade opposition, they are the top Swiss side and do pretty well in the Champions League. We are not Champions League material... yet. Do a bit of research before you post.

Agreed.

I've seen them a couple of times when in Switzerland and they are a very decent team

 


Old, Ungifted and White

tpuffpendants Flag 13 Jul 19 11.27pm

Originally posted by CT Charlie

Serious question: Has Sorloth ever made even a single play that suggests he has potential? A trap, a pass, a turn, a dummy; a shot or a header with power... I've simply never seen him make a move that suggests he might be useful. Baffling.

He once scored against chelsea but it was called off from Reidewald playing the pass with a high foot. also completely ran over Moussa Dembele against spurs. other than these two moments no.

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 14 Jul 19 2.30am

Originally posted by jeeagles

Something Roy is notorious for

it's not uncle Roy choosing targets and whatnot though is it

 

Painter Flag Croydon 14 Jul 19 3.41am

Originally posted by YT

I accept that it's a pre-season knockabout, but it's nevertheless somewhat concerning that the team we put out - even though not our strongest - could be so poor against such low grade opposition.

Since when have Champions League teams been regarded as low grade opposition.
It was purely a fitness exercise in a meaningless game.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 14 Jul 19 7.27am

Originally posted by Painter


Since when have Champions League teams been regarded as low grade opposition.
It was purely a fitness exercise in a meaningless game.

Would you say the same about Linfield and Dundalk too?

 

YT Flag Oxford 14 Jul 19 7.49am

Originally posted by gerry theagle

Read my post YT, the team we played today were not as you put it low grade opposition, they are the top Swiss side and do pretty well in the Champions League. We are not Champions League material... yet. Do a bit of research before you post.

Why does that mean we have to play so poorly against them? We have just finished 12th in 'the best league in the world'. Are you saying that we are obliged to collapse into a heap of sh!t when confronted by a team that gets a regular run-out in the 'Champions' League?

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Chubskip Flag 14 Jul 19 7.51am

The left back looked outstanding for Young Boys, maybe we should look at him for Jan window? But I didn't realise how good Benteke is untill I saw Sorloth.

Edited by Chubskip (14 Jul 2019 8.56am)

 

kev64 Flag Cambs 14 Jul 19 8.18am

Quit frankly, the person that scouted and recommended Sorloth should be fired. He cost the club 9mill plus 4 years wages for a guy that would struggle in the Nat League.

The best we can hope for his to loan him out and and someone pick up his lunch tab.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 14 Jul 19 8.26am

Sorloth was approved by RH who said at the time he had consulted his contacts in Scandanavia and was happy it was a the right thing to do, so presumably you want Roy fired.

Sorloth has not cost the club 4 years wages as he only signed in Jan 2018.

We have had so little chance to see him it's hard to make a judgement

I am much more annoyed with whoever was behind Benteke, no one will ever hold their hand up to that.

Conversely, whoever was responsible for signing Bolasie did a great job, as did whoever got AWB tied in.


Originally posted by kev64

Quit frankly, the person that scouted and recommended Sorloth should be fired. He cost the club 9mill plus 4 years wages for a guy that would struggle in the Nat League.

The best we can hope for his to loan him out and and someone pick up his lunch tab.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Casual Flag Orpington 14 Jul 19 8.36am

Originally posted by HKOwen

Sorloth was approved by RH who said at the time he had consulted his contacts in Scandanavia and was happy it was a the right thing to do, so presumably you want Roy fired.

Sorloth has not cost the club 4 years wages as he only signed in Jan 2018.

We have had so little chance to see him it's hard to make a judgement

I am much more annoyed with whoever was behind Benteke, no one will ever hold their hand up to that.

Conversely, whoever was responsible for signing Bolasie did a great job, as did whoever got AWB tied in.



Can’t really dig out whoever signed Benteke , he was a good international player over a few years , can’t remember anyone complaining at the time. A player dramatically losing form /ability a year after signing is his fault.
Even John Lewis wouldn’t honour a receipt after a year of use.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 14 Jul 19 9.55am

Originally posted by vflynn

Townsend put a shift in as usual the rest of the team well.... best we get back to beckinham quick smart and put together some attacking moves and focus on keeping the ball

It would be criminal that we don't strengthen our attack based on last season. £20 million should secure somebody half decent. Whoever comes should go straight into the team either on his own or with one of the "lumps". In relation to this friendly seemed to remember we looked half decent under FDB pre season and we all know what happened at the beginning of that season. From reading sounds like a decent outfit to play. However as you say hard work needed.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 14 Jul 19 9.58am

Originally posted by HKOwen

Sorloth was approved by RH who said at the time he had consulted his contacts in Scandanavia and was happy it was a the right thing to do, so presumably you want Roy fired.

Sorloth has not cost the club 4 years wages as he only signed in Jan 2018.

We have had so little chance to see him it's hard to make a judgement

I am much more annoyed with whoever was behind Benteke, no one will ever hold their hand up to that.

Conversely, whoever was responsible for signing Bolasie did a great job, as did whoever got AWB tied in.


DF involved I seem to remember. As we have such a bad recent record against Bristol City I've been living off this transfer for a long time. He was young player of the season for them previously.

Edited by Booted Eagle (14 Jul 2019 9.59am)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

kev64 Flag Cambs 14 Jul 19 10.03am

Originally posted by HKOwen

Sorloth was approved by RH who said at the time he had consulted his contacts in Scandanavia and was happy it was a the right thing to do, so presumably you want Roy fired.

Sorloth has not cost the club 4 years wages as he only signed in Jan 2018.

We have had so little chance to see him it's hard to make a judgement

I am much more annoyed with whoever was behind Benteke, no one will ever hold their hand up to that.

Conversely, whoever was responsible for signing Bolasie did a great job, as did whoever got AWB tied in.


It only takes ten minutes of seeing Sorloth on a pitch to see he’s no where near PL or even Championship standard , by the time his contract ends or we pay him off to leave it’s going to be 4 Years wages.

There is absolutely zero teams in FL that would have him in the starting line up, or stump up a transfer fee.

 

EddieMac Flag 14 Jul 19 11.29am

I said it within the first 20 minutes of seeing Soerloth play. The man is an absolute travesty of a player and should not be playing professional football. People on here saying he deserves a chance, he has had lots of chances and has done nothing. One of the worst signings in not only our football club but also in the history of football. Shocking

 

Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Young Boys - Match thread