You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Barnet vs Palace
November 16 2026 6.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Barnet vs Palace


Page 4 of 4 << First< 1 2 3 4
JohnB Flag 17 Jul 19 12.18pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I'm not in favour of selling our best players all.
In the case of AWB, I think that 45 million plus add ons was far too cheap a price for the best tackler in Europe with many years of playing time ahead.

To us, he was worth far more.

At the time of the transfer, £45+5 felt to me like a good deal. He's got incredible potential but he'd still only played 42 games for us and was a record breaking fee.

Roll on a couple of weeks and seeing the likes of Maguire going for £80m and Dunk for £45m, coupled with Arsenal offering £40m for Zaha. You have to feel that the deal looks poor and question why other clubs feel they can offer derogatory fees to us and not others. If Levy was in charge, AWB probably would have gone for much more....but then he wouldn't have spent any of it either.

 

Dannyh.V2 Flag Stone lickers 17 Jul 19 12.21pm

Originally posted by JohnB

At the time of the transfer, £45+5 felt to me like a good deal. He's got incredible potential but he'd still only played 42 games for us and was a record breaking fee.

Roll on a couple of weeks and seeing the likes of Maguire going for £80m and Dunk for £45m, coupled with Arsenal offering £40m for Zaha. You have to feel that the deal looks poor and question why other clubs feel they can offer derogatory fees to us and not others. If Levy was in charge, AWB probably would have gone for much more....but then he wouldn't have spent any of it either.

My fear is neither will we.

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 17 Jul 19 12.50pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I think the 6-2 makes it look worse. No Palace side should be losing by that margin to that opposition.

It makes you realise how rare someone like Wilf or AWB is and why we should not sell our future for a poultry 50 million.

I think it shows us that our reserve and youth players are not ready for EPL. we need to take a serious look at the older ones and consider if they do have a future. I am not picking on Innis but he takes up a squad place and I can not see him ever being an EPL player, release him and let him find the correct level

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 17 Jul 19 1.32pm

Originally posted by JohnB

At the time of the transfer, £45+5 felt to me like a good deal. He's got incredible potential but he'd still only played 42 games for us and was a record breaking fee.

Roll on a couple of weeks and seeing the likes of Maguire going for £80m and Dunk for £45m, coupled with Arsenal offering £40m for Zaha. You have to feel that the deal looks poor and question why other clubs feel they can offer derogatory fees to us and not others. If Levy was in charge, AWB probably would have gone for much more....but then he wouldn't have spent any of it either. [ /quote]
-------------------------------------------------------

Yeah, I know what you thought.

You were wrong.

The club couldn't wait to take the money.


Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (17 Jul 2019 1.34pm)

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 17 Jul 19 1.45pm

Originally posted by JohnB

At the time of the transfer, £45+5 felt to me like a good deal. He's got incredible potential but he'd still only played 42 games for us and was a record breaking fee.

Roll on a couple of weeks and seeing the likes of Maguire going for £80m and Dunk for £45m, coupled with Arsenal offering £40m for Zaha. You have to feel that the deal looks poor and question why other clubs feel they can offer derogatory fees to us and not others. If Levy was in charge, AWB probably would have gone for much more....but then he wouldn't have spent any of it either.

It could still be a good deal depending on who we get in. Buy Max Aaron's for 20m then that's is 30m in the pocket or on other players.

However, this should have been lined up before AWB went. Now clubs know we have 45m cash, and will try to jack up the prices.

80m for Maguire is too much, given last season he was nowhere near as good as the season before. Whilst 45m for Dunk is utterly laughable.

 

beak Flag croydon 17 Jul 19 2.31pm

Dunk may have attracted a premium over AWB because he is a centre back,centre backs are part of the spine of any team.

 

Master Coin Flag 17 Jul 19 8.48pm

Originally posted by JohnB

At the time of the transfer, £45+5 felt to me like a good deal. He's got incredible potential but he'd still only played 42 games for us and was a record breaking fee.

Roll on a couple of weeks and seeing the likes of Maguire going for £80m and Dunk for £45m, coupled with Arsenal offering £40m for Zaha. You have to feel that the deal looks poor and question why other clubs feel they can offer derogatory fees to us and not others. If Levy was in charge, AWB probably would have gone for much more....but then he wouldn't have spent any of it either.

Well the Dunk valuation is theoretical because nobody knows how legit that rumour is. Also centre backs have a higher premium than full backs throughout history so that is a factor too.

A better comparison would be that Atletico are paying £20m for Trippier who (in Southgates view at least) is ahead of AWB. So, by that logic we did great business.

I know KT only had a year left and a bad year last year so not truly comparable. But my point is neither is Dunk/Maguire. I remain confident that £50m for a full back is great business.

 

Page 4 of 4 << First< 1 2 3 4

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Barnet vs Palace