You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > var
November 22 2026 7.32pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

var


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 09 Aug 19 7.33pm

Just watching the build up to Liverpool vs Norwich. I forgot about VAR this season. It's going to be a bloody nightmare.

It will be scrapped after this season, if it makes the season.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Aug 19 7.44pm

Originally posted by Crystal_Clear

Just watching the build up to Liverpool vs Norwich. I forgot about VAR this season. It's going to be a bloody nightmare.

It will be scrapped after this season, if it makes the season.

I beg to differ.
VAR is here to stay.

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 09 Aug 19 9.08pm

Look at this !!!!!!!!!!!!

Cant start the game because the microphone doesnt work.

Just the start of the VAR debacle.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 09 Aug 19 9.35pm

I have been speaking about this with a few people and the problem with VAR is the same as not using VAR people.

While people do make the decisions it will end the same because it comes down to how each person interprates the rules and what they are seeing.

Even last season you would see multi refs on different shows watching replays and coming out with this was a pen or it wasn't.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 10 Aug 19 2.21pm

VAR killing the game!

Watching the WHUFC v MCFC game it is just a joke!

No atmosphere, the Man City goals barely celebrated because of the likely VAR review and both of the goal decisions wrong! The first Sterling goal was onside and given off and the second was offside and given on!

The TV angles used for VAR gave them one view but this gave a distorted and incorrect result and when each is viewed perfectly side on they are both wrong.

Then the saved penalty was retaken for both encroachment and the goalie moving off his line.

This is just gonna kill any excitement in watching the game IMHO.


Edited by Phil’s Barber (10 Aug 2019 2.23pm)

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 10 Aug 19 2.57pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

VAR killing the game!

Watching the WHUFC v MCFC game it is just a joke!

No atmosphere, the Man City goals barely celebrated because of the likely VAR review and both of the goal decisions wrong! The first Sterling goal was onside and given off and the second was offside and given on!

The TV angles used for VAR gave them one view but this gave a distorted and incorrect result and when each is viewed perfectly side on they are both wrong.

Then the saved penalty was retaken for both encroachment and the goalie moving off his line.

This is just gonna kill any excitement in watching the game IMHO.


Edited by Phil’s Barber (10 Aug 2019 2.23pm)

Offside used to be the players foot/leg, now it is the whole of the body from shoulder to shoulder. I too, watche BT Sports coverage of said match & was suprised bout the VAR decisions except the pen, keeper was well off his line & there were 2 WH players encroaching.

VAR is going to cause mayhem this season, BUT, its what everybody has been wanting, an old adage, be carefull what you ask for, springs to mind.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Superhorns3 Flag Harpdenden 10 Aug 19 10.53pm

The goalies have been warned about coming off their line too far ...

However I agree it will contentious in some cases but will prove to be useful in some cases .

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 11 Aug 19 12.07am

Originally posted by Crystal_Clear

Just watching the build up to Liverpool vs Norwich. I forgot about VAR this season. It's going to be a bloody nightmare.

It will be scrapped after this season, if it makes the season.

It was disastrous during the Women's World Cup. I'm guessing there will be a few results that will be heavily skewed by it this season which will leave everyone infuriated by the end of the season. It should be used very sparingly.

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 11 Aug 19 12.08am

Originally posted by grumpymort

I have been speaking about this with a few people and the problem with VAR is the same as not using VAR people.

While people do make the decisions it will end the same because it comes down to how each person interprates the rules and what they are seeing.

Even last season you would see multi refs on different shows watching replays and coming out with this was a pen or it wasn't.

Exactly that. It can be useful in a very limited capacity but I fear we're going from one explain to the other. I dread to think how many pens will be retaken this year.

 

Jamesrichards8 Flag 11 Aug 19 2.24am

Absolute VAR horror show in the man city game. No consistency, no logic and much less excitement with VAR. The sooner they scrap this nonsense the better. Instead of the referee making the (occasionally incorrect) decision with the benefit of context of the game, some inconsistent ‘officials’ are going to make the (occasionally incorrect) call from some room somewhere far away.. Where’s the benefit?

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (11 Aug 2019 2.27am)

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

Ghostship Flag Norfolk 11 Aug 19 7.18am

It is ridiculous that someone can have a goal ruled out as their shoulder was offside things like this make it a farce and in a close call like that advantage should go the attacking player.

You just know that at some point Palace will get screwed over by this

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 11 Aug 19 3.33pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Offside used to be the players foot/leg, now it is the whole of the body from shoulder to shoulder. I too, watche BT Sports coverage of said match & was suprised bout the VAR decisions except the pen, keeper was well off his line & there were 2 WH players encroaching.

VAR is going to cause mayhem this season, BUT, its what everybody has been wanting, an old adage, be carefull what you ask for, springs to mind.

I think the goalie moving wasnt the reason.
Rice clearing the ball from encroaching was.
If fabianski had pushed it to safety ie behind then it would have stood.
Well that's what dipsy la la and po said on motd

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 11 Aug 19 3.34pm

Originally posted by Ghostship

It is ridiculous that someone can have a goal ruled out as their shoulder was offside things like this make it a farce and in a close call like that advantage should go the attacking player.

You just know that at some point Palace will get screwed over by this

And probably gain from it.
Over 38 games no matter the law of averages will prove correct surely.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Aug 19 4.20pm

Originally posted by cryrst

I think the goalie moving wasnt the reason.
Rice clearing the ball from encroaching was.
If fabianski had pushed it to safety ie behind then it would have stood.

Well that's what dipsy la la and po said on motd

Spot on !

 

becky Flag over the moon 11 Aug 19 6.07pm

Strangely, VAR was used twice in our game yesterday, and no-one even noticed.......

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Invalid user 2019 Flag 11 Aug 19 6.24pm

Originally posted by Jamesrichards8

Absolute VAR horror show in the man city game. No consistency, no logic and much less excitement with VAR. The sooner they scrap this nonsense the better. Instead of the referee making the (occasionally incorrect) decision with the benefit of context of the game, some inconsistent ‘officials’ are going to make the (occasionally incorrect) call from some room somewhere far away.. Where’s the benefit?

Edited by Jamesrichards8 (11 Aug 2019 2.27am)

Agreed, and expect more of the same going forward.

 

YT Flag Oxford 11 Aug 19 7.33pm

Sorry if I'm late to the party, but I thought var was only supposed to be used in four specific scenarios, and that those scenarios didn't include goalie not on line/defender encroaching at a penalty. What's happening?

Also, the Wolves manager made a shrewd observation today. In a 0-0 draw, the only big celebration, he said, was LCFC fans giving it large when a Wolves 'goal' was ruled out by a var analysis. And that was after a couple of minutes' delay. His point was that the passion within football is in danger of ebbing away. You are supposed to go potty when your own team scores (and then occasionally end up gutted when you realise that the officials have ruled it out) - you aren't supposed to go potty at the oppo NOT scoring. It's all skewed.

Finally, a number of posters have said what I've been saying throughout the var 'debate'. Instead of one identifiable person making wrong decisions, we will now simply have a group of nameless, faceless people making wrong decisions. The "it will even itself out over a season" argument is irrelevant, and anyway that argument surely applies whether there is or isn't var. Indeed; as we know, the injustices suffered by CPFC are seldom evened out!

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

cryrst Flag The garden of England 11 Aug 19 9.32pm

It seems that an appeal can be made for a card by a footballer or club.
That's fair and correct.
All var does is gives this appeal instantly.
Even appeal results can be wrong.
If after this season it has done more harm than good then get rid.
we as fans should respect and give it a chance.
Most other sports have instant decisions with technology and it generally improves it.
Football is a sport and var will sink or swim within it.

 

Superhorns3 Flag Harpdenden 11 Aug 19 10.51pm

Well the key with those handballs and offsides is to be consistent but like most things in football it won't be !!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 13 Aug 19 10.58am

Originally posted by Ghostship

It is ridiculous that someone can have a goal ruled out as their shoulder was offside things like this make it a farce and in a close call like that advantage should go the attacking player.

You just know that at some point Palace will get screwed over by this

I have to say that I am a bit uncomfortable with the offside aspect of VAR whereby one can be given offside by the length of a toe.

In cricket, if an umpire in a LBW situation gives 'Not out' because he believes the ball is missing the stumps but technology reveals it would have just brushed the stumps, the 'Not out' stands'. I think that over half the ball needs to touch the stumps for the decision to be overturned.

Perhaps there should be a similar stance with VAR under the umbrella of a 'Clear and obvious error'.It cannot be a 'clear and obvious error' if the assistant deems a player is onside and it is revealed that he was offside by a hair's breadth.

Edited by Willo (13 Aug 2019 11.07am)

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > var