You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Something, something climate.
November 21 2026 10.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Something, something climate.


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Maggot Flag Bromley 10 Mar 20 3.41pm

Thank you. So Cryrst was wrong, and only about 12,000 people died in 1937.

 

Maggot Flag Bromley 10 Mar 20 3.44pm

Originally posted by Badger11

A more measured response to Extinction Rebellion these scientists do not think it is possible to be carbon neutral by 2050 let alone earlier without damaging our economy.

[Link]

As I said in an earlier post let's not throw the baby out with the bath water.

Edited by Badger11 (10 Mar 2020 3.05pm)

We can't save the planet, it costs too much

 

Stirlingsays Flag 10 Mar 20 3.46pm

Originally posted by Maggot

Thank you. So Cryrst was wrong, and only about 12,000 people died in 1937.

While I wouldn't say 'number of deaths' is strictly relevant due to technological and infrastructure improvements since earlier last century I would say that you did kind of ignore what that graph was saying.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Speronilover69 8=D~~ Flag Horsham 10 Mar 20 4.06pm

Originally posted by Maggot

We can't save the planet, it costs too much

Edited by Speronilover69 8=D~~ (10 Mar 2020 4.07pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 10 Mar 20 4.07pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

I agree with the UK point from a purely technical outcome - but in order to change things you also have to commit yourself for others to follow and take you seriously. I’m not sure you could expect any of the big polluting nations to listen to us, or anyone else if we weren’t at least trying to practice what we preached.

Several small steps are better than none. And yes, there’s loads of VS going on but that’s just par for the course - nothing ever happens fast unless someone takes a massive s*** on the doorstep.

At the moment the gut is starting to rumble.

Also I got bored of the man made/natural cycle/accelerated cycle/made up/not made up roundabout of arguments a while ago. It distracts from the real issue - just stop polluting.

Sorry I missed this due to my enjoyably pointless troll wars with 'progressive inc'.

Personally I don't think wearing a hair-shirt is going to make any difference to the attitude of China or indeed India.

They aren't.....how shall we put this....'pro Greta'. I'm not in favour of economically hamstringing ourselves as some sort of 'environmental Jesus on the cross' example that will get laughed at.

If you are genuinely serious about reducing pollution then get that sterilization needle out for the third world.....because that's where all the pollution growth is going to come from...as rapid population and GDP growth continue.

The Europeans are the only sados not having enough kids to replace themselves......Yet all these wackos are virtue signaling at us.

Edited by Stirlingsays (10 Mar 2020 4.08pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Maggot Flag Bromley 10 Mar 20 5.43pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays


If you are genuinely serious about reducing pollution then get that sterilization needle out for the third world.....because that's where all the pollution growth is going to come from...as rapid population and GDP growth continue.


Edited by Stirlingsays (10 Mar 2020 4.08pm)

Are you serious?

Even if we ignore the horrific, eugenic nature of this suggestion. The poorest people in the 3rd world have the smallest carbon footprints, especially compared to us wealthy westerners. They don't drive or fly and use hardly any electricity.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 10 Mar 20 5.58pm

Originally posted by Maggot

Are you serious?

Even if we ignore the horrific, eugenic nature of this suggestion. The poorest people in the 3rd world have the smallest carbon footprints, especially compared to us wealthy westerners. They don't drive or fly and use hardly any electricity.

You aren't serious about tackling pollution then. Also, rather irritatingly you don't seem to have read the post properly.

The third world is rapidly developing...Both in population and GDP and hence emissions...that's where all the extra pollution is going to come from....that and other non European sources and certainly not Europe, where the population rate is decreasing.

Eugenics has nothing whatsoever to do with it....Indeed, explain what you mean?

Plus you ignored the point about the graph.

Edited by Stirlingsays (10 Mar 2020 6.12pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

cryrst Flag The garden of England 10 Mar 20 7.23pm

Originally posted by Maggot

Thank you. So Cryrst was wrong, and only about 12,000 people died in 1937.

Oh dear.
I may have been out by a year or two but the trend is there.
If we are screwing up the earth and we are destroying humanity I would expect the graph to be rising.
Co2 we are told will melt all the ice and floods will be biblical.
Strange how in the last 2 years the arctic has had the heaviest snowfall in memory and 8 out of the last 10 years arctic ice has increased.
I suppose now its global cooling is it.
Sorry bar eagle, is it ?

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 10 Mar 20 7.23pm

Fanx ted

 

Maggot Flag Bromley 10 Mar 20 8.38pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Oh dear.
I may have been out by a year or two but the trend is there.
If we are screwing up the earth and we are destroying humanity I would expect the graph to be rising.
Co2 we are told will melt all the ice and floods will be biblical.
Strange how in the last 2 years the arctic has had the heaviest snowfall in memory and 8 out of the last 10 years arctic ice has increased.
I suppose now its global cooling is it.
Sorry bar eagle, is it ?


You seem to think that we aren't facing a climate crisis unless millions of people are killed by it.

As pointed out elsewhere advances in technology and healthcare mean that fortunately the death tolls are now lower.

Can you please provide evidence for your claims about arctic ice increasing. The amount of snowfall is irrelevant.

I refer again to my temperature graph as you ignored it previously.

Edited by Maggot (10 Mar 2020 8.46pm)

GlobalAverage_2018.png Attachment: GlobalAverage_2018.png (264.33Kb)

 

Maggot Flag Bromley 10 Mar 20 8.48pm

In the not so distant future, people will look at climate change deniers in the same light as Holocaust deniers.

 

SavoyTruffle Flag 10 Mar 20 9.55pm

The only reason this exists as any type of debate topic is because the wealthiest industry in human history has spent billions of dollars to spread disinformation in the hope of maintaining their profits.

Oil and gas companies such as ExxonMobil were tracking the effects of CO2 in the atmosphere and climate modelling as early as 1970s and on repeated occasion their own research was showing the damage their industry was having.

[Link]

You can read about it above. They then spent insane amounts of money on lobbying politicians and the media to lie and block climate legislation.

If you deny the effects of climate change you are simply doing the bidding of the fossil fuel industry, only difference is you the sucker not getting paid like the politicians and talking heads on TV.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 11 Mar 20 5.02am

Originally posted by Maggot


You seem to think that we aren't facing a climate crisis unless millions of people are killed by it.

As pointed out elsewhere advances in technology and healthcare mean that fortunately the death tolls are now lower.

Can you please provide evidence for your claims about arctic ice increasing. The amount of snowfall is irrelevant.

I refer again to my temperature graph as you ignored it previously.

Edited by Maggot (10 Mar 2020 8.46pm)

I read about the arctic ice. Where did you get your info?

 

Maggot Flag Bromley 11 Mar 20 6.22am

Originally posted by SavoyTruffle

The only reason this exists as any type of debate topic is because the wealthiest industry in human history has spent billions of dollars to spread disinformation in the hope of maintaining their profits.

Oil and gas companies such as ExxonMobil were tracking the effects of CO2 in the atmosphere and climate modelling as early as 1970s and on repeated occasion their own research was showing the damage their industry was having.

[Link]

You can read about it above. They then spent insane amounts of money on lobbying politicians and the media to lie and block climate legislation.

If you deny the effects of climate change you are simply doing the bidding of the fossil fuel industry, only difference is you the sucker not getting paid like the politicians and talking heads on TV.


Great post.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 11 Mar 20 7.12am

Originally posted by SavoyTruffle

The only reason this exists as any type of debate topic is because the wealthiest industry in human history has spent billions of dollars to spread disinformation in the hope of maintaining their profits.

Oil and gas companies such as ExxonMobil were tracking the effects of CO2 in the atmosphere and climate modelling as early as 1970s and on repeated occasion their own research was showing the damage their industry was having.

[Link]

You can read about it above. They then spent insane amounts of money on lobbying politicians and the media to lie and block climate legislation.

If you deny the effects of climate change you are simply doing the bidding of the fossil fuel industry, only difference is you the sucker not getting paid like the politicians and talking heads on TV.

There are lots of lobbies lobbying politicians and spending money to influence. I have little doubt that you would approve of some of them as you disapprove of others. So while, I'd agree that the power of lobbyists is a disfigurement of the democratic process.....I'm not exactly sure what should be done about it.....as interest groups themselves exist to enact change or the maintenance of what motivates them.

So your lobbyist point kind of gets an acknowledgement from me but also a shrug.

Moving onto your ExxonMobil points....you seem to think that everyone who reads your post is going to agree with you that oil and fossil fuel multinationals are inherently bad for us. While I'd probably agree that these companies are no different to most self interested capitalists I'd also make the point that oil and fossil fuels are essential for modern life.

If these companies didn't exist modern civilisations around the globe would collapse from their current lifestyle levels and mass starvation would exist on a national level in many locations.

In truth this is the outcome of warm worded policies pushed by the 'Greta lobby' and ExR in action and most of us are obviously opposed to it.

While I'd agree that climate change is a reality I also regard the claims made by its 'Greta' activists are mostly extreme and based upon fear mongering.

That said, the climate change from emissions is obviously going to worsen as countries continue to develop globally and the world population increases (though as stated this population increase isn't from Europeans themselves). So anyone (and I'm not saying you) serious about this issue is kidding themselves to think that using multicolored bins and less plastic carry bags makes even the slightest difference.

Indeed, it often makes me smile that those who support the 'Greta' lobby also support mass immigration into Europe.....Without seeming to realise or accept the obvious result that increasing the population in Europe will more quickly increases emissions due to the higher lifestyle.

I wonder why they would hold two such contradictory desires in their heads? I summise that for some of them it'll be because they just don't examine the ideas much...for others, it'll be because their environmentalism is just part of a wider agenda.


Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Mar 2020 7.26am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 11 Mar 20 8.02am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

There are lots of lobbies lobbying politicians and spending money to influence. I have little doubt that you would approve of some of them as you disapprove of others. So while, I'd agree that the power of lobbyists is a disfigurement of the democratic process.....I'm not exactly sure what should be done about it.....as interest groups themselves exist to enact change or the maintenance of what motivates them.

So your lobbyist point kind of gets an acknowledgement from me but also a shrug.

Moving onto your ExxonMobil points....you seem to think that everyone who reads your post is going to agree with you that oil and fossil fuel multinationals are inherently bad for us. While I'd probably agree that these companies are no different to most self interested capitalists I'd also make the point that oil and fossil fuels are essential for modern life.

If these companies didn't exist modern civilisations around the globe would collapse from their current lifestyle levels and mass starvation would exist on a national level in many locations.

In truth this is the outcome of warm worded policies pushed by the 'Greta lobby' and ExR in action and most of us are obviously opposed to it.

While I'd agree that climate change is a reality I also regard the claims made by its 'Greta' activists are mostly extreme and based upon fear mongering.

That said, the climate change from emissions is obviously going to worsen as countries continue to develop globally and the world population increases (though as stated this population increase isn't from Europeans themselves). So anyone (and I'm not saying you) serious about this issue is kidding themselves to think that using multicolored bins and less plastic carry bags makes even the slightest difference.

Indeed, it often makes me smile that those who support the 'Greta' lobby also support mass immigration into Europe.....Without seeming to realise or accept the obvious result that increasing the population in Europe will more quickly increases emissions due to the higher lifestyle.

I wonder why they would hold two such contradictory desires in their heads? I summise that for some of them it'll be because they just don't examine the ideas much...for others, it'll be because their environmentalism is just part of a wider agenda.

Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Mar 2020 7.26am)

Those that support Greta often have 2 cars and enjoy holidays in Tuscany (until recently). I had this debate with my lefty middle class friends they are all pro Greta and yet their green credentials don't stand up to examination.

We are actually not that far apart in our thinking none of us want to give up our lifestyle but that doesn't mean you can't use common-sense.

I guess the difference is that I recognise that I have a lifestyle that consumes energy and I am not prepared to wear the hair shirt whilst they are virtue signalling hypocrites.

In Europe technology will largely solve this issue over time without us having to revert to a horse and cart. As Stirlingsay we are not the problem it is the rest of the world and how they react that will make the difference.

 


One more point

Stirlingsays Flag 11 Mar 20 8.38am

Originally posted by Badger11

Those that support Greta often have 2 cars and enjoy holidays in Tuscany (until recently). I had this debate with my lefty middle class friends they are all pro Greta and yet their green credentials don't stand up to examination.

We are actually not that far apart in our thinking none of us want to give up our lifestyle but that doesn't mean you can't use common-sense.

I guess the difference is that I recognise that I have a lifestyle that consumes energy and I am not prepared to wear the hair shirt whilst they are virtue signalling hypocrites.

In Europe technology will largely solve this issue over time without us having to revert to a horse and cart. As Stirlingsay we are not the problem it is the rest of the world and how they react that will make the difference.

Yep, it's technology or bust and always has been.

The environmentaal activists always think they can point to this or that entity as the point of the problem.....yet as always if you exist you are consuming energy and I bet most of them are hypocritical when it comes to their activism or convenience....whether it's tucking into that meat product or traveling by car it's all convenience.....And all of which require the oil and fossil fuel industry.

Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Mar 2020 8.39am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

stuckinbristol Flag In the woodwork. 11 Mar 20 9.19am

Bristol has just been announced as the greenest city in Britain.
So why was it that Greta and her rent-a-mob deemed it necessary to spend a day completely shutting down the city centre, and causing thousands of pounds of damage to the grass at the council house, to thank us?

 

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 11 Mar 20 9.20am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Yep, it's technology or bust and always has been.

The environmentaal activists always think they can point to this or that entity as the point of the problem.....yet as always if you exist you are consuming energy and I bet most of them are hypocritical when it comes to their activism or convenience....whether it's tucking into that meat product or traveling by car it's all convenience.....And all of which require the oil and fossil fuel industry.

Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Mar 2020 8.39am)

Technology is not the answer. Reduce the population massively (as unPC as it sounds) will be the major step. Mother Earth can’t cope. We have bred and spread like a cancer raping and pillaging ever depleting resources. The iron, precious metals, oil, flora and fauna are not able to be replaced and we are running out fast. The outfall goes into our climate and oceans by way of pollution exasperating the problem. It’s a downward circle. Those that can’t see the link really do need to join the flat earth society.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 11 Mar 20 9.25am

Originally posted by BarEagle

Technology is not the answer. Reduce the population massively (as unPC as it sounds) will be the major step. Mother Earth can’t cope. We have bred and spread like a cancer raping and pillaging ever depleting resources. The iron, precious metals, oil, flora and fauna are not able to be replaced and we are running out fast. The outfall goes into our climate and oceans by way of pollution exasperating the problem. It’s a downward circle. Those that can’t see the link really do need to join the flat earth society.

I have some sympathy with your viewpoint however I don't in seriousness see world leaders taking the sterilization route.....So that's why I say it's technology or bust.

I'd also say that the earth will be fine regardless of whether humans are fecking up the environment or not.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Something, something climate.