You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > James McCarthy (rumour)
November 16 2026 5.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

James McCarthy (rumour)


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 04 Aug 20 1.49pm

Originally posted by doombear

I agree about Kouyate. I think he's more of a CB. With the injuries to Tomkins and Cahill, both of whom may well struggle to be back for the start of the new season, we may need to play him alongside Dann.

I think McArthur is on the decline, sadly, and am not sure how much he will feature next season.

You are right about the lack of movement. I seem to recall many occasions where a player looked up, couldn't see a forward pass, get closed down, pass sideways/backwards or even lose the ball. Occasionally there were some good interplay, often involving PvA and Wilf.

As for McCarthy, I think he may have 2 years left on his contract and if so, I'm inclined to keep him for the coming year.

I remember Danny Murphy talking about Roy drilling his players to keep their shape, and how over time their analysis tool which showed the large circles of areas each player covers during a match got smaller and smaller each week, as they ventured less and concentrated on keeping shape. Shape is important but being too rigid leads to the lack of movement that you mention, which i causing us problems. It seems only a few players have that license to move and create space we so desperately need. I don't think this is down to 'ageing squad' which is quoted on here a lot, it's simply Hodgson's way so don't expect it to change for another season.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 04 Aug 20 2.33pm

[Link]

Everybody wants him. 15 mil then.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Putitout Flag Oxford 04 Aug 20 3.18pm

So now we are told even Celtic, are keen to get him . Where the hell were all these outfits when we dragged him out of Everton, for next to nothing? Can only think he was expected to be a injury case, and has proved otherwise . So if they are that keen make sure they pay well for him, and get on with revitalising the squad.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 05 Aug 20 5.36pm

Watching McCarthy run around, break up play and play the simple pass suggests he'd be perfect in the role of feeding the better player a la Graham Roberts and Glenn Hoddle, i.e the minder for the play maker. He played best at Everton acc to some of their fans when he was supporting Gareth Barry, McCarthy's form declined before his injury when Barry went. I reckon it's why Villa want him - to look after Jack Grealish. But it looks like we can get nearer ten than 5 mil if all these others are interested as well. If he thrives elsewhere it might be another Sorloth scenario!

 

nead1 Flag 05 Aug 20 6.28pm

I suspect he will indeed thrive. He is an established PL player, an international and has just played a full season in the PL with no fitness issues. £10m for that experience and under 30 in terms of age is cheap. I have always thought he is underestimated at Palace. He has a fantastic range of passing for a start as he has demonstrated on many occasions.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 06 Aug 20 1.06pm

he does have a good range of passing, but he tends to do the worldy crossfield pass better than he does the well-weighted through ball - I like him and a lot of his work can go unnoticed, but he usually does one utterly crap thing per game, an over hit pass when someone is clean through or his charging into one of his own defenders to set up Wolves's second goal in the recent 0-2 - could be a bit of rustiness, but I think some aspects of his technical play are a bit lacking.

 

EddieMac Flag 06 Aug 20 3.21pm

All I know is he is a better player than Kouyate and McCarthur is on his last legs. Keep him.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 06 Aug 20 6.38pm

we can only sell players other teams actually want to bid for, if we are bringing in new players some will have to move on.

£5m & (prob) 70k a week into the wage budget aint to be sniffed at, especially when kouyate is just as good as him.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


EddieMac Flag 07 Aug 20 8.01am

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

we can only sell players other teams actually want to bid for, if we are bringing in new players some will have to move on.

£5m & (prob) 70k a week into the wage budget aint to be sniffed at, especially when kouyate is just as good as him.

It’s not your money so I wouldn’t stress too much about it.

 

The Dolphin Flag 07 Aug 20 11.16am

I was not that impressed with him to be honest but I agree that MacArthur is on his last legs and so if really good money comes in then he should go - if not we keep him and offload others.

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 07 Aug 20 3.07pm

Unless he's had a fall out with Roy I don't get why he would leave us to go to a club like Villa.

The Celtic thing I get.. It's his boyhood club.. Personally I think we should keep him.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

BelfastEagle Flag 07 Aug 20 6.13pm

A player that’s never recovered from the near career ending injury at Everton. Personally don’t rate him at all ....if we can get somebody to take him there is much better about.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 07 Aug 20 9.25pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

It’s not your money so I wouldn’t stress too much about it.

your right...its not my money...but dont care about the clubs finances & you end up like every other league one club fighting for its life.

Edited by braunstoneagle (07 Aug 2020 9.28pm)

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Putitout Flag Oxford 09 Aug 20 3.14pm


Agent crap . Now thought to be in new contract talks .

Edited by Putitout (09 Aug 2020 3.15pm)

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 09 Aug 20 3.45pm

Originally posted by Putitout


Agent crap . Now thought to be in new contract talks .

Edited by Putitout (09 Aug 2020 3.15pm)

Indeed, looks like that's what's happening.

[Link]

 

EddieMac Flag 09 Aug 20 5.09pm

Big season ahead for him.

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 09 Aug 20 6.51pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

Big season ahead for him.

Big season ahead for the club with a lot of rebuilding. A big relief that he's started contract terms.

[Link]

 

BelfastEagle Flag 09 Aug 20 8.27pm

It’s a big relief he may be staying...it’s a position where we have very little cover.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 09 Aug 20 10.35pm

Originally posted by BelfastEagle

It’s a big relief he may be staying...it’s a position where we have very little cover.

I’m not quite sure I get that, you mean apart from McArthur, Milivojevic, Kouyate, Riedewald and you could include Schlupp in that list as well as a utility player who can also defend.

If we are looking to freshen up our team with a bit more creativity do you think there will be space for 3 cloggers in the middle?

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 09 Aug 20 10.43pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I’m not quite sure I get that, you mean apart from McArthur, Milivojevic, Kouyate, Riedewald and you could include Schlupp in that list as well as a utility player who can also defend.

If we are looking to freshen up our team with a bit more creativity do you think there will be space for 3 cloggers in the middle?


Is he being sarcastic perhaps?

 

Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > James McCarthy (rumour)