You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why aren't we an established Premier League club
November 16 2026 5.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Why aren't we an established Premier League club


Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
CPFC1965 Flag Warrington 09 Aug 20 12.08pm

When the chances of relegation is is nigh on impossible

 

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 09 Aug 20 1.39pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

At the time Parish acknowledged that we paid over the odds for some players in order to attract them here.

That's helped change us from a team who initially looked nailed on for relegation every season to a team that now just flirts with relegation.

AWB would have gone to Man U whatever happend.

Weve done excellently to keep Zaha for this long.

And you will no doubt tell us that Parish is the saviour and without him we would not have a club.

I would say the only 'marquee,' signing was Cabaye and the others were a case of a panic buy mostly Liverpool cast offs and we were ripped off.

We have had the same manager now (for us) for a long time. In that time of supposed stability we have it seems run out of money spending little or getting free transfers on over in flared wages.

Stability has helped us survive and it seems right now our only ambition seems to be survival.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 09 Aug 20 1.50pm

Originally posted by CPFC1965

When the chances of relegation is is nigh on impossible

Were established then

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 09 Aug 20 1.56pm

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

And you will no doubt tell us that Parish is the saviour and without him we would not have a club.

I would say the only 'marquee,' signing was Cabaye and the others were a case of a panic buy mostly Liverpool cast offs and we were ripped off.

We have had the same manager now (for us) for a long time. In that time of supposed stability we have it seems run out of money spending little or getting free transfers on over in flared wages.

Stability has helped us survive and it seems right now our only ambition seems to be survival.


Are you trying to say that SP wasn't our 'saviour in 2010? Where would we have been without him do you think?

 

HesHereHesThere Flag Beckenham 09 Aug 20 2.21pm

Originally posted by doombear

Are you trying to say that SP wasn't our 'saviour in 2010? Where would we have been without him do you think?

There were four of them that saved the club but Parish went for the glory. After 8 seasons and £1.1bn what have we got to show for it? A new pitch, a bit of cladding, one FA cup final, £20m now going on the academy but boring sh*t football with no goals and a fooking old squad and no money....this is his mess and he needs to sort it out, it’s fooking embarrassing.

 

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 09 Aug 20 4.42pm

Originally posted by doombear


Are you trying to say that SP wasn't our 'saviour in 2010? Where would we have been without him do you think?

No I would say that for some that (true) simple fact renders him untouchable. My counter is that since then he has made and continues to make a handsome living from the club whilst around him as a club we are at best standing still at worse struggling.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 09 Aug 20 4.48pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

But we are an established Premier League club.
For the past seven seasons we've finished in a comfortable position, well clear of the relegation zone, I don't know how anyone could say we aren't.


We always look over our shoulder at relegation.. Everton, wolves, Leicester, west ham, burnley don't start the season thinking 'let's focus on not getting relegated' - sure, the west ham's have lost their way and get themselves in trouble... but that's the difference in an established prem club...

We, it's well documented that we over spent trying to fix errors... and now look to be neutral again.. if we make 2/3 more signings of potential this summer, it could mean a mid table finish with not even a sniff of relegation... which then means next summer, one/two signings is only really needed and we grow as a club and become established... basically where we are now, we should ahem been after our 3rd season...

 


This was once a quality forum....

jeeagles Flag 09 Aug 20 5.16pm

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

No I would say that for some that (true) simple fact renders him untouchable. My counter is that since then he has made and continues to make a handsome living from the club whilst around him as a club we are at best standing still at worse struggling.

Many speak exactly the same way about Hodgson, a man who doesn't seem to take accountability for anything.

Parishes track record is nothing short of remarkable. Trying to write it off to protect Roy Hodgson piss poor performance last year is even more remarkable.

 

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 09 Aug 20 5.49pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Many speak exactly the same way about Hodgson, a man who doesn't seem to take accountability for anything.

Parishes track record is nothing short of remarkable. Trying to write it off to protect Roy Hodgson piss poor performance last year is even more remarkable.

Remarkable? Well I guess people pass remarks.

I have not mentioned Roy aside from in the context he has been here a while and offered some stability. Mr Parish can run the club as he sees fit. It is his along with the Yanks to do so. (And they all do very well out of it.) But I would not say his performance has been remarkable. We are as a club struggling to simply stand still and in football terms that pretty much equals going backwards. Maybe that is the managers fault but equally we have needed a striker now for the last few windows and failed to sign one (well apart from one who we sent on a very generous one way loan deal)

So maybe one thing we have is a remarkable transfer policy.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 09 Aug 20 6.41pm

We are an established PL club but the term itself is illusory, as we could get relegated along with a dozen or more other clubs.

The PL is simply the domain of the super rich and is run for them and by them.

If there was a handicap system that equalised the chances then that would be different.

I am disenchanted with the PL and football in general, particularly with remote decision making by dubious VAR.

Will people will automatically go back I think not and it is a real surprise to me people are talking up transfer deals in the current crisis.

 

jeeagles Flag 09 Aug 20 7.04pm

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

Remarkable? Well I guess people pass remarks.

I have not mentioned Roy aside from in the context he has been here a while and offered some stability. Mr Parish can run the club as he sees fit. It is his along with the Yanks to do so. (And they all do very well out of it.) But I would not say his performance has been remarkable. We are as a club struggling to simply stand still and in football terms that pretty much equals going backwards. Maybe that is the managers fault but equally we have needed a striker now for the last few windows and failed to sign one (well apart from one who we sent on a very generous one way loan deal)

So maybe one thing we have is a remarkable transfer policy.

We've pretty much got a new striker every transfer window.

Last window - Tosun on loan who BFS wanted to spend £25m on as he was the top scorer in Turkey. Whilst we were happy to sent out Wickham which was inexplicable as far as I was concerned.

Then Ayew, Batshuayi, Ayew (loan), Sorloth, Benteke, Wickham, Campbell, Adebayor, Remy, Chemakh, Sonogo, Gayle, Jerome.

The most successful being Benteke when we played to his strenght. Clearly not a panic buy as we spent the whole summer negotiating the fee.

Would be nice if we tried to set the team up to the players strengths.

In the mean time. We've just got to keep hunting to unearth the next goalscorer. In recent history, that's relied more on luck than throwing cash around (Murray, Johnson, Morrison, Jansen, Armstrong, Wright vs Kuqi, Akinbuyi, Gabiadini)

 

bashy2 Flag London 09 Aug 20 7.11pm

When we stop having a relegation battle and can establish ourselves in the top 10 every year that's when we will be an established PL club

 

HesHereHesThere Flag Beckenham 09 Aug 20 7.12pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

We've pretty much got a new striker every transfer window.

Last window - Tosun on loan who BFS wanted to spend £25m on as he was the top scorer in Turkey. Whilst we were happy to sent out Wickham which was inexplicable as far as I was concerned.

Then Ayew, Batshuayi, Ayew (loan), Sorloth, Benteke, Wickham, Campbell, Adebayor, Remy, Chemakh, Sonogo, Gayle, Jerome.

The most successful being Benteke when we played to his strenght. Clearly not a panic buy as we spent the whole summer negotiating the fee.

Would be nice if we tried to set the team up to the players strengths.

In the mean time. We've just got to keep hunting to unearth the next goalscorer. In recent history, that's relied more on luck than throwing cash around (Murray, Johnson, Morrison, Jansen, Armstrong, Wright vs Kuqi, Akinbuyi, Gabiadini)

You was doing alright until you mentioned those two cvnts

 

jeeagles Flag 09 Aug 20 7.36pm

Originally posted by HesHereHesThere

You was doing alright until you mentioned those two cvnts

That was exactly my point.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 10 Aug 20 11.04am

Originally posted by Elpis

how many years do we have to be in the Premier league before we become established and whats the definition of being so ?

Serious question ,when we know whats required the answer may be easier

Given that we have been in the top division for a number of years one would argue we are an established Premier League club......until we get relegated. We all know that apart from the top 6 plus Everton every other club will at some point will go down. The likes of Leicester and Wolves are doing very well at the moment, but they could easily fall on hard times with a change of ownership. Its just the way it is.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 10 Aug 20 9.01pm

is it anything to do with our 'personality', should we be 'proud of our identity' as Nuno Espirito Santo has said he is about Wolves? It's a sign of progress that it's the foreign coaches who talk boll*x these days. We need more confiden'

 

deleted 25 Flag 10 Aug 20 10.19pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

We are an established PL club but the term itself is illusory, as we could get relegated along with a dozen or more other clubs.

The PL is simply the domain of the super rich and is run for them and by them.

If there was a handicap system that equalised the chances then that would be different.

I am disenchanted with the PL and football in general, particularly with remote decision making by dubious VAR.

Will people will automatically go back I think not and it is a real surprise to me people are talking up transfer deals in the current crisis.

Got to agree here. VAR and its hairline decisions is absolutely a farce. It seems as if things are going to carry on in the same vain


Man Utd seemed to benefit by the most penalties and Bournemouth were effectively relegated by VAR

 

martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 10 Aug 20 10.27pm

Originally posted by doombear


Are you trying to say that SP wasn't our 'saviour in 2010? Where would we have been without him do you think?

It's now 10 years on. He's dined out on that long enough.

Even Churchill didn't last that long after being the country's 'saviour'.

Edited by martin2412 (10 Aug 2020 10.27pm)

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 11 Aug 20 7.51am

Originally posted by martin2412

It's now 10 years on. He's dined out on that long enough.

Even Churchill didn't last that long after being the country's 'saviour'.

Edited by martin2412 (10 Aug 2020 10.27pm)


My point was simply to question what seemed to be a poster's statement that SP wasn't our saviour 10 years ago, when in my book he clearly was.

What SP has done in recent years is an entirely different matter.

 

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 11 Aug 20 9.44am

No I was saying exactly that point. Yes he saved - along with others - the club. But that was a long time ago. For some that renders him untouchable even after all these years.

I do not think past performance is the right way to judge the current predicament.

 

Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why aren't we an established Premier League club