This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Benteke & Batshuayi
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Canterbury Palace Whitstable 27 Nov 20 10.32pm |
|
|
Desperately trying to find something positive to say about tonight, so here it is. I thought we created more decent chances in the last half an hour once Benteke and then Batshuayi came on than in entire hour before it.
Obviously the issue is that both are so low on confidence that they can't score but is it worth having a go at starting them both in a 4-4-2 and see if somehow something clicks?
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...
|
HeathMan Purley 27 Nov 20 11.26pm |
|
|
Sounds a useful idea. There are also the silver linings that if they do well and play the full 90 minutes they will go forward with greater confidence, or if they struggle, there will be (sadly) more feared players on the bench.
|
Teddy Eagle 28 Nov 20 12.11am |
|
|
Would like to see them together. However shot Benteke’s confidence is he’s still good at hold up play and his heading is still pretty good. He might even thrive as a provider rather than scorer.
|
dreamwaverider London 28 Nov 20 8.20am |
|
Originally posted by Canterbury Palace
Desperately trying to find something positive to say about tonight, so here it is. I thought we created more decent chances in the last half an hour once Benteke and then Batshuayi came on than in entire hour before it.
Obviously the issue is that both are so low on confidence that they can't score but is it worth having a go at starting them both in a 4-4-2 and see if somehow something clicks? Two things. One. Far too much spoken about confidence. Players form comes and goes. But as you said the last 20 minutes we looked fired up up front. Not only Teks and Bats, but Schluppie Kouyate Eze were all buzzing. Two. Sadly very much doubt our management will turn to anything radical as your plan. If they did I think we would all be behind it. Imagine stirring Zaha into the mix. We’ve clearly got the players. They just need using right. Imagine if Teks header had found the net. It could have led to more.
|
palace chick South Croydon 28 Nov 20 8.34am |
|
|
I think Hodgson will go back to his trusted defensive 3 midfielders as we lost the match after bringing on Benteke and Bats.
|
hythemaceagle Hythe Kent 28 Nov 20 10.25am |
|
|
Have they ever played at the same time for Belgium?
|
Jacey 28 Nov 20 10.38am |
|
|
Just an observation,they both score goals for fun when they play for Belgium,but cannot get a fair crack of the whip under our dinosaur.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Nov 20 10.46am |
|
Originally posted by Jacey
Just an observation,they both score goals for fun when they play for Belgium,but cannot get a fair crack of the whip under our dinosaur.
Benteke has played in 2 games for Belgium since season 2016-17 and in those games he scored against Cyprus and San Marino.In the 2016-17 season he scored against Gibraltar.
Batshuayi has scored in recent seasons for Belgium against the likes of Iceland,Cyprus, San Marino,Kasakhstan, Tunisia etc etc so hardlly world beaters. In club matches he has scored a solitary goal in his last 24 games and that was against Hull.
|
*jack* Eastbourne 28 Nov 20 1.58pm |
|
|
So both should start if we draw a Div 2 club in the FA cup?
|
sitdownstandup 28 Nov 20 2.04pm |
|
|
Start them both and give em a go. They both have negative confidence, maybe they can support each other and overcome it together.
Man is the most insane species. He worships an invisible God and destroys a visible Nature. Unaware that this Nature he’s destroying is this God he’s worshipping.
Hubert Reeves
|
Eaglecoops CR3 28 Nov 20 2.15pm |
|
Originally posted by sitdownstandup
Start them both and give em a go. They both have negative confidence, maybe they can support each other and overcome it together.
Stick Wilf on the right, Townsend on the left and say to them, no tricks, no flicks, just hammer the crosses in.
|
Mojo87 28 Nov 20 6.04pm |
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Stick Wilf on the right, Townsend on the left and say to them, no tricks, no flicks, just hammer the crosses in.
Good plan to at least try, but too radical for Roy
|
TheBigToePunt 30 Nov 20 10.48am |
|
|
Odd to find oneself saying it, but Benteke must start.
He gives us the option to go quickly from back to front, and without that option we take ages to move the ball up the pitch. We had a far higher possession percentage against Burnley and Newcastle (due as much the their tactics as anything else) but couldn't do anything with it.
Just hit the big man, get the second ball.
|
PatrickA London 30 Nov 20 11.25am |
|
|
I can see why Roy would not start with Benteke and Batshuayi, particularly if Eze and Zaha are also playing, because it would leave us potentially vulnerable in midfield against the majority of teams. But I would be keen as others have suggested for Benteke to start. He has a decent understanding with Zaha and enables us to play longer and to hold the ball further up the field. Thing is Roy has his favourites and is reluctant to leave them out, which is his prerogative as they follow instructions to the letter and follow the game plan. Ayew and Schlupp have their merits, but not as a spearhead to win us games. Ayew shows no signs of recovering last season's form and for me he is a squad player.
|
Eaglecoops CR3 30 Nov 20 11.50am |
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
I can see why Roy would not start with Benteke and Batshuayi, particularly if Eze and Zaha are also playing, because it would leave us potentially vulnerable in midfield against the majority of teams. But I would be keen as others have suggested for Benteke to start. He has a decent understanding with Zaha and enables us to play longer and to hold the ball further up the field. Thing is Roy has his favourites and is reluctant to leave them out, which is his prerogative as they follow instructions to the letter and follow the game plan. Ayew and Schlupp have their merits, but not as a spearhead to win us games. Ayew shows no signs of recovering last season's form and for me he is a squad player.
Playing on the front foot with both Bats and Benteke can potentially also drive teams back and not give them a chance to dominate the midfield. If he wants Eze to play then he would take the left side over Townsend, however with two up top both his and Zahas defensive duties will be increased.
Both Zaha and Eze crossing balls in along with two strikers has to cause defensive problems for the opposition which will probably mean dragging their midfielders back and cutting off their attacking outlets.
Just an idea but it would be nice to see us on the front foot from the start for a change instead of when we are 1-0 down and chasing the game.
|
palace chick South Croydon 30 Nov 20 12.15pm |
|
|
To be able to play a more attack minded game with Benteke and Bats up front we need a stronger midfield and back four. It seems this season Hodgson is trying to play more attacking football but it’s backfiring because the two forwards are either Zaha and Ayew or as in last match a midfielder/left back moved upfront? Plus the defenders have made mistakes (namely Dann) and the midfielders have not played well / unbalanced. I just don’t think Hodgson can play any differently other than having a defensive midfield which means going back to how we have played since he took over. I just can’t see how Zaha and Eze fit in for him playing Benteke and Bats as well? It is most probable that Zaha was expected to go and Eze would then be starting with a stronger 3 alongside him. The middle two at the back needs sorting so that it’s two of Sakho, Tomkins or Cahill starting plus I think we would be stronger at left back with Mitchell. Let the midfield wide or central players supply Benteke and Bats rather than PVA losing the ball upfield and struggling to get back. Perhaps wide midfield would be stronger with one of Zaha and Eze with Schlupp on left and then the middle 2 being a choice of Luka, McCarthur, McCarthy or Reidewald?
|
Rudi Hedman Caterham 30 Nov 20 1.00pm |
|
|
I’d rather try 4-2-3-1 with Zaha right and Schlupp left seeing as roy has to pick schlupp and Townsnoend cuts back all the time on the wrong wing imo. If you can use your right foot then play on the left anyway. How many goals do these inverted wingers here score anyway? 2? 3?
Pick 2 def mids from 5-6 to be cautious
Zaha———Eze ———Schlupp (Maybe even interchange. It is allowed in football)
———pick 1 from 3 forwards———
Ayew backup winger or striker or 1st choice striker if it works. Townsowned benched.
COYP
|
sprites Auckland 30 Nov 20 7.36pm |
|
|
I think we're missing the rock that is Luka Milivojevic.
|
Rachid Rachid Rachid 30 Nov 20 9.53pm |
|
|
Both Bats and Benteke got hammered after their performances against Burnley and then the same people have criticised their being left out.
My recollection is that Benteke did three notable things on Friday;
The header that ultimately most goalkeepers would expect to save.
The shocking control which presented Newcastle with a breakaway ending with Dann (I think) being forced to give away a foul on the edge of our box.
The terrible left footed shank when in a good position in the box which went nearer the corner flag than the goal.
I would persevere with Bats as he's at least shown hunger for goals and looked capable of an emphatic finish. Irritating that he's had three goals chalked off but two were very close and at least the intent was there. An assist against Fulham as well.
Think he's generally done ok paired with Zaha.
|
sprites Auckland 30 Nov 20 11.28pm |
|
Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid
Both Bats and Benteke got hammered after their performances against Burnley and then the same people have criticised their being left out.
My recollection is that Benteke did three notable things on Friday;
The header that ultimately most goalkeepers would expect to save.
The shocking control which presented Newcastle with a breakaway ending with Dann (I think) being forced to give away a foul on the edge of our box.
The terrible left footed shank when in a good position in the box which went nearer the corner flag than the goal.
I would persevere with Bats as he's at least shown hunger for goals and looked capable of an emphatic finish. Irritating that he's had three goals chalked off but two were very close and at least the intent was there. An assist against Fulham as well.
Think he's generally done ok paired with Zaha.
That's harsh. Benteke changed the dynamic when he came on. We finally had a focal point and could build attacks.
He did well to beat the defender to that header and it was a great save from the keeper. Another day, that goes in.
Can't recall the other moments you're talking about (but not doubting they happened).
If we have other strikers banging them in, the fair enough, we can't justify CB's inclusion. But when no one's scoring, we might as well include him if we play better as a whole.
Edited by sprites (30 Nov 2020 11.28pm)
|