You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace after Zaha
November 16 2026 5.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace after Zaha


Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 10 Dec 20 6.58am

Originally posted by pompeyeagle

Clearly were he to go, which is extremely unlikely, we would have a big problem but only while Roy is the manager. Someone new would bring in a few players and adapt our playing style. Roy however has only a plan A which involves getting the ball to Wilf as soon as possible.

That is purely written to wind up the fans who don't agree with your sentiments.

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 10 Dec 20 7.00am

Originally posted by alexdyoung87

Does anyone know of any decent Championship players at the moment that could immediately make the step up in the same way Watkins, Eze and Benrahma have done this summer?

Bright Osayi-Samuel at QPR has been playing well and we've already been linked with him.

Now I don't think he's quite yet in the same bracket as those others you mention but I do think he'd suit our style and provide immediate competition for places.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 10 Dec 20 7.04am

Originally posted by uncleneal

Our problem is we will not spend the money and will buy on the cheap,

Arsenal sold Iwobi for £40m and bought Pepe for £72m - what is Wilf worth? What will we get?

Very worried for our future if he goes - feel like it will be like 1991 again.

The club know that if they don't use the money wisely they will be in serious trouble and we need to see some movement on the pitch and goals scored where Zaha isn't involved and the introduction of Eze is clearly bringing us hope.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 10 Dec 20 7.21am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Yes.

Parish wants to spend as little as possible to keep us in the top division and he knows that whilst Wilf is here and firing he will probably keep us up on his own but if he goes Parish knows that he will have to spend or be relegated

Precisely and a lot of our players are coming to their end with age and increasing injury, we have reached the situation where gambling is out.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 10 Dec 20 10.07am

Originally posted by alexdyoung87

Does anyone know of any decent Championship players at the moment that could immediately make the step up in the same way Watkins, Eze and Benrahma have done this summer?


Sarr and Brooks are obvious candidates but they will cost serious money (which we would have if Zaha went) but they are probably looking to move to a bigger club than us.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 10 Dec 20 10.15am

Originally posted by pompeyeagle

Clearly were he to go, which is extremely unlikely, we would have a big problem but only while Roy is the manager. Someone new would bring in a few players and adapt our playing style. Roy however has only a plan A which involves getting the ball to Wilf as soon as possible.


What puerile statements. Hodgson is one of football's more intelligent managers and if Wilf goes in January, of course, he'll adapt to the squad he'll have at the end of the transfer window. We might still not be enamoured with the style of football chosen, however.

But we won't fall apart. As I've said previously. There's a big difference between Wilf being out for a couple of games and Wilf being gone permanently. The management team and the squad will adapt. It may take a few games to get things right but it's unlikely to spell disaster.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 10 Dec 20 3.07pm

Originally posted by uncleneal

Our problem is we will not spend the money and will buy on the cheap,

Arsenal sold Iwobi for £40m and bought Pepe for £72m - what is Wilf worth? What will we get?

Very worried for our future if he goes - feel like it will be like 1991 again.

That's a great point.
For those too young to know, that was when we sold Wright. The issues that came from it were not only that we lost our best player, but that we spent 1.8m of the 2.5m we got for him on the wrong man.

Gabbiadini had been a good player for Sunderland up to that point, but he thrived in a very different style of play and wasn't in the same league as Wright anyway. He also didn't have that raging fire inside him that Wright did, and that emotion was as hard to replace as the goals were.

The common view is that Wright leaving was the end of the journey for that great team, all of whom realised that no further progress could be made - Palace had hit the glass ceiling. Losing our best player hurt us on the pitch, but it also ripped the heart out of the club. Upward trajectory was brutally curtailed, and we never recovered.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 10 Dec 20 3.47pm

All clubs go through their periods of reliance on certain players, Blackburn would have been nothing without Shearer and Sutton, Henry at Arsenal, Lampard and Terry at Chelsea, us with Wright and Bright initially and now with Zaha. There are loads of examples of players that have had a massive impact on a team.

The measure of a continually successful team is how they manage the change from reliance on these players to evolving into a different team whilst still being successful.

Just look at Man Utd, they have never really recovered from losing Ferguson and the last of the academy boys that brought them so much success. Money doesn’t necessarily buy you success either as Man Utd in recent times and Everton and West Ham will testify to.

Putting this into context, it will be a tough ask for us to function without Wilf, how we deal with it though is vitally important to our future. Eze is a good start but we need another talisman as he can’t do it on his own. We play best with mavericks so I’m all for going for someone like Sarr and trying to persuade him to join us.

Ultimately there are some gems in the academy that top teams have already tried to poach. We need to start filtering those in and letting them learn off the senior pros a bit at a time. I don’t think we are finished without Zaha but it will take some prudent management and expenditure to keep us functioning effectively.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 10 Dec 20 4.52pm

Originally posted by doombear


Sarr and Brooks are obvious candidates but they will cost serious money (which we would have if Zaha went) but they are probably looking to move to a bigger club than us.

Stepping stones, we come before the big teams, they want the finished article.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 10 Dec 20 5.33pm

Is he off then? What a long drawn out saga! And here he is back on form, finding a kindred spirit in Eze. Best keep him till the end of the season, eh?

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 10 Dec 20 6.24pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Is he off then? What a long drawn out saga! And here he is back on form, finding a kindred spirit in Eze. Best keep him till the end of the season, eh?

No-one is going to argue against that the way he is playing at the moment. Trouble is, the better he plays, the more attractive he looks to those needing a quality boost to their squad.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 10 Dec 20 8.31pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

No-one is going to argue against that the way he is playing at the moment. Trouble is, the better he plays, the more attractive he looks to those needing a quality boost to their squad.

He showed his destructive petulant side in that loss at Wolves didn't he and that's why I feel some of the big clubs aren't really interested, but having said that he has improved also with it, I hope for him someone does because he really really deserves to win big time with the skills he has, it'll be awful for us obviously but he has done so much for us over the years he just deserve a chance, I'd like to see him at Arsenal and see how much they improve with him causing mayhem.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 10 Dec 20 10.29pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

He showed his destructive petulant side in that loss at Wolves didn't he and that's why I feel some of the big clubs aren't really interested, but having said that he has improved also with it, I hope for him someone does because he really really deserves to win big time with the skills he has, it'll be awful for us obviously but he has done so much for us over the years he just deserve a chance, I'd like to see him at Arsenal and see how much they improve with him causing mayhem.

I don’t, I’d rather see him to PSG or Bayern. I don’t want him playing against us and I definitely don’t want him at the gooners although it is his most likely destination.

Edited by Eaglecoops (11 Dec 2020 7.20am)

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 11 Dec 20 12.27pm

Even if we got £50m for Zaha, and even if we spent the lot on one player to whom we paid the same wage we currently pay Wilf, we couldn't replace him.

There isn't a single player we could sign to directly fill his boots. Regardless of his faults, he is a once in a generation talent for a club like ours.

That doesn't mean we can't live without him, but we would need a very different looking team, playing a different way.

My fear is that in pursuing that aim we'd do what spurs did when they got big money for Bale. They managed to lose their outstanding individual, spend all the money and end up with neither a direct replacement or a stronger team.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (11 Dec 2020 12.28pm)

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 11 Dec 20 12.44pm

Originally posted by uncleneal

Our problem is we will not spend the money and will buy on the cheap,

Arsenal sold Iwobi for £40m and bought Pepe for £72m - what is Wilf worth? What will we get?

Very worried for our future if he goes - feel like it will be like 1991 again.

Good point - although Iwobi was £28m rising to £35 and Pepe's fee is over 4 or 5 years.

Yes 1991 we fell apart without Wright and Coppell never had plan b although we did have a certain Stan Collymore on our books then.

I do think Eze was partly bought to play the No 10 role currently occupied by Wilf although wasn't played there recently when Wilf was absent.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 11 Dec 20 12.48pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Even if we got £50m for Zaha, and even if we spent the lot on one player to whom we paid the same wage we currently pay Wilf, we couldn't replace him.

Don't forget that 25% of the sale price will go to Manchester United

 

EddieMac Flag 12 Dec 20 8.29am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

He showed his destructive petulant side in that loss at Wolves didn't he and that's why I feel some of the big clubs aren't really interested, but having said that he has improved also with it, I hope for him someone does because he really really deserves to win big time with the skills he has, it'll be awful for us obviously but he has done so much for us over the years he just deserve a chance, I'd like to see him at Arsenal and see how much they improve with him causing mayhem.

Sweet suffering Jesus above in heaven, I have seen it all now. You would like to see our best player move to one of our biggest rivals. You need to have a serious think about how ridiculous and shocking that sounds and maybe have a long walk in the rain to clear your head.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 12 Dec 20 8.48am

Originally posted by EddieMac

Sweet suffering Jesus above in heaven, I have seen it all now. You would like to see our best player move to one of our biggest rivals. You need to have a serious think about how ridiculous and shocking that sounds and maybe have a long walk in the rain to clear your head.

Agreed. I doubt TP is a Palace fan with a statement like that.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (12 Dec 2020 8.54am)

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 12 Dec 20 8.50am

Originally posted by EddieMac


Sweet suffering Jesus above in heaven, I have seen it all now. You would like to see our best player move to one of our biggest rivals.

In what way do you see Arsenal as one of our biggest rivals apart from the fact that they play in the same league?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 12 Dec 20 8.51am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

I doubt TP is a Palace fan.

Ridiculous post of the month

 

Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace after Zaha