This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Kirby has been out on loan before to Blackpool looks like he did well from what I read at the time but no one has been back in for him so what does that say. If you look at the players over the last few years that have been closest to the first team they have hardly gone on to prove us wrong in our decision to get rid of them.
One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A |
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
Two of the U23s loaned out. But at what level? Kirby has gone to League 2 Tranmere and he's one of the Academy players nearest to the first team squad (Woods and Pierrick are already part of the first team squad but still playing in the U23s). Webber, the U23s first choice keeper has gone to non-league Dover Athletic. Is this a reflection of the level the club think they are currently at? Or are the club undervaluing their level, or are these the levels clubs wanting loans see them at? Unlike the big clubs, you don't see Palace Academy players out on loan at Championship clubs. And yet, our Academy players can suddenly find themselves thrust into the first team and not only hold their own (as Mitchell is now doing after a difficult start) but excel (as did AWB). I do wonder what this says about our current policies regarding Academy players (excluding references to Hodgson and his alleged anti-youth sentiments). I saw that and agree with your comments. If it is your first loan out then nothing shabby about going to League 2 however where is the progression for Kirby? By now Championship clubs should have been knocking on our door for him we don't seem to loan players to the Championship which is a worry. Those that go on loan don't seem to be asked back. Maybe the quality just isn't there.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Pete53
History suggests that a loan to a lower league club is often the first step to the end of that player's Palace career. I know that the argument is that by giving the player an opportunity to play at senior level, even if with a League One or Two club, is worth more than any number of Under 21/23 games. However, I am trying to think of any of our "hopefuls" that have followed that path and then returned to establish themselves in the 1st team squad. Both Richard Shaw and John Salako were loaned out to Hull and Swansea respectively. Edited by Willo (23 Jan 2021 2.33pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Both Richard Shaw and John Salako were loaned out to Hull and Swansea respectively. Edited by Willo (23 Jan 2021 2.33pm) True Willo, but I am thinking more recent history. Say the last 10 years.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Pete53
True Willo, but I am thinking more recent history. Say the last 10 years. I have been wracking my cerebral matter but like you I cannot find any examples. Some of the players I have considered who went out on loan in recent seasons : Cadogan, N'Diaye, Sekajja, Pinney, Ladapo, Binnom-Williams, Dymond, Gray, Banton, Djilali, Croll, Appiah.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Both Richard Shaw and John Salako were loaned out to Hull and Swansea respectively. Edited by Willo (23 Jan 2021 2.33pm) In the case of Salako the Swansea fans were raving about him and even in those pre internet days that had drifted back to us fans so it was no surprise he returned and broke into the first team.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I saw that and agree with your comments. If it is your first loan out then nothing shabby about going to League 2 however where is the progression for Kirby? By now Championship clubs should have been knocking on our door for him we don't seem to loan players to the Championship which is a worry. Those that go on loan don't seem to be asked back. Maybe the quality just isn't there. and also its possible that as Danny Murphy alluded to last night that its not the kind of league for flair and they would get kicked a lot hence not tough enough and not kept. I suspect its a combination of both.
Red and Blue though and through (more than 50 years) |
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
I pop into the "other Palace forum" now and then mainly to look at "The Academy" thread as there are a couple of people who post there that seem to know what's going on. One of them is Matt Woosnam and his opinion is that none of the Development Squad players are good enough for the first team Richard Shaw said the same when he left his post as our U23 Head Coach just over a year ago.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I have been wracking my cerebral matter but like you I cannot find any examples. Some of the players I have considered who went out on loan in recent seasons : Cadogan, N'Diaye, Sekajja, Pinney, Ladapo, Binnom-Williams, Dymond, Gray, Banton, Djilali, Croll, Appiah. Well done. I'd forgotten most of those until you mentioned them. And it's fair to say that none of them went off and proved us wrong for releasing them. Roy gets lots of flak for not blooding youngsters but perhaps the reality is that very very few do have what it takes to perform in the Premier League. Of course we will never know unless they are given a run out but recent history suggests that management have been correct in their assessment of potential.
|
|
|
Found this that is interesting, teams ranked by by number of minutes played by academy players, [Link] it's done on total minutes so if Wilf players every minute of the season then we would rank as high for academy players as if five players played 8 games each but it does look like not many teams have more than 4 academy players so maybe we aren't doing as badly as we think .
One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A |
|
|
Originally posted by Ketteridge
Found this that is interesting, teams ranked by by number of minutes played by academy players, [Link] it's done on total minutes so if Wilf players every minute of the season then we would rank as high for academy players as if five players played 8 games each but it does look like not many teams have more than 4 academy players so maybe we aren't doing as badly as we think . I know that article is old, but it really makes no sense to include minutes from players who were academy players years ago and now are established. It doesn't really show what people would be interested in - Watford's minutes included Mariappa haha who graduated from their academy, went around other clubs (including ours) and arrived back at theirs. I'd like the see the same thing but maybe with an age limit cut off (23?)
|
|
|
Originally posted by YoDougie
I know that article is old, but it really makes no sense to include minutes from players who were academy players years ago and now are established. It doesn't really show what people would be interested in - Watford's minutes included Mariappa haha who graduated from their academy, went around other clubs (including ours) and arrived back at theirs. I'd like the see the same thing but maybe with an age limit cut off (23?) Think you are right, Mariappa and Jay Rodriguez at Burnley aswell stretching the point. Think we can just get away wuth including Wilf but Clyne would be included this year. If you wanted to look at which clubs promoted from within and give youth chance of development then it is fair to include Wilf or Ward-Prowse or even Mark Noble
One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A |
|
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
It does look like the academy is a big ego thing. We got all these youngsters preening around like top players who clearly aren’t gonna cut it. We got to be way more ruthless at all levels. We don’t seem to get the whole system. We got loads of older players free to walk this summer. Take Benteke. Costs us £6m a year. Last 2 seasons hardly played. Now trying to unload him but in three months he can walk for free. So if West Brom want him the most we can hope for is £2m. Anymore and he can ear another £2 m from us then sell himself. We just don’t seem to get it. Player churn. Ruthless. Big Sam has just moved on 6 players at West Brom. We have got to wake up to this while we still can. Same for all though. If we sold Benteke for £2m and picked up Demarai Gray for 1.8m and Ferguson on a tribunal fee with both salaries covered by Bentekes, some might say that’s decent business.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Same for all though. If we sold Benteke for £2m and picked up Demarai Gray for 1.8m and Ferguson on a tribunal fee with both salaries covered by Bentekes, some might say that’s decent business. True.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Same for all though. If we sold Benteke for £2m and picked up Demarai Gray for 1.8m and Ferguson on a tribunal fee with both salaries covered by Bentekes, some might say that’s decent business. Maybe WBA will agree a fee for Ferguson as part of the Benteke deal?
One more point |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.