You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who was our least effective player v Brighton .
November 16 2026 4.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who was our least effective player v Brighton .


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Brinscalleagle2 Flag Brinscall 23 Feb 21 10.37am

For me Eze. This type of game is not his bag. He hardly touched the ball and when he did he went back towards our goal and miss placed so many passes. I f we are going to set up this way again we would be better off playing someone else.

 

Kieranemm Flag Towcester 23 Feb 21 11.06am

Reluctantly I agree, if we don't have any of the ball it is pointless playing him. I also think he has had a couple of poor/ineffective games, but are sticking with him becuae with injuries options are limited at the moment.

When on the ball looks class above our other players, but if we are going to play ultra defensive all the time we would be better off with Schlupp playing on the left, or even PVA.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 23 Feb 21 11.42am

To be honest if we are going to play this way we might as well play with 2 strikers and 8 defenders. I have to agree that Eze is out of his depth playing this exhilarating style of football. Don’t be surprised if he hands in a transfer request next season if Roy is still about.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 23 Feb 21 11.43am

up until that abs magnificent cross behind the defender I wud have said Townsend, followed by Luka whose 1st half through ball to Ayew when we were 3 on 2 was abs p*ss poor - Eze tried hard to carry the ball forward but there weren't enough options available so he ran into blind alleys, though watching him allow attackers to bypass him does grate somewhat, makes a token effort to block but just unbalances himself and allows passes, crosses and shots (Villa game!) to get by - I do understand, but he cud have been an outlet to take pressure off our defence but it didn't pan out that way. Ayew got Sky MoM and rightly so - he was brilliant, he had been a bit out of sorts but I think he should get more credit, he was a legend last night.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 23 Feb 21 11.51am

It was Eze but it was not his fault. If you are playing with 3 DMs dont include him as one. He should have been up top with JP. In the 2nd half he made two surging runs and was immediately subbed for indiscipline. Roy has managed to drain all the flair out of him. Only Roy could do that. He would look great in the Weeds team.

 

aashman12 Flag 23 Feb 21 11.54am

Originally posted by Brinscalleagle2

For me Eze. This type of game is not his bag. He hardly touched the ball and when he did he went back towards our goal and miss placed so many passes. I f we are going to set up this way again we would be better off playing someone else.

Not the 1st time he'd played that bad either, can't blame tactics for his laziness giving the ball away,

 

aashman12 Flag 23 Feb 21 11.57am

Originally posted by slubglurge

It was Eze but it was not his fault. If you are playing with 3 DMs dont include him as one. He should have been up top with JP. In the 2nd half he made two surging runs and was immediately subbed for indiscipline. Roy has managed to drain all the flair out of him. Only Roy could do that. He would look great in the Weeds team.

Bore off

 

Mathers Flag 23 Feb 21 11.57am

The Eze in CM tactical decision was bizarre. He was picking up the ball with his back to goal inside our own half. Usually he is decent at turning out of tight spots but he had a poor game.

Least effective player was Luka again. Contributed nothing in defense or attack. Gutted he isnt one of the payers out of contract in the summer as im sick of seeing him on the team sheet.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 23 Feb 21 11.59am

Guaita. Not because he was bad but for a goalie in the PL he really didn't have much to do considering how much pressure we were under.

Edited by PZ Eagle (23 Feb 2021 12.00pm)

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

EddieMac Flag 23 Feb 21 12.09pm

Eze
Mitchell
Riedewald in that order.

I thought the 3 of them looked absolutely lost.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 23 Feb 21 12.09pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Guaita. Not because he was bad but for a goalie in the PL he really didn't have much to do considering how much pressure we were under.

Edited by PZ Eagle (23 Feb 2021 12.00pm)


That triple save that started with the Trossard attempt and saw the ball ricochet on the edge of the 6 yard box was more than Luka and Eze managed to achieve. Also Guaita had to stay alert for long periods, just in case.

Edited by doombear (23 Feb 2021 12.10pm)

 

EddieMac Flag 23 Feb 21 12.10pm

Originally posted by slubglurge

It was Eze but it was not his fault. If you are playing with 3 DMs dont include him as one. He should have been up top with JP. In the 2nd half he made two surging runs and was immediately subbed for indiscipline. Roy has managed to drain all the flair out of him. Only Roy could do that. He would look great in the Weeds team.

oh but it was his fault. Did you count how many times he gave the ball away in dangerous positions? He had a nightmare.

Edited by EddieMac (23 Feb 2021 12.11pm)

 

Gribbo Flag Bromley 23 Feb 21 12.27pm

On the other hand, probably the best game Patrick Van Aanholt has had in a number of weeks: no glaring errors, being caught out of position, missed lightweight tackles, or giving the ball away through poor passing. Well done Pat!

I think we can all agree, best option for Patrick... not starting him.

 

EddieMac Flag 23 Feb 21 12.30pm

Originally posted by Gribbo

On the other hand, probably the best game Patrick Van Aanholt has had in a number of weeks: no glaring errors, being caught out of position, missed lightweight tackles, or giving the ball away through poor passing. Well done Pat!

I think we can all agree, best option for Patrick... not starting him.

After watching the Mitchell horror show last night I am completely torn on who is the better player. We need a new left back.

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 23 Feb 21 12.35pm

Originally posted by Brinscalleagle2

For me Eze. This type of game is not his bag. He hardly touched the ball and when he did he went back towards our goal and miss placed so many passes. I f we are going to set up this way again we would be better off playing someone else.

Totally agree. Don’t have a problem with his effort but he’s been giving away the ball regularly over the past month or so. I’ve wanted us to sign him for the last couple of years and he’s gonna be an awesome player but I feel he has a lot to learn at this level still. Mainly when to do tricks and when is the time to play the simple pass.

 

Mstrobez Flag 23 Feb 21 12.38pm

It was Eze of course but this is the result of Roy playing a 433 - the formation which many Palace fans have been demanding for a while.

Not only is this formation bad for Eze as the midfield trio are expected to sit - it will also be bad for Wilf when he returns to the side as the wingers will be expected to track back.

The advantage of the Roy Hodgson 442 is that it allows Wilf to stay forward & drift freely in attacking situations. And despite the fact he is expected to hold his shape whilst we are defending, it also allows Eze to come inside behind the 2 front men when we have possession. It's the exact same role RLC played to great effect & it suits Eze.

Of course many Palace fans will scream "well just play a more attacking 433 then!", but it's really not as simple as that. This isn't a game of FIFA. Our best centre back is 35 years old & lacks the pace to play a high line. Whilst this remains the case, we have to set up with a certain level of defensive protection - whether that comes through a 442 or a 433. If we hadn't done that up until this point, we would be relegated.

If we go with the 433, for large parts of the game we will be set up as, effectively, a 451 & Eze will be playing a far more defensive role. We already saw that with Max Meyer during his time at the club.

Out of the 2 formations, under Roy, the 442 is better & suits both Wilf & Eze more.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

midlandspalace Flag kidderminster 23 Feb 21 12.42pm

This whole thread is just a whingefest, from the title heading onwards. What a waste of energy. We did win the game, our ninth victory of the season. Still, now you can waste some more of it whinging at me.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 23 Feb 21 12.44pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

Eze
Mitchell
Riedewald in that order.

I thought the 3 of them looked absolutely lost.

Lost? Playing the Roy H. way no wonder ball-players get lost. Eze and Riedewald are in fact two proper footballers not suited to our ultra-defensive set-up.

 

Mstrobez Flag 23 Feb 21 12.44pm

Originally posted by midlandspalace

This whole thread is just a whingefest, from the title heading onwards. What a waste of energy. We did win the game, our ninth victory of the season. Still, now you can waste some more of it whinging at me.

No it's not. Eze, who was just voted player of the month, had a very quiet game last night. That is concerning & it was quite clear (even before the game) he is not suited to the role he played last night.

The only whinge I've seen is from you in all honesty.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Mstrobez Flag 23 Feb 21 12.45pm

Originally posted by thai-eagle

Lost? Playing the Roy H. way no wonder ball-players get lost. Eze and Riedewald are in fact two proper footballers not suited to our ultra-defensive set-up.

Eze just won player of the month but other than that.. yeah I guess a "Roy out" cult member is spot on as always.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who was our least effective player v Brighton .