You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > I was very very very wrong!
November 16 2026 4.15am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

I was very very very wrong!


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Mwncisee Flag Middlesbrough 01 Nov 21 5.05pm

OK so time for me to eat humble pie. Think it's been coming and after the events over the weekend and today its the nail in the coffin.

In the summer I argued about how frustrating it was that we seemed so close to getting NES only for it to be scuppered by his demands at the last second and my argument was that we should just do it to get him......(ahem)

I then argued that I was sceptical about getting PV as manager and that I felt people were putting too much into the fact he was a world class player but this does not necessarily mean he is a good manager.......(ahem)

It seems hard to argue against me being very wrong and it seems only right that I put myself in the Homesdale Online stocks and take whatever you wish to throw at me!

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 01 Nov 21 5.10pm

They would have to be bloody big stocks as most of us would be in them!

 

fishbone Flag London 01 Nov 21 5.18pm

Originally posted by Mwncisee

OK so time for me to eat humble pie. Think it's been coming and after the events over the weekend and today its the nail in the coffin.

In the summer I argued about how frustrating it was that we seemed so close to getting NES only for it to be scuppered by his demands at the last second and my argument was that we should just do it to get him......(ahem)

I then argued that I was sceptical about getting PV as manager and that I felt people were putting too much into the fact he was a world class player but this does not necessarily mean he is a good manager.......(ahem)

It seems hard to argue against me being very wrong and it seems only right that I put myself in the Homesdale Online stocks and take whatever you wish to throw at me!

Big up respect to you!
Not many would do this, so well done.

 

TheGreatGorbo Flag sunbury 01 Nov 21 5.22pm

Some people would pay good money for a bit of that, especially if the crystals want a bit of moonlighting, my number is …..

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 01 Nov 21 5.40pm

Fair enough save me a place in the stocks.

 


One more point

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 01 Nov 21 6.12pm

Originally posted by Mwncisee

OK so time for me to eat humble pie. Think it's been coming and after the events over the weekend and today its the nail in the coffin.

In the summer I argued about how frustrating it was that we seemed so close to getting NES only for it to be scuppered by his demands at the last second and my argument was that we should just do it to get him......(ahem)

I then argued that I was sceptical about getting PV as manager and that I felt people were putting too much into the fact he was a world class player but this does not necessarily mean he is a good manager.......(ahem)

It seems hard to argue against me being very wrong and it seems only right that I put myself in the Homesdale Online stocks and take whatever you wish to throw at me!

Well, we all know that PV wasn't first choice. I certainly had my doubts about him.

It's still early days, but I have to say that he seems to fit our club like a glove.

So reserve a place for me in those stocks !

 


Old, Ungifted and White

johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 01 Nov 21 6.25pm

Well your not alone in wondering how things would go with PV. who ever is tracking and finding these young guns deservers high praise too.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 01 Nov 21 6.32pm

I do like PV he seems very level headed.

But wary of waxing too lyrical, we have only played 10 matches and squad depth is a worry in the winter months especially if there is a crop of injuries.

The PL rich clubs simply do not have that problem.

Certainly the club heading in a direction I could hardy ever have envisaged.

 

Therealeaglestilidie Flag 01 Nov 21 6.56pm

Looking at the table what a huge win against City that was.

Without it we would have been fourth from bottom and only 2 points outside the bottom three.

A sobering thought and just goes to show how important wins are as opposed to draws.

 


I'm so Palace I don't even know it

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 01 Nov 21 7.02pm

Indeed. We have a run of potentially easier fixtures now. Hopefully we can build on an excellent start and posting a few more wins

 

Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 01 Nov 21 7.05pm

I'm only half in the stocks. I too thought Nuno would be a good appointment, however when they talked about him bringing in all his staff I was less optimistic, and ended up being not that upset at the end.

I will admit I was happy with the PV appointment. I had the pleasure of watching him at NYC FC and he did a great job. Never won the league, but always was competitive and was able to handle big egos without (as far as I could tell) too much dissent.

My son also met him and said he was really nice, but the most intimidating person he's ever met.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 01 Nov 21 7.46pm


i was a stalwart of Roy H and his boring-ball.


glad all over to have been proven wrong.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

PatrickA Flag London 01 Nov 21 7.50pm

I’m disappointed and expected him to be doing better.

 

fishbone Flag London 01 Nov 21 7.56pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

I’m disappointed and expected him to be doing better.

His doing fine and not allowing for the players to burn out too soon plus for his first attempt at managing in the premier league this is brilliant.

 

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 01 Nov 21 8.29pm

Not just PV. Credit must go to Dougie and Parish for overhauling the squad so brilliantly in the summer. I really thought we would struggle to rebuild but it turned out we had a plan all along.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 01 Nov 21 9.44pm

The main difference in our style this season is that we close down much better. We conceded ground far too easily before. Our passing from the back is also much improved. The back four has been the same every week, so far, and that has helped a lot.

The improvements are largely about having better players and better coaching staff.

PV can take some credit for encouraging more energetic football, but it is not just about him. We actually spent money, and that is something that has been needed for several years.

 

CT Charlie Flag 02 Nov 21 12.07am

Any manager would have benefited from the influx of quality players: Gallagher, Andersen, Guehi, Olise, and Edouard (and the rapidly maturing Mitchell).

But few men would have the wisdom and interpersonal skills to inspire the veterans to welcome the newcomers, change their style, and rebound from the crushing "losses" to Brighton and Arsenal to play so well at the Etihad.

I'm not surprised. A friend high in the NYCFC organization told me PV is a good man who would be a great success.


 

viveasheagle Flag perth 02 Nov 21 2.34am

For a relative young manager i like the way he is handling himself in the press conferences. He could have taken credit for the Olise substitution against City but gave the credit to his team. It is a team game and he was also very specific in his praise for how everyone defended as a team against City.
I like as well the improvement that is showing in our existing players. 3 that spring to my mind are particularly Joel Ward but also Tyrick Mitchell and Christian Benteke. I saw Mitchell lose the ball against Brentford when he was forced to come inside on his right foot but this has been addressed. Ward looks like he has got a yard extra pace from somewhere and Benteke looks back to his best.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 02 Nov 21 5.17am

Originally posted by viveasheagle

For a relative young manager i like the way he is handling himself in the press conferences. He could have taken credit for the Olise substitution against City but gave the credit to his team. It is a team game and he was also very specific in his praise for how everyone defended as a team against City.
I like as well the improvement that is showing in our existing players. 3 that spring to my mind are particularly Joel Ward but also Tyrick Mitchell and Christian Benteke. I saw Mitchell lose the ball against Brentford when he was forced to come inside on his right foot but this has been addressed. Ward looks like he has got a yard extra pace from somewhere and Benteke looks back to his best.

I agree about the 3 players but from somewhere benny has found a new lease of life. Missing a few but getting in the place to have the chance. Must have been shot to bits under roy though so once he's got his sights lined up I'm sure he will be converting a few more chances.
COYP

 

antipodeagle Flag Wellington 02 Nov 21 7.28am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

The main difference in our style this season is that we close down much better. We conceded ground far too easily before. Our passing from the back is also much improved. The back four has been the same every week, so far, and that has helped a lot.

The improvements are largely about having better players and better coaching staff.

PV can take some credit for encouraging more energetic football, but it is not just about him. We actually spent money, and that is something that has been needed for several years.

While it's true we have some very good new players, I would say almost an equal factor in our improvement has been the revelation that our remaining players from last season are able to dominate matches through a close control and passing game. Who knew that a team with Guaita, Ward, Mitchell, Milivojevic, McArthur, Ayew and Benteke could pass Arsenal off of the pitch?! The only one who still can't trap a bag of cement is Kouyate, but even he now has a role to play in certain situations like against Citeh.

I actually think Nuno would have done better here (on a relative scale) than he did at Spurs, but it would have been through enhancements to the Hodgson model and approach only. He certainly doesn't seem to have the chops to have done what PV has managed to do in a very short time indeed.

Irrespective of position in the table, this is the most exciting start to a season for decades: I can't wait for the next match each week, confident that we will give anyone a run for their money, even if we don't end up with the win. Long may it continue!

Edited by antipodeagle (02 Nov 2021 7.30am)

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > I was very very very wrong!