This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
He has form!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eagle Phil
Agree 100% with Davepalace707, that’s exactly what I do. I never expect him to score, no matter how simple the chance and then when he does score it makes the goal celebration so much better. Why then, do we persist with him? I really don't understand how he gets away with fooling folk into believing he's a striker. I was underwhelmed when he joined us and I still feel the same. OK, so he's scored a few this season, but he misses too many good chances which is what this thread's about. However, funnily enough, I do agree with Tickled in that our overall performance improved after he came on.
Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled. |
|
|
Originally posted by Davepalace707
I realised a few years’ ago the only way to cope with watching Benteke is to expect him to miss absolutely everything and to only be surprised when he scores Agree. It's not just the missed chances - his passing is absolutely atrocious and I don't know if I've ever seen a striker with worse movement. Absolutely 0 poaching instincts, doesn't press, has one bit of movement to peel to the back post and hope it gets stood up.. the one time that actually paid off yesterday, he missed a free header from 6 yards. Did anyone notice the shot from the edge of the area? That's half a chance for any competent top level forward to at least work the keeper - he put it a mile wide. When are we finally going to cut our losses and just get rid?
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Agree. It's not just the missed chances - his passing is absolutely atrocious and I don't know if I've ever seen a striker with worse movement. Absolutely 0 poaching instincts, doesn't press, has one bit of movement to peel to the back post and hope it gets stood up.. the one time that actually paid off yesterday, he missed a free header from 6 yards. Did anyone notice the shot from the edge of the area? That's half a chance for any competent top level forward to at least work the keeper - he put it a mile wide. When are we finally going to cut our losses and just get rid? Because as much as I agree with everything (and I cant stand the guy most of the time) we looked better when he was on. Unfortunately whilst we see little glimpses of quality from OE, he isn't playing well enough to keep Benteke out of the team.
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
Because as much as I agree with everything (and I cant stand the guy most of the time) we looked better when he was on. Unfortunately whilst we see little glimpses of quality from OE, he isn't playing well enough to keep Benteke out of the team. I think yesterday was a bit of an exception - we weren't good enough to beat Leeds press without Andersen and Macca (two of our best/most composed ball players) so ended up having to play more direct, which suited Benteke and meant he was quite effective. I don't think there will be many other games we end up playing as direct as that, so I don't envisage that kind of impact every game. Edouard just looks a better player to me - better touch, better feet, better movement and a better finisher - will take a bit of time to settle/adapt, but I don't see how he doesn't end up a better option. If we were to have a 90th min one-on-one to win a game, I think all of us would rather it fell to Edouard than Benteke.
|
|
|
Absolutely shocking miss what in effect was an open goal from 4 yards, that cost is points in the end.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I think yesterday was a bit of an exception - we weren't good enough to beat Leeds press without Andersen and Macca (two of our best/most composed ball players) so ended up having to play more direct, which suited Benteke and meant he was quite effective. I don't think there will be many other games we end up playing as direct as that, so I don't envisage that kind of impact every game. Edouard just looks a better player to me - better touch, better feet, better movement and a better finisher - will take a bit of time to settle/adapt, but I don't see how he doesn't end up a better option. If we were to have a 90th min one-on-one to win a game, I think all of us would rather it fell to Edouard than Benteke. To your last comment, Brighton away last year. We look much more dangerous up front when Benteke plays, he gives their CBs a tough game. He holds the ball up and creates space for other players. Yes he misses some chances, but he gets in the position to have those chances, which others don’t seem to do.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
To your last comment, Brighton away last year. We look much more dangerous up front when Benteke plays, he gives their CBs a tough game. He holds the ball up and creates space for other players. Yes he misses some chances, but he gets in the position to have those chances, which others don’t seem to do. His strengths are his aerial presence and hold up play, but I disagree about getting in the right positions, I actually think that's his weakness. So often a player pings a ball across the edge of the 6-yard box and he's on the 18-yard line. I think he's improved over the last 12 months after a few years of being woeful, but he is never going to be a striker that pressures defenders with constant running and he still seems to need at least three gilt-edged chances per goal.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
PV says that Benteke is capable of scoring 10 goals this season. Not a vast amount for the position. But for Benteke, a big increase on the last few years. By my reckoning, Benteke will need to be provided with 100 scoring chances over the course of the season to achieve that number. It's a shame we couldn't compete with Newcastle for Callum Wilson, he would be ideal in our set up.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
To your last comment, Brighton away last year. We look much more dangerous up front when Benteke plays, he gives their CBs a tough game. He holds the ball up and creates space for other players. Yes he misses some chances, but he gets in the position to have those chances, which others don’t seem to do. Does once in 5 years make it worth it? Would you rather 'the chance' fell to Benteke or Edouard? If your honest with yourself, I think the answer is fairly obvious. His hold up play is horrific - he can't trap the ball and his passing is pathetic. Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (01 Dec 2021 11.46am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
His strengths are his aerial presence and hold up play, but I disagree about getting in the right positions, I actually think that's his weakness. So often a player pings a ball across the edge of the 6-yard box and he's on the 18-yard line. I think he's improved over the last 12 months after a few years of being woeful, but he is never going to be a striker that pressures defenders with constant running and he still seems to need at least three gilt-edged chances per goal. Agree re his movement - he is only ever looking for the stood up ball to the far post, which he needs to take a run at, so if a quick low ball is ever delivered he's normally stood around the penalty spot on his heels. Your last paragraph summarises it well for me.
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
His strengths are his aerial presence and hold up play, but I disagree about getting in the right positions, I actually think that's his weakness. So often a player pings a ball across the edge of the 6-yard box and he's on the 18-yard line. I think he's improved over the last 12 months after a few years of being woeful, but he is never going to be a striker that pressures defenders with constant running and he still seems to need at least three gilt-edged chances per goal. Edouard didn’t impress last night against physical defenders, I don’t think he created one chance. The difference was when Benteke came on.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
PV says that Benteke is capable of scoring 10 goals this season. Not a vast amount for the position. But for Benteke, a big increase on the last few years. By my reckoning, Benteke will need to be provided with 100 scoring chances over the course of the season to achieve that number. It's a shame we couldn't compete with Newcastle for Callum Wilson, he would be ideal in our set up. He'd be brilliant for us. He's also a bit nasty, not fun to play against but you'd love him in your team
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Edouard didn’t impress last night against physical defenders, I don’t think he created one chance. The difference was when Benteke came on. Poor old Édouard,played on the wing ,when he was bought as a centre forward,play him there and will score more than that bloody useless statue Benteke!!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Edouard didn’t impress last night against physical defenders, I don’t think he created one chance. The difference was when Benteke came on. What difference exactly? He got a toe onto a nothing diagonal which the keeper nearly f*cked up, and missed a free header from 4 yards because Wilf produced a great cross. Benteke played 22 mins, completed 3 passes (out of 7 attempted), lost possession 5 times (he only had 13 touches) and missed a sitter. Is that where we set the bar now?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.