This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Good post. However I must take issue regarding the 2nd goal, it is conclusive. Laws clearly state if play is interfering with play or distracts defender whilst in offside position it is offside. All pundits I have heard say it was offside as Firmino being there caused Mitchell to go towards him rather the Oxlade-Chamberlain. Friend was told immediately there was no reason to rule goal out, he touched his earpiece, so some communication was relayed. I suppose one could consider that even if Firmino had been onside Mitchell might still have been drawn inside towards him rather than in a wider position picking up Oxlade-Chamberlain. Overall a poor goal to concede from a defensive organisational standpoint and the fact that Jota was in acres of space,unchallenged outside the area and had all the time to deliver the cross.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I suppose one could consider that even if Firmino had been onside Mitchell might still have been drawn inside towards him rather than in a wider position picking up Oxlade-Chamberlain. Overall a poor goal to concede from a defensive organisational standpoint and the fact that Jota was in acres of space,unchallenged outside the area and had all the time to deliver the cross. Anything rather than blaming the corrupt incompetent referee eh?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I suppose one could consider that even if Firmino had been onside Mitchell might still have been drawn inside towards him rather than in a wider position picking up Oxlade-Chamberlain. Overall a poor goal to concede from a defensive organisational standpoint and the fact that Jota was in acres of space,unchallenged outside the area and had all the time to deliver the cross. Irrelevant what may have happened if Firmino was onside because the fact is, according to the laws of the game he was offside and there is absolutely no
|
|
|
Originally posted by the silurian
Clearly we are not 'Birds on the same twig' apropos officials, in fact we have always had a difference of opinion on this matter. I have no desire to enter a protracted debate on this issue as it will only disintegrate into a dastardly Willo thread.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Firstly, let's be clear - the penalty decision robbed us of what very small chance remained of atoning for yet more s*** Palace defending against a set-piece and a cross in the air. Liverpool had us chasing shadows for the first half an hour, but that's exactly when we most need to hang on in the game and avoid poor defensive mistakes. We didn't. For the first goal, Schlupp is marking Fabinho but leaves him late to run with Van Dyke, thereby blocking what small chance Andersen had of tracking the Dutchman. For the second, our midfield shape is so bad that Andersen gets dragged over to meet Robertson, leaving Jota in oceans of space, and pulling both Guehi and Mitchell over into a fragile 2v3 behind him. Even if we somehow overlook the poor quality of our finishing we have to mull over the poor defending when analysing the defeat. I'm sure our manager will be looking at both issues far more than the officiating, whatever he says in public. Turning to the decisions nonetheless: VAR itself is neither good nor bad for the game really, it's all about how it is used. Also, remember that we have had our fair share of gifts from VAR, including unreal decisions away at United and Arsenal, so let's not tell ourselves a tale of bias against the little guy here. We are dealing with incredibly poor decisions and inconsistent processes, but not bias. The argument that offside should be given against Firmino is not conclusive, but what I am amazed by is that VAR didn't seem to look at it even once. Compare this to the twenty replays they poured over for the penalty decision. The on-field ref gave nothing both times, so why the vast difference in VAR approach? Regarding the penalty, it all comes down to a sensible understanding of what a foul is, and what cheating is. At the start of this season, the league said they would avoid giving soft free-kicks for minimal contacts, and would also stop being overly forensic with VAR replays. For the first few months that worked so well that Klopp and Solskjaer were moaning about their precious babies being roughed up, and the leagues forward players seemed to be spending a bit more time playing the game and bit less time falling over. The tempo and flow of games became noticeably better once it became more about actually playing, and less about 'winning' decisions. Now it's lapsed back towards last season: A soul-destroying clipboard full of technicalities rather than a football match. For me, if you can't see the offence with the naked eye and at normal speed then the margin for human error has not been breached. The normal speed aspect is critical - all pundits agree that slow-motion makes any contact look worse, but what they neglect to mention is that it's only when watching play at normal speed that one can fully appreciate the change of direction and momentum that the nations leading s***houses employ when jumping away from the path of the ball and into a nearby defender, thereby initiating the 'foul' they benefit from. Kane has done it for years, Jota did it on Sunday. Wilf and Ayew have their moments, albeit in a slightly different style. Many footballers will play as far beyond the letter and spirit of the laws of the game as they are allowed to. These are highly competitive animals under far greater pressure to win than to play honestly, and we are all to blame for that. What I find increasingly difficult to understand is how VAR officials (who referee live games too don't forget), somehow fail to consider the tricks that modern forwards call upon the moment a slow-motion replay switches on. Baffling, alienating nonsense that pushes me further away from professional football and further towards watching the non-league game instead. Edited by TheBigToePunt (26 Jan 2022 10.49am) Very much agree with the bit in highlight, and it certainly suggests the refs are people with very limited experience of playing the game to any sort of reasonable standard. Some of the things they fall for are so obvious to anyone who has, even in real time. It's ruining the sport - there's 0 honour left in the game, winning at all costs is the only approach these days. It's a shame.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Very much agree with the bit in highlight, and it certainly suggests the refs are people with very limited experience of playing the game to any sort of reasonable standard. Some of the things they fall for are so obvious to anyone who has, even in real time. It's ruining the sport - there's 0 honour left in the game, winning at all costs is the only approach these days. It's a shame. This is a very valid point, there was a debate on here years ago & as an ex-ref as well as an ex-assessor the simple answer as to why refs haven't hardly had any footballing experience is because, atm, in this country, as well as elsewhere, to make it to the very top of refereeing, you need to start from the age of 14. Football in this country is basically run by the county associations, & if your face don't fit, thats it, no progress. Happened to me when i was starting out(although i was late 20's) i had to officiate in other counties so my grades could be assessed & enable me to progress to the level i reached till i was obliged to retire at 48, thats when i took my Assessors exams & continued in the game as well as working. There have been calls for ex-players to become refs, that went well, think the figure that applied was about 30 & only 18 passed the test(says a lot). I totally agree that it does look like they haven't got a scooby when players 'con' them, because they don't know themselves.
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Very much agree with the bit in highlight, and it certainly suggests the refs are people with very limited experience of playing the game to any sort of reasonable standard. Some of the things they fall for are so obvious to anyone who has, even in real time. It's ruining the sport - there's 0 honour left in the game, winning at all costs is the only approach these days. It's a shame. Totally agree. A big bugbare of mine is when players stop suddenly and the player behind has no option but to run into them, automatically being penalised.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Good post. However I must take issue regarding the 2nd goal, it is conclusive. Laws clearly state if play is interfering with play or distracts defender whilst in offside position it is offside. All pundits I have heard say it was offside as Firmino being there caused Mitchell to go towards him rather the Oxlade-Chamberlain. Friend was told immediately there was no reason to rule goal out, he touched his earpiece, so some communication was relayed. Having just looked at the video again for the first time since the match, I am inclined to come around to your way of thinking on the second goal. Firmino jumps for the ball as high as he can. It doesn't change the fact that Andersen stepped up to Robertson unnecessarily, leaving Guehi and Mitchell 2v3, but does make the absence of any kind of VAR intervention all the more baffling and infuriating. Also, and as a further addition to my previous rant about our s*** defending for the first Liverpool goal, not only did Schlupp block Andersen from tracking Van Dyke, but Edouard (who had been detailed to occupy the zone in which Van Dyke arrived) literally just walked away from the danger area as soon as the corner was delivered, when he should have been taking a step or two backwards and at least trying to clear it. I have carefully considered the various technical and tactical explanations for his actions, and have concluded that the guy is a total f***ing coward who didn't fancy putting his head in where it hurts. Perhaps Van Dyke would have scored anyway, but don't just walk away from your f***ing job.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Having just looked at the video again for the first time since the match, I am inclined to come around to your way of thinking on the second goal. Firmino jumps for the ball as high as he can. It doesn't change the fact that Andersen stepped up to Robertson unnecessarily, leaving Guehi and Mitchell 2v3, but does make the absence of any kind of VAR intervention all the more baffling and infuriating. Also, and as a further addition to my previous rant about our s*** defending for the first Liverpool goal, not only did Schlupp block Andersen from tracking Van Dyke, but Edouard (who had been detailed to occupy the zone in which Van Dyke arrived) literally just walked away from the danger area as soon as the corner was delivered, when he should have been taking a step or two backwards and at least trying to clear it. I have carefully considered the various technical and tactical explanations for his actions, and have concluded that the guy is a total f***ing coward who didn't fancy putting his head in where it hurts. Perhaps Van Dyke would have scored anyway, but don't just walk away from your f***ing job. To my ageing eyes, it looked like a Liverpool player blocking off Andersen who might have been designated to pick up Van Dyck and he was able to run from virtually the edge of the area and head in unchallenged.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
To my ageing eyes, it looked like a Liverpool player blocking off Andersen who might have been designated to pick up Van Dyck and he was able to run from virtually the edge of the area and head in unchallenged. I'd say Fabinho was supposed to block Andersen but didn't get the chance as Schlupp did it for him. Fabinho actually just stood still.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
I'd say Fabinho was supposed to block Andersen but didn't get the chance as Schlupp did it for him. Fabinho actually just stood still. I think you're being quite harsh to be honest - it was a good delivery, a well-timed run by someone who is virtually unstoppable in the air when he gets it right, and the ball thumped emphatically into the top corner - there are always margins for improvement, but I think it was a good set-piece that will always be fairly hard to stop. Realistically, even if Anderson managed to evade the bodies and track VVD, he has minimal chance of beating him to that header given where he met it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
I'd say Fabinho was supposed to block Andersen but didn't get the chance as Schlupp did it for him. Fabinho actually just stood still. To my ageing eyes it looked as though Fabinho just leant into Andersen preventing him from blocking Van Dyck,Andersen got free and tried to get to the Dutchman who was on the run but Schlupp was in his way.
|
|
|
Originally posted by thetopgeezer
It's taken me until now to watch MOTD and the review of the game because I was so annoyed... and I am 57. 40 years of Palace makes you circumspect, usually immune. Definitely offside for their 2nd goal. Definitely not a penalty (the worst decision I have seen, given VAR). As soon as they replayed their goal I could immediately see Firmono was offide and in play so what actually is Paulson doing at that point? Celebrating? When they replayed the penalty shout I could immediately see that the ball was gone, Joto moved towards Guaita and it was a collision. Pawson then spends 5 minutes working the clips hard enough to convince himself black is white and then shoves it onto Friend who hasn't the guts to stand by his decision. To be fair to Friend, by the time you are at the video monitor, the VAR ref has got the clips exactly right to make sure that the onfield ref has to think the VAR knows something he doesn't, i.e. a clear and obvious error. When as a professional I make errors that are blatant and my fault, I apologise to the client. Why can't we expect the same from these two? If not I suspect we will make Selhurst a place where they are neverwelcome. And rightly so. Edited by thetopgeezer (25 Jan 2022 6.56pm) I can’t argue with any of that. I was willing to give them the benefit of the doubt on the day even though my son was adamant they were blatant errors. He was right, I was wrong, and the PL bosses are delighted that the title race is a little closer. It sucks.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
VAR is total dross. Can’t celebrate goals at 100% anymore. ‘Clear and obvious errors’ only happen a few times a season (Freddie Sears phantom goal scenario), not 1-2 times per game. It’s become a worse viewing experience for fans. I’d rather it went completely, but if it was to stay, I think captains should have 1 review per game for goal/red card incidents. The ref should have a 15 second window to rewatch the incident from 2 angles at normal speed - you shouldn’t need longer then that spot a clear error. Lucky usually evens itself out over the course of the season Yes, which is what we used to say about refereeing errors. Now we are saying it about VAR - the system brought in to prevent those errors.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Very much agree with the bit in highlight, and it certainly suggests the refs are people with very limited experience of playing the game to any sort of reasonable standard. Some of the things they fall for are so obvious to anyone who has, even in real time. It's ruining the sport - there's 0 honour left in the game, winning at all costs is the only approach these days. It's a shame. Regarding refs, and as someone pointed out a few posts ago, they haven't played the game at any level really as they start so young in order to get up the leagues in time to be a premier league ref. Based on the teenage boys who referee my sons under-11s games, I doubt too many of them will end up in the top flight no matter how early they start, but Christ knows there aren't enough people who want to be refs, and if we took away the incentive that a youngster might make it to the top if he starts young enough then it'd be even harder to get officals for grass roots football. Anyway, I don't think the idea of referees having played the game is all that important really. Firstly (and this is the lesser point), if they played professional football until 35 before starting out as a ref, they would either be 50+ years old by the time they had enough training and experience to officiate at the top level (and be called too old and slow to keep up with play) or be fast-tracked into top-flight refereeing with no experience behind them (and be called under-qualified and unproven). Secondly (and this is the big issue for me), whatever playing experience and insight a ref might have doesn't really matter if he is not allowed to use it. The current system of refereeing (including VAR) seems to place no value at all on upholding the wider spirit of the game, focusing entirely on the technical rules, applied blindly and in total isolation to any one split second incident. That same system promotes and demotes referees, so even if an ex-pro has a better idea of what a player is up to when they 'draw' a foul, that ref still has to implement the wishes of the wider system if they want to stay at the top. I'd say most poor decisions (especially VAR ones) stem from fear of not implementing the letter of the law in a technical way, leading to the abandonment of the spirit of the game and fouls given for the most fleeting of contacts. TV has a lot to answer for here - if they didn't analyse every decision then perhaps refs wouldn't feel such pressure to overreact to contact. Besides, listening to the likes of Shearer say that a forward has 'the right to go down' when contacted, or has 'been clever there' (something Vieria himself said about Jota on Sunday lets not forget), I'm not sure I want many ex-pros anywhere near a whistle. On your second point, I'm not sure players ever played with true sportsmanship. From the hatchet men of the old days to the divers of today, they will get away with whatever they can because they are competitive animals under pressure to win. Obviously, it helps hugely when referees wise up (they let more contact go early this season and it made a very positive difference), but any lasting change in the honesty of players would only come about when their own fans demand it. Perhaps that means you and I have to criticise (perhaps boo or barrack?) our own players when they go over too easily, and not just reserve that treatment for Jota, Kane etc. Perhaps we have to applaud the ref when he waves play on at Zaha or Ayew, rather than join the chorus of pressure to give a free-kick. Not an easy thing to do. Edited by TheBigToePunt (26 Jan 2022 2.47pm) Edited by TheBigToePunt (26 Jan 2022 2.52pm)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.