You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is it time to let Wilf go?
November 16 2026 3.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is it time to let Wilf go?


Page 4 of 14 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
HeathMan Flag Purley 13 Feb 22 10.23pm

Who knows what the future holds. PV - after the Brentford match - said (I think) something like we have talent and that talent needs to perform. PV knows that players need game time. Wilf has not been doing an active ninety minutes. could be used as an impact starter or impact substitute. On for first 25 minutes - really go for goal or draw many fouls (allowing opponents to earn red cards. On for last 35 minutes - still fresh and able to attract opponents (special if seen to present a goal threat) leaving way clear for others to do damage.

 

The Dolphin Flag 14 Feb 22 10.11am

He really seems to have lost his pace almost overnight - last season great - this season not so and I cannot fathom it out.
Pace normally disappears over time not overnight.
An injury carried for a long time perhaps that is now having an effect?

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 14 Feb 22 5.05pm

Just an idle, random thought. I've just watched the so-called highlights of the match again and it occurred to me that if Canos had got the second yellow for hauling Wilf off the pitch which he deserved, and if a penalty had been given for Henry hauling him down in the area, I think we'd be feeling pretty satisfied with Wilf's contribution (as long as he didn't take the penalty).

 

taylors lovechild Flag 14 Feb 22 5.14pm

Originally posted by JRW2

Just an idle, random thought. I've just watched the so-called highlights of the match again and it occurred to me that if Canos had got the second yellow for hauling Wilf off the pitch which he deserved, and if a penalty had been given for Henry hauling him down in the area, I think we'd be feeling pretty satisfied with Wilf's contribution (as long as he didn't take the penalty).

I agree. First half I thought he was our best player. He dropped off a bit in the second half. Former PL referee Hackett thinks Wilf should have had a penalty: [Link]

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 14 Feb 22 8.55pm

Do you know what I still love him and taking the penalty out of the equation who else could have scored that goal, it was a Worldie?

Give him a break and enjoy the Wonder of Wilf........

 


Bring back Brolin

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 14 Feb 22 9.14pm

What the f*** are you guys on ? He is the best attacking player we have. Without him we would still be in the championship. Who else could have scored that goal at Norwich. So he slipped for the penalty , s*** happens. I dont know why I bother coming to this site ... if you think letting Wilf go is a good idea for Crystal Palace Football Club then I think you really need help.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 14 Feb 22 9.49pm

Originally posted by babylonjohn

What the f*** are you guys on ? He is the best attacking player we have. Without him we would still be in the championship. Who else could have scored that goal at Norwich. So he slipped for the penalty , s*** happens. I dont know why I bother coming to this site ... if you think letting Wilf go is a good idea for Crystal Palace Football Club then I think you really need help.

Not anymore he's not. Not even close.

Yes, without him in previous years we'd be in the championship, maybe. But we're not talking about previous years. We're talking about this season and moving into the future. He simply is not the same player.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 14 Feb 22 10.13pm

Wilf's problems are of his own making. He used to get kicked by the opposition because he was by far our best player and stopping him meant stopping us.

Now he gets kicked because they know he'll lose the plot. It wouldn't be an issue if he channeled that anger into punishing the opposition but instead it puts him off his game. Players like James Ward-Prowse know exactly how to get in his head.

It's idiotic because if he restricted his moaning to key moments I reckon he'd win a lot more penalties. But he'll get kicked on the halfway line and go mental. It's like the boy who cried wolf, the penalty calls are diluted by the constant moaning.

All of this would be moot if he was still the same player he was 3 seasons ago but, in my opinion, he looks joyless on the pitch now. He used to be full of tricks and turns but now he doesn't seem to have the same spark.

I don't know what the answer is because I'm not convinced that Vieira fancies Eze that much so, for the time being, Zaha and Olise either side of a striker seems the best bet unless Eze can get back to his best.

However, I wouldn't be heartbroken if we did sell Wilf this summer. He may well be our best ever player but I was so disappointed with the events that led to him trying to force his way out of the club that I have lost a lot of love for him. Same with Freedman, my favourite player before Wilf and the nonsense he pulled on us.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Mathers Flag 14 Feb 22 10.40pm

Originally posted by sprites

Not anymore he's not. Not even close.

Yes, without him in previous years we'd be in the championship, maybe. But we're not talking about previous years. We're talking about this season and moving into the future. He simply is not the same player.

Would love to know who you think is our best player?

The goal against Norwich shows Wilf remains a cut above anyone in our squad. It’s clear he has lost a touch of pace but his goal/ assist return shows he is still effective and deserves his starting place.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 14 Feb 22 10.52pm

Yes, it was a nice goal from Wilf. Townsend scored similar, and let's not forget the best of the bunch, Ayew dancing past wooden Wet Spam players before chipping the keeper. Now that was a goal!

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 14 Feb 22 11.59pm

I can’t see anyone buying Wilf until his contract expires. He can then move on for free. So at 30 he should still be good for say £110k/wk.
Newcastle might go for him cos money is irrelevant. Our only chance of any money for him is this summer, but even then it won’t b more than £25m. Similar situation to us and Nketiah.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 15 Feb 22 12.17am

Originally posted by Mathers

Would love to know who you think is our best player?

The goal against Norwich shows Wilf remains a cut above anyone in our squad. It’s clear he has lost a touch of pace but his goal/ assist return shows he is still effective and deserves his starting place.

For me right now, it's Gallagher. But in terms of players who are better than Wilf:

Guehi
Gallagher
Olise
Eze (not currently, but we know he can get there)

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 15 Feb 22 7.28am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Yes, it was a nice goal from Wilf. Townsend scored similar, and let's not forget the best of the bunch, Ayew dancing past wooden Wet Spam players before chipping the keeper. Now that was a goal!


And adds to the possibility of using Ayew as a striker in the short term. At least it offers something different to Mateta and Benteke.

 

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 15 Feb 22 7.43am

Originally posted by sprites

For me right now, it's Gallagher. But in terms of players who are better than Wilf:

Guehi
Gallagher
Olise
Eze (not currently, but we know he can get there)

Guehi is a good defender but hard to compare him to an attacker
Gallaher is a chelsea player and he seems to have gone off the boil of late.
Olise looks like a fantastic talent. But is still learning and can leave Wardy exposed which is why Ayu will often start over him.
Eze is another fantastic talent but hasnt quite regained his initial form after an injury.
Wilf is joint second highest goalscorer currently despite having played fewer games. Even when not at his best he will worry defences and draw extra defenders to him. He can produce the magic to turn a game and is in my humble opininion our best player.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 15 Feb 22 7.59am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider


And adds to the possibility of using Ayew as a striker in the short term. At least it offers something different to Mateta and Benteke.

Ayew is a striker. Let's not forget he was the main man in 2019/20 season:
"At the end of the season, He became the highest goalscorer for Crystal Palace with 9 goals, and won the Crystal Palace Player of the season and Goal of the season awards".

 

PatrickA Flag London 15 Feb 22 8.07am

The Mail is reporting this morning that Wilf is not planning to sign a new contract despite Palace’s desire to sign him up to an extension.
Of course it could be just paper talk or his agent on manoeuvres, but with only 18 months remaining it’s likely that there is some forward planning in place.
The article suggests that he is prepared to let his existing contract run down, in which case Palace could be tempted to sell earlier to at least realise some value.
In my view this would not me as much of an issue as it would have been in the past.
Wilf is assured of his legendary status at the club, but he is a declining force and we are no longer so reliant on him.
He is not the same player that destroyed Bournemouth at the end of the season before last when he accelerated beyond opponents leaving several in his wake and destroyed them on the day.
He doesn’t seem to trust his pace to go on the outside of defenders and is predictable in cutting inside where he frequently concedes possession.
Opponents often don’t even double up on him any more because a full back can deal with him in isolation.
This is not a criticism of a great player, but just an observation of him over a number of months.
Although he’s only 29 such a decline is not without precedent.
Walcott was a brilliant young player, but has had a rapid drop off in form as he has got older and lost pace which is partly attributable to injuries.
Wilf is still capable of great moments, but I’m not sure that he’s the first name on the team sheet any more which in itself is a novelty.
.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 15 Feb 22 8.49am

Well it looks like he'll be gone whatever. As he can't do what he used to and has a terrible attitude to boot, the best the club can hope for is a club like Newcastle come in. He's been here too long, and he knows it. Ideas of CL football were just a figment of his imagination, if he were really as good as his agent thinks he is he would be there by now.
Unfortunately for him he can't reinvent his game; a winger usually relies on pace to make up their game, Wilf is losing his. Maybe he'll get a break elsewhere and start to enjoy his game again.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 15 Feb 22 9.02am


Sad to say it may be time to let him go rather than have to hear tales of how unhappy and frustrated he is every 18 months - when a pay rise fixes his discontent.
Presumably he’d be looking for more money to play for another club whose fans won’t be as forgiving.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 15 Feb 22 9.05am

Not really much we can do about it. Power is in his hands, unless (like he has before) Parish throws silly money at the problem.

Personally I'd offer him another year or 2 extension, if he doesn't want it that's fine. Not going to force him to stay

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 15 Feb 22 9.17am

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Not really much we can do about it. Power is in his hands, unless (like he has before) Parish throws silly money at the problem.

Personally I'd offer him another year or 2 extension, if he doesn't want it that's fine. Not going to force him to stay

No, it's time to cut loose. He (and Benteke) is holding the club back. Wilf's position is not irreplacable. There are only a few select players who have long service at a single club. Usually they get less game time as the years go by, and they use their experience to positively influence younger players. If anything Wilf is getting more immature as time goes on.

 

Page 4 of 14 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is it time to let Wilf go?