This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Come grow old with me.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by manoftaste
In 30 or 40 years time (when I, unfortunately, will no longer be around to share in it) Palace supporters will be talking nostalgically of this period in the club's history - in much the same way as we reminisce today about Kenny Sansom, Vince Hilaire, and El Tel's 'Team of the Eighties.' I would say finishing 3rd in 1991 was our greatest period, this team isn’t even in the top half, but you’re right otherwise, I think we’ll all look back fondly on this period if it all goes Pete Tong, because after the last 2 or 3 years, we’re at least good to watch
|
|
|
Originally posted by monkey
I would say finishing 3rd in 1991 was our greatest period, this team isn’t even in the top half, but you’re right otherwise, I think we’ll all look back fondly on this period if it all goes Pete Tong, because after the last 2 or 3 years, we’re at least good to watch 90/91 was an exciting period, 3rd and FA cup final, but it didn’t last long. The last 10 years have been our greatest period ever, without doubt. We have gone from being a yo yo club to an established mid table Premier team, no easy task with all the money our rivals are throwing around.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
90/91 was an exciting period, 3rd and FA cup final, but it didn’t last long. The last 10 years have been our greatest period ever, without doubt. We have gone from being a yo yo club to an established mid table Premier team, no easy task with all the money our rivals are throwing around. I suppose if we’re talking as a club for consistently staying in the top flight, then I make you right, but we still haven’t reached the heights of the 1991 team, so for me it’s still our greatest period, we achieved more in a shorter space of time, but we could debate that forever. All I know is, PV has got us all enjoying our football again however this period turns out
|
|
|
Originally posted by nhp61
In those days the top division wasn't littered with clubs subsidised by mega rich owners. The vast majority of players were from the UK and Ireland. It was a much more level playing field than it is now. I would argue that Palace currently staying so long in the Premier League as it is now is a better achievement. But now WE spend millions on players as well, the early 90’s team was put together on a shoe string, made up of ex-lower league and non-league players. Still a much better achievement, but I suppose this current story is not yet over, so who knows? Edited by monkey (15 Mar 2022 4.51pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by manoftaste
In 30 or 40 years time (when I, unfortunately, will no longer be around to share in it) Palace supporters will be talking nostalgically of this period in the club's history - in much the same way as we reminisce today about Kenny Sansom, Vince Hilaire, and El Tel's 'Team of the Eighties.' I agree that this will be remembered as our golden period, but it's nothing remotely like the Team of the Eighties. For many years, that team defined our broader public image. Now, for the first time, that's no longer the case and nor should it be. The Team of the Eighties lasted precisely one year at the top level (well, we were relegated after two seasons but once Kenny left the second season was no longer really "that" team. Its reputation was built in Divisions Two and Three (not the top flight), and the whole thing really only lasted four years. In contrast, this side while now at its best yet is still improving and it's the result of ten years (not four) of steady progress, identity-building, and momentum shifting. It's nothing like the Team of the Eighties which was, in contrast, a flash in the pan. Compare Wilf, who's given us a decade of leadership and brilliance with his equivalent from the 80s, Vince Hilaire, who really had no more than a year of genuine sustained, really top-flight success. There's no comparison between the two. Compare Billy Gilbert, whose reputation exceeded what he ever really achieved in his career, with Dann or Delaney (let alone Guehi or Andersson), both of whom were top-level players who kept us up for half a decade. Compare FFS Murray and his innumerable PL goals with Swindly, who we lionise but never really matured into a top-division, year in-year out goalscorer. There's no comparison. The Team of the Eighties is largely a myth in the minds of those who weren't there, fostered by the happy memories of those of us who were. This Palace team, and its achievments, are real.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
|
Originally posted by sydtheeagle
I agree that this will be remembered as our golden period, but it's nothing remotely like the Team of the Eighties. For many years, that team defined our broader public image. Now, for the first time, that's no longer the case and nor should it be. The Team of the Eighties lasted precisely one year at the top level (well, we were relegated after two seasons but once Kenny left the second season was no longer really "that" team. Its reputation was built in Divisions Two and Three (not the top flight), and the whole thing really only lasted four years. In contrast, this side while now at its best yet is still improving and it's the result of ten years (not four) of steady progress, identity-building, and momentum shifting. It's nothing like the Team of the Eighties which was, in contrast, a flash in the pan. Compare Wilf, who's given us a decade of leadership and brilliance with his equivalent from the 80s, Vince Hilaire, who really had no more than a year of genuine sustained, really top-flight success. There's no comparison between the two. Compare Billy Gilbert, whose reputation exceeded what he ever really achieved in his career, with Dann or Delaney (let alone Guehi or Andersson), both of whom were top-level players who kept us up for half a decade. Compare FFS Murray and his innumerable PL goals with Swindly, who we lionise but never really matured into a top-division, year in-year out goalscorer. There's no comparison. The Team of the Eighties is largely a myth in the minds of those who weren't there, fostered by the happy memories of those of us who were. This Palace team, and its achievments, are real. We never actually called ourselves that it was the media and Ron Greenwood? who coined the phrase so later we were slaughtered for a nickname that we had never owned.
One more point |
|
|
Agree with much of this. Originally posted by sydtheeagle
I agree that this will be remembered as our golden period, but it's nothing remotely like the Team of the Eighties. For many years, that team defined our broader public image. Now, for the first time, that's no longer the case and nor should it be. The Team of the Eighties lasted precisely one year at the top level (well, we were relegated after two seasons but once Kenny left the second season was no longer really "that" team. Its reputation was built in Divisions Two and Three (not the top flight), and the whole thing really only lasted four years. In contrast, this side while now at its best yet is still improving and it's the result of ten years (not four) of steady progress, identity-building, and momentum shifting. It's nothing like the Team of the Eighties which was, in contrast, a flash in the pan. Compare Wilf, who's given us a decade of leadership and brilliance with his equivalent from the 80s, Vince Hilaire, who really had no more than a year of genuine sustained, really top-flight success. There's no comparison between the two. Compare Billy Gilbert, whose reputation exceeded what he ever really achieved in his career, with Dann or Delaney (let alone Guehi or Andersson), both of whom were top-level players who kept us up for half a decade. Compare FFS Murray and his innumerable PL goals with Swindly, who we lionise but never really matured into a top-division, year in-year out goalscorer. There's no comparison. The Team of the Eighties is largely a myth in the minds of those who weren't there, fostered by the happy memories of those of us who were. This Palace team, and its achievments, are real.
|
|
|
Originally posted by monkey
But now WE spend millions on players as well, the early 90’s team was put together on a shoe string, made up of ex-lower league and non-league players. Still for a much better achievement, but I suppose this current story is not yet over, so who knows? I agree, we do spend millions, but the majority of the so-called "Big Sx" spend much more. Our 5 year net spend averaged £11.2 million. Manchester City's average over the same period is £101.1 million. For a better idea of how we compare with player purchases, sold and net spend: [Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by nhp61
I agree, we do spend millions, but the majority of the so-called "Big Sx" spend much more. Our 5 year net spend averaged £11.2 million. Manchester City's average over the same period is £101.1 million. For a better idea of how we compare with player purchases, sold and net spend: [Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by sydtheeagle
I agree that this will be remembered as our golden period, but it's nothing remotely like the Team of the Eighties. For many years, that team defined our broader public image. Now, for the first time, that's no longer the case and nor should it be. The Team of the Eighties lasted precisely one year at the top level (well, we were relegated after two seasons but once Kenny left the second season was no longer really "that" team. Its reputation was built in Divisions Two and Three (not the top flight), and the whole thing really only lasted four years. In contrast, this side while now at its best yet is still improving and it's the result of ten years (not four) of steady progress, identity-building, and momentum shifting. It's nothing like the Team of the Eighties which was, in contrast, a flash in the pan. Compare Wilf, who's given us a decade of leadership and brilliance with his equivalent from the 80s, Vince Hilaire, who really had no more than a year of genuine sustained, really top-flight success. There's no comparison between the two. Compare Billy Gilbert, whose reputation exceeded what he ever really achieved in his career, with Dann or Delaney (let alone Guehi or Andersson), both of whom were top-level players who kept us up for half a decade. Compare FFS Murray and his innumerable PL goals with Swindly, who we lionise but never really matured into a top-division, year in-year out goalscorer. There's no comparison. The Team of the Eighties is largely a myth in the minds of those who weren't there, fostered by the happy memories of those of us who were. This Palace team, and its achievments, are real. Essentially the main difference with the current period and previous periods is we dont need to sell our best players, when big clubs come sniffing around. Once we survived 2 seasons in the Premier this time around, we stood a good chance to get established. The TV money has meant financial stability, if managed correctly, so we have no need to sell, but can choose if we want to sell or not. So we can keep Zaha and pay him a huge salary, in the past we couldnt and couldnt hold onto Sansom, Hilaire, Wright, Martyn, Thomas, Moses, Salako etc.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Vincehair
Without the likes of Hilaire and Cannon, Palace would have undoubtedly gone into the third tier, which in mind comparable to players who that kept Palace up in the premier in the last decade You need to dust up on your history. Palace DID go down to the third tier with Cannon in the side and were in the third tier when Hilaire started out with the club. Cannon scored on his debut (I was there) in our final home First Division match (vs. Chelsea), was thus in the side that went down to Division Two and that side was then immediately relegated again to Division Three. (Somehow, I can't see that happening with Marc Guehi.)
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
| deleted 25 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by sydtheeagle
You need to dust up on your history. Palace DID go down to the third tier with Cannon in the side and were in the third tier when Hilaire started out with the club. Cannon scored on his debut (I was there) in our final home First Division match (vs. Chelsea), was thus in the side that went down to Division Two and that side was then immediately relegated again to Division Three. (Somehow, I can't see that happening with Marc Guehi.) I don't need a history lesson from you - I'm talking post promotion to the top two divisions 45 years ago. Were you there in the early 80's ? Dosent sound like it
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.