You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What's our best line-up for the semi-final?
November 16 2026 3.43am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

What's our best line-up for the semi-final?


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
scarlet Flag Turkey 10 Apr 22 10.14am

Guaita

J. Tomkins M. Guehi J. Andersen

L. Milivojevic

W. Hughes C. Kouyaté J. Schlupp

E. Eze J. Mateta W. Zaha


I think this could be a good line-up. Id love to hear your ideas.

Edited by scarlet (10 Apr 2022 10.15am)

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 10 Apr 22 11.20am

Originally posted by scarlet

Guaita

J. Tomkins M. Guehi J. Andersen

L. Milivojevic

W. Hughes C. Kouyaté J. Schlupp

E. Eze J. Mateta W. Zaha


I think this could be a good line-up. Id love to hear your ideas.

Edited by scarlet (10 Apr 2022 10.15am)

Awful line up

************Guaita***********
Clyne*Andersen*Guehi*Mitchell
****Kouyate******Schlupp*****
************Eze**************
**Olise**************Wilf****
**********Mateta*************

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

aashman12 Flag 10 Apr 22 11.22am

Originally posted by scarlet

Guaita

J. Tomkins M. Guehi J. Andersen

L. Milivojevic

W. Hughes C. Kouyaté J. Schlupp

E. Eze J. Mateta W. Zaha


I think this could be a good line-up. Id love to hear your ideas.

Edited by scarlet (10 Apr 2022 10.15am)

Sorry but that's nowhere near our best line up for the game, odd narrow formation, no Clyne or mitchell

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 10 Apr 22 11.26am

Originally posted by scarlet

Guaita

J. Tomkins M. Guehi J. Andersen

L. Milivojevic

W. Hughes C. Kouyaté J. Schlupp

E. Eze J. Mateta W. Zaha


I think this could be a good line-up. Id love to hear your ideas.

Edited by scarlet (10 Apr 2022 10.15am)

Are you a Chelsea fan?

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 10 Apr 22 12.13pm

As

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Awful line up

************Guaita***********
Clyne*Andersen*Guehi*Mitchell
****Kouyate******Schlupp*****
************Eze**************
**Olise**************Wilf****
**********Mateta*************

This..!!

COYP

 

scarlet Flag Turkey 10 Apr 22 5.24pm

Bit harsh mate, just because you are all saying the same thing doesn't mean there are not other possibilities.

Originally posted by tonymikejoe

Are you a Chelsea fan?

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 10 Apr 22 5.39pm

Vieira favours 4-3-3, and I think he will start cautiously, so...

Butland
Clyne Guehi Andersen Mitchell
McArthur Kouyate Schlupp
Ayew Mateta Zaha

I think without Gallagher the midfield looks lacking. There should be game time for Eze and Olise.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (10 Apr 2022 5.56pm)

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 10 Apr 22 8.14pm

Originally posted by scarlet

Guaita

J. Tomkins M. Guehi J. Andersen

L. Milivojevic

W. Hughes C. Kouyaté J. Schlupp

E. Eze J. Mateta W. Zaha


I think this could be a good line-up. Id love to hear your ideas.

Edited by scarlet (10 Apr 2022 10.15am)

I think you are on drugs

 

sprites Flag Auckland 10 Apr 22 10.48pm

I'd play Eze. And McArthur. I'd also play Tekkers. Don't roll your eyes...I just think our best bet at a win here is snatching a goal from set piece or something ugly like that. And Benteke is our best weapon here.

So:

Guiata

Clyne Anderson Guehi Mitchell

Kouyate McArthur

Eze

Ayew Benteke Wilf

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 10 Apr 22 10.58pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Vieira favours 4-3-3, and I think he will start cautiously, so...

Butland
Clyne Guehi Andersen Mitchell
McArthur Kouyate Schlupp
Ayew Mateta Zaha

I think without Gallagher the midfield looks lacking. There should be game time for Eze and Olise.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (10 Apr 2022 5.56pm)

Dont think that will be a million miles away from the line up .

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 11 Apr 22 4.21am

Please, please no Schlupp. Too happy with back passing and he only has one turn in him when havig the ball. Eze any game for me..

 

sprites Flag Auckland 11 Apr 22 4.53am

Originally posted by thai-eagle

Please, please no Schlupp. Too happy with back passing and he only has one turn in him when havig the ball. Eze any game for me..

While I'd also favour McArthur and Eze for this one, I reckon Schluppy's proved a lot of doubters wrong over the last little while. No one played particularly well against Leicester, but apart from that Schlupp has done pretty well I reckon. Powerful ball runner and also slipped a couple of nice balls through, which I didn't know he had in his locker!

 

YT Flag Oxford 11 Apr 22 8.15am

This is what we'll need.

pexels-oleg-magni-1837590.jpg Attachment: pexels-oleg-magni-1837590.jpg (3,321.82Kb)

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

sebo21 Flag Selsdon 11 Apr 22 11.38am

This is a wind up surely

Originally posted by scarlet

Guaita

J. Tomkins M. Guehi J. Andersen

L. Milivojevic

W. Hughes C. Kouyaté J. Schlupp

E. Eze J. Mateta W. Zaha


I think this could be a good line-up. Id love to hear your ideas.

Edited by scarlet (10 Apr 2022 10.15am)

 

sebo21 Flag Selsdon 11 Apr 22 11.39am

he wont start jimmy mac. He will bring him on with 20 to go I would assume. he doesn't have the legs i don't think anymore.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 11 Apr 22 12.08pm

Originally posted by scarlet

Guaita

J. Tomkins M. Guehi J. Andersen

L. Milivojevic

W. Hughes C. Kouyaté J. Schlupp

E. Eze J. Mateta W. Zaha


I think this could be a good line-up. Id love to hear your ideas.

Edited by scarlet (10 Apr 2022 10.15am)

wow - changing the 4-3-3 we've played all season is a bold choice.

For me the defence picks itself if all fit, if Olise not fit Ayew plays on the RHS. Then the big choice is Eze replacing Conor or another centre mid.

Eze would be a bold choice and one i hope PV makes.

I suspect it may be a more solid midfield though with perhaps Macca coming in.

 

Talvlad Flag Streatham 11 Apr 22 12.41pm

All this ineligibility stuff has reminded me of the identical haircuts Romania sported in 1998.

I suggest we do the same thing, then Chelsea won't know who we've fielded... we might even be able to sneak Conor on as a sub!

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 11 Apr 22 1.04pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Awful line up

************Guaita***********
Clyne*Andersen*Guehi*Mitchell
****Kouyate******Schlupp*****
************Eze**************
**Olise**************Wilf****
**********Mateta*************

I agree with you that it was an auful line up. This one looks alot better , maybe Hughes or Jimmy Mac for Eze though .

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 11 Apr 22 2.20pm

this thread should be merged with the one on 'who is our best midfield trio'. Kouyate will play, most likely Schlupp - it's hard to put Eze in with Schlupp as they bother play left midfield. So he either puts Hughes or Jimmy Mac in there. He might drop Olise into midfield but I doubt it - I think he'll play a defensive, safe midfield and try and catch Chelsea on the break. But I could see Olise as a right sided midfielder linking up and swapping with Ayew on the right wing - PV will need to come up with something unpredictable, but Chelsea fans will tell you they find it hard to break down sides who park the proverbial bus, so we might see a bit of Royball again.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 12 Apr 22 8.53am

Personally I would just swap Eze straight in for Gallagher. He is our best passer of the ball and if we have any chance of winning we need some creativity. If Olise is not fit enough to start then we definitely need to start Eze. Sclupp was probably our best player against Leicester, but McArthur works harder and is better on the ball. A tough call that one. The biggest decision could be who replaces Mitchell if he's injured. His reaction to being taken off suggests it isn't serious, but you never know. Personally I'd put Schlupp there as he's quick, left footed and good going forward. Ward just looks awkward out left and is too slow to be going forward.

Chelsea are inconsistent at the moment and have a huge game against Madrid midweek (which will hopefully go to extra time and penalties!) We need to come out like we did at Arsenal and Leicester did to us and just don't give them a second's peace.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What's our best line-up for the semi-final?