This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
At the moment there has to be a question mark about the midfield options within our squad. Good post. I've stressed throughtout the season that the midfield is an area that will need attention, lest we be left with a core of Milo, McArthur, Kouyate, Schlupp, Hughes, and Eze. Excluding Eze, the remainder is bang average, if not mediocre on a bad day...
|
|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
Good post. I've stressed throughtout the season that the midfield is an area that will need attention, lest we be left with a core of Milo, McArthur, Kouyate, Schlupp, Hughes, and Eze. Excluding Eze, the remainder is bang average, if not mediocre on a bad day... Unfair. McArthur is an absolute warrior. Kouyate still very important player at this level and Hughes shows signs he will be too. Schluppy isn't a CM, but has never really let us down there. Can we upgrade them? Sure. And hopefully we can. But to call them bang average is simply not true.
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
Kouyate is a terrible passer of the ball and is awful under pressure, but against better teams he adds defensive steel and can slip seamlessly into the backline. A good squad player, but no longer a starter for me except in games where we won't have much of the ball. The question is can a club our size afford to pay high wages to an ageing squad player? Also, I read we are only offering short-term deals to players over 30. I have a feeling Kouyate might head off to Turkey, which was rumoured last summer. I like Luka, but he needs to go. Same for Jairo. Schlupp is a great impact player, but I still don't see him as a starter. I'd be happy to see him get another deal though. McArthur needs to stay because he is a real leader and still offers a lot on the pitch when fit. I'd say we're crying out for a box to box midfielder, which it sounds like Doucoure fills this criteria. We also need at least one more experienced midfielder or a top up-and-coming player. The question then is how good are the U23s? Are Boateng, Banks or Wells-Morrison ready to step up and push the seniors? Personally I think Vieira will want two quality holding midfielders to allow Eze to have more of a free role in front of them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by sprites
Unfair. McArthur is an absolute warrior. Kouyate still very important player at this level and Hughes shows signs he will be too. Schluppy isn't a CM, but has never really let us down there. Can we upgrade them? Sure. And hopefully we can. But to call them bang average is simply not true. Depends how you define bang average. A bang average Premier League player suggests you do alright in a team that finishes around mid-table. Is that not exactly what Hughes, Kouyate and a 34 year old McArthur are? Usually play but rarely outstanding (for McArthur, usually good but rarely fit) in a side that finished 12th? It's the level of Guimaraes, Moutinho, Neves, Ward-Prowse, Phillips, Eriksen, McGinn, Ndidi that give you a chance of breaking the top 10 - good Premier League players. Eze is the only central midfielder (loose definition) we currently own that would get any game time in the top 8 sides. Then you have the outstanding level (De Bruyne, Gundogan, Fabinho, Thiago, Jorginho) that manage to make the good ones look comparatively poor.
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration |
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
You're probably right, but with the new 5 subs rule the U23s might stand more of a chance of getting a few minutes here and there. Maybe in the senior environment one or two might step up and shine? Midfield definitely seems to be the area that will need investment though as well as another centre-back (especially if Kouyate does go). There was also a story a few days ago about Tomkins leaving the ground after finding out Ward would be replacing Guehi and not him. Given his age he might also want a move as he's not going to dislodge Andersen and Guehi.
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
Kouyate is a terrible passer of the ball and is awful under pressure, but against better teams he adds defensive steel and can slip seamlessly into the backline. A good squad player, but no longer a starter for me except in games where we won't have much of the ball. The question is can a club our size afford to pay high wages to an ageing squad player? Also, I read we are only offering short-term deals to players over 30. I have a feeling Kouyate might head off to Turkey, which was rumoured last summer. I'm presuming the Turkish press don't get their stories from here, but I suppose you never know...
|
|
|
Go for Eriksen and midfield supply problems instantly solved.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
Depends how you define bang average. A bang average Premier League player suggests you do alright in a team that finishes around mid-table. Is that not exactly what Hughes, Kouyate and a 34 year old McArthur are? Usually play but rarely outstanding (for McArthur, usually good but rarely fit) in a side that finished 12th? It's the level of Guimaraes, Moutinho, Neves, Ward-Prowse, Phillips, Eriksen, McGinn, Ndidi that give you a chance of breaking the top 10 - good Premier League players. Eze is the only central midfielder (loose definition) we currently own that would get any game time in the top 8 sides. Then you have the outstanding level (De Bruyne, Gundogan, Fabinho, Thiago, Jorginho) that manage to make the good ones look comparatively poor. 'Bang average' more commonly is defined as bad. Even when people say, average...what they mean isn't actually average...it's bad. PS. I'd have McArthur in my team over Ward-Prowse any day.
|
|
|
I'd look At Sande Berge at Sheffield United, a real work horse
|
|
|
Originally posted by Uphill
Go for Eriksen and midfield supply problems instantly solved. Really...doesn't he play in the same position as Eze?
|
|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
Depends how you define bang average. A bang average Premier League player suggests you do alright in a team that finishes around mid-table. Is that not exactly what Hughes, Kouyate and a 34 year old McArthur are? Usually play but rarely outstanding (for McArthur, usually good but rarely fit) in a side that finished 12th? It's the level of Guimaraes, Moutinho, Neves, Ward-Prowse, Phillips, Eriksen, McGinn, Ndidi that give you a chance of breaking the top 10 - good Premier League players. Eze is the only central midfielder (loose definition) we currently own that would get any game time in the top 8 sides. Then you have the outstanding level (De Bruyne, Gundogan, Fabinho, Thiago, Jorginho) that manage to make the good ones look comparatively poor. Thanks, you round up my original thoughts posted above where I suggest that our midfield is bang average. And just to add, I'm talking about the here and now, that is, in McArthur's case in particular, a player who for the past two seasons has spent as much time on the treatment table as on the pitch. Of course I recognise his role as an excellent servant for the club, but depending upon whether Vieira has a plan for McArthur for certain games, or wants to rotate the squad, then it's time to accept that McArthur won't be featuring prominently. Edited by southnorwoodhill (31 May 2022 1.52pm)
|
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
Kouyate is a terrible passer of the ball and is awful under pressure, but against better teams he adds defensive steel and can slip seamlessly into the backline. A good squad player, but no longer a starter for me except in games where we won't have much of the ball. The question is can a club our size afford to pay high wages to an ageing squad player? Also, I read we are only offering short-term deals to players over 30. I have a feeling Kouyate might head off to Turkey, which was rumoured last summer. I like Luka, but he needs to go. Same for Jairo. Schlupp is a great impact player, but I still don't see him as a starter. I'd be happy to see him get another deal though. McArthur needs to stay because he is a real leader and still offers a lot on the pitch when fit. I'd say we're crying out for a box to box midfielder, which it sounds like Doucoure fills this criteria. We also need at least one more experienced midfielder or a top up-and-coming player. The question then is how good are the U23s? Are Boateng, Banks or Wells-Morrison ready to step up and push the seniors? Personally I think Vieira will want two quality holding midfielders to allow Eze to have more of a free role in front of them. Decent summary, although not sure any of the U23s are ready. Maybe a loan for them next season and see how they get on. Luka and Jairo barely play and clearly aren't in PVs plan - however, both top payers and under contract so can't see anything happening there. Kouyate is better against the top 6, especially away games, as his work rate is fantastic. When we have more possession his passing is average. However, i suspect his head may be turned by Champions League football, unless Palace offer him a lucrative 2 year contract. Maybe a 1 year with an option of a 2nd is the way to go. We are like Macca but at 34 his powers are waning and he is definitely more injury prone these days - he retired from international footie due to a longstanding back injury. Hughes is ok, but not much different from what we already had in the middle so i was a little surprised we were so keen to get him. I'm hoping for big things from Eze next season, although he needs to become more involved in games, he flitters in and out too much for my liking. Schlupp has 1 year left so he is not going anywhere. If one of Kouyate and Macca re-sign we could get away with 1 extra defensive centre mid, if both leave and with Gallagher's loan ending we need a major re-jig.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.