You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > var
November 22 2026 7.32pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

var


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Spiderman Flag Horsham 04 Sep 22 3.06pm

So the media start shouting about some decisions this week and there will be a review. No mention of the decision to disallow our goal at City.
Was there any of this when we had 2 poor decisions in one match against Liverpool last season? Oh wait…..

If the are not to get involved in debatable decisions what do they get involved in? Presumably marginal offsides will not be in the remit,hardly worth having it then. Perhaps consistency by Officials would help


[Link]

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 04 Sep 22 4.18pm

Well they can stop var and we will be back to refs and Lino’s with fans moaning about wrong decisions or we can have var and moan about the officials interpretation. Not sure what is best but nothing; even video replays is full proof.

 

HeathMan Flag Purley 05 Sep 22 12.17am

Was happy to hear that one referee decided that he should not accept one way VAR - that is, he refused to be bullied into agreeing that as his decision was questioned it was wrong.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 05 Sep 22 10.56am

Personally I'm in favour of VAR, but I think it might help if people knew at the time what they were basing their decision on. I also think if the decision isn't instantly clear from watching the replay then they should go with the on-field decision. When they watch things back 20 times it gets ridiculous as it's clearly not an obvious error.

At our game VAR was quick to rule the goal out as Willock clearly smashes into Guaita with what appears to be minimal contact from Mitchell. The referee gave numerous free-kicks to Fraser and Almiron when there was little or no contact and failed to book Almiron when he dived at the end of the first half. He gave little to nothing to Wilf, including when Trippier chopped him down with a knee-high tackle. I think the ref was intimidated by the atmosphere and VAR helped him reach the correct decision.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 05 Sep 22 11.20am

Originally posted by Spiderman

So the media start shouting about some decisions this week and there will be a review. No mention of the decision to disallow our goal at City.
Was there any of this when we had 2 poor decisions in one match against Liverpool last season? Oh wait…..

If the are not to get involved in debatable decisions what do they get involved in? Presumably marginal offsides will not be in the remit,hardly worth having it then. Perhaps consistency by Officials would help


[Link]

One thinks the Saudis have slipped in a few quid now - to avoid future 'misinterpretations'.
One can just imagine Staveley chocking on her saveloy as the Newcastle goal was disallowed.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Sep 22 11.30am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Personally I'm in favour of VAR, but I think it might help if people knew at the time what they were basing their decision on. I also think if the decision isn't instantly clear from watching the replay then they should go with the on-field decision. When they watch things back 20 times it gets ridiculous as it's clearly not an obvious error.

At our game VAR was quick to rule the goal out as Willock clearly smashes into Guaita with what appears to be minimal contact from Mitchell. The referee gave numerous free-kicks to Fraser and Almiron when there was little or no contact and failed to book Almiron when he dived at the end of the first half. He gave little to nothing to Wilf, including when Trippier chopped him down with a knee-high tackle. I think the ref was intimidated by the atmosphere and VAR helped him reach the correct decision.

I am not privy to any information which indicates that the referee was "Intimidated", however I will assert that he is inexperienced at PL level, only officiating in 6 games the first of which was last season when he refereed our home game against A.Villa , a match we lost 1-2.

Edited by Willo (05 Sep 2022 11.32am)

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 05 Sep 22 11.41am

VAR was put in place to help reduce the mistakes by referees... the issue is we've got the same referees c*cking it up over at VAR HQ.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 05 Sep 22 11.45am


what I can't understand, is that how anyone (outside of newcastle) thinks that's not a foul on Guaita.

I don't think there is enough evidence to suggest Mitchell pushed him. More likely is that Willock overran the run up to such a degree that he took Guaita out. Mitchells involvement could easily have been minimal.

If you rest a hand on another - even with the lightest of touches, once that person moves away from you, your hand will naturally follow him. Too often this is seen as a 'push' - and for once, on Saturday, I thought actually the correct decision Was made, there was no force in mitchells contact with Willock.

Now, I'm normally one of the wierdos that doesn't mind Shearer on MOTD, but his view on this(and all things newcastle) is SO unbelievably biased. GL et al knew he was upset about it - (like any self respecting Geordie was) and let him spout this prejudiced rubbish unfiltered- with no attempt or inclination to counter, or try to suggest what the ref was thinking.

to me, VAR worked on this occasion.


 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 05 Sep 22 11.52am

For once Gary Lineker gets it right when he says "VAR decisions are sucking the life and joy out of the game".

It could be said that you win some, you lose sum. But, as it's been written before on other threads, the spontaneity has been eliminated.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Behind Enemy Lines Flag Sussex 05 Sep 22 11.59am

I think the review system that cricket uses may be a better option going forward, whereby each team has 3(?) reviews instigated through the captain when they want something reviewed. Thereby it's up to the teams whether something is reviewed, not some muppet locked in a cupboard somewhere.

 


hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing.

dentina Flag forest hill london 05 Sep 22 12.09pm

Quite agree, with most of comments covering this, but add that, it might work better if we could find team of ex footballers who have actually PLAED the game, obs not Lineker or terrible Shearer

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 05 Sep 22 12.10pm

We wouldn't need VAR if the laws on handball and offside were simple and clear to all.

Handball - deliberate arm to ball.

Offside - foot in front of the last man, at the time the ball is kicked.

I watch our other youth teams, the championship, I never miss VAR.

Refs do make mistakes, so have clear simple rules to make their task easier.

We wanted VAR to work but it didn't, and everything we have done to make it work has made it even worse.


 

HeathMan Flag Purley 05 Sep 22 12.19pm

Total terror - Mr Lineker reviewing VAR decisions on MOTD with power to change results.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 05 Sep 22 12.31pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

We wouldn't need VAR if the laws on handball and offside were simple and clear to all.

Handball - deliberate arm to ball.

Offside - foot in front of the last man, at the time the ball is kicked.

I watch our other youth teams, the championship, I never miss VAR.

Refs do make mistakes, so have clear simple rules to make their task easier.

We wanted VAR to work but it didn't, and everything we have done to make it work has made it even worse.



Agree completely we should have kept the game simple,just as you say. But once TV got its hands on the game it was never going to be simple again. I have said this elsewhere but VAR has only happened because TV was already doing off field introspection of decisions. Now it does off field inspection of VAR decisions.
The bottom line is some rules now are so vague they can only be thought contentious when ruled on ,no matter the system. Someone back in the thread says it needs ex players. I wouldn’t agree simply because the players want it all ways as long as it goes their way. Most changes we see have happened because of player,manager whinging .
Take Wilf, he can’t move unless someone grabs , pushes, kicks ,trips him, and all he gets is he goes down to easy , he buys it ,and so on. This is what the players want until it smacks them in the face.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 05 Sep 22 12.53pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

We wouldn't need VAR if the laws on handball and offside were simple and clear to all.

Handball - deliberate arm to ball.

Offside - foot in front of the last man, at the time the ball is kicked.

I watch our other youth teams, the championship, I never miss VAR.

Refs do make mistakes, so have clear simple rules to make their task easier.

We wanted VAR to work but it didn't, and everything we have done to make it work has made it even worse.



Deliberate Handball is not a Simple rule.

Handball is a Simple Rule, but one you start adding players thought processes in (i.e. it was deliberate), it becomes one for interpretation by the ref.

Offside is a simple Rule, but VAR in it's current state isn't good enough to accurately determine it in those times that it's 'marginal'
It needs changing; and here's how:
1) Ignore arms. Torso, legs and head are the only thing that can be offside.
2) a 'buffer' added to the attackers 'line'. say 30cm. If the VAR lines then overlap, you stick with the onfield decision.

Really, the only was to Stop this speculation by the pundits is to have the Refs explain their decisions. or be mic'd up. or both.

Edited by CrazyBadger (05 Sep 2022 12.54pm)

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 05 Sep 22 12.58pm

The implementation is shocking. We were certainly fortunate on Saturday, but I've seen far worse VAR decisions which didn't hit the headlines.

Said it before and I will again... Scrap it for normal play and give each captain 1 review per game to be used on penalty/goal/red card incidents. Captain will keep the review if they correctly overturn the decision. 20 second limit to review from two angles - shouldn't need more time than that to spot a 'clear and obvious' error.

VAR was introduced to prevent phantom goal situations and clear errors which might realistically happen 5 times a season. Not interfering with every goal incident. Can't celebrate goals anymore. Hate it.

Retrospective bands for diving should also be reintroduced. Good idea, but never implemented properly.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 05 Sep 22 1.24pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

One thinks the Saudis have slipped in a few quid now - to avoid future 'misinterpretations'.
One can just imagine Staveley chocking on her saveloy as the Newcastle goal was disallowed.

I think you may be correct on all points . Some very strange comments about taking things forward with the authorities!

[Link]

Edited by Spiderman (05 Sep 2022 1.26pm)

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 05 Sep 22 1.31pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

The implementation is shocking. We were certainly fortunate on Saturday, but I've seen far worse VAR decisions which didn't hit the headlines.

Said it before and I will again... Scrap it for normal play and give each captain 1 review per game to be used on penalty/goal/red card incidents. Captain will keep the review if they correctly overturn the decision. 20 second limit to review from two angles - shouldn't need more time than that to spot a 'clear and obvious' error.

VAR was introduced to prevent phantom goal situations and clear errors which might realistically happen 5 times a season. Not interfering with every goal incident. Can't celebrate goals anymore. Hate it.

Retrospective bands for diving should also be reintroduced. Good idea, but never implemented properly.

Absolutely agree with everything there.

Tennis the most obvious comparison for me but not 3 'challenges' I'd say 1 'challenge' per half or even game.

If you get it right, keep it. If wrong, you lose it. Teams would then be far more selective about which decisions they'd want reviewed and ultimately be responsible for their own fate. Would draw attention away from referees for criticism too or expose them for how useless they are.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Spiderman Flag Horsham 05 Sep 22 1.40pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Absolutely agree with everything there.

Tennis the most obvious comparison for me but not 3 'challenges' I'd say 1 'challenge' per half or even game.

If you get it right, keep it. If wrong, you lose it. Teams would then be far more selective about which decisions they'd want reviewed and ultimately be responsible for their own fate. Would draw attention away from referees for criticism too or expose them for how useless they are.

The problem with this is that, the same idiots are making the decisions

 

eaglesdare Flag 05 Sep 22 1.50pm

Amazing that the only league in the world that VAR does not work in is the Premier league!

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > var