You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > How do you know when a Manager has ‘lost’ the team
November 16 2026 3.17am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

How do you know when a Manager has ‘lost’ the team


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
VinceHilaire Flag London 07 Jan 23 3.00pm

I’m no expert, so wondered what the signs are that the manager has lost the trust of the team.

PV has been a breath of fresh air - but watching the reactions at full time this day sent alarm bells ringing…not just the result, but reaction of the players when PV approached them.

Ready to be educated…..

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 07 Jan 23 3.06pm

When they're not playing with any oomph or passion! Just like today!

 

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 07 Jan 23 3.35pm

Originally posted by eritheagle

When they're not playing with any oomph or passion! Just like today!

Well they need to do what the f***ing manager tells them to do. His managerial CV - not to mention his playing career - is infinitely better than anything any one of those lot has ever achieved.

It's not their choice whether they turn up to work or not.

Zaha was the only one who looked like he gave a s***. And he is unlikely to be here in 6 months.

Today it was like we had a good start, and then just assumed that because it was Southampton that the result was a formality. Then once we conceded, there was zero ability or desire to shift the tide of momentum. And worst of all.... it wasn't as if Southampton ground out a result. They were s***. They are s***. They will be s*** for the remainder of the season. Both their goals were f*** ups from players just playing without the required intensity.

So does that mean they don't respect the manager? I don't know. I don't want to give up on him yet. Where would that leave us?

Eze could be good, Olise could be good, Edouard could be good, but none of them strike me as a leader of men when the going is tough. Where is MacArthur for 2023, or Jedinak, or anyone for that matter who will intimidate the opposition as well as our own players?


Oh, what it would be to have a Bryan Robson, or a Roy Keane in midfield. Or a Vieira.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 07 Jan 23 3.41pm

Watch the last three games, forget the term manager, and replace it with boss, thats what he should be, not pals with the players, tough, ruthless, tactically astute and an impressive record, PV and Roberts have none of that, they look and act more like a comedy Duo

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 07 Jan 23 3.43pm

Originally posted by Qwijibo

Well they need to do what the f***ing manager tells them to do. His managerial CV - not to mention his playing career - is infinitely better than anything any one of those lot has ever achieved.

It's not their choice whether they turn up to work or not.

Zaha was the only one who looked like he gave a s***. And he is unlikely to be here in 6 months.

Today it was like we had a good start, and then just assumed that because it was Southampton that the result was a formality. Then once we conceded, there was zero ability or desire to shift the tide of momentum. And worst of all.... it wasn't as if Southampton ground out a result. They were s***. They are s***. They will be s*** for the remainder of the season. Both their goals were f*** ups from players just playing without the required intensity.

So does that mean they don't respect the manager? I don't know. I don't want to give up on him yet. Where would that leave us?

Eze could be good, Olise could be good, Edouard could be good, but none of them strike me as a leader of men when the going is tough. Where is MacArthur for 2023, or Jedinak, or anyone for that matter who will intimidate the opposition as well as our own players?


Oh, what it would be to have a Bryan Robson, or a Roy Keane in midfield. Or a Vieira.

All S***e managers

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 07 Jan 23 3.50pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

All S***e managers

I'm asking for some leadership in midfield. Not Roy Keane as manager.

Would Shaun Derry have put up with that s***? Or Jedinak? In days gone past, players with a fraction of the ability of those currently in the side would have done something to increase the collective heart beat, even if it was just Clint Hill booting an opponent. I just feel like there's a lot of shoulder-shrugging and very little examples of anyone taking ownership of the performance.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 07 Jan 23 3.51pm

Originally posted by Qwijibo

Well they need to do what the f***ing manager tells them to do. His managerial CV - not to mention his playing career - is infinitely better than anything any one of those lot has ever achieved.

It's not their choice whether they turn up to work or not.

Zaha was the only one who looked like he gave a s***. And he is unlikely to be here in 6 months.

Today it was like we had a good start, and then just assumed that because it was Southampton that the result was a formality. Then once we conceded, there was zero ability or desire to shift the tide of momentum. And worst of all.... it wasn't as if Southampton ground out a result. They were s***. They are s***. They will be s*** for the remainder of the season. Both their goals were f*** ups from players just playing without the required intensity.

So does that mean they don't respect the manager? I don't know. I don't want to give up on him yet. Where would that leave us?

Eze could be good, Olise could be good, Edouard could be good, but none of them strike me as a leader of men when the going is tough. Where is MacArthur for 2023, or Jedinak, or anyone for that matter who will intimidate the opposition as well as our own players?


Oh, what it would be to have a Bryan Robson, or a Roy Keane in midfield. Or a Vieira.


They do not have to do as the manager tells them at all.

PV CV is nothing special as a manager player is meaningless he is a manager now.

Again you are making out the players are robots they have a choice.

Zaha has done f all for ages and how you come to conclusion he cares is laughable he cares about himself not the team this is clear to see when he doesn't even celebrate when others score etc.

Good I will be happy when he goes he should be star player setting example driving the team not being a child who looks very lazy.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

johnny the eagle Flag wivenhoe 07 Jan 23 3.52pm

The bells, the bells, the alarm bells...................... they are making me deaf.

 


South London born and bred
red and blue till im dead.

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 07 Jan 23 4.04pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


They do not have to do as the manager tells them at all.

PV CV is nothing special as a manager player is meaningless he is a manager now.

Again you are making out the players are robots they have a choice.

Zaha has done f all for ages and how you come to conclusion he cares is laughable he cares about himself not the team this is clear to see when he doesn't even celebrate when others score etc.

Good I will be happy when he goes he should be star player setting example driving the team not being a child who looks very lazy.

They do have to do what the manager tells them. It's their job. They might not agree, they might not believe in it, but they need to do as they're told. Vieira may not have the strongest managerial CV, but he is the boss, and he's no doubt managed a couple of hundred games. A few 26 year old footballers who have basically achieved nothing, are not qualified to decide they know better. Clearly, if they don't buy into what the manager says, then it's a problem, as their heart and soul needs to be involved. But they put in 100% regardless and let the hierarchy determine if the manager is good enough.

Yes, Zaha only plays for himself. I agree there.

 

waddy Flag Highton,Melbourne 07 Jan 23 4.06pm

I’m thinking he is lost with them to be honest !

He can instill a process - try to up the character but oh j no it the lack of passion & doggedness is shocking -
1) from throw ins no f***er moves of his play
2) hardly anyone challenge in midfield for a highball in a challenge ( jumping 30cm off the ground is not a challenge)
3) passing back versus taking on a player - why is it only Wilf who has the confidence in actually getting past a player - yet out miss always pass back
4) When keeper has the ball face the damn ball - Ayew always looks away or at ground


Why is it our coaching team cannot see it but the crowd can ?

We need x3 key players we ALl know it - Wilf if he doesn’t sign up I wouldn’t blame him

 


Forever Palace Proud

PatrickA Flag London 07 Jan 23 4.33pm

I’ve just read Vieira’s post match comments.
You could cut and paste them from other games - ‘need to improve decision making ‘…’not taking chances’ …‘frustrating’….’improvement will take time as a young team.’
The trouble is we seem to be going backwards at the moment, both in terms of our passing and as a team.
It seems clear that Vieira is unlikely to change his tactical approach or player preference in terms of selection.
So what will be the catalyst for improvement if Vieira does not change his approach?
It seems to me that it will have to be through the addition of first team ready players this window who can make an immediate impact, or through a step up in form from existing players like Olise, Eze and Edouard who have frankly disappointed this season.
We have a decent points total so far this season, but by no means a sum to be complacent when you consider our imminent run of games.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 07 Jan 23 4.37pm

Originally posted by Qwijibo

They do have to do what the manager tells them. It's their job. They might not agree, they might not believe in it, but they need to do as they're told. Vieira may not have the strongest managerial CV, but he is the boss, and he's no doubt managed a couple of hundred games. A few 26 year old footballers who have basically achieved nothing, are not qualified to decide they know better. Clearly, if they don't buy into what the manager says, then it's a problem, as their heart and soul needs to be involved. But they put in 100% regardless and let the hierarchy determine if the manager is good enough.

Yes, Zaha only plays for himself. I agree there.


What world are you living in no one has to do anything someone else tells them to do no matter the position they are in.

Players have way more power than other staff.

Lets use some other clubs for example who have had players not even turning up for training what does the club do nothing they have no power and some may sell the player which at times is what the player wants.

Dele Ali clear example awful attitude yet clubs are still paying him for not doing anything.

Achieved nothing? not sure what you mean they have reached the highest tier of the game in this country and are paid millions that is not nothing.

Good to see we agree on one thing which is about Wilf.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 07 Jan 23 4.39pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

I’ve just read Vieira’s post match comments.
You could cut and paste them from other games - ‘need to improve decision making ‘…’not taking chances’ …‘frustrating’….’improvement will take time as a young team.’
The trouble is we seem to be going backwards at the moment, both in terms of our passing and as a team.
It seems clear that Vieira is unlikely to change his tactical approach or player preference in terms of selection.
So what will be the catalyst for improvement if Vieira does not change his approach?
It seems to me that it will have to be through the addition of first team ready players this window who can make an immediate impact, or through a step up in form from existing players like Olise, Eze and Edouard who have frankly disappointed this season.
We have a decent points total so far this season, but by no means a sum to be complacent when you consider our imminent run of games.

Agree with all of that.

Must say though I hate it, absolutely hate it, now and always have, when a manager shows a distinct lack of acknowledgement or alignment with fans on the situation and repeats the same mantras over and over again without even hinting at an objective analysis and therefore plan to counteract pathetic performances and situation. Would suggest a lack of understanding and confidence in reversing the situation. Said it a few times now but outside of my personal feelings on him which are of no consequence, I think PV will be gone soon.

Very worrying.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 07 Jan 23 4.40pm

Until the board give PV some transfer funds I can't blame him.

We need another hard tackling midfielder who will boss the opposition plus 2 fullbacks. I doubt we will get any of them during this window so I don't blame Pat.

 


One more point

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 07 Jan 23 4.58pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Until the board give PV some transfer funds I can't blame him.

We need another hard tackling midfielder who will boss the opposition plus 2 fullbacks. I doubt we will get any of them during this window so I don't blame Pat.

Complete rubbish, open your eyes, the players are nowhere as bad as the performances, get those PV tinted glasses off

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 07 Jan 23 5.03pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


What world are you living in no one has to do anything someone else tells them to do no matter the position they are in.

Players have way more power than other staff.

Lets use some other clubs for example who have had players not even turning up for training what does the club do nothing they have no power and some may sell the player which at times is what the player wants.

Dele Ali clear example awful attitude yet clubs are still paying him for not doing anything.

Achieved nothing? not sure what you mean they have reached the highest tier of the game in this country and are paid millions that is not nothing.

Good to see we agree on one thing which is about Wilf.

I don't need examples. I'm aware of what goes on. It doesn't mean it's right.

It's the board's decision whether the manager should go, not the players. If you want examples, see Manchester United's form since Ronaldo left.

Yes they're high achievers. Yes they're paid millions. They're paid millions to play football for Crystal Palace to the best of their ability. Under a management structure. They're not paid to direct club strategy, or recruit their own bosses. They're not entitled to decide whether the manager is worthy of their effort.

Why are you so confrontational? Asking 'what planet I'm on?' In another thread you stated that someone was talking 'absolute rubbish' after they articulated some perfectly reasonable points. You don't have to agree with what people say, but it's not as if you yourself are anyone of any consequence. You're a complete irrelevance. Show some respect.

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 07 Jan 23 5.23pm

When has a manager"lost" the team/dressing room ?

When you lose

1-0 away at Forest
3-0 home to Fulham
4-0 home to Spurs
1-2 home to Southampton

 

joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 07 Jan 23 7.27pm

I don't think he's lost the team. If you watch all the training videos etc he seems to be really liked by all of them and they are always having a laugh together.
I think the problem is if you mix a clueless manager and assistant with a dumb, lazy prima donna attack and useless full backs it's not going to work out too well.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Jan 23 7.36pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

I’ve just read Vieira’s post match comments.
You could cut and paste them from other games - ‘need to improve decision making ‘…’not taking chances’ …‘frustrating’….’improvement will take time as a young team.’
The trouble is we seem to be going backwards at the moment, both in terms of our passing and as a team.

It seems clear that Vieira is unlikely to change his tactical approach or player preference in terms of selection.
So what will be the catalyst for improvement if Vieira does not change his approach?
It seems to me that it will have to be through the addition of first team ready players this window who can make an immediate impact, or through a step up in form from existing players like Olise, Eze and Edouard who have frankly disappointed this season.
We have a decent points total so far this season, but by no means a sum to be complacent when you consider our imminent run of games.

I am in agreement apropos PVs post-match comments.

I also concur with your sentiments regarding our direction of travel.It is very concerning.

 

dorking Flag 07 Jan 23 10.09pm

Under Hodgson, I'm convinced he wanted to get out of the cups as quickly as possible - after all his job depended on keeping Palace up, and I think he saw the cups as potentially getting in the way of that. Hence weak teams in the cups, never playing Zaha in those games etc

But Patrick has won the FA Cup 5 times, he's a winner and I'm sure he'd love to lift it as manager

But he can't get a tune out of his team for more than 1 half per game at the moment. And we're not missing anyone really key to the team, like a Wilf or a Doucoure.

As has already been said on here, the fans will tell SP when it's time.

Just hope we don't then go chasing Southgate.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > How do you know when a Manager has ‘lost’ the team