You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Eighteen trillion underestmate of UK reperations .
November 21 2026 9.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Eighteen trillion underestmate of UK reperations .


Page 4 of 4 << First< 1 2 3 4
Stirlingsays Flag 30 Aug 23 3.18pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Yup but it was a while ago. Oh for the record have you seen what’s happening in Africa. Niger and now Gabon being taken over by the military. Despotic regimes. That’s the way to go. What an amazing example of self rule. South Africa and Zimbabwe need a mention as well. Africa if f***ed.

I think the best that the west should do about Africa is get out of it completely....aside from humanitarianism purely on a voluntary basis.

Leave it to the Chinese and Russians.....it's nothing but a giant money hole.

Invest in Asia.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 30 Aug 23 3.35pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I think the best that the west should do about Africa is get out of it completely....aside from humanitarianism purely on a voluntary basis.

Leave it to the Chinese and Russians.....it's nothing but a giant money hole.

Invest in Asia.

Africa is like a giant Notting Hill Carnival.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 30 Aug 23 7.36pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

Africa is like a giant Notting Hill Carnival.

With just slightly more stabbings.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

cryrst Flag The garden of England 30 Aug 23 7.51pm

Originally posted by Glazier#1

The current Lod Harewood, David, the 8th Earl Of Harewood:

Harewood House was commissioned by his ancestor Edwin Lascelles in the mid-18th century.

The expensive project was funded by money Edwin's father Henry made in the West Indian sugar trade.

He owned 26 plantations and 3,000 slaves, who were forcibly shipped to the Caribbean to produce sugar, rum, cotton and tobacco for the European market.

Archived documents show the family had plantations in Barbados, Jamaica, Tobago and Grenada.

And they ranked among the top one percent of aristocratic slave-owning families of the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, according to researchers at the University of York.
("experts" are academics who are funded by the taxpayer and have to justify their existence", so we're told)

Lascelles himself said he doesn't feel shame in a personal way but feels "accountable" in some way.

Confronting his past in a new Channel 5 series, he said: "I don’t feel that feeling guilty for something you have no involvement with is a helpful emotion.

"I think you need to take responsibility for your own actions. For this I don’t feel responsible — but I feel accountable, I guess.

"You know, there’s nothing you can do to change the past, but you can be active in the present.

"What I am responsible for is what I try to do about that legacy. To try in a small way to make that a force for good today."

Edited by Glazier#1 (30 Aug 2023 3.23pm)

Edited by Glazier#1 (30 Aug 2023 3.24pm)

Who sold him the slaves in Africa ?

 

Stirlingsays Flag 30 Aug 23 8.16pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Who sold him the slaves in Africa ?


And even more spicy lets not look into who were mostly handling the slaves once the tribes sold them.....Funny when you look into the merchant class just how often you'd find that it wasn't a Mr Smith or Mr Brown.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 30 Aug 23 11.40pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

Africa is like a giant Notting Hill Carnival.

....nope, because Notting Hill had electricity 24 hours a day.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 31 Aug 23 7.59am

Ex Tory MP asks to be forgotten. Don't worry dear like the rest of the former MPs you soon will be.

[Link]

She has a point though why is she being singled out funny how the university is now all in favour of defending free speech.

 


One more point

cryrst Flag The garden of England 31 Aug 23 9.28am

Originally posted by Badger11

Ex Tory MP asks to be forgotten. Don't worry dear like the rest of the former MPs you soon will be.

[Link]

She has a point though why is she being singled out funny how the university is now all in favour of defending free speech.

It is ironic to say the least. A bit of personal nimbyism

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 31 Aug 23 10.29am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays


And even more spicy lets not look into who were mostly handling the slaves once the tribes sold them.....Funny when you look into the merchant class just how often you'd find that it wasn't a Mr Smith or Mr Brown.

It is a bit more nuanced than that.

Firstly, slavery in Africa was a phenomenon way before we got there; but we made it considerably worse by adding a huge market for them. Mea culpa on that one.

Secondly, there were always tribal wars in Africa. Like slavery, one in the grain of their culture. However, the motive for war altered from being the usual land grab to also people grab in order to feed that insatiable market.

Thirdly, (I know you are talking about something else) the reason there were no Mr Smith of Mr Brown on the ground is because life expectancy was less than a year, largely from malaria. Europeans learned to have others do our dirty work for us.

That said, we didn't force them to go to war, sell their own people for cash etc. African leaders exhibiting pure greed and corruption - never! And while we have white guilt about this, you can bet the Arab world cares not a jot about their much longer history in this crime.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 31 Aug 23 10.37am

Originally posted by silvertop

It is a bit more nuanced than that.

Firstly, slavery in Africa was a phenomenon way before we got there; but we made it considerably worse by adding a huge market for them. Mea culpa on that one.

Secondly, there were always tribal wars in Africa. Like slavery, one in the grain of their culture. However, the motive for war altered from being the usual land grab to also people grab in order to feed that insatiable market.

Thirdly, (I know you are talking about something else) the reason there were no Mr Smith of Mr Brown on the ground is because life expectancy was less than a year, largely from malaria. Europeans learned to have others do our dirty work for us.

That said, we didn't force them to go to war, sell their own people for cash etc. African leaders exhibiting pure greed and corruption - never! And while we have white guilt about this, you can bet the Arab world cares not a jot about their much longer history in this crime.

Only idiots and fools do.

Here's another example of the lunacy that surrounds anything to do with historic slavery.

[Link]

Edited by georgenorman (31 Aug 2023 12.47pm)

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 31 Aug 23 1.47pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

Only idiots and fools do.

Here's another example of the lunacy that surrounds anything to do with historic slavery.

[Link]

Edited by georgenorman (31 Aug 2023 12.47pm)

I know I have been lazy not looking up a thread, but that article was posted only 2 posts up!

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 31 Aug 23 1.58pm


It's impossible to atone for past events; it would be better to concentrate on contemporary issues.


[Link]

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 31 Aug 23 2.37pm

Originally posted by silvertop

It is a bit more nuanced than that.

Firstly, slavery in Africa was a phenomenon way before we got there; but we made it considerably worse by adding a huge market for them. Mea culpa on that one.

Secondly, there were always tribal wars in Africa. Like slavery, one in the grain of their culture. However, the motive for war altered from being the usual land grab to also people grab in order to feed that insatiable market.

Thirdly, (I know you are talking about something else) the reason there were no Mr Smith of Mr Brown on the ground is because life expectancy was less than a year, largely from malaria. Europeans learned to have others do our dirty work for us.

That said, we didn't force them to go to war, sell their own people for cash etc. African leaders exhibiting pure greed and corruption - never! And while we have white guilt about this, you can bet the Arab world cares not a jot about their much longer history in this crime.

It is indeed nuanced. That's what's wrong with some of the calls for reparations as far as I can see - that they don't recognise and address the nuance.

If the subject interests you (as it does me on occasion) I would highly recommend a podcast called 'Human Resources' - part of the Hardcore History series from Dan Carlin.

Despite being white, male, American and fairly mainstream (and at times treading very carefully indeed, therefore) he covers issues like the worldwide history of slavery before the Atlantic slave trade, the nature and definition of slavery compared to being (for instance) a wage slave or a peasant, the impact (or otherwise) of moral and religious issues over the period of the Atlantic slave trade, but most significantly of all, how much sense can be made of the whole ghastly business by seeing it in economic terms.

He (carefully) outlines how, if seen in economic terms, the 'trade' was affected by the same factors as any other. From the impact of new regulations (the Pope banning the trade of Christians as slaves) to sudden profit incentives in the cotton industry to the general increase in international trade, transit and logistical capacity, to the misfortune of the sub-Saharan African people to be the better 'product' due to their resilience against diseases that wiped out most of the original people of Cuba and other lands who might otherwise have toiled in their place, the size of the trade makes much more sense when you picture it in those terms. It was something people had always done, influenced by the usual rules of the market, hence the incompatible scale compared to any previous slavery trade or custom. None of that is a justification, but it is very important to understand it.

He also talks about the moral debate around the world at the time, the forces brought to bear that eventually ceased the trade, and all sorts of other things.

Highly recommended.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (31 Aug 2023 2.40pm)

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 31 Aug 23 2.55pm

the Triangle of Slave Trade was...

finished textiles to African tribes
for
Slaves to the USA cotton plantations
for
raw Cotton to Northern Mill Towns ( eg Manchester, Burnley, Accrington ) in England, for finishing

Repeat......


---------------------------------------------------

and so, do we nuke all Northern Towns that had textile factories ?

that's a lot of nukes.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Glazier#1 Flag 31 Aug 23 3.51pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

the Triangle of Slave Trade was...

finished textiles to African tribes
for
Slaves to the USA cotton plantations
for
raw Cotton to Northern Mill Towns ( eg Manchester, Burnley, Accrington ) in England, for finishing

Repeat......


---------------------------------------------------

and so, do we nuke all Northern Towns that had textile factories ?

that's a lot of nukes.

Nuke?!?

 

Stirlingsays Flag 31 Aug 23 4.10pm

Originally posted by silvertop

It is a bit more nuanced than that.

Firstly, slavery in Africa was a phenomenon way before we got there; but we made it considerably worse by adding a huge market for them. Mea culpa on that one.

Sure, but only insomuch as we were guilty as everybody else of these crimes.

Originally posted by silvertop

Secondly, there were always tribal wars in Africa. Like slavery, one in the grain of their culture. However, the motive for war altered from being the usual land grab to also people grab in order to feed that insatiable market.

I would argue that natural culture is a sub product and thus expression of genetics. Indeed, culturally, not that much has changed in large expanses of Africa.

Originally posted by silvertop

Thirdly, (I know you are talking about something else) the reason there were no Mr Smith of Mr Brown on the ground is because life expectancy was less than a year, largely from malaria. Europeans learned to have others do our dirty work for us.

Europeans did all the initial fighting, so I'd argue that the real dirty work was indeed done by us on the actual ground. However, when it comes to the merchants....Mmmmm....In a lot of cases let's just say that I think you are being extremely charitable.

Originally posted by silvertop

That said, we didn't force them to go to war, sell their own people for cash etc. African leaders exhibiting pure greed and corruption - never! And while we have white guilt about this, you can bet the Arab world cares not a jot about their much longer history in this crime.

The Arabs aren't busily engaged in piling up their own funeral pyre, as someone prophetic once said.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 01 Sep 23 1.31pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

the Triangle of Slave Trade was...

finished textiles to African tribes
for
Slaves to the USA cotton plantations
for
raw Cotton to Northern Mill Towns ( eg Manchester, Burnley, Accrington ) in England, for finishing

Repeat......


---------------------------------------------------

and so, do we nuke all Northern Towns that had textile factories ?

that's a lot of nukes.

Nobody would notice in many places. Bradford may be improved.

 


Red and Blue Army!

silvertop Flag Portishead 01 Sep 23 2.32pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Nobody would notice in many places. Bradford may be improved.

Bill Bryson described Bradford as a cement museum.

 

Page 4 of 4 << First< 1 2 3 4

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Eighteen trillion underestmate of UK reperations .