You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why are Brighton so much better than us right now?
November 16 2026 2.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Why are Brighton so much better than us right now?


Page 4 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 23 Sep 23 10.30am

I don't want a civil conversation about the pros and cons of Brighton and Hove Albion. As far as I'm concerned, they can do one.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Sep 23 10.43am

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I don't want a civil conversation about the pros and cons of Brighton and Hove Albion. As far as I'm concerned, they can do one.

I expressed similar sentiments to some Brighton blithering idiot who was being disparaging about our club at a local football match.
His voice was reduced to 'Mute' after I expressed my viewpoint.

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 23 Sep 23 11.06am

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I don't want a civil conversation about the pros and cons of Brighton and Hove Albion. As far as I'm concerned, they can do one.

My sentiments exactly.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 23 Sep 23 11.24am

Before people get too envious of those current media darlings, there are other things to consider.

Their current success didn't happen overnight. Bloom financed a series of duff player purchases, mainly from the Dutch League, before hitting on the data driven formula that's working for them now. Bloom has absorbed all the losses then and continues to prop them up financially now.

The Amex ? A ballache to get to and from. The promised transport improvements failed to materialise. That's why even on their European debut, they had supporters sitting in coaches going back to Brighton because they were scheduled to depart earlier than the game finished ! That's why you have the mass exodus on 80 minutes as well.

Their support ? Probably the same hard core number as Palace. The rest are all fans of other clubs that see no problem in supporting two teams. Plastics.

Yes I envy their European adventure, the ability to work the transfer market as they do, and their play - at the moment.

Let's see if they can stay in the Premier League for 11 consecutive seasons.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 23 Sep 23 11.52am

Originally posted by Willo

Brighton have finished above us in the PL in the last 2 seasons, but finished below us in the previous 4 PL seasons.

They were of course not in the PL when we were ploughing our furrow at this level seasons 2016-17, 15-16, 14-15 and 13-14.

Exactly Willo.

Brighton have been below us for all of the last decade apart from the last two seasons.

Restoring our dominance sound like good motivation to me.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 23 Sep 23 12.36pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Before people get too envious of those current media darlings, there are other things to consider.

Their current success didn't happen overnight. Bloom financed a series of duff player purchases, mainly from the Dutch League, before hitting on the data driven formula that's working for them now. Bloom has absorbed all the losses then and continues to prop them up financially now.

The Amex ? A ballache to get to and from. The promised transport improvements failed to materialise. That's why even on their European debut, they had supporters sitting in coaches going back to Brighton because they were scheduled to depart earlier than the game finished ! That's why you have the mass exodus on 80 minutes as well.

Their support ? Probably the same hard core number as Palace. The rest are all fans of other clubs that see no problem in supporting two teams. Plastics.

Yes I envy their European adventure, the ability to work the transfer market as they do, and their play - at the moment.

Let's see if they can stay in the Premier League for 11 consecutive seasons.

Star lizard obviously provides both intelligence and finance to move them up. However we have got shareholders with far deeper pockets who may be doing more than we realise. We are also led by a Palace fan who has easily the same lev l of football knowledge as Bloom. Who knows, maybe we are also a client of the Star Lizard data room.

 

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 23 Sep 23 12.47pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I don't want a civil conversation about the pros and cons of Brighton and Hove Albion. As far as I'm concerned, they can do one.

Unfortunately they have ... to the next level, Europe, top 8, bought and sold to vast profit etc.

But I get your general drift.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 23 Sep 23 6.42pm

Brighton are so good these days even Danny Welbeck is scoring goals, who would have thought?

 

Stirlingsays Flag 23 Sep 23 7.10pm

It's all that gay sex.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Gribbo Flag Bromley 23 Sep 23 7.28pm

More progressive ownership.
Bigger stadium.
Better scouting network.
Manager who has a system, switches players in and out and bloods youngsters and new acquisitions.
I don't expect it will last long-term, but they seem to have more ambition than survival each year.

We cant get one new stand built, a decent right back, or a half reasonable striker. Bought a reserve keeper instead. Owners not interested in moving things forward, more interested in being part of a consortia to takeover Chelsea - says it all.

 

CPFC Dartford Flag Dartford 24 Sep 23 12.00pm

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

Ok this may upset a few but as they are about to embark on a European adventure, it seems that Brighton by pretty much any measure are pulling way ahead of us.

They are cementing their reputation earned last season as a tough team to beat, they are soaring up the league and staying there. That have stability, they seem to buy players for buttons then sell them on at a huge profit only to unearth a better option for less buttons.

Ok we have been in the league longer and we have a great academy (even if we seem to not be seeing the results in terms of the first team right now.

What are they doing right that we are not?

They have been building this for years. In my obviously biased eyes, I believe we should be getting more plaudits than them. The reason being is we didn’t really plan for anything. We put a team of youth, loans, freebies and snips together and somehow got promotion, beating them by the way in the process. Then somehow this team of misfits stayed up and the rest is history. We have at least half the team now of star players that the top 6 would all snap up given the chance.

Let Brighton enjoy their time in the sun, it did take them 30 years to catch up. They only really got to Europe because some of the big boys flopped. Hopefully some will flop again and we will be there this time getting into Europe.

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 24 Sep 23 12.03pm

It took Brighton awhile to get it right. They did spend alot of money initially on players which simply didn't work out.

To think they would have been relegated had WE not beaten Cardiff that season.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 24 Sep 23 4.20pm

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

There is a lot to look at here. They buy players cheap and sell them on. Yes they do and do it bloody well as not only do they sell on for a huge profit they then unearth another gem. When was the last time we sold a player for a few let alone a profit. Aside from the odd small sale it must have been AWB.

They have a billionaire owner? So do we. Parish does not own Palace. We actually have more than one billionaire owner. They just don't seem that bothered.

As for the ground...well Spurs and Arsenal built new grounds far closer to central London than we are. Most of Croydon is now falling down. You could slap a ground in the town centre there is so much vacant land now Westfield have given up.

A deal of naivety as to how things are done. You have serious money bag clubs who will pay whatever is required to get their new ground and a considerably smaller club trying (more or less successfully) to run it sustainably in the most expensive league on earth. Thus, for arsenal an extortionate ransom strip - pay em off. The authority impose outrageous 106 conditions - whatever. We lack the financial clout but have the corporate principles not to tolerate what others accept. You must decide whether you support a club that is bound to its convictions or one so rich they can afford not to have them.

 

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 24 Sep 23 9.33pm

Originally posted by silvertop

A deal of naivety as to how things are done. You have serious money bag clubs who will pay whatever is required to get their new ground and a considerably smaller club trying (more or less successfully) to run it sustainably in the most expensive league on earth. Thus, for arsenal an extortionate ransom strip - pay em off. The authority impose outrageous 106 conditions - whatever. We lack the financial clout but have the corporate principles not to tolerate what others accept. You must decide whether you support a club that is bound to its convictions or one so rich they can afford not to have them.

Not sure we have 'corporate principles,' - whatever they are. Indeed we have a dysfunctional triumvirate at our head who I doubt could agree on a set of principles.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 25 Sep 23 12.05pm

Along with Luton, they’re probably the biggest overachievers in the country currently.

Well run operation, excellent recruitment strategy with a seeming conveyor belt of good players meaning they are not reluctant to sell their best players as they already have a replacement.

Annoyingly they are our rivals. Best to focus on ourselves, we’re also punching above our weight by gradually becoming a competitive and established PL club. Let them have their day. It’s taken them about 50 years to get ahead of us.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 25 Sep 23 12.59pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

Along with Luton, they’re probably the biggest overachievers in the country currently.

Well run operation, excellent recruitment strategy with a seeming conveyor belt of good players meaning they are not reluctant to sell their best players as they already have a replacement.

Annoyingly they are our rivals. Best to focus on ourselves, we’re also punching above our weight by gradually becoming a competitive and established PL club. Let them have their day. It’s taken them about 50 years to get ahead of us.

Its hard sometime to focus on the positives when out manger comes out ahead of the first cup game of the season, saying we aren't going to be able to compete.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 25 Sep 23 1.34pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Its hard sometime to focus on the positives when out manger comes out ahead of the first cup game of the season, saying we aren't going to be able to compete.

Completely agree with sentiment Robbo but just as an attempt:

We sort of remind me of myself at school now - there's potential there for so much more and a good foundation but TBH we're almost guaranteed to be fine even with the most minimal of effort and coasting off that. The difference here is that Palace's position is due to finances whereas my own was down to the want for chasing tail and the lack of inclination to devote a large proportion of my time to academics. I'd suggest this is why we have seen very little investment of late and as a result, a paper thin squad.

A positive spin on this is perhaps that we have a manager who is willing to call this out whilst still soldiering on, doing his job. I would also suggest a lot of teams 'throw' the Carabao Cup and/or are equally unable to compete yet do not voice this. I'd rather have a manager who's honest with both fans and the board than one who seemingly bobbles their head and goes along. We may, may see some investment in January, especially if we are still ravaged by injuries and results fall off a cliff but also perhaps more favourable draws in the FA Cup, the proper one.

United away is hardly a banker, although perhaps very winnable, and Roy's comments may also be aimed to lighten the burden on the players, put the onus on an already under fire United, and perhaps create the conditions for a very mild 'shock'.

COYP, in Roy we trust.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 25 Sep 23 1.45pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Completely agree with sentiment Robbo but just as an attempt:

We sort of remind me of myself at school now - there's potential there for so much more and a good foundation but TBH we're almost guaranteed to be fine even with the most minimal of effort and coasting off that. The difference here is that Palace's position is due to finances whereas my own was down to the want for chasing tail and the lack of inclination to devote a large proportion of my time to academics. I'd suggest this is why we have seen very little investment of late and as a result, a paper thin squad.

A positive spin on this is perhaps that we have a manager who is willing to call this out whilst still soldiering on, doing his job. I would also suggest a lot of teams 'throw' the Carabao Cup and/or are equally unable to compete yet do not voice this. I'd rather have a manager who's honest with both fans and the board than one who seemingly bobbles their head and goes along. We may, may see some investment in January, especially if we are still ravaged by injuries and results fall off a cliff but also perhaps more favourable draws in the FA Cup, the proper one.

United away is hardly a banker, although perhaps very winnable, and Roy's comments may also be aimed to lighten the burden on the players, put the onus on an already under fire United, and perhaps create the conditions for a very mild 'shock'.

COYP, in Roy we trust.

I think you’re being generous. If we’d had Exeter at home he would still have come out with the same comments and fielded the reserves.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 25 Sep 23 2.01pm

Originally posted by Davepalace707

I think you’re being generous. If we’d had Exeter at home he would still have come out with the same comments and fielded the reserves.

I think he would too Dave but as a result of us not having a big enough squad to fight at full strengths on all fronts, it's just the reality.

I think Roy's comments reflect the fact that the PL and survival within it is the priority and as a result we will see weaker sides and the big names rested for cups due to our smaller squad.

Again, this may change with more investment in the team, lesser injuries, progress in the league to see us virtually safe and perhaps in the FA Cup, a more prestigious trophy.

Until then we will have to accept that the League Cup is not a priority and we will not be giving it our all at Old Trafford on a Tuesday night. The other scenario is we play our best team, have someone or numerous players get injured, still lose/go out and then struggle even more so in the league.

I'd love us to give the league cup a go, few games then you're in the final at Wembley, but can see perhaps why we do not.

As for the title of the thread, BHA aren't really that much better than us now thought they are in Europe and do have a bigger squad. They lost to Athens at home the other day in Europe, a team I would expect us to beat, and whilst starting well won't be a million miles ahead of us in the league. They've done things a lot better but c'est la vie, not much point b!tching about it though we can discuss it for academic purposes.

We have our own way of doing things, are punching above our weight and look set to do so for the foreseeable future. Doesn't mean we shouldn't always strive for better but hardly a catastrophe. If there's anything we can learn from BHA then great but until then I'm more concerned with Palace and whilst it doesn't explain the never ending wait for a RB and no incoming wingers, we're not doing too badly at all in my books.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 25 Sep 23 2.15pm

And end of the day Brighton are no more likely to win a cup than we are

 

Page 4 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why are Brighton so much better than us right now?