You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Everton to be deducted 12 points
November 16 2026 2.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Everton to be deducted 12 points


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Plaistow Eagle Flag 26 Oct 23 7.05pm

No one would like to see this..!!

[Link]

Would put them on -5 points plus presumably a lengthy transfer embargo..!!

With Sheff Utd on 1 point and Bournemouth, Burnley and Luton all struggling to - you’ve got to be thinking anyone with more than 30 points staying up this season.

Not that I’m worried about it from our perspective - we’re good enough for a top 10 finish, once we get all the walking wounded back..!!

But if you’re Everton - got to be worried - poor squad, better players will probably want to move on in January - no funds to replace them - new ground to pay for - all seems very bleak..!!

See we moan about Palace/Parish not splashing the cash - this is the potential for spending beyond your limit - who would you rather be us or Everton right now..!!

On a purely Palace perspective - payback for attacking Vieria..!!

COYP

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 26 Oct 23 7.45pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

No one would like to see this..!!

[Link]

Would put them on -5 points plus presumably a lengthy transfer embargo..!!

With Sheff Utd on 1 point and Bournemouth, Burnley and Luton all struggling to - you’ve got to be thinking anyone with more than 30 points staying up this season.

Not that I’m worried about it from our perspective - we’re good enough for a top 10 finish, once we get all the walking wounded back..!!

But if you’re Everton - got to be worried - poor squad, better players will probably want to move on in January - no funds to replace them - new ground to pay for - all seems very bleak..!!

See we moan about Palace/Parish not splashing the cash - this is the potential for spending beyond your limit - who would you rather be us or Everton right now..!!

On a purely Palace perspective - payback for attacking Vieria..!!

COYP

Trying to be sympathetic toward their fans although I doubt it would be reciprocated.
It took 3 days to dock us 10 points and we were only a fraction in the debt they have.
The only hope they've got is that Man City have more charges against them so would face tougher sanctions although their army of lawyers would probably spin the case out for years.


[Link]

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 26 Oct 23 8.10pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Trying to be sympathetic toward their fans although I doubt it would be reciprocated.
It took 3 days to dock us 10 points and we were only a fraction in the debt they have.
The only hope they've got is that Man City have more charges against them so would face tougher sanctions although their army of lawyers would probably spin the case out for years.


[Link]

Mate as I was writing my post I was conscious of Bill Kenwright sadly passing away this week - which is terrible, Everton through and through..!!

RIP Bill Kenwright from all of us in Red and Blue..!!

But his values are/were no longer represented by the club he built - hence the problems they are in..!!

As you say if we were in the same position would we get any sympathy from them - no way..!!

I agree on Man City what is it 140 odd charges - this as I understand is just one.

At this rate City would be playing in the Northern Premier League.

If the Premier League are going to make a stance on this - it has to be fair to all, otherwise you know what will be coming - big club preferential treatment etc..

But it has to be said if you are Leicester of Leeds now - who both narrowly went down with Everton just escaping - what are you thinking..??

The League needs to make a stance on FFP - otherwise what's the point..??

COYP

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 26 Oct 23 8.25pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Mate as I was writing my post I was conscious of Bill Kenwright sadly passing away this week - which is terrible, Everton through and through..!!

RIP Bill Kenwright from all of us in Red and Blue..!!

But his values are/were no longer represented by the club he built - hence the problems they are in..!!

As you say if we were in the same position would we get any sympathy from them - no way..!!

I agree on Man City what is it 140 odd charges - this as I understand is just one.

At this rate City would be playing in the Northern Premier League.

If the Premier League are going to make a stance on this - it has to be fair to all, otherwise you know what will be coming - big club preferential treatment etc..

But it has to be said if you are Leicester of Leeds now - who both narrowly went down with Everton just escaping - what are you thinking..??

The League needs to make a stance on FFP - otherwise what's the point..??

COYP

I guess since the case has been referred to "an independent commission" to make the decision the F.A. can hold their hands up and say "we made a recommendation but they decided against it".

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 26 Oct 23 9.05pm

No sympathy from me after that disgraceful pitch invasion and the assault on our players. What goes around…

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 26 Oct 23 9.06pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

I guess since the case has been referred to "an independent commission" to make the decision the F.A. can hold their hands up and say "we made a recommendation but they decided against it".


which may well be what happens. It will be interesting to see:
1} whether the independent commission finds Everton guilty and
2) if so, what punishment they choose to give.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 27 Oct 23 7.42am

I think our being docked 10 points was because we went into administration (there was no case to prove or answer to, it was a stone cold fact) so we had the points deducted almost immediately.

But I am with you completely on the delays in administering these FFP charges, I am a firm believer that if someone breaks the rules they should have the punishment administered in the same season that the offence occurred to retain the integrity of the season ( or at least during the summer break so that the new season can start with a clean slate) otherwise as in this case you have 3 clubs waiting to sue Everton because they suffered relegation when ( if the FFP case is proven) one of them might have escaped relegation with Everton going down instead.


Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Trying to be sympathetic toward their fans although I doubt it would be reciprocated.
It took 3 days to dock us 10 points and we were only a fraction in the debt they have.
The only hope they've got is that Man City have more charges against them so would face tougher sanctions although their army of lawyers would probably spin the case out for years.


[Link]

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 27 Oct 23 8.20am

Originally posted by doombear


which may well be what happens. It will be interesting to see:
1} whether the independent commission finds Everton guilty and
2) if so, what punishment they choose to give.

And who sits on this independent commission and how were they appointed?

I am cynical that Everton will get their just desserts because most of the PL clubs will not want it to happen.

There are a number of clubs Man City and Chelsea spring to mind who must be concerned about FFP and then there is Forrest and perhaps others we don't know about.

I suspect that they will not want Everton to get hit hard not for any love of the club but in fear that they will get similar treatment.

Let's hope that is not the case.

 


One more point

Painter Flag Croydon 27 Oct 23 8.59am

Originally posted by Badger11

And who sits on this independent commission and how were they appointed?

I am cynical that Everton will get their just desserts because most of the PL clubs will not want it to happen.

There are a number of clubs Man City and Chelsea spring to mind who must be concerned about FFP and then there is Forrest and perhaps others we don't know about.

I suspect that they will not want Everton to get hit hard not for any love of the club but in fear that they will get similar treatment.

Let's hope that is not the case.

Agree, there is no chance they will get a points deduction, it will set a precedent in the Premier and other clubs don’t want that.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 27 Oct 23 10.45am

Originally posted by Badger11

And who sits on this independent commission and how were they appointed?

I am cynical that Everton will get their just desserts because most of the PL clubs will not want it to happen.

There are a number of clubs Man City and Chelsea spring to mind who must be concerned about FFP and then there is Forrest and perhaps others we don't know about.

I suspect that they will not want Everton to get hit hard not for any love of the club but in fear that they will get similar treatment.

Let's hope that is not the case.

Agree,. Surely no one else in football could be called independent. The rules have to allow for this to happen , or it can’t happen, so why not just implement the rules..
Until not so long ago self protecting was a wide spread attitude in the FL at least. Re-election was common place for many years for instance when some clubs had been a lost cause for years..

 

taylors lovechild Flag 27 Oct 23 11.04am

Everton fans have had to put up with a mess of a club for a few years now, so I'd actually feel sorry for them if this happened. For most of us football is one of the few things to look forward to each week, irrespective of who we support. However, as others have said, what's the point in FFP if it just results in a few slapped hands and fines that make no impact. I recently read Simon Jordan's book and I have no confidence that much has changed and due to the size and history of Everton they'll probably get off with a fine and a transfer ban. If it was us, Luton or Burnley, for example, they probably wouldn't blink at deducting 12 points or more.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 27 Oct 23 11.52am

Originally posted by Badger11

And who sits on this independent commission and how were they appointed?

I am cynical that Everton will get their just desserts because most of the PL clubs will not want it to happen.

There are a number of clubs Man City and Chelsea spring to mind who must be concerned about FFP and then there is Forrest and perhaps others we don't know about.

I suspect that they will not want Everton to get hit hard not for any love of the club but in fear that they will get similar treatment.

Let's hope that is not the case.

Totally agree with you. No way Everton are going to get hammered, although I would love to see it

 

madcap_v2 Flag SE25 / Ibiza 27 Oct 23 11.59am

For the implications it would have on the league and football, I hope this happens. However, for the implications this will have on the league, football and the likes of the forementioned Chelsea, Man City, Forest etc... I don't think this will happen.

I don't even feel for Everton fans if it does, they would be happy the club are spending money to improve their standings in the league. Our deduction, we didn't even see the benefit of, we just had an incompetant owner who wasn't fit to run a bath, let alone a football club.

 


La la la your mum

Goalpost1 Flag Worcester Park 27 Oct 23 11.59am

I think they'll end up losing 6 points because the powers that be will want to give them a chance to escape relegation. Even with their recent Houdini style acts in recent seasons it'd be a mountain for them to climb with a 12 points deduction. They'd need to be in the territory of playing to the level to get into Europe and they are nowhere near that.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 27 Oct 23 12.06pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Totally agree with you. No way Everton are going to get hammered, although I would love to see it

A Toffee hammer?

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 27 Oct 23 12.08pm

Possibly reinforced by some kind of transfer embargo.

Originally posted by Goalpost1

I think they'll end up losing 6 points because the powers that be will want to give them a chance to escape relegation. Even with their recent Houdini style acts in recent seasons it'd be a mountain for them to climb with a 12 points deduction. They'd need to be in the territory of playing to the level to get into Europe and they are nowhere near that.

 

eaglesdare Flag 27 Oct 23 1.35pm

amazing that in italy clubs are regulary deducted points when they step out of line but The FA / premier league / "Powers that be" in england have no backbone.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 27 Oct 23 3.06pm

If convicted it will be a fine they can easily afford plus a transfer embargo so heavily conditioned as to be effectively worthless and it will be applied at the time most convenient to Everton.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 27 Oct 23 3.08pm

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

I think our being docked 10 points was because we went into administration (there was no case to prove or answer to, it was a stone cold fact) so we had the points deducted almost immediately.

But I am with you completely on the delays in administering these FFP charges, I am a firm believer that if someone breaks the rules they should have the punishment administered in the same season that the offence occurred to retain the integrity of the season ( or at least during the summer break so that the new season can start with a clean slate) otherwise as in this case you have 3 clubs waiting to sue Everton because they suffered relegation when ( if the FFP case is proven) one of them might have escaped relegation with Everton going down instead.



Correct as soon as you go into administration it is applied.

It is delayed because it's complex.

Think of it as a trial you need to gather the evidence and present it to the other side first with a fair amount of clubs making it slow/difficult to even get all the records required.

Look at Man City for example its been years and on purpose they are holding things up because they can afford to.

Those clubs which have been relegated it's over and have no valid case you can't prove that by them spending more has changed any results and the same with if you argue if they had so many points they would have been relegated again you don't know that.

It's messy and doesn't look good for the sport I expect some payments will be paid that is it.

They need to make football in this country transparent too much hidden away everything when it comes to money side of things should be open (they wont do this because its another corrupt sport)

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

YT Flag Oxford 27 Oct 23 4.30pm

I don't think they'll win the 'Most successful bit of cheating award'.

Edited by YT (27 Oct 2023 5.45pm)

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Everton to be deducted 12 points