This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Football teams are all about players. A good manager might add a little something, but in the main, the most you can ask for is to avoid appointing a bad one who reduces the natural level of the players. We struggle when Eze and Olise are not fit, which is quite often this season. We miss Zaha. of course. The players who take their places are not as good (not even remotely usually) and that's our problem in a nutshell. We are not Man City, and will never have five or six top-class attacking players from which to pick two or three. We need our key players fit and in form to do well, otherwise it's all a bit of a grind. The key is not to dream of what could be if only we had a bench full of top internationals, but instead to devise a plan to get the required points when our key players are missing. That is what Roy does. When the best players are back and fit, that same plan looks very different, of course. No new manager will change any of that, so why change the manager? We've tried all sorts over the years now and never found anyone better than Roy. Fair point. I'm not sure Roy would actually want to go on beyond the end of this season but if he doesn't common sense tells you we need another pragmatist. Preferrably with a decent level of experience.
|
|
|
Originally posted by est1905
Fair point. I'm not sure Roy would actually want to go on beyond the end of this season but if he doesn't common sense tells you we need another pragmatist. Preferrably with a decent level of experience. Chris Hughton fits the bill.Experienced manager (Over 500 games), PL experience !
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Football teams are all about players. A good manager might add a little something, but in the main, the most you can ask for is to avoid appointing a bad one who reduces the natural level of the players. We struggle when Eze and Olise are not fit, which is quite often this season. We miss Zaha. of course. The players who take their places are not as good (not even remotely usually) and that's our problem in a nutshell. We are not Man City, and will never have five or six top-class attacking players from which to pick two or three. We need our key players fit and in form to do well, otherwise it's all a bit of a grind. The key is not to dream of what could be if only we had a bench full of top internationals, but instead to devise a plan to get the required points when our key players are missing. That is what Roy does. When the best players are back and fit, that same plan looks very different, of course. No new manager will change any of that, so why change the manager? We've tried all sorts over the years now and never found anyone better than Roy. I agree with this, still very annoying when we put in poor performances against the likes of Luton. I wonder if Roy had any input into the deals for Henderson and Franca which so far have been a waste of money when we needed a striker
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
You can tell a lot about the strength of a clubs playing staff by the quality they have on the bench on match day, the top clubs have more money sitting on the bench than we have been able to spend on the entire first team. Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Football teams are all about players. A good manager might add a little something, but in the main, the most you can ask for is to avoid appointing a bad one who reduces the natural level of the players. We struggle when Eze and Olise are not fit, which is quite often this season. We miss Zaha. of course. The players who take their places are not as good (not even remotely usually) and that's our problem in a nutshell. We are not Man City, and will never have five or six top-class attacking players from which to pick two or three. We need our key players fit and in form to do well, otherwise it's all a bit of a grind. The key is not to dream of what could be if only we had a bench full of top internationals, but instead to devise a plan to get the required points when our key players are missing. That is what Roy does. When the best players are back and fit, that same plan looks very different, of course. No new manager will change any of that, so why change the manager? We've tried all sorts over the years now and never found anyone better than Roy.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Football teams are all about players. A good manager might add a little something, but in the main, the most you can ask for is to avoid appointing a bad one who reduces the natural level of the players. We struggle when Eze and Olise are not fit, which is quite often this season. We miss Zaha. of course. The players who take their places are not as good (not even remotely usually) and that's our problem in a nutshell. We are not Man City, and will never have five or six top-class attacking players from which to pick two or three. We need our key players fit and in form to do well, otherwise it's all a bit of a grind. The key is not to dream of what could be if only we had a bench full of top internationals, but instead to devise a plan to get the required points when our key players are missing. That is what Roy does. When the best players are back and fit, that same plan looks very different, of course. No new manager will change any of that, so why change the manager? We've tried all sorts over the years now and never found anyone better than Roy. When Eze and Olise have been out we amassed 4 points. A turgid performance and a lucky point at home to Forest and a somewhat fortuitous win against a Burnley side who have lost all of their games at home this season. I'm starting to wonder if Roy's steadfast approach is starting to get old hat. To say managers don't make a difference is odd. I agree you can't turn a crap squad into prime Barcelona by changing the manager, but you only have to look at Villa and Brighton as two obvious examples where a new manager with fresh ideas have taken squads to another level. I think a manager who would bring more intensity to our play would be good, similar to what O'Neill has done at Wolves. Attack with intent and less slow passing around sideways and backwards.
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
When Eze and Olise have been out we amassed 4 points. A turgid performance and a lucky point at home to Forest and a somewhat fortuitous win against a Burnley side who have lost all of their games at home this season. I'm starting to wonder if Roy's steadfast approach is starting to get old hat. To say managers don't make a difference is odd. I agree you can't turn a crap squad into prime Barcelona by changing the manager, but you only have to look at Villa and Brighton as two obvious examples where a new manager with fresh ideas have taken squads to another level. I think a manager who would bring more intensity to our play would be good, similar to what O'Neill has done at Wolves. Attack with intent and less slow passing around sideways and backwards. I understand where TBTP is coming from but I very much agree with this. That's not to say I think I am correct of course, just mirrors my thoughts.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
Aside from the need to buy/loan a new defensive midfielder to replace Doucoure, my one wish for January would be to add some genuine pace to the attack. In conversation with a supporter at the weekend he kept using the word "Moribund" to describe our current situation and positivity was in short supply.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
The summer transfer activity seems to be attracting media scrutiny at the moment, and not in a positive way. So far no benefit has been realised from any of our signings apart from Lerma who I think has done ok. I question what kind of budget will be available in January. I don’t think Palace envisaged needing to go into the market. However, a combination of injuries, current form and upcoming fixtures indicate that the Board will have to shrug off their complacent approach to the season and take some decisive action. I like to think of myself as a realist as opposed to an optimist or pessimist, but the way things are going at the moment, I’m heading towards the latter. Agree. I did think however our supposed indifference to the summer transfer market, or any urgency there, was a confidence thing. If we do see the awful run many are predicting (rightly so IMHO) perhaps that will change and a short sharp shock to the system might provoke a reaction from the board? Either that or we really do have very little if no money to spend. I'd be highly shocked if funds were there though, Parish et al would just sit back with us languishing near if not in the relegation zone saying 'meh, we'll be OK'. That may change of course if we do, by some miracle, pick up some points between now and January.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
The summer transfer activity seems to be attracting media scrutiny at the moment, and not in a positive way. So far no benefit has been realised from any of our signings apart from Lerma who I think has done ok. I question what kind of budget will be available in January. I don’t think Palace envisaged needing to go into the market. However, a combination of injuries, current form and upcoming fixtures indicate that the Board will have to shrug off their complacent approach to the season and take some decisive action. I like to think of myself as a realist as opposed to an optimist or pessimist, but the way things are going at the moment, I’m heading towards the latter. Suffice to say that my reservoir of cautious optimism has run dry in recent weeks but of course our fortunes could change!
Edited by Willo (30 Nov 2023 10.04am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
As someone else alluded to, the fact that Hodgson publicly spoke of us missing out on two late deals in the summer (likely Hall and Ekitike) it is possible there is still a budget and a willingness to expand the squad. Mind you, we've had similar instances in the past and that logic doesn't always seem to follow. I look on those reports as red herrings designed to placate the fans. The Ekitike was pure rubbish - didn't ask the club? Yeah right. Hall would have needed actual money and gumption - neither of which we had/ have. I want us to address our problems but kind of know that, in reality, we won't - until we absolutely have to. I won't be holding my breath in January.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
To return to the original point of the thread, I should think the only reasons we might not spend in any given January are that either the right players are at a premium at that time, or we are skint. The idea that we wouldn't spend because we expect to have a new manager in the summer is based partly on memories of the old model in which the manager dealt with transfer business, and partly on the idea that we should mainly sign players to suit a particular managers tactical style. On the first point, and in common with many clubs, no modern Palace manager holds the purse strings. Pulis and Allardyce may have been able to apply more pressure than most, but both experiences seemed only to solidify the commitment to a Director of Football model. On the second point, following the De Boer experience I very much doubt that we would ever again employ a manager with such rigid tactics that highly-specific recruitment must take place just to make his methods work. You just can't change the squad fully enough and quickly enough to do that. Look at Roy. He, like Pulis and Allardyce before him, has safety-first tactical methods but, like his predecessors, would bite your hand off for better players of any type, size and style, and will fit them in if he gets them. I doubt many people looked at Olise and Eze and thought 'Thats a Hodgson type of player, for sure' yet both have not only been accommodated, they have had the team built increasingly around them, and have thrived. Finally, most players are capable of playing different styles to some extent. I imagine Olise and Eze will be asked to press more and come back less when they eventually play for top six clubs, but it's not like learning a different sport or anything. Anyone we buy at any time should be able to make a decent fist of whatever tactics any future manager employs, within reason (again, presuming we do not appoint another De Boer). All in all, the invention of the transfer window makes it almost imperative to do good business whenever you are able, and not miss that chance. If someone out there is a good player at a good price, we should try for them as hard in January as in the summer. The rest is just details. Edited by TheBigToePunt (30 Nov 2023 1.20pm) I agree with the general thrust of these sentiments, in actual fact I have had discussions to this effect fact outside of HOL.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.