You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Thin squad going to get thinner
November 16 2026 2.28am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Thin squad going to get thinner


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
DenTyler Flag Sidcup 08 Dec 23 2.11pm

I’ve not seen anything related to Ayew being away for international duty. This is going to make our current problem much worse. We all know it so you have to think that SP and DF know it and have some sort of plan. Surely they can see the problem we have and it’s in there interest to get Roy some help in January.

 

Zaha127 Flag 08 Dec 23 3.39pm

Could this be a blessing in disguise? I remember on Talksport yesterday a fan calling in and saying how players like Mitchell and Wan Bissaka Palace were forced to play them due to injury.

It does make you think sometimes RB is a position that everyone knows Palace need. Why not play Dan Imray? He is someone we need an attacking minded RB. Also have Adaramola who would be decent cover for Mitchell and could even break in to the first XI.

We keep hearing how good are academy is which is true (Ozoh, Wells Morrison, Rodney, Adaramola, Imray, Ola Adebomi, Whitworth etc)

Ola Adebomi has been playing very well with players like Franca, Eze and Olise on the ball he could become a prolific goal scorer. What is the point of the academy if we very few make it to the first team?

Some decisions make you scratch your head. Buying Rob Holding. Buying Franca but he gets very limited minutes. Buying Henderson when you have Johnstone (yes there were rumours about Johnstone leaving but Palace should have offered him reassurance at the time plus he was under contract till 2026 so Palace did have power to keep him) Whitworth is a good number 2 having someone like Henderson and Johnstone just causes a bigger headache.

We know Palace will not be big spenders. If the board know that is the case why are they not pushing more players from the academy to train with the first team and be a part of squad. There is potential that never gets used.

Edited by Zaha127 (08 Dec 2023 3.57pm)

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 08 Dec 23 4.19pm

Originally posted by Zaha127

Could this be a blessing in disguise? I remember on Talksport yesterday a fan calling in and saying how players like Mitchell and Wan Bissaka Palace were forced to play them due to injury.

It does make you think sometimes RB is a position that everyone knows Palace need. Why not play Dan Imray? He is someone we need an attacking minded RB. Also have Adaramola who would be decent cover for Mitchell and could even break in to the first XI.

We keep hearing how good are academy is which is true (Ozoh, Wells Morrison, Rodney, Adaramola, Imray, Ola Adebomi, Whitworth etc)

Ola Adebomi has been playing very well with players like Franca, Eze and Olise on the ball he could become a prolific goal scorer. What is the point of the academy if we very few make it to the first team?

Some decisions make you scratch your head. Buying Rob Holding. Buying Franca but he gets very limited minutes. Buying Henderson when you have Johnstone (yes there were rumours about Johnstone leaving but Palace should have offered him reassurance at the time plus he was under contract till 2026 so Palace did have power to keep him) Whitworth is a good number 2 having someone like Henderson and Johnstone just causes a bigger headache.

We know Palace will not be big spenders. If the board know that is the case why are they not pushing more players from the academy to train with the first team and be a part of squad. There is potential that never gets used.

Edited by Zaha127 (08 Dec 2023 3.57pm)

The problem is we don't actually know how good they are, the matches aren't real (Beating Man C etc). All their good kids are already out on loan.

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 08 Dec 23 4.47pm

The one thing I would say about Academy players coming in, is that the PL is more based towards skills and movement whilst lower divisions can have more of an emphasis on physicality.

They could prosper if they have the skill and footballing intelligence. They will need to be able to make quick decisions with the ball otherwise they will be caught in possession too much and/or lose the ball.

 

Norbury Old Git Flag London 08 Dec 23 4.53pm

Good points Zaha. AWB and Tyrick were discovered during a period of squad injuries and neither had Football League experience let alone that of the Premier League. We also have Malachi Boateng a central defensive midfielder playing regularly in the Scottish Premier League for Dundee and Phillips at Wickham Wanderers who plays a more attacking midfield role who may be able to be called back. It may be worth Mark Bright and a senior coach watching MB against Rangers this weekend. Phillips has already done well against Manchester United in a preseason friendly a year ago and recently starred for the RoI U-21 team against Italy and scored in the 2-2 draw.I believe both these 20 year olds are ready to move up.

 

DenTyler Flag Sidcup 08 Dec 23 5.49pm

Originally posted by Zaha127

Could this be a blessing in disguise? I remember on Talksport yesterday a fan calling in and saying how players like Mitchell and Wan Bissaka Palace were forced to play them due to injury.

It does make you think sometimes RB is a position that everyone knows Palace need. Why not play Dan Imray? He is someone we need an attacking minded RB. Also have Adaramola who would be decent cover for Mitchell and could even break in to the first XI.

We keep hearing how good are academy is which is true (Ozoh, Wells Morrison, Rodney, Adaramola, Imray, Ola Adebomi, Whitworth etc)

Ola Adebomi has been playing very well with players like Franca, Eze and Olise on the ball he could become a prolific goal scorer. What is the point of the academy if we very few make it to the first team?

Some decisions make you scratch your head. Buying Rob Holding. Buying Franca but he gets very limited minutes. Buying Henderson when you have Johnstone (yes there were rumours about Johnstone leaving but Palace should have offered him reassurance at the time plus he was under contract till 2026 so Palace did have power to keep him) Whitworth is a good number 2 having someone like Henderson and Johnstone just causes a bigger headache.

We know Palace will not be big spenders. If the board know that is the case why are they not pushing more players from the academy to train with the first team and be a part of squad. There is potential that never gets used.

Edited by Zaha127 (08 Dec 2023 3.57pm)


This is a good way of looking at it, maybe we need to turn to the academy. If the management knows there is no money and nobody likely coming in then if I were the manager I would have a good look at what is already on the books and make it work. Time now training with the first team, sub appearances followed by a few starts has got to be better than what we have. We are losing anyway. Might as well lose trying something new and maybe uncovering another AWB or Wilf (a man can dream)

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 08 Dec 23 7.05pm

Originally posted by DenTyler


This is a good way of looking at it, maybe we need to turn to the academy. If the management knows there is no money and nobody likely coming in then if I were the manager I would have a good look at what is already on the books and make it work. Time now training with the first team, sub appearances followed by a few starts has got to be better than what we have. We are losing anyway. Might as well lose trying something new and maybe uncovering another AWB or Wilf (a man can dream)

Some of us on here (well, I have anyway) been crying out for some of our academy starlets to be given a game. Unfortunately, the last time Roy did this it crashed badly. Adapting to the pace and sheer skill prevalent in the PL is almost impossible for youngsters to cope with, no matter how good they appear in the Under 21s.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 08 Dec 23 8.12pm

Plenty of young players have been blooded in cup games in recent seasons with poor results followed by the inevitable whines that the club / manager don't take the cups seriously. Can't have it all ways.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 09 Dec 23 5.50pm

to what extent will today's blizzard of cards be problemmatic ? Ayew....2 yellows hence a red. I expect we will try to appeal it ?

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Dec 23 5.51pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

to what extent will today's blizzard of cards be problemmatic ? Ayew....2 yellows hence a red. I expect we will try to appeal it ?

One can appeal a straight Red but not two Yellows.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 09 Dec 23 6.17pm

Unavailable XI

GK - Johnstone / Henderson
LB - Mitchell
RB - Ferguson
CB - Holding
CB - ?
CM - Doucoure
CM - Eze
CM - Lerma
LW - Ayew
RW - Rak-Sakyi
CF - Edouard

Missing a CB but that's a strong side.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Swindy Flag Bromley 09 Dec 23 6.24pm

Why all the panic, I wonder, especially from the Parish-lovers.
Our saviour Steve is going to spend big in January on players who will actually be used this time in the starting XI - there's a thought and Roy's going to wake up on January 1st with a New Years' resolution to play the odd young player.
Oh hang on .......

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 09 Dec 23 8.23pm

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

Some of us on here (well, I have anyway) been crying out for some of our academy starlets to be given a game. Unfortunately, the last time Roy did this it crashed badly. Adapting to the pace and sheer skill prevalent in the PL is almost impossible for youngsters to cope with, no matter how good they appear in the Under 21s.

i have always argued that an Academy is appropriate for League One and the Championship. Prem clubs buy in proven talent- aged 21+.

but what would i know, i never even managed a medium-sized club.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 09 Dec 23 8.33pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

i have always argued that an Academy is appropriate for League One and the Championship. Prem clubs buy in proven talent- aged 21+.

but what would i know, i never even managed a medium-sized club.

The U21's were beaten 2-0 recently by AFC Wimbledon whom, I'm told, didn't field a full strength team.

Palace's starting line up included Ahamada, Ozoh, Franca and Ebiowei.

Ahamada doesn't look up to it based on what I've seen so far but is being selected ahead of the others.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 09 Dec 23 8.48pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

The U21's were beaten 2-0 recently by AFC Wimbledon whom, I'm told, didn't field a full strength team.

Palace's starting line up included Ahamada, Ozoh, Franca and Ebiowei.

Ahamada doesn't look up to it based on what I've seen so far but is being selected ahead of the others.

Some of us bother to watch them Rachid, not just that night but other times ,certainly enough to know they all are clever and talented, but there physicality is not yet there enough to be thought consistent, their decision making tends to be caught up in narrow channels , making it easy for lower league players to read let alone Premier players to read. And although clever technically not good enough, first touches are not completely missing , but no where near consistent for the unforgiving Premier league. If you watch our under twenty ones in general they get away with poor control quiet a bit, won’t happen in the Premier.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 09 Dec 23 9.02pm

Originally posted by Putitout

Some of us bother to watch them Rachid, not just that night but other times ,certainly enough to know they all are clever and talented, but there physicality is not yet there enough to be thought consistent, their decision making tends to be caught up in narrow channels , making it easy for lower league players to read let alone Premier players to read. And although clever technically not good enough, first touches are not completely missing , but no where near consistent for the unforgiving Premier league. If you watch our under twenty ones in general they get away with poor control quiet a bit, won’t happen in the Premier.

Thank you for the insight. Gentleman.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 10 Dec 23 7.50am

Some of the youngsters may not be ready yet but sometime a harsh does of reality is what they need to spur them on.

With so many players out against City now is a good time to give a couple a try.

It's a free hit we are not expecting anything from the game, I don't mean wholesale changes but perhaps 1 or 2.

 


One more point

The Yorkshire Eagle Flag Great Ouseburn, N Yorkshire 12 Dec 23 8.50am

Following a punch-up last night, or rather assault on a referee, unbelievably by The President of the TFA, the entire Turkish league has been “suspended indefinitely”.
We could plead extenuating circumstances to the Prem, Wilf could take a few weeks leave and help us out over the Christmas period!
On a more serious note, although it was time for him to move on, it has become apparent these past weeks that we so do miss him. Regardless of his failings latterly with fitness and oft attitude, he was the one player who gave us that feeling of expectancy whenever he got the ball, as you nearly always could be certain something would happen when he played and received the ball... if only drawing a foul. His very presence could also draw a defence to create space. Even our current breed of starlets, injured of otherwise don’t raise the excitement to the same level as he once did. Pack your case Wilf !

Happy Christmas.

 

SnapperKain Flag SE25 6PU 12 Dec 23 9.13am

And we might also lose Schlupp to Ghana as well if he gets called up...

I think we might be forced to bring some of the youngsters that we've included in the squad this year into the first team and perhaps we might get a Zaha, AWB or Mitchell style impact from one of them, but having too many against someone like Man City... it'll be men versus boys.

 


The trouble with computers, of course, is that they're very sophisticated idiots

Midlands Eagle Flag 12 Dec 23 9.41am

Originally posted by SnapperKain

And we might also lose Schlupp to Ghana as well if he gets called up...

But Schlupp is no good anyway. I know that because I read it repeatedly on here

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Thin squad going to get thinner