This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
Does this include white English women marrying white non UK men? what, like, fellas from Poland or Norway ? your guess is as good as mine. i would expect the legislation to be colour-blind and to merely focus upon the nationality and/or domicile of the relevant parties. But the old romantic notion of ANYBODY can go off with ANYBODY ELSE seems to be under attack. Will this new law discriminate against poor people ? And what about multi-millionaires who do not work, and therefore do not earn ?
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
what, like, fellas from Poland or Norway ? your guess is as good as mine. i would expect the legislation to be colour-blind and to merely focus upon the nationality and/or domicile of the relevant parties. But the old romantic notion of ANYBODY can go off with ANYBODY ELSE seems to be under attack. Will this new law discriminate against poor people ? And what about multi-millionaires who do not work, and therefore do not earn ?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
A friend bitterly complained to me about the visa process. Her son was engaged to a Mexican lady who had no work skills that I could tell of. Like the Archbishop of Canterbury and the Guardian my friend was outraged that the government was interfering in love. But is it so outrageous? The Mexican lady is hardly an asset to this country. I certainly don't want to tell people who they should marry but at the same time her husband would expect his new wife to have access to benefits and healthcare so is it that noble to expect the rest of us to fund his lifestyle choices? She got her visa and they are married. This doesn’t affect me so I haven’t researched the issue but do we know why the figure has been chosen? Is that what people are meant to earn to be self sufficient or is that the amount that will generate enough tax revenue not to be a ‘drain’ on the UK.
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
what, like, fellas from Poland or Norway ? your guess is as good as mine. i would expect the legislation to be colour-blind and to merely focus upon the nationality and/or domicile of the relevant parties. But the old romantic notion of ANYBODY can go off with ANYBODY ELSE seems to be under attack. Will this new law discriminate against poor people ? And what about multi-millionaires who do not work, and therefore do not earn ? You have conveniently left out the rest of western Europe, but, failed to think of the rest of the world. You have to realise there is a very big world outside of Eire.
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
You have conveniently left out the rest of western Europe, but, failed to think of the rest of the world. You have to realise there is a very big world outside of Eire. i reckon this new Law would have been forbidden by the EU, before Brexit. The treatment of EU versus spouses from the Commonwealth, versus the Rest of the World.....you are correct. A very big place. will this new law equally affect everybody ? male and female ? rich and poor, black and white, Christian and Heathen, young and old ?
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines
This doesn’t affect me so I haven’t researched the issue but do we know why the figure has been chosen? Is that what people are meant to earn to be self sufficient or is that the amount that will generate enough tax revenue not to be a ‘drain’ on the UK. I have some sympathy for people in that situation the heart wants what the heart wants. I take your point about the UK citizen I was thinking more about the foreign spouse and the likelihood the the UK taxpayer will be funding them rather than them making a positive contribution to our society. Back in the day I knew a bunch of guys in Leiwsham who married Thai girls. The girls were poor and uneducated and basically so were the men they married. Not exactly a win win for the UK taxpayer. Edited by Badger11 (10 Dec 2023 7.33pm)
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
A friend bitterly complained to me about the visa process. Her son was engaged to a Mexican lady who had no work skills that I could tell of. Like the Archbishop of Canterbury and the Guardian my friend was outraged that the government was interfering in love. But is it so outrageous? The Mexican lady is hardly an asset to this country. I certainly don't want to tell people who they should marry but at the same time her husband would expect his new wife to have access to benefits and healthcare so is it that noble to expect the rest of us to fund his lifestyle choices? She got her visa and they are married. There is no change to the underlying principles. Just to the level of income expected, which has more than doubled having not been adjusted for inflation for many years. So yes it does discriminate against the poor. It does apply to everyone. New arrivals cannot immediately draw benefits and must pay an annual NHS surcharge. Couples cannot meet online and agree to marry. Nor can anyone else just arrange things for them. They have to show evidence that they have spent time together and that a genuine relationship exists or a visa will be refused. There are though specialist agencies which advise and support people to navigate a long and tricky process strewn with many barriers. Not least of which is that it costs a lot and there is no refund if a visa is refused. Which they are if any of the requirements aren’t fulfilled. The British partner has to bear all of the costs for an extended period. It is, in today’s shrinking world, the government interfering in love. People now travel for work, leisure and study much more than in the past. It’s only natural that some will meet their partner whilst doing so. It happens when people come here, or when a Brit goes abroad. Sometimes the Brit relocates. Sometimes their new partner will. We need to get rid of the “Little England” mentality than still seems to infect the attitudes of some. An attitude to be found here. Even today it reared its ugly head again with the expressed desire to send people they didn’t approve of out of the country. This isn’t simply unrealistic. It’s a refusal to acknowledge that we now live in a global village where mobility is the new normal. So I would like to see our government taking a completely neutral stance on this, whilst ensuring it is not abused in any way. I understand why it’s there. It is to ensure that there is sufficient resource available to avoid poverty, given that no support is available but that decision should be left to the couple and their families. Having any kind of minimum salary requirement is an insult to fairness and common sense. It is just a sop to the anti-immigration lobby which hurts their fellow citizens whilst doing nothing at all to try to deal with genuine problems.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
The Home office do request copies of bank account, P60 & salary certificates for applicants if there is a financial threshold component to the Visa application. Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines
This doesn’t affect me so I haven’t researched the issue but do we know why the figure has been chosen? Is that what people are meant to earn to be self sufficient or is that the amount that will generate enough tax revenue not to be a ‘drain’ on the UK.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dubai Eagle
With immigration being a hot topic (as it has been for some time) to me this announcement feels as though its the government trying to broadcast that they have done something that's going to make a difference to the overall immigration situation, I dont know the specific numbers involved but surely increasing the financial threshold for which you can bring a foreign spouse to the UK isn't really going to make very much difference to the overall immigration numbers - Aren't illegal immigrants arriving in boats claiming asylum are by far the biggest drain on the economy / health services etc etc, sort that out & its much more likely to make a significant difference. This specific measure may not impact that many? However the big issue is actually legal migration. Post Brexit the government has encouraged foreign students to come with their families. Some of these people are rich high achievers but: How many bring their families? How many overstay their visa? How many do not complete their studies but don't return home? How many are doing mickey mouse degrees? Now even if the answer to the above is that they are all rich hard working high achievers who aren't impacting our benefits or health system the sheer volume is too high. A few years back there was the scandal over English language schools. People were getting visas to study English at bogus schools they simply disappeared. I wonder if something like this is happening now. As for the universities they are bitching that there is not enough student accommodation and the government should do more. Well they have massively increased the number of students to line their pockets but expect the rest of us to fund this. Edited by Badger11 (11 Dec 2023 8.02am)
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
This specific measure may not impact that many? However the big issue is actually legal migration. Post Brexit the government has encouraged foreign students to come with their families. Some of these people are rich high achievers but: How many bring their families? How many overstay their visa? How many do not complete their studies but don't return home? How many are doing mickey mouse degrees? Now even if the answer to the above is that they are all rich hard working high achievers who aren't impacting our benefits or health system the sheer volume is too high. A few years back there was the scandal over English language schools. People were getting visas to study English at bogus schools they simply disappeared. I wonder if something like this is happening now. As for the universities they are bitching that there is not enough student accommodation and the government should do more. Well they have massively increased the number of students to line their pockets but expect the rest of us to fund this. Edited by Badger11 (11 Dec 2023 8.02am) This has little or nothing to do with the issue of British citizens being able to live with their spouse if that spouse happens to have been born elsewhere. Just imagine how you would feel if the person you love and want to spend the rest of your life with is banned from being with you solely on financial grounds. Would that feel fair? The issue of students is entirely different and has already been addressed in these pages. The rules change in January when only those on post grad research degrees will be permitted to bring family members with them. They pay fees, often higher than those asked of home students. International students will have their visa marked with “no access to public funds”, so won’t get benefits. They will pay the NHS surcharge. Overstaying is possible but why would they do it? They cannot access benefits and would never be able to go home. They aren’t illegals trying to hide from the system or asylum seekers. They have generally been sponsored in some way as their costs are high.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
This has little or nothing to do with the issue of British citizens being able to live with their spouse if that spouse happens to have been born elsewhere. Just imagine how you would feel if the person you love and want to spend the rest of your life with is banned from being with you solely on financial grounds. Would that feel fair? The issue of students is entirely different and has already been addressed in these pages. The rules change in January when only those on post grad research degrees will be permitted to bring family members with them. They pay fees, often higher than those asked of home students. International students will have their visa marked with “no access to public funds”, so won’t get benefits. They will pay the NHS surcharge. Overstaying is possible but why would they do it? They cannot access benefits and would never be able to go home. They aren’t illegals trying to hide from the system or asylum seekers. They have generally been sponsored in some way as their costs are high. And if someone's on the dole and they go on holiday to Thailand and bring back a wife then that's just fine?
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
And if someone's on the dole and they go on holiday to Thailand and bring back a wife then that's just fine? is it feminism in the West ? overweight unattractive British women, with 4 kids by 4 different dads.....and they all get furious when they see a good looking bloke, Nigel from Croydon, with a pretty overseas wife ? a wife with no previous baggage. So the unattractive women will ban Nigel from importing a wife in the vainglorious hope that he will pick them instead ? somebody please explain the economics & demographics of this new Law ? are 'importers of Spouses' mostly male or female ?
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
And if someone's on the dole and they go on holiday to Thailand and bring back a wife then that's just fine? what's good for the goose is good for the gander ? Literally. If Sharon is already on the dole, and returns from a Thai holiday, pregnant ( with or without the Thai kickboxer fella )....that's just fine ? The UK taxpayer can raise the kid ? Edited by PalazioVecchio (11 Dec 2023 11.21am)
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
And if someone's on the dole and they go on holiday to Thailand and bring back a wife then that's just fine? Depends what she looks like. If you've contributed toward paying for her, surely you are allowed a go? Worth the yellow if it comes BTW
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.