You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Franca Matheus to start v Everton!?
November 16 2026 2.28am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Franca Matheus to start v Everton!?


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
pssguy Flag 05 Jan 24 12.38pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

I don't want to be pessimistic, and of course it is very early days, but I didn't see any sort of quality in Franca whatsoever last night, or in his previous sub appearances.

That's unjustified. He hardly got a touch early on and when he did he immediately was hacked down just outside the box leading to a wasted effort by Eze. He was then in the ideal position for a pass from Lerma who instead decided to blast over. Finally, an astute first-time pass to Eze led to a well-saved shot from our closest chance of scoring

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 05 Jan 24 1.08pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

I don't want to be pessimistic, and of course it is very early days, but I didn't see any sort of quality in Franca whatsoever last night, or in his previous sub appearances...


Were you at the Etihad? I was there and thought he helped change the game when he came on with his direct play against the Citeh defence and his vision to pick out a wonderful cross field pass to Olise which enabled us to keep Citeh under pressure.

As for last night, I thought he was basically ignored by his team mates in the first 25 minutes when, on a number of occasions, he was in acres of space with the ball instead going to the other wing and quickly then lost. It's hardly encouraging for a player in his first start if your team mates won't give you the ball.

Yes he made some poor decisions but he also showed he had good close ball skills. I am sure he will improve - and quickly, as he is (according to Hodgson) a quick learner.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 05 Jan 24 1.23pm

He's played 116 minutes for us across several months and I feel like he's being written off by some posters here.

Poor bloke got bugger all service last night and did his best when he was given the ball. He'll need time to adjust to the physicality of the English game, something he is no doubt aware of now after Tarkowski clattered him.

If we're writing him off based on last night, or his last couple of performances, then perhaps we need to write the rest of the team off too as I don't know many others, bar Michael Olise, who have been world class. That includes Eze who has been dreadful since he returned from injury.

Our current system and our current manager are not designed to help young, expressive, attacking players succeed. It is a system and a manager who value conservative, discipline and organised football above anything else. That is why Jordan Ayew thrives. Because he does defensive work and gets fouled on the ball to win free kicks.

Maybe we should let him play 200 minutes for the club before we categorically decide he was a waste of money.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 05 Jan 24 1.36pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

He's played 116 minutes for us across several months and I feel like he's being written off by some posters here.

Poor bloke got bugger all service last night and did his best when he was given the ball. He'll need time to adjust to the physicality of the English game, something he is no doubt aware of now after Tarkowski clattered him.

If we're writing him off based on last night, or his last couple of performances, then perhaps we need to write the rest of the team off too as I don't know many others, bar Michael Olise, who have been world class. That includes Eze who has been dreadful since he returned from injury.

Our current system and our current manager are not designed to help young, expressive, attacking players succeed. It is a system and a manager who value conservative, discipline and organised football above anything else. That is why Jordan Ayew thrives. Because he does defensive work and gets fouled on the ball to win free kicks.

Maybe we should let him play 200 minutes for the club before we categorically decide he was a waste of money.

Agree, as with DB above.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 05 Jan 24 1.46pm

Franca's interview from l/n . . . [Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 05 Jan 24 2.28pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

I can only comment on what I know.

The medical team ‘ release ‘ players to the manager when they are deemed to be ready to return to training and therefore selection. Hodgson was advised to rest Olise soon after his return from the injury he picked up playing for France. Which he did .

I have not read anything from the medical team in which they advised Hodgson to sub Olise . If you can be bothered, please feel free to post in on here.

And maybe you could also prove that Hodgson is “ deflecting “ by sharing the medical report that you read. I’m sure we would all like to understand more.

I don’t always back Roy. If you are capable of reading my posts without the prejudice you always display towards him, that might sink in although I’m far from confident it will.

I never feel the need to explain myself to a Roy apologist as you amongst a couple of others on here won’t hear a bad word against him. Where did I say that the medical team told him to sub Olise? Roy was told to take care in his use of him. Oh and finally, do your own research I don’t make stuff up, I just quote what I’ve read online.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 05 Jan 24 2.50pm

Ive seen enough of the lad to know he will be a massive asset to the club .
Don't get the negatives ,I reckon some have been spoiled

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 05 Jan 24 3.05pm

Originally posted by Elpis

Ive seen enough of the lad to know he will be a massive asset to the club .
Don't get the negatives ,I reckon some have been spoiled

All I know is that we are a premier club severely limited by lack of shareholder funds.
Last summer we spent virtually £50m on three players none of whom started the season in the first team, and only one who has subsequently come in through injury (Henderson).

As a comparison, Fulham secured Adam Traore on a free transfer last summer age 26.
There are many others out there who we could have got for sub £10m who would have been instant starters. Ok, their salaries would have been more but they would have shored up our holes.

I dont get what we are doing. We are constantly buying in junior injured players in the hope they get fit and eventually make the first eleven. It just seems a very strange strategy.

I remain hopeful that Franca will learn and improve. But I am at odds to question what he is being taught right now. The boy showed a few nice touches and raw talent last night in a dire game of negativity. Maybe he has a future in the top leagues of football but as yet the jury is out. Is that grounds for us to spend nearly half our annual budget on? Not in my book.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 05 Jan 24 3.29pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I never feel the need to explain myself to a Roy apologist as you amongst a couple of others on here won’t hear a bad word against him. Where did I say that the medical team told him to sub Olise? Roy was told to take care in his use of him. Oh and finally, do your own research I don’t make stuff up, I just quote what I’ve read online.

Just the kind of response I was expecting from you.

As I’ve said before, I’m no Roy apologist. I’ll defend him where I think criticism is unwarranted or when I agree with his management when others don’t. That doesn’t give him a free pass on everything he does. But you don’t have it in you to understand that do you ?

You said - “ if Roy had protected him ( Olise ) as advised by his medical staff and taken him off once we had a two goal lead “ etc etc. Your words.

I’m not accusing you of making stuff up, I invited you to share content which directly contradicts what Hodgson said about the injury Olise picked up last Saturday . I’ll draw my own conclusions from your reluctance to do so.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Brinscalleagle2 Flag Brinscall 05 Jan 24 7.50pm

I guess his natural ball playing ability was the skill which Freedman must have identified as being his major asset. If that is the case then training in this area for him is likely to be less needed. Roy’s vast experience particularly in the art of adding system play and modern defensive awareness to his game will be vital for his development and he should soak up all he is being shown in order to give him a chance of succeeding in this part of the football world. He has potential but currently is nowhere near a starter.We all hope he grows physically and learns to add to his natural ability.COYP

 

Hannes Flag Vienna 05 Jan 24 8.12pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

All I know is that we are a premier club severely limited by lack of shareholder funds.
Last summer we spent virtually £50m on three players none of whom started the season in the first team, and only one who has subsequently come in through injury (Henderson).

As a comparison, Fulham secured Adam Traore on a free transfer last summer age 26.
There are many others out there who we could have got for sub £10m who would have been instant starters. Ok, their salaries would have been more but they would have shored up our holes.

I dont get what we are doing. We are constantly buying in junior injured players in the hope they get fit and eventually make the first eleven. It just seems a very strange strategy.

I remain hopeful that Franca will learn and improve. But I am at odds to question what he is being taught right now. The boy showed a few nice touches and raw talent last night in a dire game of negativity. Maybe he has a future in the top leagues of football but as yet the jury is out. Is that grounds for us to spend nearly half our annual budget on? Not in my book.

I fully agree with every word ..... unfortunately!

 

EddieMac Flag 05 Jan 24 9.36pm

Just remember Olise’s first few games. No one would have thought how he would turn out. Impossible to know how it will turn out with Franca but I feel hopeful.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 05 Jan 24 10.16pm

Sadly I elected to go to game and agree with the assessment that he was a little disappointing.

He must be showing some quality in training to have been entrusted with the corners and free kicks when he came on against Spurs and the fee requires no explanation.

Ahamada was poor but that came as no real surprise whereas Ozoh did well after IMO a difficult game against Brighton. He looks strong and showed really good recovery speed at one point.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 06 Jan 24 9.15am

Always remember, first few times we see Andy Johnson, he had nickname ‘fast but useless’ and the rest was history

Give this lad a chance, skipping passed people in the Brazilian league is obviously going to be easier than the most physical league in the world, so he needs to adjust, which is hard when you’re not playing regularly

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 06 Jan 24 12.53pm

For me, I'll probably always value the Franca transfer in the context of 'we probably could have got Jack Clarke instead'.

Season 1, we'd definitely have been better off with Clarke. I don't think that's debatable given Franca's near zero impact.

We'll see how the future goes.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 06 Jan 24 1.11pm

Originally posted by ambrose7

For me, I'll probably always value the Franca transfer in the context of 'we probably could have got Jack Clarke instead'.

Season 1, we'd definitely have been better off with Clarke. I don't think that's debatable given Franca's near zero impact.

We'll see how the future goes.

My son pointed out that our more successful signings in the last few years have been improving players from the Championship whereas the most of the players signed from abroad have had questionable impact or made slow progress - Riedewald, Sorloth, Meyer, Ahamada, Mateta. Doucoure obviously a recent exception.

 

CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE Flag bloomfield 06 Jan 24 1.37pm

Patience Eagles. Early days for someone coming from a different league, country, culture. Both Ebs and Olise needed run in periods too and they were playing English football in England already.

 

Kenteagle80 Flag Kent 06 Jan 24 1.56pm

Originally posted by monkey

Always remember, first few times we see Andy Johnson, he had nickname ‘fast but useless’ and the rest was history

Give this lad a chance, skipping passed people in the Brazilian league is obviously going to be easier than the most physical league in the world, so he needs to adjust, which is hard when you’re not playing regularly

Absolutely, I loved his energy as a kid before the goals but I remember plenty in the stand around me saying he was useless……no doubt they changed their minds in time

 

Houston Eagle Flag Houston 06 Jan 24 2.05pm

He seems to possess the main attributes to be a real quality signing which is pace and excellent close control (Don Rodgers, Wilf when younger and Michael today). He will need to add physic and gamesmanship to his natural talents and we could have a real gem! I’m not sure what the average tenure of a player at a football club is but I feel year one has been somewhat wasted for him and us with year 3 onwards a never ending click bait saga!

 

taylors lovechild Flag 06 Jan 24 2.14pm

He's clearly not the finished product but he had an almost perfect first touch, is quick and can clearly dribble. The issue on Thursday seemed to be he didn't really know where he was supposed to be and players weren't passing to him when he was open (quite common when a youngster starts). It was hard to judge him as pretty much the whole team was useless. Also, it seemed bizarre to give him his first start in a position that is new to him. Hopefully he starts again in the replay but on the left. What he needs more than anything is game time as without a run of games he is never going to get the experience he needs to grow. What does sadden me a bit is he seems to have lost that confidence that he seemed to show when he entered the club.

To write him off after so little time is just really bizarre especially when it is clear he has technical ability, but then I remember quite a lot of people saying we should sell Zaha when he was a kid as he had no end product and the same for Bolasie. Once Roy is gone I think we'll see a different player if we bring in a manager who actually coaches his forward players on how to attack and who allows space for the youngsters to make mistakes and grow.

 

Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Franca Matheus to start v Everton!?