You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace loans out
November 16 2026 2.28am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace loans out


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
palace99 Flag New Mills 10 Jan 24 11.21am

Something seems to be going wrong for our youngsters.

Both Gordon (Cambridge) and Plange (Carlisle) have been returned without setting the world alight. This is the 3rd disappointing loan Plange has now had.

Others such as Phillips at Wycombe has been in and out of the team and i think the only regular is the goalie, Goodman, at Colchester.

Phillips in particular looked highly rated and had a good loan at Shrews last year. A few Championship clubs were interested in the summer and he signed a new contract. This year he seems to have gone backwards.

Maybe they are just not good enough

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 10 Jan 24 11.40am

I think it just highlights the huge gap between youth team football and the professional league. There can of course be situations where the loan just doesn't work out for whatever reason but when it's back to back unsuccessful loans then you have to start to wonder (Plange).

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 10 Jan 24 12.30pm

A few more.

Kofi Balmer at Port Vale
Sean Grehan just gone to Carlisle
Malachi Boateng at Dundee

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 10 Jan 24 1.14pm

Originally posted by Crystal_Clear

A few more.

Kofi Balmer at Port Vale
Sean Grehan just gone to Carlisle
Malachi Boateng at Dundee


Boateng has been a regular starter at Dundee in the Scottish Premiership so has been playing at a reasonable level.

Balmer has been injured and I think he's struggling now to get game time.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 10 Jan 24 1.20pm

Doesn't fill you with hope does it.

I'm more worried about the guys that should be out but aren't. Would love to know what the plan is with:

Ebiowei
JRS
Adaramola
Franca

Not sure how sensible it is to get to the end of the season without any professional experience in any of them

Edited by MrRobbo (10 Jan 2024 1.21pm)

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 10 Jan 24 1.36pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Doesn't fill you with hope does it.

I'm more worried about the guys that should be out but aren't. Would love to know what the plan is with:

Ebiowei
JRS
Adaramola
Franca

Not sure how sensible it is to get to the end of the season without any professional experience in any of them

Edited by MrRobbo (10 Jan 2024 1.21pm)

JRS & Ahamada are rumoured to be going out in this window, or in the summer. Ola-Adebola is going to Shrewsbury & has already been seen in the stands.

Edited by eagleman13 (11 Jan 2024 9.24am)

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 10 Jan 24 2.04pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

JRS & Ahamada are rumoured to be going out in this window, or in the summer. Ola-Adebola is going to Colchester & has already been seen in the stands.

Good news! High hopes for him

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 10 Jan 24 4.27pm

Originally posted by doombear


Boateng has been a regular starter at Dundee in the Scottish Premiership so has been playing at a reasonable level.

Balmer has been injured and I think he's struggling now to get game time.

Boateng has had a few loans now. Probably not Prem class but perhaps a decent lower champ/div 1 signing.

Balmer has been unlucky with injuries - he is 23 now though so again maybe the club need to make a decision. We need to avoid another Inniss.

Ola-Adebola is going to Shrewsbury i think - good opportunity, and they need striker based on the chances they missed v Wrexham.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 10 Jan 24 4.30pm

Originally posted by samprior

I think it just highlights the huge gap between youth team football and the professional league. There can of course be situations where the loan just doesn't work out for whatever reason but when it's back to back unsuccessful loans then you have to start to wonder (Plange).

Plange is a dilemma. Cut his teeth in the Champ and we paid a cool £1m for him. Scored a hat trick in a pre season game and looked useful. Now after 3 failed loans, the last of which he was unable to get a game in a struggling Div 1 side, it is unclear where his future lies.

Maybe needs to get some confidence back playing for the U21s

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 10 Jan 24 10.15pm

Originally posted by palace99

Boateng has had a few loans now. Probably not Prem class but perhaps a decent lower champ/div 1 signing.

Balmer has been unlucky with injuries - he is 23 now though so again maybe the club need to make a decision. We need to avoid another Inniss.

Ola-Adebola is going to Shrewsbury i think - good opportunity, and they need striker based on the chances they missed v Wrexham.


That's my understanding - not Colchester.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 11 Jan 24 9.25am

Originally posted by doombear


That's my understanding - not Colchester.

Cheers DB, I have corrected my post, God knows why I thought it was Colchester.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Jan 24 9.28am

Aporos Shrewsbury, last season both Killian Phillips and Rob Street were loaned to the club when Steve Cotterill was the manager.

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 12 Jan 24 4.15pm

As Rak-Sakyi did, lighting up League 1 at the age of 20 is probably the lowest acceptable performance for a player who could have a lengthy Premier League career.

If you're in/out of a mid-table League 1 side at the age of 21+, we may as well be moving that player on. At best they could be a bit part player for us but nothing to get excited about.

When he was Ola-Adebomi's current age, Olise had been bought by Palace - he had already done it in the Championship. Marc Guehi was in a 40 game season at Swansea in the top 6.

Doesn't appear to be anything special in this 19-21 group and Ozoh seems to be the genuine prospect in the 17-19 group. Maybe Derry or Marsh could come through, but they need to have a big 18 months from now.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 12 Jan 24 4.35pm

Originally posted by ambrose7

As Rak-Sakyi did, lighting up League 1 at the age of 20 is probably the lowest acceptable performance for a player who could have a lengthy Premier League career.

If you're in/out of a mid-table League 1 side at the age of 21+, we may as well be moving that player on. At best they could be a bit part player for us but nothing to get excited about.

When he was Ola-Adebomi's current age, Olise had been bought by Palace - he had already done it in the Championship. Marc Guehi was in a 40 game season at Swansea in the top 6.

Doesn't appear to be anything special in this 19-21 group and Ozoh seems to be the genuine prospect in the 17-19 group. Maybe Derry or Marsh could come through, but they need to have a big 18 months from now.

Fully agree. Basically we have Ozoh and JRS as possible PL players for us. The only other possibility is Malachi Boateng but that depends on the extent of the gulf between the Scottish and English top leagues. There clearly is one but as he'has been a regular starter we should give him the benefit of th doubt until he shows otherwise in pre-season.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 12 Jan 24 4.45pm

Originally posted by ambrose7

As Rak-Sakyi did, lighting up League 1 at the age of 20 is probably the lowest acceptable performance for a player who could have a lengthy Premier League career.

If you're in/out of a mid-table League 1 side at the age of 21+, we may as well be moving that player on. At best they could be a bit part player for us but nothing to get excited about.

When he was Ola-Adebomi's current age, Olise had been bought by Palace - he had already done it in the Championship. Marc Guehi was in a 40 game season at Swansea in the top 6.

Doesn't appear to be anything special in this 19-21 group and Ozoh seems to be the genuine prospect in the 17-19 group. Maybe Derry or Marsh could come through, but they need to have a big 18 months from now.

the only thing i would add to that is that some players clearly develop later than others, so we shouldn't be writing everyone off just because they haven't played 50 leagues games by 21.

Gareth Southgate only became a regular at 22 and ended up getting over 50 caps for England.

Others such as Rooney and Ferguson at BHA were physically grown men at 16, whereas say JRS still has some way to go.

Harry Kane had a few dodgy loans before he came good, so we need to take that into account too, however, with say Plange that is now 3 in a row, so maybe there is something wrong and/or he just isn't that good.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Jan 24 5.32pm

Originally posted by ambrose7

As Rak-Sakyi did, lighting up League 1 at the age of 20 is probably the lowest acceptable performance for a player who could have a lengthy Premier League career.

If you're in/out of a mid-table League 1 side at the age of 21+, we may as well be moving that player on. At best they could be a bit part player for us but nothing to get excited about.

When he was Ola-Adebomi's current age, Olise had been bought by Palace - he had already done it in the Championship. Marc Guehi was in a 40 game season at Swansea in the top 6.

Doesn't appear to be anything special in this 19-21 group and Ozoh seems to be the genuine prospect in the 17-19 group. Maybe Derry or Marsh could come through, but they need to have a big 18 months from now.

Late development does happen in a minority of cases but I think this is a sensible analysis.

We are developing professionals but it's always going to be a reality that a top quality premiership player is a relative rarity. However, Zaha was a transformative player for us and without the academy it's less likely that would have happened.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 12 Jan 24 5.38pm

Originally posted by palace99

the only thing i would add to that is that some players clearly develop later than others, so we shouldn't be writing everyone off just because they haven't played 50 leagues games by 21.

Gareth Southgate only became a regular at 22 and ended up getting over 50 caps for England.

Others such as Rooney and Ferguson at BHA were physically grown men at 16, whereas say JRS still has some way to go.

Harry Kane had a few dodgy loans before he came good, so we need to take that into account too, however, with say Plange that is now 3 in a row, so maybe there is something wrong and/or he just isn't that good.

It's not a rule without any exception albeit I'm struggling to think of them. Much easier to think of those that developed early than couldn't get in a League 1 side at 20/21 and made it.

Harry Kane actually got 21 Premier League goals in the season when he was 21 which is Plange's current age, and only 1 year older than Kymani-Gordon and Ola-Adebomi. The loans are a touch unfair too - he got 9 in 27 at Millwall in the Championship when he was 18.

Palace haven't got a first team outfield player who wasn't playing either bit part PL or every week, genuinely contributing lower level football at the age of 20/21.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 12 Jan 24 7.18pm

Originally posted by palace99

Something seems to be going wrong for our youngsters.

Both Gordon (Cambridge) and Plange (Carlisle) have been returned without setting the world alight. This is the 3rd disappointing loan Plange has now had.

Others such as Phillips at Wycombe has been in and out of the team and i think the only regular is the goalie, Goodman, at Colchester.

Phillips in particular looked highly rated and had a good loan at Shrews last year. A few Championship clubs were interested in the summer and he signed a new contract. This year he seems to have gone backwards.

Maybe they are just not good enough

This is what I keep saying, people keep banging on about giving youth a chance, well just maybe they’re not good enough. Especially once they start sending them out on loan, no matter how much they big them up saying it’ll help with their progress, it’s usually the first sign that they’ve got no chance of making it big time with us and eventually they’ll be gone permanently to the lower or non leagues

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Jan 24 7.26pm

Originally posted by palace99

the only thing i would add to that is that some players clearly develop later than others, so we shouldn't be writing everyone off just because they haven't played 50 leagues games by 21.

Gareth Southgate only became a regular at 22 and ended up getting over 50 caps for England.

Others such as Rooney and Ferguson at BHA were physically grown men at 16, whereas say JRS still has some way to go.

Harry Kane had a few dodgy loans before he came good, so we need to take that into account too, however, with say Plange that is now 3 in a row, so maybe there is something wrong and/or he just isn't that good.

His first loan spell was at L.Orient signed by Russell Slade.
Nigel Pearson signed him for Leicester and at the club at that time was Jeffrey Schlupp and Neil Danns.

I believe that as a youngster Kane was rejected by Arsenal for being too portly and not that fleet of foot.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 15 Jan 24 9.22am

Originally posted by ambrose7

It's not a rule without any exception albeit I'm struggling to think of them. Much easier to think of those that developed early than couldn't get in a League 1 side at 20/21 and made it.

Harry Kane actually got 21 Premier League goals in the season when he was 21 which is Plange's current age, and only 1 year older than Kymani-Gordon and Ola-Adebomi. The loans are a touch unfair too - he got 9 in 27 at Millwall in the Championship when he was 18.

Palace haven't got a first team outfield player who wasn't playing either bit part PL or every week, genuinely contributing lower level football at the age of 20/21.

for accuracy, Harry Kane was 18 when loaned to Orient and was 19 when at Millwall. He then had 2 pretty unsuccessful spells at Norwich and Leicester before he made an impact at Spurs.

Edited by palace99 (15 Jan 2024 9.23am)

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace loans out