You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Everton vs. Crystal Palace match thread
November 16 2026 2.28am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Everton vs. Crystal Palace match thread


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 18 Jan 24 7.39am

Originally posted by PatrickA

We’ve never had any sort of cup run under Hodgson.
Therefore over roughly 5 seasons we’ve more or less thrown the towel in on 10 competitions(FA Cup and Carabo Cup).
Personally I’m uneasy with this.
Had we won last night we would have had a home draw v Luton and the opportunity of a proper cup run.
Have people already forgotten the excitement and feel good factor of the cup run a couple of seasons ago that took us to the semi final?

One of the posters said sagely before that game that Hodgson would set us up to achieve a narrow defeat and it certainly had that feel about it.
Does anyone seriously think that the lame defeat yesterday will leave us better equipped to face Arsenal?
I envisage another defeat with the excuse being made that we had a tough game a few days before.
Even if one accepts the argument about the squad not being particularly strong, there’s no excuse for not giving it our best shot e.g giving it a go with both Edouard and Mateta on at the same time, by not playing four players out of position.
No doubt the excuses will continue, but I’m told that’s not just 6 wins in 26 games.
That speaks for itself.

Ive forgotten the excitement and feel good factor of football full stop since he's been manager.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 18 Jan 24 7.43am

This is Roys 5th attempt at the cup here. Four third round exits but a run to the 6th rd once which included games against Grimsby and Doncaster. He's no fan of the cup

 

mtp1958 Flag Oswestry 18 Jan 24 7.44am

when was the last game you all see on a freezing cold night that was a exciting game , most of the prem cup games have been crap and im getting that from there supporters ,

Roy done right with the subs 5 players taken off have all had injurys , and we could play all out football and get slaughtered ever game then relegation and then supporters complain about we shouldnt have do all out attack , cant win .

we had won 3-0 people on here still would complain and say nothing todo with Roys picks and set up , yes i would love a cup run but we are building be it slowly a very good team of players ,

Arsenal cant score nor can we , has arteta sent up Arsenal wrong maybe , can see us getting a result there so resting players was right

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 18 Jan 24 7.48am

Originally posted by slubglurge

This is Roys 5th attempt at the cup here. Four third round exits but a run to the 6th rd once which included games against Grimsby and Doncaster. He's no fan of the cup

You could argue he’s no fan of football, just dour results fulfilling a need. We could do with some fresh ideas in this team before they stifle themselves into relegation problems and the Championship.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 18 Jan 24 8.18am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

I actually said to my mate last night (a WH fan) whilst trying not to sound bitter (lol)- Everton break the Profit & Sustainability rules, get found out & penalized in the league, but are able to use the same squad value that contributed to the financial discretion to compete in the cups -

Well it’s true isn’t it. It’s why these 10 point deductions are handied out

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Jan 24 8.18am

Originally posted by monkey

I can’t make you out Willo, Sheffield Utd on a freezing cold Tuesday night in January? What’s not to like?

Not forgetting the 4 hour round trip in the dark from/to my abode on the south coast.

I envisage myself imbibing some alcoholic refreshments in a local Public House with certain employees and customers in a state of shock due to my presence in this establishment rather than at Selhurst Park.

 

Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 18 Jan 24 8.36am

Originally posted by EagleinSF

Originally posted by robdave2k

Johnstone/Henderson

Anderson/Guehi
Dacoure/Lerma/Eze/Olise


That’s a solid core.

Last I checked you can't play 2 keepers, Dacoure and Olise are injured. Not such a solid core really.


You can you know! Last week Arbroath brought their substitute keeper on to play up front because they had no one else on the bench when the striker got injured. He scored a worldly from 40 yards out. Maybe that’s the answer! [Link]

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 18 Jan 24 8.48am

Originally posted by Palacesince64


You can you know! Last week Arbroath brought their substitute keeper on to play up front because they had no one else on the bench when the striker got injured. He scored a worldly from 40 yards out. Maybe that’s the answer! [Link]

Sign him up as a striker

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 18 Jan 24 8.52am

Originally posted by Willo

Not forgetting the 4 hour round trip in the dark from/to my abode on the south coast.

I envisage myself imbibing some alcoholic refreshments in a local Public House with certain employees and customers in a state of shock due to my presence in this establishment rather than at Selhurst Park.

Similar to me coming up from Kent, I know how you feel, if I still lived in Bromley or South Norwood, no matter how grim it got, I just couldn’t keep away, but now with the trek up, sometimes I just think sod that, especially n December and January…….but other than that I’m pretty loyal

 

martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 18 Jan 24 9.05am

Originally posted by mtp1958

when was the last game you all see on a freezing cold night that was a exciting game , most of the prem cup games have been crap and im getting that from there supporters ,

Roy done right with the subs 5 players taken off have all had injurys , and we could play all out football and get slaughtered ever game then relegation and then supporters complain about we shouldnt have do all out attack , cant win .

we had won 3-0 people on here still would complain and say nothing todo with Roys picks and set up , yes i would love a cup run but we are building be it slowly a very good team of players ,

Arsenal cant score nor can we , has arteta sent up Arsenal wrong maybe , can see us getting a result there so resting players was right

Skybet are offering 10/1 for Palace to beat Arsenal on Saturday. Let us know how much you're sticking on.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 18 Jan 24 9.27am

Hodgson, as Palace manager at least, doesn't do Cup games. The evidence is out there, and the approach must have the full approval of Parish - the league takes utmost precedence.
As I've said before, the team is the image of the manager.
On a happier note I recommend watching the highlights of the AFCON games, the ball goes forward most of the time.

 

1969eagle Flag manchester 18 Jan 24 9.35am

5 man defence plus 2 defensive midfield players set out Roys usual intent. But despite that we still should have comfortably won. Their keeper made great saves and we missed several. Guehi was great going forward in the end. And Ahamada. Eze had 2 good runs but spent the rest of the evening losing possession. Andersen lost his passing touch for once. Lerma is a great combative midfielder but next to useless going forward. Clyne had the best game I have seen. Johnstone is much more reliable than Henderson it seems to me. Ozoh and Franca got 20 mins each but didn't do much. They are both fine players and need more game time. Richards has the makings of a fine combative centre half but is really nervous in possession. The midfield experiment needs to be replaced by an incoming loan. Frustrating night. A game we could have won easily with a more positive approach.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 18 Jan 24 9.44am

We face the ignominy of being beaten 3 times by one mediocre team in one season. However...

...the last time I recall this happened, it was Watford. I also seem to recall they went down that season and we did not.

Screw the Cup. This season is all about safe mid table till we get someone more exiting to manage.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 18 Jan 24 9.45am

Originally posted by 1969eagle

5 man defence plus 2 defensive midfield players set out Roys usual intent. But despite that we still should have comfortably won. Their keeper made great saves and we missed several. Guehi was great going forward in the end. And Ahamada. Eze had 2 good runs but spent the rest of the evening losing possession. Andersen lost his passing touch for once. Lerma is a great combative midfielder but next to useless going forward. Clyne had the best game I have seen. Johnstone is much more reliable than Henderson it seems to me. Ozoh and Franca got 20 mins each but didn't do much. They are both fine players and need more game time. Richards has the makings of a fine combative centre half but is really nervous in possession. The midfield experiment needs to be replaced by an incoming loan. Frustrating night. A game we could have won easily with a more positive approach.

Thanks for that insight, I find it far more useful than any media corporation's commentary when a fan posts about our games. Perhaps not all doom and gloom then but as you say, the team and therefore performances/results reflect the manager... who IMHO reflects the board.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Jan 24 9.52am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Thanks for that insight, I find it far more useful than any media corporation's commentary when a fan posts about our games. Perhaps not all doom and gloom then but as you say, the team and therefore performances/results reflect the manager... who IMHO reflects the board.

In the final analysis we were defeated and never scored against Everton in either FA Cup game.In actual fact privately I was asked about our prospects before the game last night and my message was "Loss without scoring".

The grand total of 2 victories in our last 15 games with some abject performances along the way, have really tried the patience of many a supporter.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 18 Jan 24 11.47am

Seems the media have picked up on l/n 'discontent' with our fans & what/why plus who they(the i) think we should have in charge . . . [Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

The Dolphin Flag 18 Jan 24 11.52am

Good article - it sums everything up very nicely.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 18 Jan 24 11.58am

Originally posted by eagleman13

Seems the media have picked up on l/n 'discontent' with our fans & what/why plus who they(the i) think we should have in charge . . . [Link]

This is a direct copy and paste from the article:

"The final point is a particular bone of contention. Palace have not started a player aged below 21 in the Premier League this season. Two years ago, Palace had the oldest squad in the Premier League and despite promising to lower that, they still have the fourth oldest.

When Franca, Jesurun Rak-Sakyi and Ahamada were brought off the bench against Tottenham in late October, Hodgson publicly said: “They didn’t do anything for us”. He later apologised but has still not made any effort to integrate the young talents."

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Martin 78 Flag Caterham 18 Jan 24 12.35pm

I was there last night thought we played quite well despite the usual defensive line up.Our strikers missed some good chances and they scored from a brilliant free kick.Disappointed he took Eze off and other negative subbs to ‘save’ them for the weekend.I would have taken a win last night over any result against Arsenal.Well done to the 500 or so who went we made more noise than them awful home support from a big crowd in a cup tie.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 18 Jan 24 12.39pm

Originally posted by Martin 78

I was there last night thought we played quite well despite the usual defensive line up.Our strikers missed some good chances and they scored from a brilliant free kick.Disappointed he took Eze off and other negative subbs to ‘save’ them for the weekend.I would have taken a win last night over any result against Arsenal.Well done to the 500 or so who went we made more noise than them awful home support from a big crowd in a cup tie.

Yes, including yourself Martin.

I couldn't nor wouldn't want to have gone but unreserved admiration and respect for those that did.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Everton vs. Crystal Palace match thread