You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What has happened/is going to happen?
November 16 2026 2.29am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

What has happened/is going to happen?


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 20 Jan 24 7.15pm

Apologies for yet another thread but this is a genuine attempt to look at the whole thing holistically and provoke some insight/thought/answers:

This is all conjecture of course however it does look as though it’s either catastrophically/severely bad judgement from our board or there is no money whatsoever:

- I don’t know if other fans feel similarly, and yes FFP and all that jazz, but I wouldn’t recognise any other PL team (of reasonable duration) to spend as little money/bring in so few players as we do.

- If there is so little money, you lose your best player (possibly of all time) and you have gaps in the first team, why the f**k would you spend the little you have on back up goalies/CBs and young players who aren’t even going to be given the chance to play in the first team let alone may not bring any value in the first instance? A literal question as it seems incredibly f**king stupid and did at the time.

- There must be some recognition that ‘football has moved on’. So why continue to employ a manager whose singular identity is play as suffocating and antiquated football as possible? Perhaps that’s all we can hope for as we don’t buy players nor have the money for a manager however he’s now proving he can’t even do that effectively. We might have got draws against the Manchester clubs but elsewhere and last dozen games it’s been as bad as possible.

- Why come out and talk about ‘Top 10’ etc (Parish) if you know you can’t fund anything but the mitigation of a descent? Is it a deliberate tempt of fate or winding up of fans?

I can get quite miffed but I do make an effort to not jump on ‘Roy/Parish out’ bandwagons spontaneously, plus I do reserve something for my ignorance on management/running a club, but I’ve no further energy for their excuses and what feels like blatant falsehoods deliberately told to pacify fans who would be, and rightly are, angry with the reality.

This isn’t hindsight, I’d of said at the end of last season: we need to look for the next manager, scout some wing backs plus a replacement for Wilf and perhaps see if there are any GK’s available on the cheap who could could be decent stand-ins. That’s all before doing anything positive beyond plugging gaps. None of this has happened. I assumed it meant there was another plan in place and this season was just a ‘muddle through’ but it’s looking an absolute sh!tshow now and that’s not down to a couple of injuries.

Parish has been extremely quiet, Roy seems to bite back at all the objectively deserved criticism he receives, the players are rightly unhappy and the fans on the precipice of eruption. The only positive I can foresee is a couple signings, some sort of statement from Parish and a result in the next game. I don’t see any of those as likely let alone guaranteed however.

Were the Americans only brought in to provide some bailout when the last cohort all simultaneously ran out of legs/retired etc but are now a huge hinder/not interested?

Is the feeling of panic, despair and anger justified?

Are we in fact absolutely skint? If so what is/was the plan?

Is our race run? Is that just the reality and we’ve never moved on from miracles and a bit of staying power?

There have already been rumblings and Everton seemed at the very least a look to provoke a reaction which we got, a 5-0 loss. What has gone so badly wrong and is there any hope left for us?

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Painter Flag Croydon 20 Jan 24 7.20pm

Another thread saying the same that has been posted before, whats the point?

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 20 Jan 24 7.23pm

Originally posted by Painter

Another thread saying the same that has been posted before, whats the point?

It’s just I never notice you post much beyond whining at other posters and I don’t want you to get bored.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 20 Jan 24 7.32pm

Go back five months and this board was full of fans/posters/bulls*** merchants claiming this was a great team / squad when it patently isn't.

There are four really good outfield players and the rest are limited even by Championship standards. It's the worst since 2013 and Parish & co have gambled on the promoted teams not being good enough.

We're the worst fans in the League for overrating our players.

Edited because my initial thoughts were too direct and and not aimed at the OP

Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (20 Jan 2024 7.36pm)

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 20 Jan 24 7.40pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Go back five months and this board was full of fans/posters/bulls*** merchants claiming this was a great team / squad when it patently isn't.

There are four really good outfield players and the rest are limited even by Championship standards. It's the worst since 2013 and Parish & co have gambled on the promoted teams not being good enough.

If you couldn't see this coming then you should pack up watching football.

We're the worst fans in the League for overrating our players.

Seems harsh, not sure I agree on ‘worst since 2013’ and ‘worst fans for overrating players’ but that’s of little concern and the rest I agree with.

As to how good the players are, I was reasonable in my assessment however we only had about 6/7 PL quality players and one left. That makes the lack of and any actual spending we did even more bizarre though, albeit I thought the board were gambling on us being ‘OK’ previously.

We look far from OK though, and anything being done to change that does not look imminent. It’s quite hard to gauge what the outcome in the near future will be, beyond our continual plummet.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 20 Jan 24 7.55pm

Aplogies Nicholas I realised it was bit reactionary and unfair hence my editorial above.

But I think there's a lot whose assessment at the start of the season has proven way off not least Roy who must be bitterly regretting towing the Palace media line at the time.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 20 Jan 24 8.01pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Aplogies Nicholas I realised it was bit reactionary and unfair hence my editorial above.

But I think there's a lot whose assessment at the start of the season has proven way off not least Roy who must be bitterly regretting towing the Palace media line at the time.

No problem at all! I realise emotions are high.

And agree again, I’m glad someone has said something about Roy as I have a suspicion much of what he says is out of loyalty to perhaps Steve but more so perhaps to just not rock the boat any further.

It is sort of the point of my thread, rather than picking on everything individually I am trying to look at the big picture. Much has gone wrong including, I believe, the assumption we’d be fine. It’s just the lack of comment and action from the club I’m pondering - Will there be one? Is it coming? Are they able to do anything? Nervous times.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Croydon-Trucker Flag 20 Jan 24 8.25pm

Yes it would be good manners for Mr Parish to make something in the way of a statement as to what is happening behind the scenes, and what the plan is going forward instead of spouting the same old bullshivte he does every window " we tried to get a few across the line but ran out of time " or " we are working hard to get the deals done " ect ect .. What ever happened to " if you stand still in this league you're going backwards " We have gone backwaards !! We deserve to know what is going on . What is a club with no fans .

 

Painter Flag Croydon 20 Jan 24 9.08pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

It’s just I never notice you post much beyond whining at other posters and I don’t want you to get bored.

I tend to take a more pragmatic view. This whole season has gone tits up, because of Eze, Olise and Zaha. When Roy reappeared last season, all 3 were fit and flying, so we played attractive football and everyone was happy.
Then Olise got injured playing for France U21s only played about 5 games since. Eze got injured twice and has missed a lot of games. Zaha kept us hanging on a string about whether he would resign, apparently indicated he would, then changed his mind.
So Roy has had to revert to type and grind out result, as his 3 stars from last year arent available. None is Roys fault or Parish except for not telling Zaha to resign by 1st July or piss off.

 

Brinscalleagle2 Flag Brinscall 20 Jan 24 10.15pm

.I did not know which thread to comment on with all the meltdown going on at the moment so I chose this one as the title suits the situation the best.
As far as I remember Roy was a last resort appointment for this season and cannot be blamed for taking on the poison chalice . He had reason to be confident in last seasons performance and the possibility of adding players to move the team forward.In my view the problem was the board were unable to get the manager that fulfilled their vision of moving forward and clamped down on spending as they wanted to use the funds for their chosen manager to utilise. Spending on promising youngsters for the future would present no risk hence Franca and Henderson. At this point there is no suggestion wewould be in danger of relegation. Fast forward and injuries occur to all of our most influential players outside of the back four. This results in us having to be reactive rather than proactive which is fine as we have in Roy the ideal manager to handle this predicament.A section of our fans however are dissatisfied with our style and perceived points tally culminating in the displays shown today. The Club now has only one objective don’t get relegated so how do they achieve this and as a secondary consideration keep the fans on side. There is no point in taking on a new manager which does not fit their forward plans unless he is available now just to placate the fans but if he is available get him in now. If not then we already have the manager in place who is equipped to see the season through but they must support him with player additions to achieve it. The choice is with the Board get it wrong and they only have themselves to blame. Roy is not the cause of this situation but a victim of the situation along with us fans who have to witness the style of football needed to see out the season avoiding relegation. It will be interesting to see which way they turn but in my view either way an influx of new players now is key whoever the manager is.COYP

 

radicalsteve Flag ottawa 20 Jan 24 10.16pm

Lot of truth in this, particularly being so dependant on Wilf for many years, however it also points to having a very shallow squad as injuries are always going to happen and we have not got the dosh to deepen the squad and our promotable academy players are not getting the chance to replace the mediocrity of players like Schlupp, Hughes and Lerma, none of who are adding value on the pitch.

Still, there are better managers than Roy who would get more out of the team and at least be more tactically driven. Now we are just canon fodder for 19 other teams. Hard to think we can persist with this set up and survive. Should never have allowed Roy the chance to embarrass himself and the club this season - poor leadership decision making at the top.

Originally posted by Painter

I tend to take a more pragmatic view. This whole season has gone tits up, because of Eze, Olise and Zaha. When Roy reappeared last season, all 3 were fit and flying, so we played attractive football and everyone was happy.
Then Olise got injured playing for France U21s only played about 5 games since. Eze got injured twice and has missed a lot of games. Zaha kept us hanging on a string about whether he would resign, apparently indicated he would, then changed his mind.
So Roy has had to revert to type and grind out result, as his 3 stars from last year arent available. None is Roys fault or Parish except for not telling Zaha to resign by 1st July or piss off.

Edited by radicalsteve (20 Jan 2024 10.17pm)

 

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 20 Jan 24 11.20pm

I think realistically many things have happened and in time many things will happen.

Sadly evolution has not been all it's cracked up to be as we have failed to learn from what has happened and have a seeming inability to influence what is to come.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 21 Jan 24 6.30am

I feel that Roy (2nd time around) was only a placeholder to steady the ship / keep us in the PL until we -

a) Get the main stand built (which increases the stadium capacity & therefore revenue, which helps us with profit & sustainability)
b) Lower the salary / revenue %age (83% down to 64% down to ?
c) Complete the academy / sports science upgrade (soon ?)

The underlying feeling of the shareholders at the start of the season being that the current squad should be good enough to carry us through until the summer window when the main stand construction begins & the other 2 targets are sorted - Obviously injuries have thrown a spanner in the works.

At the risk of stating the obvious - the big question is what do we do next with a little over a week of the transfer window left,
Effectively its stick or twist with the manager & the transfer window - those are big decisions, SP will earn his money on Monday morning & only history will dictate whether he made the right decisions.


 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 21 Jan 24 8.18am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

I feel that Roy (2nd time around) was only a placeholder to steady the ship / keep us in the PL until we -

a) Get the main stand built (which increases the stadium capacity & therefore revenue, which helps us with profit & sustainability)
b) Lower the salary / revenue %age (83% down to 64% down to ?
c) Complete the academy / sports science upgrade (soon ?)

The underlying feeling of the shareholders at the start of the season being that the current squad should be good enough to carry us through until the summer window when the main stand construction begins & the other 2 targets are sorted - Obviously injuries have thrown a spanner in the works.

At the risk of stating the obvious - the big question is what do we do next with a little over a week of the transfer window left,
Effectively its stick or twist with the manager & the transfer window - those are big decisions, SP will earn his money on Monday morning & only history will dictate whether he made the right decisions.


That’s a quicker way of what I was trying to get at DE, also:

Brinscall: That’s why I started the thread to be a more generic, all encompassing conversation.

Painter: That’s more like it! Completely agree as I thought there was an expectation for Eze and/or Olise to become our new Zaha. Never understood any Wilf bashing from Palace fans, he carried us for a decade. We are once again in a situation where we are utterly dependent on one/two players otherwise we begin looking like a semi-professional outfit.

I’ve seen posts on other threads which have essentially alluded to the same thing - We have become a business model and that has taken absolute precedence over footballing concerns (I also started a thread on that). Problem remains that the model is now under sincere threat.

I wouldn’t underestimate the Board’s inclination to just keep everything as is, relying upon Eze/Olise returning, three worse teams and Roy somehow steering us to safety. That’s the cheapest therefore most preferable option. My hope though is that a bit of panic has been instilled and they at least buy some players, which would need to happen in any instance, as just changing manager would almost certainly not be enough.

Edited by Nicholas91 (21 Jan 2024 8.20am)

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 21 Jan 24 8.54am

I think our present problems are a result of a series of bad decisions made last summer.

* the assumption that Zaha was going to stay . My suggestion of giving him a deadline to make up his mind was not met with widespread enthusiasm on here, but he left at the eleventh hour and the club failed to replace him. It was also known at that time that Olise had an injury likely to keep him out for some time
* the assumption that the squad had sufficient depth of quality. Far from having Top Ten potential, the more pertinent question would be to gauge if it was enough to even achieve our usual mid table spot. Factor in a couple of inevitable injuries….
* the signings of Henderson and Franca. Henderson still makes little sense to me. Could we not have identified a decent back up for Johnstone without eating so much into our limited transfer budget ? Franca looks like one for the future, but not for the now. Forget the hefty transfer fee, if he had come through the Academy would you not be thinking, has potential but raw and not ready yet ?
It all feeds into a lack of coherent and structured approach to player recruitment and fee developing strategy.
* re-appointing Roy. To me that was a Red Flag as to the extent of this seasons ambition. I think this is one of those “ weak decisions “ referred to yesterday at the Emirates. As Roy said, ultimately it’s the manager that carry’s the can for poor results and while I don’t hold him solely responsible for our predicament, he’s appearing increasingly like somebody that wants his future decided for him. Which leaves Parish in a position that I’m sure he didn’t want to be in, trying to find a new manager in mid season.

The club feels like a ship without a captain at the moment. A real lack of inspirational leadership on and off the field.

I think the problems start at the top, at Board level. So the what next should start there too, but more likely it won’t. It’s more likely to be a new manager. But I suspect that once again we will be appointing someone that was not first choice but who is available.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 21 Jan 24 9.07am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I think our present problems are a result of a series of bad decisions made last summer.

* the assumption that Zaha was going to stay . My suggestion of giving him a deadline to make up his mind was not met with widespread enthusiasm on here, but he left at the eleventh hour and the club failed to replace him. It was also known at that time that Olise had an injury likely to keep him out for some time
* the assumption that the squad had sufficient depth of quality. Far from having Top Ten potential, the more pertinent question would be to gauge if it was enough to even achieve our usual mid table spot. Factor in a couple of inevitable injuries….
* the signings of Henderson and Franca. Henderson still makes little sense to me. Could we not have identified a decent back up for Johnstone without eating so much into our limited transfer budget ? Franca looks like one for the future, but not for the now. Forget the hefty transfer fee, if he had come through the Academy would you not be thinking, has potential but raw and not ready yet ?
It all feeds into a lack of coherent and structured approach to player recruitment and fee developing strategy.
* re-appointing Roy. To me that was a Red Flag as to the extent of this seasons ambition. I think this is one of those “ weak decisions “ referred to yesterday at the Emirates. As Roy said, ultimately it’s the manager that carry’s the can for poor results and while I don’t hold him solely responsible for our predicament, he’s appearing increasingly like somebody that wants his future decided for him. Which leaves Parish in a position that I’m sure he didn’t want to be in, trying to find a new manager in mid season.

The club feels like a ship without a captain at the moment. A real lack of inspirational leadership on and off the field.

I think the problems start at the top, at Board level. So the what next should start there too, but more likely it won’t. It’s more likely to be a new manager. But I suspect that once again we will be appointing someone that was not first choice but who is available.

Agree with everything.

The lack of leadership from board room down to the pitch is the most worrying thing.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

southnorwoodhill Flag 21 Jan 24 9.17am

What happened? We were promoted, we survived. We've not really progressed since.
Recruitment in general has been poor. Despite some big transfers and big wages back then I can only think of one player of extra class that made a difference and was worth the investment: Cabaye.
Over reliance on one player, Zaha.
We've not had a genuine striker since the days of Murray.
A number of managers have come and gone, whilst Roy is in his fifth season - doesn't this speak volumes? 14th place is good enough for the board, and it should be for you fans as well, you've never had it so good.
What is going to happen? Entropy. The gradual decline is already underway. Can it be halted? Not by doing the same things that led us here.
All things go in cycles, it could well be that we are near to completing ours in the PL and a return to the Championship beckons, if not this season then likely next.
We have a very patchy side made up of players of varying ability. Some are mediocre, some are just ordinary. Only Olise stands out as being exceptional, yet he is injured.
We have a manager who, imho has lost the plot entirely. Not only are his team selections dully predictable, his statements are increasingly disconcerting.
I am genuinely curious who the new manager is to be and what is expected of him to stop the rot, and the means at his disposal.
All this without mention of the shareholders, financial situation, the new stand etc.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 21 Jan 24 9.32am

Do we expect Roy to be incharge against Sheff Utd, and do we expect any new signings to be playing in that game.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 21 Jan 24 9.44am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Do we expect Roy to be incharge against Sheff Utd, and do we expect any new signings to be playing in that game.

Yes & no

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 21 Jan 24 9.58am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Apologies for yet another thread but this is a genuine attempt to look at the whole thing holistically and provoke some insight/thought/answers:

This is all conjecture of course however it does look as though it’s either catastrophically/severely bad judgement from our board or there is no money whatsoever:

- I don’t know if other fans feel similarly, and yes FFP and all that jazz, but I wouldn’t recognise any other PL team (of reasonable duration) to spend as little money/bring in so few players as we do.

- If there is so little money, you lose your best player (possibly of all time) and you have gaps in the first team, why the f**k would you spend the little you have on back up goalies/CBs and young players who aren’t even going to be given the chance to play in the first team let alone may not bring any value in the first instance? A literal question as it seems incredibly f**king stupid and did at the time.

- There must be some recognition that ‘football has moved on’. So why continue to employ a manager whose singular identity is play as suffocating and antiquated football as possible? Perhaps that’s all we can hope for as we don’t buy players nor have the money for a manager however he’s now proving he can’t even do that effectively. We might have got draws against the Manchester clubs but elsewhere and last dozen games it’s been as bad as possible.

- Why come out and talk about ‘Top 10’ etc (Parish) if you know you can’t fund anything but the mitigation of a descent? Is it a deliberate tempt of fate or winding up of fans?

I can get quite miffed but I do make an effort to not jump on ‘Roy/Parish out’ bandwagons spontaneously, plus I do reserve something for my ignorance on management/running a club, but I’ve no further energy for their excuses and what feels like blatant falsehoods deliberately told to pacify fans who would be, and rightly are, angry with the reality.

This isn’t hindsight, I’d of said at the end of last season: we need to look for the next manager, scout some wing backs plus a replacement for Wilf and perhaps see if there are any GK’s available on the cheap who could could be decent stand-ins. That’s all before doing anything positive beyond plugging gaps. None of this has happened. I assumed it meant there was another plan in place and this season was just a ‘muddle through’ but it’s looking an absolute sh!tshow now and that’s not down to a couple of injuries.

Parish has been extremely quiet, Roy seems to bite back at all the objectively deserved criticism he receives, the players are rightly unhappy and the fans on the precipice of eruption. The only positive I can foresee is a couple signings, some sort of statement from Parish and a result in the next game. I don’t see any of those as likely let alone guaranteed however.

Were the Americans only brought in to provide some bailout when the last cohort all simultaneously ran out of legs/retired etc but are now a huge hinder/not interested?

Is the feeling of panic, despair and anger justified?

Are we in fact absolutely skint? If so what is/was the plan?

Is our race run? Is that just the reality and we’ve never moved on from miracles and a bit of staying power?

There have already been rumblings and Everton seemed at the very least a look to provoke a reaction which we got, a 5-0 loss. What has gone so badly wrong and is there any hope left for us?

Firtstly Nicholas an excellent post and indeed the replies. There comes a time when you are found out and I think our time is here. Clearly we are reliant on Textor and co’s cash and all being able to be on the same page. If the media reports are true this is now not the case which, will inevitably affect the running of the club. For the good of CPFC the board need to sit down and have a grown up conversation and resolve the issues and quickly.
There is seemingly no recruitment plan and this goes back years. I would love to know what our scouting network is I.e where we find rough diamonds for decent money and polish them up. Given the results of this I doubt it extends much beyond Google! When you look at Brighton (very sorry to say) it is clear they have something we can only dream of and bringing players through from the academy …. The centre forward Ewan ?? springs to mind. They can do it so why can’t we??

We don’t seem to think ahead, no strategic planning and because of this we are forever working hand to mouth and doing our transfer window shopping in Aldi at 9.45pm. Saying all this we must be careful what we wish for in wanting SP out ….. Reading FC!!

Finally, the manager, a previous post said that good managers improve players and sorry Roy but this isn’t happening and I also believe that you have lost the dressing room. Lots of things to put right and it needs strong leadership from the top to right the ship.

 


Bring back Brolin

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What has happened/is going to happen?