This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Why should the taxpayer be subsidising the richest in society to go to better schools than everyone else? Why should those who pay school fees also pay the cost of those who don't?
|
|
|
Originally posted by JRW2
Why should those who pay school fees also pay the cost of those who don't? This is a nonsense stance, mainly because the VAT take won't come anywhere near close to 'paying for the cost of those who don't'. Private schools have ridden the questionable charity wave for too long. I repeat again, sending kids to private school is a lifestyle choice. It's a luxury. If certain parents are now panicking because suddenly they can't afford it, or it means dropping one of their three holidays a year, making other non-essential adjustments... cry me a river. Seriously.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Private education is a luxury. Fact. In reply to the different point you're making... A utopia where all state schools have the same facilities as the private sector and compete accordingly for parents attention is pure fantasy, even if the education system was properly funded this wouldn't happen. Amusing that there is a distinct socialist and or communist tinge to your musings. It would be great to pay teachers more and recruit more of them (and train them properly) as that would be the main route to improved standards. Any suggestion from Labour that the VAT increase will solve this is also fantasy... that's a big number, several orders of magnitude larger than 1.5bn. No party can afford that. Also the performance of grammar schools is way overstated if you actually look into how the system worked, and the irony is that they created a two tier selective system within the state system anyway, that had its fair share of problem creation. Instead of paying fees, parents that could afford it paid for private tutoring to get little middle class johnny in through the door. That plus being able to pay for a more expensive house to get closer to prime catchment areas. In other words, very similar to the private system vs state system now. The social mobility and educational accessibility argument with regard to grammars is totally flawed. Private schools, increased state funding or otherwise, ultimately those that earn more will always have better opportunities. Doesn't mean people shouldn't try to make the approach better, but solving it is a fantasy. The whole pining for grammar thing is mainly rose tinted nonsense. Edited by SW19 CPFC (17 Jun 2024 3.46pm) Edited by SW19 CPFC (17 Jun 2024 5.16pm) For 'could' read 'can'. There is still selection in some counties - Buckinghamshire for example and, I believe, Kent.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
This is a nonsense stance, mainly because the VAT take won't come anywhere near close to 'paying for the cost of those who don't'. Private schools have ridden the questionable charity wave for too long. I repeat again, sending kids to private school is a lifestyle choice. It's a luxury. If certain parents are now panicking because suddenly they can't afford it, or it means dropping one of their three holidays a year, making other non-essential adjustments... cry me a river. Seriously. I fear that you have completely misunderstood my post - perhaps that was my fault. I was making the point that parents of children at fee-paying schools not only pay those fees but through their taxes pay towards (i.e., subsidise) the education of other people's children. VAT has nothing to do with my point. Many years ago I was chatting (sorry for name-dropping) with Lord Adonis, at that time a Labour junior minister in the Education Department, and he said that he would have no problem with a system under which governement would provide parents not using the state system with a cash voucher equivalent to the cost of a state education. Seems unbelievable now.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Why should the taxpayer be subsidising the richest in society to go to better schools than everyone else? As these people will be the best in the educated bracket and you would think bring great wealth to these islands. Although with a % being state funded it does seem a bit dim to put vat on what hmg are fundamentally already shelling out for.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
It's silly to want someone to be able to explain why they think a policy is a good idea? Cmon... It's not about penalising anyone - that's a childish framing. It's applying the same tax that everyone else pays for services, to a service predominantly used by the rich - that's literally it, and you don't seem able to offer a proper argument as to why it should be subsidised to begin with.
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace99
Fairness? How much have the Tories clawed back in tax evasion? Why was Prince William's best mate (the Duke of Westminster) allowed to inherit his dad's £8bn estate without paying a penny in inheritance tax?? Why do we have capital gains tax levels that are lower than income tax equivalents benefitting the richest in society? None of these seem fair to me but the Tories seem happy to allow all of these to prosper It isn’t fair that illegal immigrants get loads of free stuff when they get off a boat if you want to discuss fairness. If you come back with wrong thread line I will post especially for you on the correct thread. Doubt you will answer though!
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Private education is a luxury. Fact. In reply to the different point you're making... A utopia where all state schools have the same facilities as the private sector and compete accordingly for parents attention is pure fantasy, even if the education system was properly funded this wouldn't happen. Amusing that there is a distinct socialist and or communist tinge to your musings. It would be great to pay teachers more and recruit more of them (and train them properly) as that would be the main route to improved standards. Any suggestion from Labour that the VAT increase will solve this is also fantasy... that's a big number, several orders of magnitude larger than 1.5bn. No party can afford that. Also the performance of grammar schools is way overstated if you actually look into how the system worked, and the irony is that they created a two tier selective system within the state system anyway, that had its fair share of problem creation. Instead of paying fees, parents that could afford it paid for private tutoring to get little middle class johnny in through the door. That plus being able to pay for a more expensive house to get closer to prime catchment areas. In other words, very similar to the private system vs state system now. The social mobility and educational accessibility argument with regard to grammars is totally flawed. Private schools, increased state funding or otherwise, ultimately those that earn more will always have better opportunities. Doesn't mean people shouldn't try to make the approach better, but solving it is a fantasy. The whole pining for grammar thing is mainly rose tinted nonsense. Edited by SW19 CPFC (17 Jun 2024 3.46pm) Edited by SW19 CPFC (17 Jun 2024 5.16pm) Not fact. Your opinion. Do you also think that private health care is a luxury? What about private housing? It is a rubbish argument. Private does not mean luxury. It is simply paying for a better standard than the state currently provides. Americans have to pay for health care. Is that luxury? Since you claim that the amount of revenue raised will go nowhere near paying for improved state education, then what is the point? Why pick on private education? Answer. Because people who pay for private education probably don't vote Labour. Also because Labour have always had a bee in their bonnet about elitism, despite most of those hypocrites sending their kids to private schools.
Vote Reform.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
As these people will be the best in the educated bracket and you would think bring great wealth to these islands. Although with a % being state funded it does seem a bit dim to put vat on what hmg are fundamentally already shelling out for. If that was the desired outcome, it would be entrance criteria based on academic performance, not who has rich parents.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Not fact. Your opinion. Do you also think that private health care is a luxury? What about private housing? It is a rubbish argument. Private does not mean luxury. It is simply paying for a better standard than the state currently provides. Americans have to pay for health care. Is that luxury? Since you claim that the amount of revenue raised will go nowhere near paying for improved state education, then what is the point? Why pick on private education? Answer. Because people who pay for private education probably don't vote Labour. Also because Labour have always had a bee in their bonnet about elitism, despite most of those hypocrites sending their kids to private schools.
Vote Reform. And buying up council houses when given the chance. Typical socialists as if that rule came out now with big discounts they would vote against it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
It isn’t fair that illegal immigrants get loads of free stuff when they get off a boat if you want to discuss fairness. If you come back with wrong thread line I will post especially for you on the correct thread. Doubt you will answer though! There are hundreds examples of unfairness all over the world - I don’t think the existence of other unfair things is a reason not to address any of them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by JRW2
I fear that you have completely misunderstood my post - perhaps that was my fault. I was making the point that parents of children at fee-paying schools not only pay those fees but through their taxes pay towards (i.e., subsidise) the education of other people's children. VAT has nothing to do with my point. Many years ago I was chatting (sorry for name-dropping) with Lord Adonis, at that time a Labour junior minister in the Education Department, and he said that he would have no problem with a system under which governement would provide parents not using the state system with a cash voucher equivalent to the cost of a state education. Seems unbelievable now. Because we don’t calculate tax bills based on individual usage of services - why should that uniquely be the case when it comes to education?
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
If that was the desired outcome, it would be entrance criteria based on academic performance, not who has rich parents. As the state entrance now is and that is meritocracy.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
As the state entrance now is and that is meritocracy. Do I think the vast majority of privately educated kids are of average intelligence..? Yes, I do.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Not fact. Your opinion. Do you also think that private health care is a luxury? What about private housing? It is a rubbish argument. Private does not mean luxury. It is simply paying for a better standard than the state currently provides. Americans have to pay for health care. Is that luxury? Since you claim that the amount of revenue raised will go nowhere near paying for improved state education, then what is the point? Why pick on private education? Answer. Because people who pay for private education probably don't vote Labour. Also because Labour have always had a bee in their bonnet about elitism, despite most of those hypocrites sending their kids to private schools.
Vote Reform. It's absolute fact. You don't need to pay for private school. You can find a good quality state school and send your kids there. It's a luxury item, a lifestyle choice. 'Luxury – a state of great comfort or elegance, especially when involving great expense.' Bang on the money. No pun intended. Also 'lefties'... 'probably don't vote labour' etc. then goes on to say Labourites send their kids to private schools. Well the first part is observably wrong, the second is right – A large swathe of the left wing set send their kids to private school. Pretty much the entirety of the middle class Guardian set you so despise either send them there or aspire to do so. I'm afraid you're sorely mistaken if you think only right wingers and Tories send their kids to private schools. Perhaps Eton, Westminster and the elite schools, but the private system is extensive, diverse and more than just about the stereotypes that stem from the big names. Private healthcare in the UK is a luxury expense, yes. As is private education. Americans don't have a choice. We do. As already pointed out, I don't think the way the policy is being implemented will make as much difference as Labour are claiming (shock horror). However I think that it will make some difference, and that's better than no difference at all. A lot of private schools should also not be charities, and it's about time someone closed this loophole.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Do I think the vast majority of privately educated kids are of average intelligence..? Yes, I do. So are the state funded ones but that’s DEI for you.
|
|
|
Originally posted by JRW2
I fear that you have completely misunderstood my post - perhaps that was my fault. I was making the point that parents of children at fee-paying schools not only pay those fees but through their taxes pay towards (i.e., subsidise) the education of other people's children. VAT has nothing to do with my point. Many years ago I was chatting (sorry for name-dropping) with Lord Adonis, at that time a Labour junior minister in the Education Department, and he said that he would have no problem with a system under which governement would provide parents not using the state system with a cash voucher equivalent to the cost of a state education. Seems unbelievable now. OK, but the title of this thread is... And you are actually indirectly making the point that charging VAT would be in effect charging these parents twice. There is some logic in the voucher approach... but only as one of those classic 'That sounds like it makes sense' sort of thought experiments. I had similar thoughts years ago to private vs. NHS. But when you actually start working it through it makes less and less sense. The fact you are not sending your kid to state school, or not choosing to use the NHS is already saving both institutions that cost. And as both systems are critically underfunded, paying that money saved out as some sort of dividend would be counterproductive – there would be no difference between you using the NHS or not using it, as it costs it the same amount regardless. If we lived in a utopia and both systems were funded appropriately, and the amount of funding was precisely aligned to the amount of qualifying children and adults in the population, then sure, you might have a point. Money that had been allocated to an individual based on the assumption they would use the service in question would be surplus and could be returned. Although even then, your taxes as an individual pay for a diverse range of services. You'd have to somehow make it proportionate... it gets hideously complex, fast, and falls on it's arse. And actually returning to the point of this thread, if the view is that the VAT add is purely ideological rather than rational, I'd suggest that advocating for returning money to wealthy people from the state coffers without proper thought is similarly ideological and a vote buying strategy. Edited by SW19 CPFC (17 Jun 2024 6.58pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
So are the state funded ones but that’s DEI for you. This isn't really true. The bursary and scholarship system is widely deployed across the private system for exactly this purpose. Kids from less privileged backgrounds that are identified as exceptionally bright are often actively encouraged to sit entrance exams by private schools. It's also not all about high intelligence... kids that are clever enough to pass the entrance exams but don't excel academically are often contributing to the school in other ways, such as sport, the arts etc. So yes not every child is elite level intelligent, but they're clever enough to get in. And trust me it doesn't matter how much you're paying in fees, if your kid is dragging the table averages down they'll get booted fast enough. An average private school kid would be identified as above average or higher in average state schools. Not just academically but from an all round perspective. Edited by SW19 CPFC (17 Jun 2024 7.18pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
This isn't really true. The bursary and scholarship system is widely deployed across the private system for exactly this purpose. Kids from less privileged backgrounds that are identified as exceptionally bright are often actively encouraged to sit entrance exams by private schools. It's also not all about high intelligence... kids that are clever enough to pass the entrance exams but don't excel academically are often contributing to the school in other ways, such as sport, the arts etc. So yes not every child is elite level intelligent, but they're clever enough to get in. And trust me it doesn't matter how much you're paying in fees, if your kid is dragging the table averages down they'll get booted fast enough. An average private school kid would be identified as above average or higher in state schools. Not just academically but from an all round perspective. ‘Less privileged’ is the key. This indicates that the brightest whose parents earn but can’t afford 6k a year are penalised because they aren’t on the breadline. If it genuinely was the brightest a few ‘less privileged’ would get bursaries but kids from working families would as well. It’s not about academia, it’s about quotas sadly. Oh and labour are going to put vat on their own outlay, don’t you think that’s stupid or virtue signalling with some of my money ?
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
‘Less privileged’ is the key. This indicates that the brightest whose parents earn but can’t afford 6k a year are penalised because they aren’t on the breadline. If it genuinely was the brightest a few ‘less privileged’ would get bursaries but kids from working families would as well. It’s not about academia, it’s about quotas sadly. Oh and labour are going to put vat on their own outlay, don’t you think that’s stupid or virtue signalling with some of my money ? 'Less privileged' encompasses anyone who can't afford to pay fees. Are you suggesting that kids from 'working families' don't go to private school? Because they absolutely do, along with the 'less privileged'. Obviously not in vast numbers - yes quotas - private schools can only afford a certain number of full or part bursary kids each year, otherwise they'd go under. Family straightforward. This is the point of the bursary system – to encourage households that earn under a certain level with bright kids to apply. Above that level you need to get scholarships to get discounts. Further, if a child demonstrates scholarship level aptitude at the higher end schools will often make fee concessions to ensure they get them in. Why? Competition. Also it's helpful to think broader than just intelligence when considering if a kid is a good fit to a private school. There's behavioural, cultural and other areas that need considering. Not everyone is right for it, wealthy, working or otherwise. Finally... 6k a year? You mean 6k a term. Minimum. Try 20k a year at the cheaper end for the private secondary system.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.