You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > I thought we were not a selling club anymore?
November 16 2026 2.15am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

I thought we were not a selling club anymore?


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
pax3908 Flag 27 Jun 24 10.03pm

I have to say despondency is setting in for me,it looks like we will be losing our true superstars plus one or to other worthies,after peaking at the end of last season what are we going to come back to? In all seriousness is it even worth buying a season ticket,when we look like having our arm twisted into accepting offers for guys l thought we didn't have to sell,
I just hope that some of this click baiting can be fought off,and we manage to hang on to some of the good guys,and definitely the manager,it will not be a happy ship if we go back to where we started last season.Mr Parish you have to make sure that isn't the case,l don't want a wondefull new stand,and a debt free club going down to the championship!!!

 

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 27 Jun 24 10.12pm

Originally posted by pax3908

I have to say despondency is setting in for me,it looks like we will be losing our true superstars plus one or to other worthies,after peaking at the end of last season what are we going to come back to? In all seriousness is it even worth buying a season ticket,when we look like having our arm twisted into accepting offers for guys l thought we didn't have to sell,
I just hope that some of this click baiting can be fought off,and we manage to hang on to some of the good guys,and definitely the manager,it will not be a happy ship if we go back to where we started last season.Mr Parish you have to make sure that isn't the case,l don't want a wondefull new stand,and a debt free club going down to the championship!!!

I agree. It sucks. I guess the clubs we got them from feel the same way about us. Law of the jungle.

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

YT Flag Oxford 27 Jun 24 10.14pm

This is the way the cookie will crumble, I'm afraid. We don't have the financial power to come anywhere close to paying our better players what they can potentially earn elsewhere. The fact is that NOT having done so well under OG might have been better in terms of keeping the squad together for next season.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

dreamwaverider Flag London 27 Jun 24 10.34pm

Olise is the only one with a release clause right?
So the ball is in our court.
Therefore, Eze £80m. Guehi £76m.
Bank that alongside Olise and we are north of £200m.
With Dougie and Glasner we can really go to work on securing some special young talent.
It's where we are at.

 

The groover Flag Danbury 27 Jun 24 10.44pm

If someone has a release clause and wants to go there is little we can do.

If someone wants to go we should try to keep them but if they still want to go then we move on.

Its their job. They want to be at the highest level they can get too.

If I was head hunted and offered more opportunity then I would go. Just as I have done. Twice.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 27 Jun 24 11.25pm

Beyond Real Madrid and possibly Man City, I can't think of any club that would not qualify as a 'selling club' in that if one of the aforementioned comes along, there's very little a club can sometimes do. PSG won't ever have the same attraction, playing in Ligue 1 and no CL and Barca lack the finance as do the German and Italian clubs. Liverpool, Man United, Arsenal, Chelsea and perhaps Newcastle don't quite have the combination of finance/prestige to demand the same pull.

Therefore, unless you are considered to be the biggest club in world football, or the new(ish) challenger to the crown, every other club is essentially loomed over.

I imagined that being a 'selling club' was incorporated into our new 'philosophy'? It's almost inevitable. Also many on here used to look resentfully and enviously at the model the likes of the weed were employing, we are now doing similar.

We somehow or for very particular reasons kept hold of Wilf but look at even the likes of Villa and Grealish. The moment we have a player performing well for us, the poachers will take notice. Therefore, so long as we keep buying them young(ish) and cheap(ish), we can sustain the club, perhaps even make some dosh and achieve some success without collapsing as a result of a few outgoings.

S'ton within a short period of time had some real players (Bale, Walcott, VVD, Mane, Shaw, Alex O-C etc.) but didn't manage that well. Perhaps we've taken some lessons there. A number of flops will also be involved but occasionally we will unearth gems and if they go, it will be off the back of us gaining from them being here.

Under a manager like Glasner, and the recruitment team who brought us the likes of Olise, Guehi, Eze, Wharton, Doucoure, Munoz etc., we may well be on the incline whilst successfully navigating the inevitable. It's certainly preferable for me than years past.

COYP

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Midlands Eagle Flag 28 Jun 24 6.19am

Originally posted by The groover

If someone has a release clause and wants to go there is little we can do.

If someone wants to go we should try to keep them but if they still want to go then we move on.

Rumour has it that Michael Olise was happy to stay for another year but the German club came in with an offer that he just couldn't turn down - Champions League plus a doubling of his wages

 

taylors lovechild Flag 28 Jun 24 8.20am

When Olise was fit last season he was operating at a different level and sadly it was inevitable a top club would poach him. I am at least pleased he is going to a genuinely top club. I'd be far more upset if we sold one of our stars to a Spurs or a Newcastle.

As it stands, we seemingly already have a potential star in Kamada signed up to step in and Riyad ready to come in and push for a place in the back three. If we were to sign one or two of the exciting players we're linked with then I see no reason not to be optimistic, especially when you consider Doucoure and Franca should hopefully be fit again. Last summer we had a strong first XI but a weak squad. Our squad is already stronger this summer and selling Olise may in the long run help the club to improve the team as a whole, even if it loses that individual brilliance.

 

PatrickA Flag London 28 Jun 24 8.22am

If you are a club that inserts release clauses into your players’ contracts you are an actively selling club.
Think of a shop window with a price on a piece of merchandise.
If you want the merchandise ,and can afford it, you go and purchase it.

The argument in favour of the clauses is that the club can protect it’s investment and incentivise the better players to sign up with us through these clauses, with the players knowing we won’t stand in their way.

I can understand this argument to a degree, but for me it’s more like a case of the cart driving the horse.
The players pick and choose their clubs at times that suit them and the clubs that supposedly manage them forego their right to control their resources.
Five year contracts , with release clauses, become largely redundant.

If this seems an exaggeration does anybody seriously believe that Palace want to lose Olise this summer (with perhaps more to follow)?

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 28 Jun 24 9.01am

I hate this notion that there are 'selling clubs'. Every club on the planet bar about 5 are 'selling clubs'

And the OPs insinuation that it was pointless getting a season ticket etc.

We've signed some good young players, who have got better and have ambitions about our level. Nothing wrong with that. Its part of the process, and if anything makes us a better prospect to exciting young talent. DF can point to Olise as an example of the progress you can achieve with Palace.

Trap these guys in, and the story loses its ending.

Be happy that we've got to enjoy their talent, and look forward to the exciting new players that we are signing.

 

The Dolphin Flag 28 Jun 24 9.01am

It is very frustrating but it will always be the case until we are strong enough and good enough to ward off predators.
We need to find this talent for another few years, by which time we should be able to push back.
In the interim we will build a new stand and have more income from the extra fans and hospitality in the ground.
As long as we don't do a Southampton and sell the family silver every season then it is sort of acceptable.

 

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 28 Jun 24 9.41am

What makes you think we are no longer a selling club?

We are now a mid range Premier League side. We have never won a major trophy or qualified for Europe.

As such we will see out players picked off by bigger clubs and good luck to them.

Where we have to get cute is to identify those next generation players, but them at the right time and sell them at the right time for a profit.

We have done that recently so hope we can continue to do so.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 28 Jun 24 9.42am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Rumour has it that Michael Olise was happy to stay for another year but the German club came in with an offer that he just couldn't turn down - Champions League plus a doubling of his wages

i think the Olise transfer is a little bizarre. His agent has managed his career very well, from an agent's perspective, and was very clever in inserting a release clause in both his initial Reading contract and also when he first signed for Palace.

Last summer it is clear that the agent was giving potential buying clubs details of the release clause in a attempt to push through a move. As we know Chelsea met this but the player signed a new contract that doubled his wages.

We also know the release clause was increased, but it is unclear exactly what it is - c£60m has been mentioned.

Clearly, if the release clause is met there is little Palace can do to stop a player leaving. Now it appears Bayern has paid less than this. If so what are we doing?

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 28 Jun 24 10.12am

If we had wanted to keep Olise, I'm sure a big pay rise would have done it. The trouble is that if you have one player on £200k and the others on far less, there is an obvious issue with players wanting pay rises, not to mention the immediate impact on the wages budget.

In this case, the release clause was the problem. It was low because of Olise's rapid rise in profile. Had he been so sought after last season, I'm sure the clause would have been far higher.

Any other players under contract without release clauses cannot leave unless we allow them to. Having lost a star player, I'm sure the board would not sanction another sale unless the money offered was off the scale.

I hope Eze has no desire to leave or has some silly release clause, because the fans of this club deserve better.

They have endured enough mediocrity.

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 28 Jun 24 10.42am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Having lost a star player, I'm sure the board would not sanction another sale unless the money offered was off the scale.

The one risk being the Guehi situation, otherwise known as the Zaha situation.

Once a player gets into the last 2 years and you know they're going to want to move on in the next 2 years, do you take the market value now (and probably end up £40m odd in the black) or do you let them go on a free, sign a replacement and probably end up ~£20m in the red once you've bought a replacement.

You've got to be a hell of a player for a mid-table Prem club to take a ~£60m financial swing to keep you for 2 years.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 28 Jun 24 11.45am

Not alot the club can do if there are release clause in contracts.

The would not have wanted to sell Olise.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 28 Jun 24 12.27pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

If we had wanted to keep Olise, I'm sure a big pay rise would have done it. The trouble is that if you have one player on £200k and the others on far less, there is an obvious issue with players wanting pay rises, not to mention the immediate impact on the wages budget.

In this case, the release clause was the problem. It was low because of Olise's rapid rise in profile. Had he been so sought after last season, I'm sure the clause would have been far higher.

Any other players under contract without release clauses cannot leave unless we allow them to. Having lost a star player, I'm sure the board would not sanction another sale unless the money offered was off the scale.

I hope Eze has no desire to leave or has some silly release clause, because the fans of this club deserve better.

They have endured enough mediocrity.

I doubt it. Wilf essentially trapped himself with payrise after payrise.

Olise has his suiters and will (like all players) want to play at the highest level.

Olise's team would have been pushing for the clause to be low, we would have been pushing high, they would have met somewhere in the middle. At a level that gives us a decent profit, and isn't prohibitive to Olise getting the move he wants.

We cant really moan, we got him for £8m.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 28 Jun 24 12.41pm

It’s not clubs that want release clauses it’s the players that want them, if the club says no to the players who want them, they will stay then go for free, I thought the whole idea in any business, including football is, buy small, sell big

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 28 Jun 24 1.31pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

I doubt it. Wilf essentially trapped himself with payrise after payrise.

Olise has his suiters and will like all players) want to play at the highest level.

Olise's team would have been pushing for the clause to be low, we would have been pushing high, they would have met somewhere in the middle. At a level that gives us a decent profit, and isn't prohibitive to Olise getting the move he wants.

We cant really moan, we got him for £8m.

My only doubt is about how hard we tried to keep him and if he will ever manage a full season without getting another serious injury.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 28 Jun 24 1.34pm

Originally posted by ambrose7

The one risk being the Guehi situation, otherwise known as the Zaha situation.

Once a player gets into the last 2 years and you know they're going to want to move on in the next 2 years, do you take the market value now (and probably end up £40m odd in the black) or do you let them go on a free, sign a replacement and probably end up ~£20m in the red once you've bought a replacement.

You've got to be a hell of a player for a mid-table Prem club to take a ~£60m financial swing to keep you for 2 years.

He is worth more to us on the field than money in the bank.
However, I'm not quite so convinced by him as others seem to be.

Whatever he loses in value this season, would probably be what we would pay to replace him.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > I thought we were not a selling club anymore?