Quote matt_himself at 19 May 2014 11.19pm
Quote SloveniaDave at 19 May 2014 11.05pm
Quote matt_himself at 19 May 2014 10.51pm
Quote SloveniaDave at 19 May 2014 10.42pm
Quote matt_himself at 19 May 2014 10.34pm
Quote SloveniaDave at 19 May 2014 10.24pm
Quote matt_himself at 19 May 2014 10.21pm
Quote kevpofcpfc at 19 May 2014 7.08pm
-.-'
[Link]
Let's be honest here. Would you want a group of Romanians moving next door to you? Imagine it is a mixed group. No discernible family logic but a group. Would you tut and ignore it, welcome it as part of the multicultural idyll the left strive for or be concerned that house prices will plummet because all sorts of s***e will be dropped on the pavement and left there?
I await with interest.
Fine by me. I have Albanians on one side and Palestinians on the other. Both great, and much more friendly than the average London street.
Good for you. Believe you are being honest.
However intrigued as you know how this is better than the average London Street. Please expand.
Simply that they are more friendly and open - although I accept its not a very scientific survey. But I have lived with Macedonian, Slovenian, Bulgarian neighbours etc and the same applies.
But by definition, I am a foreigner where I live so my experience is not typical.
In your previous post, you referred to a 'group' rather than a family, but isn't that a bit like living next to a student house in the UK? I don't see the Romanian group, or the Poles or the Brits as any better or worse.
We all have problems with Roma (as opposed to Romanians) now, wherever we live and that is another issue entirely, but if I was desperate for a bowl of soup, I think I would be a lot more comfortable going to a Romanian neighbour than an English one.
Appreciate your honesty. You are the first person to enter into this debate on experience and not prejudice with me, so well done.
You are right to say that your experience is different and not what others may view it as.
Would it be like a student house? Yes, I guess, but as most students are middle class in this country the response to their anti social behaviours would be dealt with differently than to a group of non British nationals by most people in this country.
Would I give you a bowl of soup? Yes, I would. I believe it neighbourly and he right thing to do as I believe in a civic mentality.
I am sorry your host nation has not made you feel as welcome as you make out. That is a problem for all of us, left and right, although I am sure it is the rights fault from the moral majority on here.
And perhaps my 'inverse prejudice' is not accurate either as I have never asked a neighbor for a bowl of soup in England or anywhere else.
My guess is that it has more to do with 'big cities' than countries - people are generally supportive but large urban areas, with transient, anonymous populations are much harder to integrate into, wherever or whoever you are.
My experience stems from almost 20 years of living and working in central & eastern Europe so you can certainly say that I have a perspective which is different to most, but that experience tells me that
- most people are decent - immigrants, by definition are not 'typical' for many reasons (good and bad) - the Brits can do a great deal of good in spreading our approach to others, in terms of ethics, pragmatism, rule of law and political neutrality in the application of the law (that is why I am here)
The UK has every right to reject the EU but my concern is that it should do so from an informed position of the full consequences.
This debate is welcomed. It is balanced and speaking from experience.
I don't disagree with much of your thoughts. I would add the following that Britons have not had the luxury of debate about how we want our country for nearly forty years. What politicans forget is that by its nature, the UK and London will be susceptible to changes that the rest of Europe, and most World cities with the exception of Singapore, Hong Kong, the Arab capitals and possibly Sydney, are undergoing, without consultation of its born inhabitants. Should you challenge this pervading acceptance, you are a reactionary racist. Seemingly. Should you want to have a debate about future direction and how you want the landscape to look like, you are holding up the inevitable progress and economic future the riches unlimited immigration will bring. Without understanding or debating the social implications or the change in lifestyle a wholly new community of hashed together immigrants, whether from other parts of the UK or abroad, will bring to your community.
This sucks. And needs addressing by others than those who live in the Westminister bubble, who do not have to live with its consequences on a daily basis or wish to make sense of it.
Completely agree. I will strongly argue for a pro-European approach because, while I see most of the plusses and minuses it is very hard to weigh them accurately, without an informed debate.
But the serious debate has been ignored for too long or has been masked in a different guise. I do not have an issue with Powell, in terms of his being brave enough to address a real problem and it is a shame there were and are not more honest politicians like him nowadays.
There is no simple answer, but my hope is that the debate will at least be informed, not done through headlines in the Sun and the Daily Mail.
Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!
My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.
(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)
|