You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Calais migrant trouble
November 22 2026 2.21am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Calais migrant trouble


Page 40 of 51 < 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 >
nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 12 Aug 15 8.39pm

Quote corkery at 12 Aug 2015 5.42pm

Quote palace_in_frogland at 12 Aug 2015 1.41pm

Been thinking about the idea of using empty houses for migrant families, as has been suggested several times.



Was that actually suggested? The hippies come out with weird odd suggestions.


Is it morally right to have both homeless and empty homes at the same time?

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 12 Aug 15 8.58pm

Quote nickgusset at 12 Aug 2015 8.39pm

Quote corkery at 12 Aug 2015 5.42pm

Quote palace_in_frogland at 12 Aug 2015 1.41pm

Been thinking about the idea of using empty houses for migrant families, as has been suggested several times.



Was that actually suggested? The hippies come out with weird odd suggestions.


Is it morally right to have both homeless and empty homes at the same time?

The subtext of the above is that you appear to be saying that all empty homes should be handed over to the 'homeless'.

Therefore, I ask in turn is is right to force people to use their property for purposes they don't want it to be used for? Is the forcing of people to hand over property against their will totalitarian? Is that morally right?


Edited by matt_himself (12 Aug 2015 9.36pm)

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

palace_in_frogland Flag In a broken dream 12 Aug 15 10.12pm

Quote matt_himself at 12 Aug 2015 8.58pm

Quote nickgusset at 12 Aug 2015 8.39pm

Quote corkery at 12 Aug 2015 5.42pm

Quote palace_in_frogland at 12 Aug 2015 1.41pm

Been thinking about the idea of using empty houses for migrant families, as has been suggested several times.


Was that actually suggested? The hippies come out with weird odd suggestions.


Is it morally right to have both homeless and empty homes at the same time?

The subtext of the above is that you appear to be saying that all empty homes should be handed over to the 'homeless'.

Therefore, I ask in turn is is right to force people to use their property for purposes they don't want it to be used for? Is the forcing of people to hand over property against their will totalitarian? Is that morally right?


Edited by matt_himself (12 Aug 2015 9.36pm)

That' s kind of where I was going with this - my original question was how long does a home have to be empty before it is considered "fair game" for possession.

So again, would someone care to define "empty home"?

 

legaleagle Flag 12 Aug 15 10.30pm

I think quite a lot of the numbers re empty homes relate to people who have a second home (quite a few having a main home in another country),and empty "local authority" and "housing association" properties.

Lets stay away from the "forcing" point.

Would it be desirable if more empty properties were available for homeless people to live in?

If answer no.Stop there.If yes...

then you look at how you might encourage it in a legal way in ways that don't relate to people like you. ie,is there an argument for making it less financially attractive for people to have a second home without a decent reason (ie someone in the family based away from home for a long period because of work).

Doesn't seem like using empty council houses or housing association properties would throw any one "living there" out of "their homes"

Edited by legaleagle (12 Aug 2015 10.32pm)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 13 Aug 15 12.32am

I'd introduce an empty home tax. Might encourage some to rent their properties out thus increasing stock and hopefully lead to lower rents because of more availability.

I'm sure there are many homeless ex servicemen and women that would look after the property.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 13 Aug 15 6.50am

Quote nickgusset at 13 Aug 2015 12.32am

I'd introduce an empty home tax. Might encourage some to rent their properties out thus increasing stock and hopefully lead to lower rents because of more availability.

I'm sure there are many homeless ex servicemen and women that would look after the property.

How would you police this 'tax'? How would you stop people from housesitting in vacant properties? How would you help local economies dependant on second home income, such as villages in the Cotswolds and Cornwall, overcome a sudden loss of income due to your tax?

Progressive tax policy isn't progressive. It is simply more taxes. It is this sort of 'progressive politics' that will strangle our economic recovery and make the UK an unattractive place to do business in.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

chris123 Flag hove actually 13 Aug 15 7.08am

Quote legaleagle at 12 Aug 2015 10.30pm

I think quite a lot of the numbers re empty homes relate to people who have a second home (quite a few having a main home in another country),and empty "local authority" and "housing association" properties.

Lets stay away from the "forcing" point.

Would it be desirable if more empty properties were available for homeless people to live in?

If answer no.Stop there.If yes...

then you look at how you might encourage it in a legal way in ways that don't relate to people like you. ie,is there an argument for making it less financially attractive for people to have a second home without a decent reason (ie someone in the family based away from home for a long period because of work).

Doesn't seem like using empty council houses or housing association properties would throw any one "living there" out of "their homes"

Edited by legaleagle (12 Aug 2015 10.32pm)


I think for many second homes are assets, either acquired or inherited - and really no different than having a portfolio of shares or a pension fund. The moment you start messing with these dynamics we've lost a basic freedom.

 

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 13 Aug 15 8.09am

Why not stop tinkering with these progressive socialist policies and get straight into building multi-storey concrete tower blocks where everyone can be put. Allocation would be on a progressive planned basis according to their needs and contribution to society, or how persecuted they were in their country of origin if an asylum seeker (top priority course). We could call the first block Victory Mansions and have a big mural of Jeremy on the side.

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

palace_in_frogland Flag In a broken dream 13 Aug 15 8.21am

Quote nickgusset at 13 Aug 2015 12.32am

I'd introduce an empty home tax. Might encourage some to rent their properties out thus increasing stock and hopefully lead to lower rents because of more availability.

I'm sure there are many homeless ex servicemen and women that would look after the property.


What's your definition of an empty home qualifying for this tax?

 

palace_in_frogland Flag In a broken dream 13 Aug 15 8.38am

Quote legaleagle at 12 Aug 2015 10.30pm

I think quite a lot of the numbers re empty homes relate to people who have a second home (quite a few having a main home in another country),and empty "local authority" and "housing association" properties.

Lets stay away from the "forcing" point.

Would it be desirable if more empty properties were available for homeless people to live in?

If answer no.Stop there.If yes...

then you look at how you might encourage it in a legal way in ways that don't relate to people like you. ie,is there an argument for making it less financially attractive for people to have a second home without a decent reason (ie someone in the family based away from home for a long period because of work).

Doesn't seem like using empty council houses or housing association properties would throw any one "living there" out of "their homes"

Edited by legaleagle (12 Aug 2015 10.32pm)

Yes, if we make the distinction between stock let's say, in the private and public domain, I have no objection to loc authority stock being used for migrant housing, providing of course that all already on a waiting list are housed first.

As far as the privately owned housing is concerned, I can't see any government of any colour daring to legislate against multiple property ownership. Political suicide, in my opinion.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 13 Aug 15 8.46am

From what I've read, it seems many have no problem having homeless people and empty houses in this country.

Fair enough.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Aug 15 9.38am

Quote matt_himself at 12 Aug 2015 8.58pm

Quote nickgusset at 12 Aug 2015 8.39pm

Quote corkery at 12 Aug 2015 5.42pm

Quote palace_in_frogland at 12 Aug 2015 1.41pm

Been thinking about the idea of using empty houses for migrant families, as has been suggested several times.



Was that actually suggested? The hippies come out with weird odd suggestions.


Is it morally right to have both homeless and empty homes at the same time?

The subtext of the above is that you appear to be saying that all empty homes should be handed over to the 'homeless'.

Therefore, I ask in turn is is right to force people to use their property for purposes they don't want it to be used for? Is the forcing of people to hand over property against their will totalitarian? Is that morally right?


Edited by matt_himself (12 Aug 2015 9.36pm)

UK law permits for Compulsory Purchase Orders, so its not totalitarian at all, if compensation or provision is made to allow for compensation. The state could of course utilize existing properties by compulsory letting, and taking responsibility as a temporary owner of the property.

To forcibly take property, without compensation is beyond the capacity of the state, outside of a State of Emergency. It would take an act of parliament (which would never be accepted by the Lords).

The problem really is the idea of property as a means of investment and return, as has become very common practice since the 80s housing boom.

People throw the word totalitarian and freedom around far to easily.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

chris123 Flag hove actually 13 Aug 15 9.41am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Aug 2015 9.38am

Quote matt_himself at 12 Aug 2015 8.58pm

Quote nickgusset at 12 Aug 2015 8.39pm

Quote corkery at 12 Aug 2015 5.42pm

Quote palace_in_frogland at 12 Aug 2015 1.41pm

Been thinking about the idea of using empty houses for migrant families, as has been suggested several times.



Was that actually suggested? The hippies come out with weird odd suggestions.


Is it morally right to have both homeless and empty homes at the same time?

The subtext of the above is that you appear to be saying that all empty homes should be handed over to the 'homeless'.

Therefore, I ask in turn is is right to force people to use their property for purposes they don't want it to be used for? Is the forcing of people to hand over property against their will totalitarian? Is that morally right?


Edited by matt_himself (12 Aug 2015 9.36pm)

UK law permits for Compulsory Purchase Orders, so its not totalitarian at all, if compensation or provision is made to allow for compensation. The state could of course utilize existing properties by compulsory letting, and taking responsibility as a temporary owner of the property.

To forcibly take property, without compensation is beyond the capacity of the state, outside of a State of Emergency. It would take an act of parliament (which would never be accepted by the Lords).

The problem really is the idea of property as a means of investment and return, as has become very common practice since the 80s housing boom.

People throw the word totalitarian and freedom around far to easily.



Completely agree with para 3.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Aug 15 9.42am

Quote nickgusset at 13 Aug 2015 8.46am

From what I've read, it seems many have no problem having homeless people and empty houses in this country.

Fair enough.

I do, and I find it immoral, not so much that the properties are empty, but that the state has abandoned homeless people with successive cuts to the point that assistance and support is largely reliant on charities that now bid for the council business of 'outreach'.

You probably can't save everyone, but you should at the very least make it reasonable difficult to become homeless, and easy to get out of homelessness.

Its not the fault of people with multiple properties, but successive governments cuts that stimulate homelessness as a common problem - a phenomena of our life times.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 13 Aug 15 10.23am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Aug 2015 9.38am

Quote matt_himself at 12 Aug 2015 8.58pm

Quote nickgusset at 12 Aug 2015 8.39pm

Quote corkery at 12 Aug 2015 5.42pm

Quote palace_in_frogland at 12 Aug 2015 1.41pm

Been thinking about the idea of using empty houses for migrant families, as has been suggested several times.



Was that actually suggested? The hippies come out with weird odd suggestions.


Is it morally right to have both homeless and empty homes at the same time?

The subtext of the above is that you appear to be saying that all empty homes should be handed over to the 'homeless'.

Therefore, I ask in turn is is right to force people to use their property for purposes they don't want it to be used for? Is the forcing of people to hand over property against their will totalitarian? Is that morally right?


Edited by matt_himself (12 Aug 2015 9.36pm)

UK law permits for Compulsory Purchase Orders, so its not totalitarian at all, if compensation or provision is made to allow for compensation. The state could of course utilize existing properties by compulsory letting, and taking responsibility as a temporary owner of the property.

To forcibly take property, without compensation is beyond the capacity of the state, outside of a State of Emergency. It would take an act of parliament (which would never be accepted by the Lords).

The problem really is the idea of property as a means of investment and return, as has become very common practice since the 80s housing boom.

People throw the word totalitarian and freedom around far to easily.


Compulsory purchase is used to facilitate infrastructure developments such as roads and railways. The compensation given is usually generous. Seizing the property of people against their will, even if you compensate them, for the purpose of effectively giving the property to less well off people is indeed totalitarian - something they did in Soviet Russia. I find it utterly bizarre that a 'serious' discussion is being held on here talking about dispossessing indigenous people to house various disparate immigrants - many of whom are here illegally. There really is no limit to the foolishness of you new lefties.

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 13 Aug 15 10.59am

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Aug 2015 10.23am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Aug 2015 9.38am

Quote matt_himself at 12 Aug 2015 8.58pm

Quote nickgusset at 12 Aug 2015 8.39pm

Quote corkery at 12 Aug 2015 5.42pm

Quote palace_in_frogland at 12 Aug 2015 1.41pm

Been thinking about the idea of using empty houses for migrant families, as has been suggested several times.



Was that actually suggested? The hippies come out with weird odd suggestions.


Is it morally right to have both homeless and empty homes at the same time?

The subtext of the above is that you appear to be saying that all empty homes should be handed over to the 'homeless'.

Therefore, I ask in turn is is right to force people to use their property for purposes they don't want it to be used for? Is the forcing of people to hand over property against their will totalitarian? Is that morally right?


Edited by matt_himself (12 Aug 2015 9.36pm)

UK law permits for Compulsory Purchase Orders, so its not totalitarian at all, if compensation or provision is made to allow for compensation. The state could of course utilize existing properties by compulsory letting, and taking responsibility as a temporary owner of the property.

To forcibly take property, without compensation is beyond the capacity of the state, outside of a State of Emergency. It would take an act of parliament (which would never be accepted by the Lords).

The problem really is the idea of property as a means of investment and return, as has become very common practice since the 80s housing boom.

People throw the word totalitarian and freedom around far to easily.


Compulsory purchase is used to facilitate infrastructure developments such as roads and railways. The compensation given is usually generous. Seizing the property of people against their will, even if you compensate them, for the purpose of effectively giving the property to less well off people is indeed totalitarian - something they did in Soviet Russia. I find it utterly bizarre that a 'serious' discussion is being held on here talking about dispossessing indigenous people to house various disparate immigrants - many of whom are here illegally. There really is no limit to the foolishness of you new lefties.

They have broken the law and should be treated as criminals not given money housing and free health care. We should speed up the process of getting rid of them as soon as they arrive on our shores. They are here illegally not real asylum cases...They deserve NOTHING and should get NOTHING !!!

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Aug 15 11.18am

Quote susmik at 13 Aug 2015 10.59am

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Aug 2015 10.23am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Aug 2015 9.38am

Quote matt_himself at 12 Aug 2015 8.58pm

Quote nickgusset at 12 Aug 2015 8.39pm

Quote corkery at 12 Aug 2015 5.42pm

Quote palace_in_frogland at 12 Aug 2015 1.41pm

Been thinking about the idea of using empty houses for migrant families, as has been suggested several times.



Was that actually suggested? The hippies come out with weird odd suggestions.


Is it morally right to have both homeless and empty homes at the same time?

The subtext of the above is that you appear to be saying that all empty homes should be handed over to the 'homeless'.

Therefore, I ask in turn is is right to force people to use their property for purposes they don't want it to be used for? Is the forcing of people to hand over property against their will totalitarian? Is that morally right?


Edited by matt_himself (12 Aug 2015 9.36pm)

UK law permits for Compulsory Purchase Orders, so its not totalitarian at all, if compensation or provision is made to allow for compensation. The state could of course utilize existing properties by compulsory letting, and taking responsibility as a temporary owner of the property.

To forcibly take property, without compensation is beyond the capacity of the state, outside of a State of Emergency. It would take an act of parliament (which would never be accepted by the Lords).

The problem really is the idea of property as a means of investment and return, as has become very common practice since the 80s housing boom.

People throw the word totalitarian and freedom around far to easily.


Compulsory purchase is used to facilitate infrastructure developments such as roads and railways. The compensation given is usually generous. Seizing the property of people against their will, even if you compensate them, for the purpose of effectively giving the property to less well off people is indeed totalitarian - something they did in Soviet Russia. I find it utterly bizarre that a 'serious' discussion is being held on here talking about dispossessing indigenous people to house various disparate immigrants - many of whom are here illegally. There really is no limit to the foolishness of you new lefties.

They have broken the law and should be treated as criminals not given money housing and free health care. We should speed up the process of getting rid of them as soon as they arrive on our shores. They are here illegally not real asylum cases...They deserve NOTHING and should get NOTHING !!!

They don't receive benefits, unless they're fraudulently claiming them using fake or stolen ID's. That said, as criminals, they do have to be housed somewhere whilst processed and entitled to health care pending deportation (and prison is an exceptionally expensive option).

Also, some of them will also be victims of crime themselves(forced trafficking and sex trafficking), and may be required as witnesses for a prosecution.

The real issue with illegal immigrants isn't the immigrants themselves, but the people who employ them and bring them in. Most illegals in the UK will be working in some form or another in order to survive, or pay off a debt to traffickers (the traffickers will typically sell them onto affiliate gangs in the country, who will then put them to work to pay debts, or for a pittance, whilst providing some kind of accommodation and food).

These gangs essentially provide these people as cheap labor into various UK businesses, or in the sex trade they're generally pressed into prostitution. Most have lives that are pretty terrible even by third world standards.

Illegal migrants lives is maybe one up from being homeless and living on the streets in the UK.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Aug 15 11.21am

Quote leggedstruggle at 13 Aug 2015 10.23am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Aug 2015 9.38am

Quote matt_himself at 12 Aug 2015 8.58pm

Quote nickgusset at 12 Aug 2015 8.39pm

Quote corkery at 12 Aug 2015 5.42pm

Quote palace_in_frogland at 12 Aug 2015 1.41pm

Been thinking about the idea of using empty houses for migrant families, as has been suggested several times.



Was that actually suggested? The hippies come out with weird odd suggestions.


Is it morally right to have both homeless and empty homes at the same time?

The subtext of the above is that you appear to be saying that all empty homes should be handed over to the 'homeless'.

Therefore, I ask in turn is is right to force people to use their property for purposes they don't want it to be used for? Is the forcing of people to hand over property against their will totalitarian? Is that morally right?


Edited by matt_himself (12 Aug 2015 9.36pm)

UK law permits for Compulsory Purchase Orders, so its not totalitarian at all, if compensation or provision is made to allow for compensation. The state could of course utilize existing properties by compulsory letting, and taking responsibility as a temporary owner of the property.

To forcibly take property, without compensation is beyond the capacity of the state, outside of a State of Emergency. It would take an act of parliament (which would never be accepted by the Lords).

The problem really is the idea of property as a means of investment and return, as has become very common practice since the 80s housing boom.

People throw the word totalitarian and freedom around far to easily.


Compulsory purchase is used to facilitate infrastructure developments such as roads and railways. The compensation given is usually generous. Seizing the property of people against their will, even if you compensate them, for the purpose of effectively giving the property to less well off people is indeed totalitarian - something they did in Soviet Russia. I find it utterly bizarre that a 'serious' discussion is being held on here talking about dispossessing indigenous people to house various disparate immigrants - many of whom are here illegally. There really is no limit to the foolishness of you new lefties.

Well you wouldn't be giving it, you'd be purchasing it as state housing infrastructure. I don't agree with it per se, but the capacity is there for the state to make compulsory purchases of housing, without actually having to seize property.

Of course more sensible, would be to incentivize people with additional property to rent it out.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

matt_himself Flag Matataland 13 Aug 15 11.40am

Quote nickgusset at 13 Aug 2015 8.46am

From what I've read, it seems many have no problem having homeless people and empty houses in this country.

Fair enough.


What people are saying is that this subject is not black & white.

Given that private sector pensions have significantly diminished in value in recent years, many people are turning to property as a way to obtain an income through retirement. By forcing those people to give up second homes you are not only denying people a right of self determination, freedom & ownership but also denying people an income in retirement.

One cannot help but think that the opposition to multiple home ownership has far more to do with an ideological agenda than wishing to resolve homelessness.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

matt_himself Flag Matataland 13 Aug 15 11.42am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Aug 2015 9.38am

Quote matt_himself at 12 Aug 2015 8.58pm

Quote nickgusset at 12 Aug 2015 8.39pm

Quote corkery at 12 Aug 2015 5.42pm

Quote palace_in_frogland at 12 Aug 2015 1.41pm

Been thinking about the idea of using empty houses for migrant families, as has been suggested several times.



Was that actually suggested? The hippies come out with weird odd suggestions.


Is it morally right to have both homeless and empty homes at the same time?

The subtext of the above is that you appear to be saying that all empty homes should be handed over to the 'homeless'.

Therefore, I ask in turn is is right to force people to use their property for purposes they don't want it to be used for? Is the forcing of people to hand over property against their will totalitarian? Is that morally right?


Edited by matt_himself (12 Aug 2015 9.36pm)

UK law permits for Compulsory Purchase Orders, so its not totalitarian at all, if compensation or provision is made to allow for compensation. The state could of course utilize existing properties by compulsory letting, and taking responsibility as a temporary owner of the property.

To forcibly take property, without compensation is beyond the capacity of the state, outside of a State of Emergency. It would take an act of parliament (which would never be accepted by the Lords).

The problem really is the idea of property as a means of investment and return, as has become very common practice since the 80s housing boom.

People throw the word totalitarian and freedom around far to easily.


What the left appear to be saying is that multiple home ownership is evil. The problem is not to do with property as a means of investment, it is the fact that other forms of investment, such as pensions, simply do not provide significant incomes for the retired.

I still believe that the multiple homes ownership 'debate' has more to do with ideology than practicality.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Page 40 of 51 < 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Calais migrant trouble